Skip to content

Mayock "stunned" McCoy managed just 23 reps

NFL Network analyst Mike Mayock has been one of the biggest supporters of Oklahoma defensive tackle Gerald McCoy, ranking him ahead of Nebraska’s Ndamukong Suh as the best player in the 2010 NFL draft.

But Mayock said he thinks McCoy’s performance in the bench press at the scouting combine (23 repetitions of 225 pounds) is a red flag.

“When you start comparing numbers, which is what this combine is all about, in the weight room yesterday Suh did 32 and McCoy did 23,” Mayock said Monday on NFL Network. “I was stunned that McCoy only did 23 reps. That tells me he hasn’t been in the weight room the way he should have been over the last three years.”

McCoy was tied for 35th among 50 defensive linemen who benched at this year’s combine. Suh ranked sixth. The top defensive lineman, Jeff Owens of Georgia, got 44 reps of 225 pounds. The worst showing went to Antonio Coleman of Auburn, who managed 18 reps.

Permalink 43 Comments Feed for comments Latest Stories in: Rumor Mill, Sprint Football Live - Rumors, Top Stories
43 Responses to “Mayock "stunned" McCoy managed just 23 reps”
  1. tre_fizzle says: Mar 1, 2010 11:29 AM

    Ha! And “little” McCluster put up 20!

  2. Citizen Strange says: Mar 1, 2010 11:29 AM

    “I was stunned that McCoy only did 23 reps. That tells me he hasn’t been in the weight room the way he should have been over the last three years.”
    …. So does that mean there is more upside once McCoy goest to s pro team that will start making him put in the work in the weight room?
    In other words if McCoy played that great without being a dedicated gym rat workout warrior imagine how good he’ll be once he starts.

  3. KingJoe! says: Mar 1, 2010 11:33 AM

    Or McCoy doesnt want to play for the Rams. Mayock is a complete tool Ignore that bag.

  4. last starfighter says: Mar 1, 2010 11:36 AM

    Don’t guys with really long arms typically do fewer reps? They have to push the weight farther which takes more power. I’m not sure how he stacks up with other guys in that respect but come one, aren’t you the one with your nose in the air over how scouts the take combine test results too seriously? Make up your mind already.

  5. AutumnWind999 says: Mar 1, 2010 11:36 AM

    Mayock might be right, but people should realize that it’s much, much harder for long-armed big guys to put up big bench press numbers than smaller barrel-chested guys. Some people will look at the number and think it means McCoy is only as strong as some QBs and DBs who put up around the same number — which is ridiculous.

  6. BigBoy says: Mar 1, 2010 11:36 AM

    As a loyal follower from the early days…I’m boycotting any companies with these invasive ads. Count on it. Your content aint that great anymore Florio.

  7. blacktoothgrin says: Mar 1, 2010 11:43 AM

    23 reps? thats pathetic for a guy his size that is ranked so high. I watches Dexter McCluster, a 172 lb RB crank out 20 yesterday. I’m sure McCoy has lots of other intangibles and whatnot, but he’s gonna need to step in up for the NFL

  8. se18a29 says: Mar 1, 2010 11:44 AM

    Who cares…

  9. CanadianVikingFan says: Mar 1, 2010 11:44 AM

    He probably just blew his 1st round chances.
    Now if I was Antonio Coleman, I wouldn’t even bother showing up..

  10. WarrenMoonGOAT says: Mar 1, 2010 11:45 AM

    i’m stunned mayock can’t even lift 225

  11. tombrookshire says: Mar 1, 2010 11:47 AM

    Would love to see Mayock press 225 pounds 23 times. Ain’t easy for a guy in super great shape let alone a “reporter.” Most he’s lifting this week is 16 oz.

  12. WTE says: Mar 1, 2010 11:54 AM

    Gosh, there’s nothing more exciting than combine talk.
    I can’t wait for the broad jumps to ~zzzzzzzzzzzzzzz~
    Huh? What?

  13. Dawgpound2009 says: Mar 1, 2010 12:00 PM

    Dear Mr. Holmgren :
    Please do not draft anyone named “Mccoy” in the 2010 draft unless his first name is Leonard H. and you need a team doctor.
    Sincerely:
    Gerrard Warren and Tim Couch

  14. Big Stretch says: Mar 1, 2010 12:02 PM

    Please stop calling it the Underwear Olympics. I know it was cute at first because the Winter Olympics were going on at the same time, but it’s become really annoying and the saying isn’t accurate.
    Maybe if it was sponsored by Hanes it would make sense, but it just really comes off as you trying to be cooler than you are. We have all seen you on those amateur looking PFTV posts and everyone is already aware that you were, are, and always will be the geek who finally got the jocks to pay attention.

  15. mnmaverick says: Mar 1, 2010 12:10 PM

    This bud’s for you Florio….
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jhETfAnnUr4&NR=1

  16. RayDaMayor says: Mar 1, 2010 12:12 PM

    So is McCoy going to be bench pressing barbells this fall or sacking QB’s? Just wondering…

  17. Thor says: Mar 1, 2010 12:17 PM

    Can’t blame the Auburn guy for finishing last. He was probably spending his spare time in the library coloring with their new crayons.

  18. chief says: Mar 1, 2010 12:20 PM

    what’s he squat???? As a lineman, I’d like to know how he can use his lower half more than arms. Arms are important, but leverage is everything.

  19. Shawn says: Mar 1, 2010 12:23 PM

    I believe Mayock and not KingJoe!, McCoy probably hasen’t been in the weight room like he should have. Why wouldn’t you want to be first pick? You make more money than anyone else, usually.

  20. allnstride says: Mar 1, 2010 12:24 PM

    Last I checked football isn’t played while laying on a bench and pushing players into the sky for reps. Unless you want your defensive lineman face up on the ground with the opposing team’s lineman pancaked on top of them. In which case you rightly deserve to have the 32nd ranked run defense. Further, regular bench press isn’t even hitting the correct angle that these players will be in while taking on opponents. If anything, incline bench is a better test exercise. Regardless, strength is only one factor to consider because football is really a game of collisions where large moving masses collide with other large moving masses with the winner being the one who generated the greatest amount of momentum (mass X velocity). Maxing out on a bench press doesn’t accurately reflect this. While 23 reps isn’t impressive, it is adequate enough to demonstrate that his strength is sufficient for the rigors of NFL football. So what does his film tell us? Prior to this “test” he was the consensus #2 overall prospect behind Suh. This shouldn’t change that perception. Besides, McCoy is a penetrating tackle who relies more on his athleticism than strength alone.

  21. Babie Hoodie says: Mar 1, 2010 12:24 PM

    I love how you clowns on this site make references to arm length, yet fail to do any legitimate research:
    Suh’s Arm Length: 33 1/2 in.
    McCoy’s Arm Length: 33 3/4 in.
    So what is your excuse for him benching 225 9 less times than Suh again?

  22. raiders177 says: Mar 1, 2010 12:32 PM

    Did anyone else think this was initially about Colt McCoy?

  23. We need linemen says: Mar 1, 2010 12:34 PM

    It’s hard to judge just from watching the videos but there seem to be huge disparities between how much extension in the arms each player produced per rep.
    No one seemed to be making sure that every one locked their arms on each rep. McCoy seemed to use a pretty narrow grip and locked his arm out whilst Jeff Owens used a wide grip and appeared to keep a pretty decent elbow bend. I wouldn’t have counted many his 44.
    Suh had pretty good form and produced the better performance, but McCoy’s primary failing seemed to be to be that it looked more like a work out than an attempt to try and get away with as little lifting as possible so that he could pump out the maximum number of reps.
    I was shocked, considering the importance placed on these tests, you would think they would want apply a consistant standard.

  24. Whiskeytangofoxtrot says: Mar 1, 2010 12:35 PM

    These idiot pundits, and their ridiculous obsession with raw numbers, crack me up. The so-called “draft geniuses” are the same guys who let Jerry Rice slide down to the 2nd half of Round 1 because he was “too slow”, who let Joe Montana slide to the 3rd round because he was “too small” and didn’t have a “big arm”, and who vaulted Cryin’ Ryan Leaf to #1 overall pick because of his size and arm strength, despite having more red flags than a Chairman Mao parade. Bottom line – these guys might as well use a dart board, since too often they don’t pay attention to stuff that counts, like character and how good of a football player the prospects are.

  25. Browns_fan_in_therapy says: Mar 1, 2010 12:48 PM

    raiders177… I did. Brady Quinn probably read the headline and sent out a challenge to poor Colt.

  26. Louie says: Mar 1, 2010 1:00 PM

    Can someone please clarify, all the other articles I’ve seen have McCoy doing 26 reps, not 23. Which is it?

  27. TrueFan says: Mar 1, 2010 1:14 PM

    Hey “Big Stretch”
    You know what is REALLY tiresome? People who come to this site, and then complain about the content as if they are expert bloggers.
    It’s HIS blog
    He’s been successful doing it
    He’s a respected NFL source
    He can write any dang thing on it he wants
    Please, please, PLEASE go away from here and stop trying to talk to the author of the blog as if he listens to you or cares at all what you think.
    Just go elsewhere if you don’t like it.

  28. mnmaverick says: Mar 1, 2010 1:18 PM

    Height can affect balance, not sure about length affecting strength.
    Short folks usually have better balance than tall folks. But strength? That’s a reach.

  29. brasho says: Mar 1, 2010 1:23 PM

    Attention dummies and non-weightlifters:
    McCoy’s pathetic number of reps of 225 (yes, it is pathetic when a guy 100 lbs heavier than me benches 225 for fewer reps than I do it is pathetic) doesn’t mean he is not strong, it just means he was not dedicated in the weightroom.
    If a player is not dedicated in the weightroom then it is apparent that he has not been doing the little things to get better at his craft. This is a redflag.
    For those of you who think that he’ll be even better once he dedicates himself, you have to realize that once he starts getting paid, his actualy dedication will likely fade even more. People just don’t learn how to be dedicated over night, it is something that has always been a part of you, and if McCOy isn’t dedicated now, he won’t be once you stick a bunch of money in his face.

  30. Buff_bronc_fan says: Mar 1, 2010 1:32 PM

    Mayock’s point–which is clearly stated in Florio’s post–is not that McCoy isn’t strong or that you have to do well in the bench press to be a good D-tackle… It’s that he obviously hasn’t been doing as much weight training as some of his peers or he would have been able to get more reps up…
    That’s his only point. If you’re going to invest $30 million + on a kid, you’d like to know his work ethic is top notch.

  31. JollyRoger says: Mar 1, 2010 1:34 PM

    Dawgpound2009 says:
    March 1, 2010 12:00 PM
    Dear Mr. Holmgren :
    Please do not draft anyone named “Mccoy” in the 2010 draft unless his first name is Leonard H. and you need a team doctor.
    ___________________________________
    This made me LOL.
    chief says:
    March 1, 2010 12:20 PM
    what’s he squat???? As a lineman, I’d like to know how he can use his lower half more than arms. Arms are important, but leverage is everything.
    ___________________________________
    This is a good question.

  32. last starfighter says: Mar 1, 2010 1:58 PM

    # TrueFan says: March 1, 2010 1:14 PM
    Hey “Big Stretch”
    You know what is REALLY tiresome? People who come to this site, and then complain about the content as if they are expert bloggers.
    It’s HIS blog
    He’s been successful doing it
    He’s a respected NFL source
    He can write any dang thing on it he wants
    Please, please, PLEASE go away from here and stop trying to talk to the author of the blog as if he listens to you or cares at all what you think.
    Just go elsewhere if you don’t like it.
    ————————————————————
    Is that you Florio?
    Seriously though, these guys aren’t really any more football experts than us commenters are. They never played or coached or even worked in a front office. Just because they figured out how to stir up hits on a blog doesn’t mean theyknow sh*t about football.

  33. Cameltoecleavage says: Mar 1, 2010 2:00 PM

    Prolly only put up 23 so he’ll drop and not be stuck on the rams and never be heard from again like chris long

  34. Big Stretch says: Mar 1, 2010 2:08 PM

    @TrueFan says:
    hey douche bag all i was saying is that the term underwear olympics is stupid.
    it’s called the “NFL combine” or the “combine”
    using underwear olympics instead is like calling giving someone a nickname that is longer than their real name i.e. TrueFanOfPenis instead of just TrueFan

  35. Pantherfan10 says: Mar 1, 2010 2:28 PM

    Ofcourse he hasn’t worked out, he’s been resting/rehabbing injured shoulder. Bench press and pushups are a no-no when doing so.

  36. Big Stretch says: Mar 1, 2010 2:33 PM

    P.S. Truefan how does Florio’s ass taste?

  37. dlr4skins says: Mar 1, 2010 2:43 PM

    MayCock is an idiot.
    I suggest he bow out now and fix his lisp before the public knows what the league already does…. that is he’s not respected among talent evaluators.

  38. Big Stretch says: Mar 1, 2010 2:47 PM

    @last starfighter
    Is that you Florio?
    Seriously though, these guys aren’t really any more football experts than us commenters are. They never played or coached or even worked in a front office. Just because they figured out how to stir up hits on a blog doesn’t mean theyknow sh*t about football.
    ————————————————–
    my thoughts exactly

  39. andfitch82 says: Mar 1, 2010 3:15 PM

    I can see this effecting him. Or I don’t see it effecting him.
    Didn’t Chris Williams only put up 22 bench reps at the combine last year? He still went 14th overall.

  40. CTifer says: Mar 1, 2010 3:39 PM

    “…. So does that mean there is more upside once McCoy goest to s pro team that will start making him put in the work in the weight room?
    In other words if McCoy played that great without being a dedicated gym rat workout warrior imagine how good he’ll be once he starts.”
    Yes, that’s an excellent point you bring up because as everyone knows, lazy people all of a sudden become ‘gym rat workout warriors’ once the checks start coming in.
    ……………………………
    Perfect example of a fat guy dominating little guys in college. I was intrigued by him until I saw this. You’re that big you better put up some fantastic strength numbers because almost everyone in the Pros will be more athletic than what he went against in the NCAA / High School.

  41. Kevin from Philly says: Mar 1, 2010 4:19 PM

    Dawgpound2009 says:
    March 1, 2010 12:00 PM
    Dear Mr. Holmgren :
    Please do not draft anyone named “Mccoy” in the 2010 draft unless his first name is Leonard H. and you need a team doctor.
    For God’s sake, I’m a doctor not a damn General Manager!

  42. edgy1957 says: Mar 1, 2010 5:49 PM

    I think it says a lot more than some people want to admit. Let’s face it, PRESUMABLY, Suh has been making the rounds on the banquet circuit and yet, he shows up to the Combine in better shape than a lot of guys who didn’t. Mayock was talking up McCoy and then he comes in and while he may not have blown his shot at a Top 5 pick, I think he blew a chance at the top pick. Unlike QBs, his pro day will be pretty close to what he did at the Combine and he may disappoint a lot of others like Andre “Biscuit Factory” Smith did last year when he showed up out of shape to the Combine and then didn’t impress anyone at his pro day. The Bengals still took a flier on him and after a holdout, he shows up and breaks his foot.

  43. Route36West says: Mar 1, 2010 8:30 PM

    McCoy said he wasnt a rep guy and all the idiots at the combine doing the talking said they have no clue what that means.
    Its simple when McCoy goes to the weight he does low rep of large weights. So after warming up he might be doing sets of 3 at 375lbs+. The guys that are rep guys do sets of 225 lbs 15-20 times.
    I dont know why thats so hard to understand. I mean even if you dont lift weights its not that hard to figure out.
    Doing alot of reps of lower wieghts helps endurance and builds your fast twitch muscles. While doing low reps of alot weight builds pure power.
    If your high school football team had a weight lifting program you know what Im talking about. You might start out at 8 reps of 135. Then move on to 8 reps 155 then 6 reps of 185 to warm up.
    After that you might switch to 5 reps of 225 and then 3 at 250 until your down to 1 rep each time you switch the weight until you meet your max out.
    Thats how you build pure power which is what you need when your young and trying to improve your strength.
    Power lifters like to adjust their weights often during worksout when rep lifters like to just stay at 1 weight the whole.
    Its not hard to understand.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!