Skip to content

Accuser wants Ben's black book

Lost in the hoopla over the hollow settlement offer recently made by the woman suing Steelers quarterback Ben Roethlisberger for sexual assault is the fact that her lawyer recently has asked for a list of all women with whom Ben has had relations.

The request came in a Tuesday court filing aimed at defeating Roethlisberger’s motion to dismiss the case.

The accuser also wants Roethlisberger to identify whether any of his sexual partners have alleged misconduct on his part.  (Suddenly, we’re reminded of the scene where Jerry Seinfeld calls Patty Lawrence.)

Though likely outrageous to the non-lawyers in the crowd, this is a fairly common practice in the pre-trial discovery process.  In this case, Roethlisberger’s accuser wants to find out whether other women have accused him of sexual assault.  If the process for getting that information creates a hassle or an embarrassment for Roethsliberger, it’s an added benefit, from the perspective of the plaintiff.

Meanwhile, lawyer Calvin Dunlap apparently claims that the woman, whose credibility has been dramatically undermined by the fact that she filed no criminal complaint after the incident, told a doctor about the alleged assault, presumably within a short period of time after it occurred.

Permalink 60 Comments Feed for comments Latest Stories in: Legal, Pittsburgh Steelers, Rumor Mill, Top Stories
60 Responses to “Accuser wants Ben's black book”
  1. realityonetwo says: Sep 10, 2009 10:30 AM

    Now do you see why he just should have written her a check?

  2. Bob Nelson says: Sep 10, 2009 10:31 AM

    Just laughable.

  3. Florios-Lawyer says: Sep 10, 2009 10:33 AM

    “…In this case, Roethlisberger’s accuser wants to find out whether other women have accused him of sexual assault. …”
    Weak. Wouldn’t that have made the news?
    “…Calvin Dunlap apparently claims that the woman, … told a doctor about the alleged assault, presumably within a short period of time after it occurred….”
    Bought and paid for.

  4. Child_Please! says: Sep 10, 2009 10:34 AM

    Ben:
    Never,,,, and I repeat N E V E R share your black book with ANYBODY!
    You must protect it with your life!!!!!!!!!!

  5. Ken1313 says: Sep 10, 2009 10:37 AM

    Earth to Calvin Dunlap……come home now…….you’ve been floating in space too long…and your mind has deteriorated.

  6. Stillerz says: Sep 10, 2009 10:42 AM

    Bens Black Book:
    1. Hallie Berry
    2. Jessica Alba
    3. Jennifer Aniston
    4. That hot golfer chick
    5. Andrea McNulty
    Bens Hitlist:
    1. Andrea McNulty
    2. Bart Scott
    3. Lincoln Continental Windsheld – CHECK

  7. Florios-Lawyer says: Sep 10, 2009 10:42 AM

    “I don’t recall…”
    It works for politicians.

  8. missy says: Sep 10, 2009 10:45 AM

    I read the motion and this is what sticks out to me …She states she went tot he pharmacy to get a morning after pill, before she made the spoof “email that she was moving to Pittsburgh” but she didnt got to the hospital to verifiy she was raped, contridicting yourself there Mcnutty, then stated that she told roomate about it why didnt moron take her to the hospital, to get proof if this is true, and you can tell a dr anything , i could go to the Dr right now and tell them i was raped by Ben and they would have to take my word for it “I really wasnt just making a point” come on that still doesnt convince me, and all of this comes out after the fact all the other people she is suing released info about her,,,now were talking, she told Dr in DEC she was raped in July you cant tell me that anyone believes this shit anymore than they have her other lies, and then them asking for him to produce all the women he slept with , like he even remembers, LMAO so here we go again the straw grasping, Ithink Ben should ask for all the men she has slept with fair is fair as her ambulance chaser stated in the motion, see right through her , she is a money grubbing bitch that is pissed off she didnt get preggers and did not become Mrs. Roethlisberger and now shw is crying rape I hope Bens attorneys go after them even harder now and bury them in that rancid hole they came out of….

  9. Bwa Ha Ha says: Sep 10, 2009 10:46 AM

    Hey, I’d like to have Ben’s black book too!

  10. The Movie Whore says: Sep 10, 2009 10:49 AM

    Florio correct me if I am wrong, which I could be, but aren’t Drs required to report sexual abuse?

  11. Bwa Ha Ha says: Sep 10, 2009 10:49 AM

    Hey, I’d like to have Ben’s black book too!

  12. The Jimmy says: Sep 10, 2009 10:50 AM

    That’s going to be a very difficult list to compile since I’m sure the numbers are astronomical and he won’t even know the names, or remember many of them.

  13. BenRapistberger says: Sep 10, 2009 10:51 AM

    Why would I keep the phone numbers of all the people who have fixed my TVs in the past?

  14. missy says: Sep 10, 2009 10:54 AM

    @ realityonetwo Now do you see why he just should have written her a check?
    ___________________________________
    I would not pay that money grubbing nutjob anything she has no proof , which she would have had if she would have went to the dr instead of the pharmacy to get the “playing without protecting ” pill and she would not have been braggin about the best sex ever…lmao

  15. Kiss Bills Rings says: Sep 10, 2009 10:56 AM

    The Lawyer should have asked him to include a list of all the guys too……BOOM YOUR FACE!!!

  16. mrmagoo says: Sep 10, 2009 11:01 AM

    Stillerz says:
    September 10, 2009 10:42 AM
    Bens Black Book:
    1. Hallie Berry
    2. Jessica Alba
    3. Jennifer Aniston
    4. That hot golfer chick
    5. Andrea McNulty
    Bens Hitlist:
    1. Andrea McNulty
    2. Bart Scott
    3. Lincoln Continental Windsheld – CHECK
    ______________________________
    You can scratch #2 off Ben’s Hitlist.
    Hines knocked the crap out of him, but he couldn’t quite knock the whine out of him.

  17. favrecansuckit says: Sep 10, 2009 11:01 AM

    As if a professional athlete remembers the names of all the chicks he’s banged….

  18. katdawg215 says: Sep 10, 2009 11:04 AM

    your black book should only see other hands once you get married in which it gets handed off to your best friend(unless you’ve been sleeping with some of his girls hahahaha) with a promise to give it back if you get divorced lol

  19. PkrNboro says: Sep 10, 2009 11:04 AM

    Can’t this site ever talk about football ?
    it should be renamed:
    http://www.profootballgossip.com
    Divas (Favre, Vick. Crabtree, Seymour)
    Alleged assaults (Roethlisberger. Merriman, Quinn)
    Tweetings (ocho-nobody and other skanks)
    How about 32 articles, each discussing new starters for each team?
    How about an article discussing the merits/impact of previous year’s strength-of-schedule vs. current year’s schedule ?
    How about the merit of some recent coaching changes — should offense be simplified ? or diversified?
    Let’s talk football…

  20. Siggy00 says: Sep 10, 2009 11:05 AM

    My favorite McNutty claim: “They took my emails out of context”.
    How that happened, when SHE WROTE them, is one I’d like to hear.

  21. Flimflam1 says: Sep 10, 2009 11:09 AM

    Holy run-on sentence, Batman.
    Missy, great points, but go buy yourself a couple periods and start using them. It’ll work wonders for getting your point across to all these other clown shoe knuckleheads who can’t read.

  22. DonTerrelli says: Sep 10, 2009 11:10 AM

    Ben’s black book:
    1. Cheerleader chick from college
    2. Cheerleader’s friend and her friend
    3. Sorority House after winning that big game.
    4. That dancer girl in the Bahamas after getting first paycheck from Steelers.
    5. That other nice but weird dancer lady that Coach Cowher introduced me to after Supa Bowl.
    6. That hot golfer lady with the big boobies, harf harf harf
    7. That canadian actress lady from that crappy show I never heard of on the WB
    8. Oh yeah, Hines’ little sister
    9. And that night at Charlie Batch’s house
    10. That really nutty chick in Tahoe that wouldn’t get off my nuts. Oh yeah, and her friend later, harf harf harf
    11. that mean lady with the penis that said Bart Scott sent her at my hotel room in Baltimore
    12. That really, really nice lady that Coach Tomlin introduced me to after this last Supa Bowl.

  23. Florios-Lawyer says: Sep 10, 2009 11:15 AM

    “…# The Movie Whore says: September 10, 2009 10:49 AM
    Florio correct me if I am wrong, which I could be, but aren’t Drs required to report sexual abuse?…”
    Excellent point.

  24. Vikefanman says: Sep 10, 2009 11:16 AM

    Ben should give them Wilt Chamberlains black book…..that would keep them busy for a while.
    Seriously….he should furnish a book with this nutcase as the only entry. Make THEM prove he ever had sex with anyone else…..even then he could claim that he didnt remember or didnt keep their personal information.

  25. Duck Butter says: Sep 10, 2009 11:23 AM

    A few thoughts that come to mind:
    -That Biznatch is crazy
    -I cant remember the names of all the girls I have slept, no way Worthlessburger can.
    -I bet he regretted banging her when he sobered up (have you seen her pictures), by now he should REALLY be regretting it.

  26. sweetleb says: Sep 10, 2009 11:27 AM

    still looking for evidence that ben had sex with her let alone raped her. you get raped and you get a morning after pill for $44 dollars. let me guess, pay for it in cash. but you fail to go to the police to have a rape kit done,hmm. when by your own story he did not wear a condom. so you had evidence that there was at least sex. but yet no rape kit or a complaint filed. wow!!!!!

  27. hay1111 says: Sep 10, 2009 11:29 AM

    Ben, just pay and it goes away.
    Sincerely,
    Kobe Bryant & Michael Jackson

  28. jamaltimore says: Sep 10, 2009 11:33 AM

    Problem with that strategy is one would assume FATBURGER can actually spell names correctly. Between the Bart Scott Hit, 60 sacks a season and running into cars without a helmet on it’s obvious the guy is now full blown stupid. I mean how else does he’s ask andrea mchorsey to fix his television set? apparently he couldn’t even work the on/off switch.
    The good news for steelers fans is that since his head is hollow it acts as a speaker so the rest of team can hear the play call with out Rapistburger having to think or say anything.

  29. KHat says: Sep 10, 2009 11:42 AM

    Even though everyone here has both the accuser and accused tried and convicted or acquitted, I have to point out that what is hitting the media is strangely different from what was in the original complaint (http://www.thepittsburghchannel.com/download/2009/0721/20132331.pdf).
    We all made fun of Monica Lewinsky for keeping the dress but now we’re faulting Andrea McNulty for having NO proof that Ben spewed all over her belly like she claims, huh?
    The thing that bugs me about this case is the prevailing opinion that a sex act is about women allowing a man permission to obtain his pleasure, so once she’s expressed an interest, apparently it gives him license to do whatever he wants with it … regardless of whether she agrees to THEN, THERE and THAT way. So even if the discovery motion unearths a dozen more women who say they flirted with Ben and he just took them the same way, in the court of American public opinion it means nothing compared to the number of men that Andrea McNulty eagerly CONSENTED to sex with.
    So many people say it’s about the money, but even if she were asking only for legal costs, payment of the medical bills including her admissions to St. Helena, Carson City, and Barton Memorial Hospitals, and lost wages, it would still be a considerable sum. Remember, she’s also suing the members of Harrah’s staff that basically added “Ben’s prostitute” to her job expectations … I imagine she’s got a bigger grievance against them, but without the original action has no cause against them.
    As a woman, I can’t imagine anyone opening herself up to this kind of castigation but there ARE all kinds out there these days, so who knows.

  30. texasPHINSfan says: Sep 10, 2009 11:44 AM

    the entire case should be blown out of the water based on the fact she was bragging about sleeping with him after the fact, and the tidbit about her looking forward to going to “fix” his tv, which apparently is slang in Nevada for knockin boots.

  31. FrankyFiveFingers says: Sep 10, 2009 11:46 AM

    Ben uses my black book.

  32. mustbechris says: Sep 10, 2009 11:50 AM

    This worked for Kobe when it was the other way around…I don’t see it working here, though.

  33. The Rural Juror says: Sep 10, 2009 11:51 AM

    Ben can ‘deny remembering’ all he wants.
    But the accuser may also put an open call out to the media for anyone who has slept with Ben Roethlisberger to come forward…

  34. Florios-Lawyer says: Sep 10, 2009 11:54 AM

    “…# jamaltimore says: September 10, 2009 11:33 AM
    [ / rant spared ]
    Ray Lewis is a murderer.

  35. Florios-Lawyer says: Sep 10, 2009 12:23 PM

    “…The Rural Juror says: September 10, 2009 11:51 AM
    Ben can ‘deny remembering’ all he wants.
    But the accuser may also put an open call out to the media for anyone who has slept with Ben Roethlisberger to come forward…”
    LOL
    Oh yeah, I’m sure that will work.
    After all, it’s not like it’ll draw any more crazy attention whores out of the woodwork.
    Think about that. Would it surprise you if people, who never even met the guy, came forward, just for their 15 minutes?
    Me either.

  36. Big Stretch says: Sep 10, 2009 12:23 PM

    This girl and her lawyer are a joke. I hate the Steelers, but i hope Big Ben turns around and sues this GOLD DIGGER for every penny she has and then donates the money to a mental illness charity.

  37. tt0074958 says: Sep 10, 2009 12:27 PM

    “Meanwhile, lawyer Calvin Dunlap apparently claims that the woman, whose credibility has been dramatically undermined by the fact that she filed no criminal complaint after the incident, told a doctor about the alleged assault, presumably within a short period of time after it occurred.”
    This is yet again another example of poor journalism on your part. The lawyer “apparently” claimed? Do you have any source for this, or is it just some rumor? Also, you said that she went to the doctor, “presumably” shortly after this supposedly happened. Are you just speculating again? This is far worse than hack journalism. It is grossly irresponsible, and can only hurt all parties in this case.

  38. roadkill says: Sep 10, 2009 12:40 PM

    - Andrea McNulty
    – Sarah Jessica Parker
    – Barbaro (crossed out)
    – the cast from Quest for Fire
    – Dotty (his neighbor’s dachshund)

  39. tk1966 says: Sep 10, 2009 12:48 PM

    jamaltimore says:
    September 10, 2009 11:33 AM
    The good news for steelers fans is that since his head is hollow it acts as a speaker so the rest of team can hear the play call with out Rapistburger having to think or say anything.
    Seriously? Did you even read this before you hit “submit”. Dude, that is just about the stupidest nonsense I’ve ever read posted here, and there’s been alot of stupid crap posted here! Great job! Momma would be proud of you.

  40. Big ben Rapistburger says: Sep 10, 2009 12:49 PM

    The black book is useless. 90 percent of my conquests were livestock anyways, and have since been slaughtered. I simply thought Andrea McNulty was a horse. Had I realized she wasnt a horse, I wouldnt have been interested in the first place. Now, I wish someone had told me she wasnt a horse, because it would have avoided all of this trouble…… Damn I hate being as dumb as a sneaker full of shit….

  41. Florios-Lawyer says: Sep 10, 2009 12:53 PM

    “…# tt0074958 says: September 10, 2009 12:27 PM
    Are you just speculating again? This is far worse than hack journalism. It is grossly irresponsible, and can only hurt all parties in this case….”
    True, but irrelevant.
    Florio’s job is to generate site hits.
    Besides, there are no journalists anymore, just newsprint salesmen. His “writing” future is secure as long as TMZ and the National Enquirer are still in business.

  42. The Rural Juror says: Sep 10, 2009 1:15 PM

    “Oh yeah, I’m sure that will work.
    After all, it’s not like it’ll draw any more crazy attention whores out of the woodwork.
    Think about that. Would it surprise you if people, who never even met the guy, came forward, just for their 15 minutes?
    Me either.”
    NOW you’re catching on…
    Ben Better settle, or crap like this will continue for quite some time while the accuser is in the “exploratory” phase before the trial…

  43. Igottz5onit says: Sep 10, 2009 1:27 PM

    Hey she wants his black book? Nice. I bet he wants a rocket ship so he can fly her back to her planet of insane horsepeople with lousy attorneys.

  44. Keith Beresheim says: Sep 10, 2009 1:46 PM

    Keith Beresheim
    Its like James Cagney would say “thats for the authorities to figure out”

  45. LL Live says: Sep 10, 2009 2:01 PM

    Maybe she was just covering up for being a slut…not that there’s anything wrong with that…I prefer slutty women myself!

  46. paddy says: Sep 10, 2009 2:03 PM

    Come on….this boy’s being snowed…..
    If you want a genuine rapist, he’s wearing No. 6 for the Jets…..

  47. The Rural Juror says: Sep 10, 2009 2:15 PM

    roadkill says:
    September 10, 2009 12:40 PM
    – Andrea McNulty
    – Sarah Jessica Parker
    – Barbaro (crossed out)
    – the cast from Quest for Fire
    – Dotty (his neighbor’s dachshund)
    ____
    +5

  48. slipkid says: Sep 10, 2009 2:23 PM

    sur real

  49. Babedolll says: Sep 10, 2009 2:40 PM

    To Paddy:
    Who are you talking about? The Mexican?

  50. paddy says: Sep 10, 2009 3:20 PM

    That’s correct….
    USC has a way of making rape charges against it’s football players disappear….
    He was one of them…..
    He’s a scumbag of the highest order, but you won’t hear anything about it….they’re too busy making him a minority hero.
    …makes me sick.

  51. MIKE B says: Sep 10, 2009 4:05 PM

    These high profile ass wipes should keep it in their pants.

  52. bunbun says: Sep 10, 2009 7:15 PM

    Perhaps benny boy would do better with a pro athlete like Semenya. Run benny boy run

  53. scott says: Sep 10, 2009 7:24 PM

    maybe this could all be settled if rick pitino would recomend a restaurant they could talk at????

  54. Reba says: Sep 10, 2009 7:44 PM

    Hey, if Ben doesn’t produce the “black book” and doesn’t “recall”… ask his team members about the chicks he CLAIMS to have done. Ben looked a heck of a lot better before the accident. Now he looks like a bad nose job.
    HE’S A FOOTBALL PLAYER NOT GOD PEOPLE. Forrest Gump was a better player than Rapistberger. Hard to say that since I’ve been a Steeler fan since I was 8. Too bad this man who can’t keep it in his pants has soiled the team’s reputation. Polumalu, Ward… classy guys. Ben your numbers suck and the only reason you have a 2nd ring is because of the defense. The defense carried the team and Tomlin said so on the NFL Network. Ben, take your country ass home to Ohio and let the team shine again.

  55. phillygirl says: Sep 11, 2009 10:19 AM

    Why would you continue to go to work at a place that you were raped? To walk in there over and over again everyday, when something so horrible happened there is beyond me. That is why I do not believe this woman. If it really happened she would not have even wanted to continue showing up at work. Nothing about this womans story makes any kind of sense. It’s a real shame for woman who really are raped but now you have to question them all because nasty who$es like this beotch ruin it by lying. Btw… someone should explain to her that you can’t rape the willing.

  56. dat crazy bok says: Sep 11, 2009 10:51 AM

    Ben should take some advice from Tim Tebow. Just say you’re a virgin Ben!

  57. Tiberime says: Sep 11, 2009 10:55 AM

    If any of you ever hit the lottory for big money watch how fast the false accusations and lawyers accelerate in your direction.
    It is so sad how you can put a pile of money in front of almost anyone and watch a leopard change its spots.

  58. RagnartheViking says: Sep 11, 2009 11:11 AM

    Title should read she’s after his BANK book not his black book.

  59. SwissChick says: Sep 11, 2009 12:33 PM

    realityonetwo – There is no difference between you and the money-grubbing nutjob. None.

  60. SwissChick says: Sep 11, 2009 12:41 PM

    Apparently, there’s a lot of these bloggers who happen to be in bed with Ben to know who he’s in bed with all the time.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!