Except for the fact that he leads the league in TD passes over 25 yards.

As ESPN posted yesterday, his % of passes less than 10 yards are on the exact same level as Brady, Rodgers, Manning.

I’ll take the guy who is perceived to throw short and at the top of the league in all QB categories over the guy who has the most turnovers as a QB and the lowest completion %. The only reason Luck is getting slurped is cause the Colts have the easiest schedule in the league. How’d they (and he) look against New England?

Some of you are just too funny. I know you’re afraid of RG3 but quit hating.

Uhhh but like most losing players say.. “we beat ourselves, and we should have won that game.” lol

The saddest thing about this post is that, as anyone can infer from the Good Burger reference, you’re actually an adult and not a pre-teen whose daddy is currently socializing them into the world of trash-talking fandom.

To those who spoke about NYG & drama, I’ve said the same for years. They love drama almost as much as the NYJ, at least under Coughlin. They play their best when their backs are against the wall…and the rest of the time they are hit or miss. That’s why Eli is perfect for them, he’s the same way (minus the drama stuff).

But, I don’t want to sound like sour grapes but I am not at all impressed with Robert Griffin as much as I thought I’d be. This pistol offense is very gimmicky and to be quite frank, not at all something that should be ran in the professional ranks.

If the Redskins really want to have a quarterback that can lead them to the playoffs and eventually a Super Bowl, they need to have that kid actually dropping back to make passes. Griffin has the potential but the offense he’s in will not allow him to blossom as a quarterback.

Also, judging by some of the hits he took last night, he might not even play five plus seasons.

2. What would the record be if Garçon has been healthy all year?!?! Not so much because I think he is a top 5 WR in the league (I am clean, I get drug tested at work but because he does “open” things up, and can take those slants and turn them into big gains…a la a Rod Smith.

I think Robert Griffin would do. I think we know who he is.

I don’t disagree that RGIII is anything short of incredible, but you can take away what Andrew Luck is doing simply based on personal stats alone. For example, does Luck have Alfred Morris? One could presume that a QB’s stats would improve if opposing defenses respected the run.

I know that stats and quantifying everything into nicely bound empirical bundles is en vogue, but there’s simply more to it than that. There has to be some weight given to situation and circumstance as well.

That being said at this point, I would contend that either RGIII or Luck are nothing short of incredible in their own rights.

Playing with our weak schedule and division, we’d easily be 10-2 or better with RGIII @ the helm.

I’m cool with Luck and 8-4 but I admit it makes me long for what could have been….

By the way, Crabtree, there are four weeks to go in the season, not five.

Then he complained about how there were only three calls against Washington. Okay, the holding call I’ll give you. But, the DPI call was doubtful, at best, because the defender was making a play on the ball. And, the OPI call against Logan Paulsen was just ridiculous and should never have been made.

Bottom line, the Skins made the plays which counted the most, and the Giants did not.