Right, Tim Ryan?

But y’all just keep on crying, because how dare ANYONE vote against your precious CJ and his record-breaking stats.

The idea that it was a biased vote from a former Bear for a Bear over a Lion kind of goes away when the Bear he voted for was the other first team guy.

Like I said, if I had a vote, I’d have voted for Megatron, but like it or not, Ryan gave legit reasons for supporting the guys he did.

“Was he a dominant player? Did he win his matchups?”

Yes, just not against the Bears or Seattle…Still an All-Pro, just like Marshall and Green, in spite of a couple subpar games.

Personally, I still would’ve voted Johnson All-Pro. But just because someone disagrees doesn’t mean that deserves an 800 word moralizing screech basically calling that person an idiot. But then again, I’m not as desperate for attention as Michael David Smith

Now, let’s think about the silliness as to why either Marshall or Green would be voted for instead of Andre Johnson.

With that said, there’s a huge difference in piling up yardage in meaningful games and piling up yardage when your team is down in garbage time. If they did a wide receiver ranking similar to the QBR which weighted contributions based on situation and “clutchness” I don’t think Calvin would be in the top group.

That said, it’s not really Calvin’s fault that his team sucks and if there was a draft of all the WR’s in the league, he would be picked first every time.

Huge Homer Alert! If you want to see a guy making awesome catches and run after catches in the clutch this year, see Michael Crabtree…FINALLY!!

The Lions deserve to get snubbed because no team in the NFL failed harder and with greater disappointment than the Lions did based upon what they had and what they should have done. It serves us right, even if it’s unfair to CJ, but that’s the price you pay when your team lets you down as hard as the Lion’s staff did this year.

If Megatron is basically the only weapon Detroit has, then he is constantly bracketed, double teamed and focused upon. Wouldn’t that make his accomplishments even more impressive?

Tim Ryan’s logic is flawed at best. These guys that were on the fringes of being in the NFL, then become an “analyst”, start to think that they are so much smarter than everyone else.

Forget the record and every other stat

CJ was the best WR in the game last year, often he was the best player on the field.

If you asked the 32 HC’s and OC’s in the League to choose 1 WR for their team, everyone would say CJ.

All-Pro, one of the easiest calls ever, except for one imbecile.

People please stop making excuses, Tim Ryan made a mock of his ballot.

Why not just make the team with the most wins the Associated Press All Pro Team?

The guy is anti-Lions, his decision is so bad and so clear we ought to stop talking about it.

Now, re-read the paragraph above, substitute Luke Kuechly for CJ, sacks for touchdowns, tackles for yards, and linebacker for wide receiver. Then you could basically make the same argument for Carolina LB Luke Kuechly that everyone is making for CJ. CJ had ONE writer not vote for him, and Kuechly didn’t even make the All-Pro team. I don’t see why everyone’s jumping all over Tim Ryan for this.

My point is, there are a lot of things to vote on… people seem to recognize that for other positions, so why not wide receiver?

so i could see how this writer has a point. but either way, megatron was the best at his position, so this writer has no idea what he is talking about.