Your Thursday Michael Vick update

AP

So will Michael Vick play on Sunday night against the Giants?

It depends on who you ask.  ESPN’s Adam Schefter says Vick is unlikely to play.  Almost all of the Eagles beat writers think Vick won’t play.

Eagles offensive coordinator Marty Mornhingweg disagrees, saying he’s “optimistic” Vick will play.

“He’s a tough guy and he wants to play,” Mornhinweg said Thursday. “He’s tough mentally and physically and he’s doing everything he can, so we’ll see.”

Nick Fierro of the Morning Call isn’t seeing it.

“Don’t care how tough Vick is.  He ain’t playing Sunday.  Just saw him a minute ago.  He could barely walk,” Fierro said.

It sounds like Vince Young is preparing to make his first Eagles start. Vick didn’t practice Thursday. If Vick doesn’t get on the practice field Friday, we won’t probably won’t hear any more conflicting information.

54 responses to “Your Thursday Michael Vick update

  1. I think it could be done (playing with broken ribs) if you are talking a drop back–pocket passer, which Vick isn’t.
    On his best day he gets hit a dozen times, any one of which could send him off on a stretcher.

  2. Guess they have to play Vince Young, as they stupidly gave him a butt-load of money for just this. He’s still terrible however.

  3. Dunce Young has just been confirmed to start and Las Vegas just gave an extra 8 points to the Eagles.

  4. *Somehow this will turn into a bash Vick post….
    *This deserves to be a bash Vince “mentally” Young post….

  5. hopefully he does play and the giants end his season once and for all. also, the giants dont have the greatest track record against back-ups in general, or against vince young specifically. the guy who i hope doesnt play is maclin.

  6. Why does anyone care anymore?? He’s a long way away from where he was last year when all you media ppl were on his jock. NO ONE besides eagle fans and the loser falcon fans still holding their Vick jerseys still give a crap about him. You all had given the Eagles the Lombardi before preseason even started,its quite amusing to me.

  7. All this commotion over a dead 3-6 team! Who cares who plays QB, RB or fat head coach. The Iggles are done. Let’s move on to the teams that have a shot at winning a title shall we?

  8. The “Dream” has turned into a nightmare for Eagles fans.
    Remember; there’s no “I” in Dream, I mean Team, haha!

  9. Taking a week off is probably for the best. He just hasn’t been the same player as he was in 2010. I don’t know if it’s the new contract or the lack of a real preseason. Seems like it’s been a real struggle for Vick this season though.

  10. “Vick doesn’t get on the practice field Friday, we won’t probably won’t hear any more conflicting information.”

    Proofreading REALLY isn’t that difficult….

  11. JHANDCOKE wants Vick to play so the Giants can end his season. O.K. i hope Eli catches a helmet on the knee. i beleive people on here like the word KARMA.

  12. bangitfootball says:
    Nov 17, 2011 3:29 PM
    Dunce Young has just been confirmed to start and Las Vegas just gave an extra 8 points to the Eagles.
    ————-
    Giants’ fan here. Was taking the Eagles anyway but if this is true, I’m betting my kid’s college fund.

  13. if Vick cant start,, then that would say Tony Romo is tougher than Mike Vick.. Just another slap in the pants to the Eagles…

    I never once thought that signing Vince Young was a smart move. Especially since they only gave him a one year deal.
    Now all the unknowledgeable fans will say, “we can just trade him after the season.” How can we?/ he’s and unrestricted FA..

    Also, Kafka has been in our system for 2 years, he has the knowledge to be competitent. .
    I’d like to have Kafka start & keep the gameplan run heavy.. That might show Andy that a balanced attack is necessary.

    but instead VY will start, we will throw 80% of the plays & Shady will only get 14 carries again.. Pack your bags mister Reid.

  14. Will he at least give a postgame press conference? Not sure I can go a week without staring into those dead eyes.

  15. for those making comments about romo allegedly
    playing with broken ribs and a punctured lung, (and you really believe this) please call me as i have some oceanfront property in the midwest i’m looking to unload.

  16. The only Vick update that matters is his UPDATED DEPARTURE SCHEDULE-
    out of Philly and off of my favorite team!

    At least Bad Newz will prove to be instrumental in getting us a new Head Coach. :mrgreen:

  17. All Vick has done this season is prove he’s the same guy ON THE TURF he was in Atlanta. Flashes of greatness but serious inconsistency issues.

  18. m.e.c.w. – Worry not. McCoy will run 30 times for a buck-fitty with 8 catches for another 75. Eagles will win 27-21 and be right back in the race. Giants’ fan here has seen it too many times.

  19. Start Kafka so you can start the trade bait for next year! They won’t be worse with Young if he starts. The general public’s love (or hate) for Vick doesn’t mean he’s really all that good.

  20. greymares says: Nov 17, 2011 4:11 PM

    JHANDCOKE wants Vick to play so the Giants can end his season. O.K. i hope Eli catches a helmet on the knee. i beleive people on here like the word KARMA.

    —-

    I’m pretty sure he meant that he wanted the EAGLES’ season to be ended. The TEAM, as a whole. Losing this week would certainly be the end for them. Didn’t look like an injury wish on Vick to me

  21. bhink73 says:
    Nov 17, 2011 3:36 PM
    All this commotion over a dead 3-6 team! Who cares who plays QB, RB or fat head coach. The Iggles are done. Let’s move on to the teams that have a shot at winning a title shall we?
    —————————————-
    apparently you care enough to post a comment

  22. myeaglescantwin says: Nov 17, 2011 4:12 PM

    but instead VY will start, we will throw 80% of the plays & Shady will only get 14 carries again.. Pack your bags mister Reid.
    =================================

    That’s the first time I’ve ever seen someone want a coach fired for what you THINK he’s going to do.

  23. bluefan204 says: Nov 17, 2011 4:52 PM

    greymares says: Nov 17, 2011 4:11 PM

    JHANDCOKE wants Vick to play so the Giants can end his season. O.K. i hope Eli catches a helmet on the knee. i beleive people on here like the word KARMA.

    —-

    I’m pretty sure he meant that he wanted the EAGLES’ season to be ended. The TEAM, as a whole. Losing this week would certainly be the end for them. Didn’t look like an injury wish on Vick to me
    ===================================

    Problem is, he said “his season”, not “their season”. No sale.

  24. nfloracle says:
    Nov 17, 2011 3:45 PM
    Vick isn’t as tough as Tony Romo, that’s for sure.
    ———————————————

    You are right, romo is a tough idiot

  25. xxwhodatxx says:
    Nov 17, 2011 3:35 PM
    Why does anyone care anymore?? He’s a long way away from where he was last year when all you media ppl were on his jock. NO ONE besides eagle fans and the loser falcon fans still holding their Vick jerseys still give a crap about him. You all had given the Eagles the Lombardi before preseason even started,its quite amusing to me.

    ————————————————

    Why does anyone care?………………………..For the same reason you do, which is exactly why you and the others took the time to read the article and take even more time to write a comment. You all say you don’t care and then read and write on every article written about Vick, you even take the time to find these articles, now that is what is quite amusing to me.

  26. I guess these reporters will find a need to write an article about Michael Vick if he even farts in wrong direction, and you fools will read the article and make a comment. Nothing worse than a bunch of haters, its really quite comical.

  27. greymares
    Nov 17, 2011, 4:11 PM EST
    JHANDCOKE wants Vick to play so the Giants can end his season. O.K. i hope Eli catches a helmet on the knee. i beleive people on here like the word KARMA.
    —————————–
    GM, the difference is vic deserves what he gets. Eli didnt take pride and enjoy pain inflicted on helpless animals. In this case karma is the equalizer, and as you can see, working well.

  28. karma is the equalizer,
    ===============
    karma = a 100 mil contract and stinky season. Karma’s not that bad.

  29. You could melt Vick and Young together and you still wouldn’t get one good quarterback. They are both bozos and losers.

  30. choice1329 says: Nov 17, 2011 6:01 PM

    Nothing worse than a bunch of haters, its really quite comical

    “Comical” is having to endure 2 months of how unstoppable and loaded with talent the “Dream Team” was, and how the Super Bowl was a foregone conclusion. Seeing that translate into 3-6 and constant rumblings about their $100 mil QB, and Reid, has been far more “comical”, my man. Take my word for it.

  31. Everyone is predicting a Giants blowout on Sunday, but just wait and see….Vince Young is going to throw for over 300 yards, with a couple of TDs, run for about 90 more yards and the Eagles are going to squeak out a win….27-24.

  32. bluefan204 says:
    Nov 17, 2011 8:22 PM
    choice1329 says: Nov 17, 2011 6:01 PM

    Nothing worse than a bunch of haters, its really quite comical

    “Comical” is having to endure 2 months of how unstoppable and loaded with talent the “Dream Team” was, and how the Super Bowl was a foregone conclusion. Seeing that translate into 3-6 and constant rumblings about their $100 mil QB, and Reid, has been far more “comical”, my man. Take my word
    ——————————————

    Why would I take your word for anything. Reading these comments that are full of nothing more than hate, jealousy and racism “my man” is more than comical. There is no need to take your word.

Leave a Reply