The QB’s you mentioned can actually throw the football. You mentioned Tebow not having any INT’s. It’s hard for defenders to get INT’s when the ball is thrown out of bounds or 20 yds away from the receiver they are covering. Tom Brady took a 1-4 team to the Superbowl and won in his first year as a starter so Tebow’s accomplishment is nothing. TJ Yates led the Texans to the second round as well. Why isn’t he 95 on the list? Aaron Rodgers and Big Ben went one and out in the playoffs. They are still a lot better than Tebow.

As for “all the records” he has. He has a bunch of single game records for throwing deep balls against a beat up Steelers secondary. He also has a game winning drive record. A really good QB ensures his team isn’t in a situation to have to get game winning drives.

He’s on the list to promote outrage within anyone possessing a functioning brain, and to validate the beliefs of the people without one.

How did Sanchez do in the playoffs? That is my point. What Tebow did against the number 1 defense, breaking records, is far more important to the argument than playing bad against the 31st ranked defense. Tebow didn’t allow 6 touchdowns to Brady did he? The fact that you think his 9-26 136 yard no int performance is the worst in post season is laughable and shows you just will not give him credit. You really think it was worse than Flaccos 13-30 141 yards and 3 picks? Is it worse than Delhommes 5 ints? Worse than Mcnabbs 10-22 100 yards and 3 picks? How about Morton’s 4-15 39 yards and 4 picks? The only difference is those guys weren’t in their 16th start.

You forgot to mention one game. As a Patriots fan, I watched every second of it. You must remember it. It was quite possibly the worst QB playoff performance of all time. Against the 31st ranked defense. If you are going to use playoff performance in your argument. At least use his whole playoff performance.

Tebow had 6 lost fumbles. I never said Tebow was a better player because of rush yards. I said you chose to use stats without using all of them. My logic is this is the top 100 players from last season. Sanchez led a team that had just gone to the AFC championship, starting out 0-0, to an 8-8 record. Tebow led a team that had the number 2 overall pick, started out 1-4 and was 7-26 to a 7-5 record and a win over the number 1 rated defense. That is my Logic and that is all. Thank you.

Well if we are going to look at the players as running backs. During the season, both players scored 6 rushing TDs. Tebow ran for 660 yds with 13 fumbles. Sanchez had 103 yds with 10 fumbles. So with your logic, Tebow is the better player because he had more rushing yards than Sanchez.

Of those 8 wins the broncos had, Tebow started 7 of them. They were 1-4 when he took over. You also forgot the 800 yards rushing and rushing TD’s. Nice try though

1. Both the Jets and Broncos went 8-8. The only reason Denver made the playoffs was because of a weak division. Obviously 8-8 isn’t going to win the AFC East.
2. Of those 8 wins, Sanchez played all the games. Tebow didn’t even start until halfway through the season.
3. Sanchez – 308-543, 3474 yds, 56.7% comp, 26-18 TD/INT, 78.2 rating.
4. Tebow – 126/271, 1729 yds, 46.5% comp, 12-6 TD/INT, 72.9 rating.

I’m a Pats fan and dislike Sanchez, but definitely believe he is a better QB than Tebow.

Then again I am just a “Tebowmaniac” because I think he is a good young QB.

You see, you have to be a Tebow Lover and crazy right wing fanatic, to think he is good. Not the greatest QB to ever live, with no room for improvement. Just good. You are a crazy Tebowmaniac unless you call him a fullback and say every throw he makes hits the dirt.

Most of us “Tebowmaniacs” just see him as a young QB who took a really bad team to the playoffs and don’t really understand why people hate him. Does he need to get better and improve his completion %? Absolutely! But you cannot do what he did last year, while breaking records and be as horrible as everyone makes him out to be.

That’s why there is debate if Peyton manning should appear on the list at all. He’s obviously one of the top players but he didn’t play last year.

http://www.nfl.com/news/story/09000d5d8288db51/article/nfl-films-ranks-tim-tebow-above-campbell-allen-on-heisman-list

Will other networks jump on this ratings bandwagon ?
7th rated national park is…Tim Tebow
9th most dangerous predator…Tim Tebow
2nd ranked deity of all time…

Wake me up when they accomplish something worth reading about. Meanwhile snore, snore.

I don’t get it….the NFL doesn’t need bad players to boost ratings, yet we are bombarded with Tebow ad nauseum even when he is clearly NOT an NFL QB.

I seriously doubt that NFL players “voted” for Teblow.