He is a good coach- wins off of byes, prime time wins, and improves as the season goes on are ways to prove this. He has gotten tremendous value from the QBs he’s moved on from, and they have both played terribly elsewhere. If he were fired, he’d have his next job pretty quickly.

But in 12 years as coach, Andy’s teams have NEVER played well and are disorganized in pressure situations. Clock management is atrocious. Short yardage playcalling is always under fire. This year, ahead of all others, there has been absolutely no sense in how this team is coordinated (Shady-28, 30 touches = 2 wins in a row, 14 carries the next wk, loss. No Nnamdi in press coverage on Fitz).

The Eagles have been terrible defensively since Jim Johnson passed (rip). Andy Reid now has no answers on D, and hired a guy with no experience as his coordinator. His drafts over the past 2 years have yielded squat.

Thumbs up if you want to keep Andy Reid, perhaps with stripping him of all duties outside of coaching the team.

Thumbs down if you want him gone.