Oops, I gave the class of 2004 an extra Lombardi. Just a little XLV denial there

That guy said best QB class “athletically”. If you take their stats from the combine and combine it with Pryor’s–he’s totally correct.
————————————————-
No, actually hobartbaker said:

“Pryor makes this the best overall QB class in history, I’d say.”

Then he went on to discuss their athletic stats. And I maintain that we can’t evaluate their “overall” place in history until we see what they accomplish in terms of starts, wins, championships, pro stats, and to be completely fair, Hall of Fame berths.

The Class of 83′s John Elway, Jim Kelly, and Dan Marino may not have had the physicality of Cam Newton and Tyrell Pryor, but they played in 10 Super Bowls, won two Lombardis, and are all in the Hall of Fame. So far 2004′s Roethlisberger, Rivers, and Eli Manning have played in four Super Bowls and have four Lombardis. Right now, we don’t know if any of the QB class of 2011 will start or even last more than three years. To crown them the best overall is ridiculously premature. Spread QBs like Newton and Pryor are entertaining. But so far, they haven’t been winning a lot of Super Bowls.

That guy said best QB class “athletically”. If you take their stats from the combine and combine it with Pryor’s–he’s totally correct.

dont do it Uncle Al..didnt you learn your lesson with JaWalrus?

***

So you’re comparing a first overall draft pick, on which Al Davis was the envy of several other owners for Russell’s potential, with a kid that has shown huge potential on the field yet has had so many problems OFF the field, he has already been suspended by the NFL before taking one snap, even in practice. He didn’t even qualify for the draft in the first place. Pryor appears to have lots of tools and potential and might get into a roster on the practice squad. His recent mentors all claim that”he’s a great kid and has a great attitude and great potential, and learns a great deal and has already learned from his mistakes, and hey, we all make mistakes, and hey, he’s a great kid and deserves an NFL shot”.

JaMarcus Russell was given it all on a silver and black platter with diamonds and pearls and every bell and whistle imaginable. Russell blew it all out his butt. That’s why Russell is the trivia answer we all know. Pryor will have to bust his little ass for years to even get a chance to play, no matter the position.

Your logic is nonexistent, dork.

If not….Welcome to Megalow Mart! My name is Terelle, would you like a cart?

[Kevin Colbert the GM is there]

Or I may be talking through my cheeks.

….

Is this where we talk about his intelligence or lack there of? Wasn’t he like a Dean List type guy or something? I’m sure all me ‘neck friends will gladly tell us why he’s bust waiting to happen and why no team will be interested. Oh yeah and why he shouldn’t even be allowed to play in the NFL. Sorry, I’m late.

Best QB class in history? Let’s revisit that in about five years. You’re counting your chickens way to early.

I don’t think you understand how the practice squad works.

From his freshman year, all I could see is a raw Randall Cunningham. Someone is going to develop this talent.

What a corner this guy would be…or a receiver? If he is adamant that he wants to be a QB, then it wouldn’t work for the Steelers unless they could work him as an option.

My guess, Redskins!