1- i never said that smith or cokehaead dont belong there.. all i said was that they got in their first ballot without any issues and outshined better players than them on the ceremony they were introduced.

2- JERY RICE > emitt smith.

3- you are an idiot! hahahaha

———————————-
No they don’t. His longevity matches up well with just about anyone.

He is not top 50 in any efficiency stat.

There are WRs who are on pace or comparable to Rice for efficiency stats. (no one quite as good as him): Andre Johnson, Fiztgerald, Irvin, Sterling Sharpe, Art Monk, Tory Holt, Don Hutson (no idea who that is), Bob Hayes, Steve Largent, Lynn Swane.

Carter is not on par with those guys

Branch has better stats than Swann – check it out..
———————————————–

You’re 100% right. On career stats, postseason stats, playing his best against the best in the biggest games, Cliff Branch is a surefire Hall of Famer to anyone he played with or against. the greatest deep threat of his era. For some reason the voters don’t see it that way.

Cliff has a better case than Carter, Reed, or Brown.

Why?

Because all he cared about was his stats. He never showed up in the big games and hurt his team almost as much as he helped even with his talent.

Football is the ultimate team game and when your teammates dont think you belong in the hall then who am I to argue?

Steve Largent was a 5’11″, 180 lb, #1 wide receiver. If you think that’s some kind of joke, you never saw him play. Even more than being a wide receiver, he was a football player. The two plays from his career that I remember the most are: 1) The hit he put on Mike Harden after an INT. Harden had cheap-shotted him in Denver earlier that year, and in the rematch, Harden gets a pick and Largent puts one of the greatest hits of all-time on him forcing a fumble and leaving Harden dizzy. Youtube search “Largent hit on Harden” for the video. 2) On a screen pass against the Bears in the 80s, he gets out front and puts a textbook block on Mike Singletary, who outweighed him by 60-70 pounds, to spring John L. Williams for a 75 yard touchdown.

Lester Hayes called Largent the best WR he ever played against. Carter would have been so much roadkill under Lester’s cleats.

I don’t hear of many old teammates complaining either.

You can’t bitch your way into the Hall.

No.”

When I think of CC, I think of “the complain”. Which is what he did to the refs every time he dropped a ball.

Branch has better stats than Swann – check it out..

Why is he not in and steve freaking media lovin largent is….

Late

hmm a little cowboy biased people?
_________________________________

Can’t decide what’s funnier…….Carter’s whining and crying, or the fact that you think there’s a bias FOR Cowboys to get into the HOF????

Where have you been??? The HOF voting committee has overlooked the Cowboys for years and with people like Balzer, Ira Ledger and especially Peter King carrying the anti-Cowboys media bias, that’s why ‘Boys fans like me get on here calling for at the very least, a fair and just process…..because Dallas has suffered from the yellow journalism and bias of the committee.

And try giving your opinion to:
- Drew Pearson
- Harvey Martin (RIP)
- Cliff Harris
- Ed Jones
- Charles Haley

There are 5 HOF-ers right there that should be in the Hall today…….for example, Harris is the only member of the NFL’s all-time 70s team NOT in the HOF.

And suggesting that Michael Irvin and Emmitt Smith shouldn’t be in the HOF shows you know nothing about football and nothing about those Cowboys teams……..

Clearly he’s a little delusional.

He has the numbers and he deserves to get in, but that’s all he has and he still doesn’t “get it”……

Every WR in the HOF has intanglibles that Carter will never have.

Irvin is in because of his leadership…..without him, those Cowboys teams would never have won 3 in 4 years.

Largent is in because he is an HOF with the numbers when he retired and he’s a class guy.

CC has none of those things and he alienated himself from virtually everyone he came in contact with.

Too bad, no one has told him this…..maybe if he came out with a mea culpa he might win back some people, but his ego is so out of control it will never happen.

hey tatum – you just proved all of our points that wide receiver is overrated and easily replaceable.

tell me in what other position can you get rid of the SUPERBOWL MVP and not miss a beat?

No – thank YOU for playing.”

Yeah, losing Larry Brown killed the Cowboys.

As long as it’s not a QB, you can likely survive the loss of one guy who happened to be the MVP of one particular game.

Also, the Steelers really, really could have used Holmes in that loss to the Packers. I absolutely think they win that game if they have him. Assuming he doesn’t pout and they still get there.

not the hall of really good…

Rice and Carter played during the same era.

Rice has 8000 more yards, 67 more TDs, and 20 yards per game more.

Carter is not even top 50 in the efficiency metrics.

What about Carter makes him a HOFer?

He was great, no doubt, he was not a HOFer.
___________________________________

if you’re going to compare WR’s to Jerry Rice then no WR will ever make the HOF ever again. He’s the GOAT, comparing other’s stats to him is completely unfair. Take away Jerry Rice and Cris Carter’s stats match up well with just about any WR. 130 TD’s alone means he should be in the Hall.

hmm a little cowboy biased people?