u must not be a giants fan clearly because youd know our defense was by the bottom all the way up until the playoffs..eli personally got us there and personally won us that year.

2 rings 2 sb mvps.. im sure when everyone sits back and really thinks about it to themselves theyd take eli over 23-25 other qbs

Compare that inconsistency to Brees/Rodgers;
Brees may look human for a game or 2 a season – other than that he’s an Unstoppable Stat Monster.

Rodgers “struggled” early this year – a little inaccurate/A few turnovers/dropped passes – yet he still had several Touchdowns and a Good Passer Rating – oh by the way – he was up against Seattle/San Fran/Chicago ‘s defenses to start the season.

Eli has so many come from behind wins, and scores in the 2 min before the half..I think it gets overlooked… So while Brady, Rodgers, Peyton, are throwing picks to end games they are trailing. Eli has been winning these games to the point it’s routine.. Everyone expects him to come back and win, but forget how difficult it is to do. Eli is in a class by himself when the game is on the line and also the last 2 minutes of a half.. He is a flat out beast.

I wonder if Phil considers himself elite? I’ll bet he does, even though he’s got pretty much the same resume as Eli.

1) lost your job to Eli
2) were replaced by Eli as the greatest QB of the franchise you played for
3) root for a stat god QB who chokes magnificently in the playoffs
4) root for a stat god QB who Eli took to the woodshed in the playoffs in your own backyard.
5) you’re a Chargers fan still wailing about the past rather than taking AJ Smith to the woodshed

The rest of us are babsically intelligent well-adjusted members of society.

2 SB wins and solid stats means that at a minimum, Eli is on the bubble of elite status.

I think that Dan Marino, winner of ZERO SuperBowl titles, was elite. Eli is not … but somehow we often forget about football being a team game when it comes to winning titles. Phil Simms is just realizing that he, like a lot of people, completely over-reacted to a guy winning a second Superbowl title and forgot that Eli is an inconsistent, streaky QB who has only ever led the league in one statistical category … interceptions (and he’s done that twice).

Eli’s 2 Super Bowl MVPs are bogus. He was far from the MVP in both games. It just goes to the quarterback by default…
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Really loser, then how come plenty of other players have won the award that are not Qb’s? Get a grip there Bitter Bob, I mean who really cares anyway as long as you win the SB, which is the goal in the first place.