It’s time, actually past time, for Andy to leave Philadelphia. The team needs new direction and new leadership. Andy’s failings are both critical and consistent. He doesn’t “hear” the voice of experience, either, as he keeps repeating the same obvious, fundamental, head-slapping mistakes over and over. Agree 100% with joe3001 above.

Andy had some good years early on, but he has not improved with time. Methinks he was lucky with getting McNabb, Westbrook, Jim Johnson, and a young, talented team (except for WRs) during some down years in the NFC. Nothing wring with luck, but Andy will never win the SB, unless he absolutely lucks into it (which I’ve been saying for oh, 10 years).

There a lot of good coaches available, some of whom are big names and some of whom are relatively anonymous, who can and will improve the Eagles over what Andy would do. Even though Lurie hates dead money (for Andy’s contract in 2012-13), it’s time for a change.

Andy’s “luck” has run out. If Eagles fans are giving up….

BTW Tyelee, be careful what you wish for the Bucs. You may get it.

Too bad there isn’t a way to fire the Dirty Rotting Bird fans.
=====================================

Coming from a Giants fan. What will Brandon Jacobs think of you this week?

The real problem is that Reid’s poor draft choices have left the Eagles high and dry at key positions. He should be replaced, but whoever replaces him has at least one hard rebuilding year ahead.

Seen more Eagles games then I ever really cared to since then.

Trust me – Eagles fans are right. Andy Reid is TERRIBLE on game day.

The decisions he makes are incomprehensible … the only HC I’ve ever seen to be on the road with a 7 point and 2:45 left in the 4th quarter … throw the ball 3 times in a row. All incompletions. Took no time off the clock. Other team got the ball back with all their time outs and the 2 minute warning. That’s a Football 101 fail.

That’s the kind of stuff that goes on weekly with the Eagles.

flavordave says: Nov 28, 2011 8:10 AM

And a second thing about all you other fans judging Eagles fans. We were right about McNabb. So stuff that in your turkey.
—————————————————

You’ve done so well since he left.
=====================================

And somehow McNabb would have made these past two seasons better? He’s worse than Rex Grossman and Chris Ponder. ‘Nuff said.

If Lurie is going to honor the extension he signed Andy to, he needs to strip him of all player/personnel responsibilities and fire the coordinators he chose that are responsible for much of this failure in my eyes.

I know this isn’t a popular comment given the timing, but Andy Reid is a good coach. He deserves at least one offseason to bring these guys together. The coordinators do not, because they clearly cannot see the strengths and weaknessees of their players over this short term. Even the fans can….

And bring in who?????? Philly fans are morons……

**********************************************

And who exactly was Andy Reid when he was picked from obscurity by Jeff Lurie? I can guarantee you that 90% of the Eagles fans (and possibly most every day NFL fans) never heard of the guy before then either. And the only reason he got the gig, as the story goes, is that he wowed the front office with his dissertation of the long snapper’s role in the game and the big 3-ring binder he brought along with him.

Everyone is replaceable.

And a second thing about all you other fans judging Eagles fans. We were right about McNabb. So stuff that in your turkey.
—————————————————

You’ve done so well since he left.

The well respected legendary Joe “Pa” Paterno will be the new Eagles head coach. Joe is a proven winner and will bring with him staff that knows how to attract and motivate young, talented football players.
=====================================

If that actually happened I would give up my season tickets. Not that it would matter since they’d get scooped up immediately…

You keep saying ‘and hire who’. You don’t think there aren’t a million coaches out there that could take this team to a better record than the Eagles have right now? Didn’t they say ‘Who is Jon Harbaugh?’ and ‘Why Mike Smith?’ They don’t always work out, but if you don’t try, how do you know? Someone had to give Belichick a second chance. No one wanted Chan Gailey in Buffalo (Jury is still out, but they look better this year than they have in YEARS). Denver is a mess, but they’re winning with John Fox. So, yeah. Theres people out there, even if they don’t have a huge name.

The free-agent frenzy, giving Vick $100M, and agreeing to let Castillo become DC have all backfired. A good team can absorb one of those failed decisions, but not all three. Lurie has to hold someone accountable, and that person should be Reid.

He has had a nice run. But the inmates now run that asylum. They ran McNabb out of town. Kept Vick in town and now Jackson is a malcontent.