NFL reminds teams not to simulate snap counts

AP

The Cowboys and Titans complained last weekend about the simulation of snap counts by the defenses of the Redskins and Broncos, respectively.  Cowboys owner Jerry Jones said Friday that the league has reminded all teams that such conduct is forbidden.

“That notice came out from the league this week, so I know that the league is looking at it,” Jones told KRLD-FM, via Tim MacMahon of ESPNDallas.com.  “We in general though are approaching it, we’ve just got to make it work.  We’ve got to get in here and have our count and have our snaps and not make it a point of concern for our quarterback and certainly not make it a point of concern for the game, because those are like turnovers and can be turnovers and do stop drives.”

The problem, as former NFL V.P. of officiating Mike Pereira pointed out during an appearance this week on PFT Live, is that the movement of the umpire from his former position behind the defensive line to a new position behind the offense leaves no official in position to hear what the defensive linemen may be saying to prompt offensive linemen to jump early — or to trick the center into snapping the ball in shotgun formation before the quarterback is ready for it.

The umpire returns to his traditional position in the final five minutes of each half.  For the other 50 minutes of each game, however, there’s currently no effective way of catching culprits along the defensive line.

As a result, offensive teams will have to figure out how to deal with it.

“There’s been noise on the line of scrimmage in the NFL since Pudge Heffelfinger was around,” Cowboys coach Jason Garrett said Thursday, via MacMahon.  “So, that’s how it works.  We just have to understand what the issues are there and we have to focus on whose voices we’re listening to and just get locked in and snap the ball the way it needs to be snapped.”

For Cowboys center Phil Costa, who apparently was duped multiple times by former Cowboys and current Redskins defensive lineman Stephen Bowen on Monday night, that’s apparently far easier said than done.

56 responses to “NFL reminds teams not to simulate snap counts

  1. The coaches in the NFL are always in search of the next loophole……looks like the DEF coach figured out that with the position of the umpire his men can get away with more.

    That is why good coaches in football are a great need.

  2. What a crock. They want me to believe that the on-field officiating crew can’t hear the calls, but the players can? That’s incredulous. If they contend that it was continuous, why didn’t they tell the refs to get it stopped? BOGUS!

  3. Defenses get blamed for a lot these days, but I just don’t understand how a center can be induced to snap the ball by D-linemen. Even if they are able to mimic the cadence, they can’t know the count. And unless they practice ventriloquism, how hard is it to realize the QB is behind you not in front of you? If the crowd noise is such that the center can’t hear, go silent count.

  4. shouldn’t the center know the damn snap count? Offensive lineman like Costa shouldn’t be coddled…it’s a loud stadium, who cares if the defender says ‘hike’

  5. Can’t really blame the defense for trying to gain an edge with the game clearly headed towards an offensive advantage.

  6. Here’s a thought: keep the umpire where he is, and just add another umpire to the field to put in the traditional umpire position. An extra set of eyes on the field can’t hurt too much and may help them catch most of the crap they’ve been somehow managing to miss.

  7. Stephen Bowen called Phil Costa a liar. So, it appears you are in agreement with Costa and are calling Bowen a liar.

    Shanahan says the center’s are mic’d up. A better article would have also investigated that angle instead of lazily ending with a “he said, she said” finish.

  8. sooo people are stealing signals? across the league? fine everyone half a mil and a first round pick. oh wait i guess that only happens when you win 3 out of 4 super bowls and your team is destroying everyone

  9. How many years until Goodell limits the number of pass rushers and the game becomes Pro Bowl like?

  10. If you go back and look at some of those bad snaps, other Cowboys offensive linemen were firing off at the same time Costa was. Somebody had to have been barking out the count because it obviously wasn’t Romo.

  11. Phil Costa botched four snaps and simply wants a scapegoat… he just plain sucks. The only non-Romo snap count that he heard came from the voices in his head.

    Centers are vicariously mic’d up (due to their proximity to the QB)… don’t you think we would’ve heard the audio by now if there was any truth to Costa’s ridiculous claims?

  12. Darn it…Albert Haynesworth who has one tackle so far could have added this skill to his repertoire; and quite possibly EARNED the paycheck he has collected for years.

  13. Yea, and if you’re standing on 2nd base don’t look at the catcher’s signs to the pitcher either…

  14. Yes, just boys being boys.

    Unless the Patriots are doing it, then it’s a ten million dollar fine and the loss of that year’s draft and cries of outrage that every Patriot win since the dawn of time is now tainted.

  15. So because Costa said it happened, that make it factual? No possibility he just sucks and is lying, huh?

  16. During the game, Romo the “brave courageous leader” never complained to the officials, nor did Costa. His highness only yelled at the center. Seems to me a fabricated excuse to save face after the fact.

  17. Why should it be wrong for the defense to simulate snap counts? The qb’s do it with a hard count all the time.

  18. As shannahan pointed out, centers are mic’d now a days so would seem pretty easy to prove if happened. More likely costa who also had bad snaps against jets got tired of explaining himself so took cowardly way out.

  19. Didn’t Shanahan say center’s are miked now? Or is it only for certain games? Couldn’t they replay the audio and hear what the center was hearing?

  20. They have microphones that can pick up what the lineman are saying. Use the mics and tell the players if the are caught it will be a five game suspension. The problem will stop.

  21. The league brings these issues on themselves. Maybe if they would not have 2 sets of rules taking place (booth replays only in final 2 mins of the half, umpires relocating in final 5) during a game, they’d have more control.

  22. …”who was apparently duped”? How about some actual proof of ANY sort before you jump on that bandwagon? One guy who played maybe the worst game any pro center has played the last decade or more is whining a major league copout whine after he was humiliated on National TV.

    He was mic’ed up during the game and whattaya know, not a single thing showed up there and that would have picked up any “signals” called out loud enough to affect anyone on the Offense. If these snap counts were being called out and the Redskins were cheating then why was Costa the only guy biting, why not a single false start or even a whiff of one from the other linemen? If this was happening why is Costa the ONLY one who evidently picked up on it? No other linemen, no TE’s no RB’s, no WR’s not even the QB….why exactly is that? Does Costa have bionic hearing no one else on the field does?

    Last but certainly not least, 4 out of the 6 bad snaps came on shotgun formation plays where THERE IS NO SNAP COUNT. No one to blame there but Costa. If the Redskins were calling out snaps then
    a. the rest of the team would have heard them on silent counts and
    b. he shouldn’t have had any problems on shotgun snaps anyway since he’s waiting for the QB to signal visually that he’s ready for the ball.

    Please PFT…for the love of all humanity stop giving this guy’s bunk voice without the derisive breakdown it deserves.

  23. Lions got called for this week 1 against the Bucs. I had never heard the ruling before, but this clears it up.

  24. I was under the impression that half the players on the field were miles up at any one time. Surely, because the miles are part of NFL Films that if the NFL wanted to, they could mike up linemen and then listen to them.

  25. I’m not for players and coaches cheating, but really now, as a center you can’t tell if the snap call is coming from a line man in front of you or your QB behind you?, and I’m sure they know the difference in players voice. If not you must be pretty stupid. But if the NFL wants to change things around I can’t blame coaches and teams to scheme and find loop holes to use as an advantage. Footballs a game of scheme and match ups.

  26. Bad thing about it is, all week they made a big deal over a rookie center making up the entire story!! Where is the follow up that acknowledges the guy was lying?? Next time maybe the NFL should send reminders out for guys not to make up stories if he muffs the snap counts on his own but lies instead of owning up to his F’ ups! Only the cowgirls would get a win and whine

  27. Centers and QBs often get mic’d up by NFL films for no reason at all. Why wouldn’t they volunteer to do it every week as long as only the league could review the tape?

  28. Thumbs up if you think Pudge Heffelfinger is the most awesome name ever.

    Had to google this guy and he actually did exist and is apparently the first football player to get paid for playing ($500 for a game in 1892).

  29. Has it even been confirmed that the Redskins d-line was simulating the snap count? Costa was miked for the game so they should be able to listen and see if the snap count was simulated. Have there been any reports about this yet? I haven’t heard of anything. If they really were simulating the snap count, wouldn’t we have heard about it in the news already?

  30. He was mic’ed up during the game and whattaya know, not a single thing showed up there

    ———————–

    Where did you hear this audio?

  31. What a crock. They want me to believe that the on-field officiating crew can’t hear the calls, but the players can? That’s incredulous.

    ———————

    Why, considering the fact that the refs are a good 10 yards or so behind the line of scrimmage, now?

  32. Well lets see if Costa costs the girls another butterfinger snap…….maybe the skins will fax the snap count to the rams…….then the girls can whine about that. I mean the girls won the game and they still whine. If that dont beat all.

  33. At the risk of being ID’d a dinosaur, whatever became of sportsmanship?

    The multi-million dollar paychecks at stake would be my guess.

  34. you people will find anything to bitch about the cowboys. they won the Damn game, why would they be making up excuses? get over it, yes they are netter then your team.

  35. Well, my comment from last night has miraculously disappeared!

    The Centers are mic’ed up to provide audio since the judge is no longer close enough to the action.

    If there was something to this it, the NFL would have the smoking gun since Costa had a mic on him the whole game.

    Just another example of Jerruh calls and Goodell jumps!

Leave a Reply