Skip to content

Clowney lawsuit likely would fail

NCAA Football: Vanderbilt at South Carolina AP

At the root of the question of whether the interests of South Carolina defensive end Jadeveon Clowney would best be served by sitting out the 2013 college football season is a rule that prevents him from entering the draft before 2014.

Mike Silver of Yahoo! Sports (who apparently survived that giant plate of hot dog chili with shredded cheese that he scarfed down as a possible last meal during the Super Bowl blackout) argues that Clowney should challenge the rule in a court of law.  And while Silver makes a variety of salient philosophical points, the problem is that this ground already has been plowed unsuccessfully — under a stronger set of facts.

In 2004, Maurice Clarett initially secured a floodgates-opening ruling that struck down the NFL’s three-year waiting period, which arises from a desire to strike the right balance with college football coaches who run the league’s free farm system, and who can make it much harder for NFL teams to scout college football players by restricting access to practices and film and other pertinent information.  (Receiver Mike Williams joined the flurry of otherwise ineligible players, and then Williams found himself ineligible to return to USC after the ruling failed on appeal, because he had signed with an agent.  Williams was the 10th overall pick in the 2005 draft; Clarett went to the Broncos at the bottom of round three.)

At the time Clarett sued, the three-year rule wasn’t part of the labor deal.  The fact that the waiting period didn’t result from bargaining between the NFL and the NFLPA helped Clarett’s case at the district court level.  Even though Clarett’s case ultimately failed before the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit, the NFL insulated itself against a future challenge in a state falling within another circuit (there are 13 in all) by making the rule part of the 2006 CBA.

That’s why it’s odd, to say the least, to see Silver explain that the union would welcome a challenge to the rule.  The union has agreed to the rule, making the union as much to blame for its existence as the NFL.

Moreover, should the union really welcome the opportunity for more players to potentially bump current union members out of jobs?  For every players who gets in to the NFL earlier than he otherwise would under the existing rule, that’s one more veteran who gets pushed out.  (And it’s that kind of protectionist thinking that spawned the current rookie wage scale.)

Though the three-year rule is unfair to the men who play football for free (or close to it) at the college level, the fact that the NFLPA has signed off on the rule makes it even harder for Clowney or anyone else to fight it.

Besides, Clowney apparently wouldn’t file suit, even if he had a good chance of winning.  By all appearances, Clowney remains fully under the spell of a multimillionaire “Ball Coach” who has no problem with shaming his players into playing football for peanuts in comparison to the paycheck given to a guy who never has to step between the white lines and put his future earning potential at risk.

Permalink 33 Comments Feed for comments Latest Stories in: Home, Rumor Mill

Broncos’ Shiloh Keo pleads guilty to misdemeanor DUI

SANTA CLARA, CA - FEBRUARY 07:   Shiloh Keo #33 of the Denver Broncos celebrates after Super Bowl 50 at Levi's Stadium on February 7, 2016 in Santa Clara, California. The Broncos defeated the Panthers 24-10.   (Photo by Ezra Shaw/Getty Images) Getty Images

Broncos safety Shiloh Keo was arrested for driving under the influence the week after his team won the Super Bowl. Now he has pleaded guilty.

Keo pleaded guilty today to a misdemeanor DUI charge, TMZ reports.

He was sentenced to one year of probation, a suspended license, a $952.50 fine and community service in the form of speaking at eight high schools. If he does all that, the conviction will be expunged from his record.

Keo could now be subject to NFL discipline.

Permalink 2 Comments Feed for comments Back to top

Ex-Cowboy C.J. Spillman gets five years in prison for sexual assault

Dallas Cowboys v Washington Redskins Getty Images

Former Cowboys cornerback C.J. Spillman was sentenced to five years in prison today after a jury found him guilty of sexual assault.

A judge in Fort Worth, Texas, ordered Spillman to be taken into custody immediately after he was sentenced.

A woman accused Spillman of sexually assaulting her in a team hotel used by the Cowboys in Grapevine, Texas, on September 20, 2014. Spillman wasn’t actually charged until June 30, 2015, and played the rest of the 2014 season for the Cowboys.

According to the New York Daily News, Spillman was also accused of attempted rape in December of 2013, when he played for the 49ers. He was not charged in that incident. According to the Star-Telegram, Spillman’s ex-girlfriend, who is the mother of his three children, got a restraining order against him after he pulled a gun on her.

Spillman played six seasons in the NFL, from 2009 to 2014, with the Chargers, 49ers and Cowboys.

Permalink 6 Comments Feed for comments Back to top

Seven years with NBC, and counting


On July 1, 2009, the flip was switched on the partnership between NBC and PFT. It wasn’t a purchase; it was a partnership. Seven years to the day later, the partnership remains as strong as ever.

It’s been a great arrangement for PFT, even if my initial reaction when NBC exec Rick Cordella approached me about the possibility was to resist it. I enjoyed PFT’s independence, and I didn’t want to lose that. While the process of becoming mainstream necessarily entails a certain softening of (some) rough edges, PFT has for the most part continued to cover the league in a frank, candid, informative, and hopefully entertaining way.

Our main goal continues to be enhancing the experience of being an NFL fan, giving people accurate information, thought-provoking analysis, and ongoing ideas for improving the game, the league, and everything associated with it.

Some interpret PFT’s periodic criticism of the NFL as a dislike of the NFL. I love the NFL, and I have for more than 40 years. But that doesn’t mean the current stewards of the game get a blank check to do whatever they want without scrutiny. The much-discussed “integrity of the game” hinges more on ensuring true competitive balance among the 32 franchises and less on P.R.-driven investigations and punishments that ignore the broader culture of the sport. Otherwise, teams improperly have their otherwise fair chance at contending taken away from them.

Our content ranges from big-picture issues to relative mundane transactions, and everything in between. It’s a constantly-updated, comprehensive companion for the zealous football fan who cares deeply about the sport and, typically, one specific team in the league (along with a smattering of players on a given fantasy team). We’re going to keep doing it this way indefinitely, and definitely for at least seven more years with NBC.

If you have any ideas or suggestions as to how we can improve or expand what we do, feel free to mention them in the comments. And feel free to keep coming back on a regular basis, because when it comes to all of our content, “free” has been the operative word from November 1, 2001 through July 1, 2009 through today — and hopefully for many years to come.

Permalink 11 Comments Feed for comments Back to top

Special legislative session could determine fate of Las Vegas stadium

128091287 Getty Images

Now that Las Vegas has the attention of the NFL and the Raiders, the question becomes whether Las Vegas will do enough to turn flirtation into something much more than that.

That question could largely be determined by a special session of the Nevada legislature, which could happen later this summer.

As one source with knowledge of the dynamics in Nevada recently explained it to PFT, Governor Brian Sandoval (who has the authority to call a special session) and other politicians are strongly opposed to the proposed $750 million contribution, wanting that number to be $200 million or more lower than that.

Ultimately, the question becomes how badly Nevada wants an NFL team, and whether it can still lure a team like the Raiders (or the Chargers) with $550 million instead of $750 million in public contributions.

With the Chargers now looking less likely to get a stadium built in San Diego, Nevada has an opportunity to pit the Raiders and Chargers against each other, perhaps luring the Chargers for $550 million in lieu of getting the Raiders for $750 million — or possibly squeezing the Raiders down to $550 million.

The NFL, which usually is the one squeezing multiple potential partners in order to get the best possible deal for the league, won’t be thrilled with being on the inside of the vise. But with little or no public money available in most American cities, Las Vegas should be able to get one team or the other for a lot less than $750 million.

Permalink 9 Comments Feed for comments Back to top

Bears end up claiming Shaw after Saints share their intentions

DeAngelo Tyson, Connor Shaw AP

The Chicago Bears have claimed quarterback Connor Shaw via waivers.

It was just a simple Friday transaction — except that the Saints put in a claim on Shaw, too, and apparently thought they had added him. Per Peter Schrager of FOX Sports, the Saints jumped the gun on thinking they’d claimed Shaw and let that info leak.

The Bears, who were a spot ahead of the Saints in the waiver order, got Shaw. In what Schrager called “a clerical error,” the Saints had sent an email about claiming Shaw to the entire league instead of just the NFL personnel department.

As proof that someone told something prematurely, ESPN’s Field Yates reported that the Saints had waived tight end Jack Tabb to make room on the roster for Shaw. He later clarified that the Bears actually claimed Shaw.

Well, now Tabb knows he’s the 90th man on the Saints’ offseason roster.

Shaw was waived by the Browns on Thursday. The Browns went through the spring with five quarterbacks, and the new administration chose to move on from the former undrafted free agent brought in by the previous regime.

Shaw played in one game during his time with the Browns, the 2014 season finale. He performed well given the circumstances; he’d spent the first 16 weeks of his rookie season on the practice squad as the Brian HoyerJohnny Manziel saga drug on. Now Shaw is reunited with Hoyer in the Bears’ quarterbacks room.

A preseason thumb injury forced Shaw to spend all of last season on injured-reserve.

Permalink 4 Comments Feed for comments Back to top

Six players declared eligible for supplemental draft

EAST RUTHERFORD, NJ - SEPTEMBER 13: The NFL shield is painted in gold and black after a game between the Cleveland Browns and the New York Jets  at MetLife Stadium on September 13, 2015 in East Rutherford, New Jersey. The new color scheme is to commemorate this years' Super Bowl witch will be the 50th edition. (Photo by Rich Schultz /Getty Images) Getty Images

It’s July 1, which means that supplemental draft fever is rising across this great land of ours.

The big day for players who have had a change of circumstance in their collegiate careers since the early-entry deadline for the NFL draft is July 14 and six players are eligible to be selected. That group includes Purdue defensive lineman Ra’Zahn Howard, whose presence in the draft pool was reported last month.

Per NFL Media, Ole Miss cornerback Tee Shepard is also eligible after leaving the team last season. Shepard has a hearing loss and took issue with the way the school’s coaching staff pointed to that publicly as the reason for struggles on the field without talking to him first.

Virginia Tech long snapper Eddie D’Antuono, Sam Houston State running back Jalen Overstreet, University of Calgary wide receiver Rashaun Simonise and Concordia defensive end Cameron Walton are the others eligible for the supplemental draft. If a team should pick any of the six, they’ll forfeit their pick in the same round during the 2017 draft.

Permalink 3 Comments Feed for comments Back to top

Ravens tight end Darren Waller suspended four games

ATLANTA, GA - SEPTEMBER 03:  Ricardo Allen #37 of the Atlanta Falcons tackles Darren Waller #12 of the Baltimore Ravens at Georgia Dome on September 3, 2015 in Atlanta, Georgia.  (Photo by Kevin C. Cox/Getty Images) Getty Images

The NFL had shifted the Friday-afternoon-before-three-day-July-4th-weekend bad news dump to Thursday. But apparently there was more bad news than one afternoon could hold.

The league has announced that Ravens tight end/receiver Darren Waller has been suspended the first four games of the season for violating the substance-abuse policy.

Waller had two catches for 18 yards last season, in six games.

The bigger question is whether Waller is the first suspension to be announced on Friday afternoon, or the last.

Permalink 9 Comments Feed for comments Back to top

Goodell pay not significantly impacted by #Deflategate, either

GettyImages-462643470.0 Getty Images

The immediate reaction to the news that Commissioner Roger Goodell’s compensation for 2015 dipped by seven percent to $31.74 million was obvious: Goodell took a hit, but not a huge one, in the first full year after the Ray Rice mess of September 2014.

But 2015 also was the year of #Deflategate, and Goodell’s pay shows that one of the three men who determine what Goodell gets — Patriots owner Robert Kraft — wasn’t all that miffed at Goodell over a scandal that made Kraft as made at the league office as he ever has been.

Meanwhile, and as reported by Daniel Kaplan of SportsBusiness Journal, NFL general counsel Jeff Pash saw his total pay for 2015 drop 13 percent, to $6.5 million. It’s widely believed that Kraft and the Patriots emerged from #Deflategate with very strong feelings regarding Pash’s role in the investigation and ultimate conclusions.

Plenty of people would gladly take far less money to have their bosses far more upset with them. Moving forward, no one will know how much Goodell or Pash or anyone else at 345 Park Avenue is making, regardless of how happy or otherwise the folks who determine how much they make may be.

Permalink 25 Comments Feed for comments Back to top

Bears will be jockeying for St. Louis fans, too

antenna1 Getty Images

The Chiefs already plan to horn in on St. Louis turf vacated by the Rams. The Bears will be trying to invade the city that lost its second NFL team since 1987, too.

Via Dan Caesar of the St. Louis Post-Dispatch, KTVI will televise Chicago Bears preseason games. Previously, KTVI carried Rams exhibitions games.

KMOV in St. Louis will show Chiefs games, giving folks in St. Louis twice the inventory of preseason games to enjoy. And one of those Kansas City games features a matchup against the Rams in Los Angeles.

Caesar also points out that folks in St. Louis will get extra regular-season games on local TV, due to the quirky rules that apply when a city’s team is playing at home.

None of it will matter if St. Louis eventually lures another team to town. After the Cardinals left in the 1980s, the Rams arrived in 1995.

Permalink 10 Comments Feed for comments Back to top

Tarvaris Jackson says he’s broke, requests a public defender

St Louis Rams v Seattle Seahawks Getty Images

Former Seahawks, Vikings and Bills quarterback Tarvaris Jackson made more than $12 million in his NFL career, but now he says he’s so broke that he can’t even afford a lawyer to defend him against charges that he threatened to kill his wife.

Jackson requested a public defender because he can’t afford an attorney, TMZ reports.

In court documents, Jackson says he has no income, savings or investments. His only asset is a car worth $100,000.

The judge overseeing Jackson’s case denied the request for the public defender, perhaps reasoning that after he made $1.5 million with the Seahawks last year and found a way to buy that car, Jackson can find a way to pay a lawyer, too.

The 33-year-old Jackson was a second-round draft pick of the Vikins in 2006 and has been in the NFL since. He is not currently under contract, and given the legal issues hanging over his head, his NFL career is probably over.

Permalink 70 Comments Feed for comments Back to top

NFL still looking into Aqib Talib shooting

SANTA CLARA, CA - FEBRUARY 04:  Aqib Talib #21 of the Denver Broncos speaks to the media during the Broncos media availability for Super Bowl 50 at the Stanford Marriott on February 4, 2016 in Santa Clara, California. The Broncos will play the Carolina Panthers in Super Bowl 50 on February 7, 2016.  (Photo by Ezra Shaw/Getty Images) Getty Images

A fuller police report from the night that Broncos cornerback Aqib Talib was shot in the right leg has been made available, but it doesn’t offer much new insight into what led to Talib’s wound.

There were reports at the time that Talib told police that he didn’t know who shot him as well as reports that he accidentally shot himself, although the Dallas police said they were investigating it as an aggravated assault. The report, obtained by Ian Rapoport of NFL Media and Lindsay Jones of USA Today, confirms that Talib said he didn’t know who shot him and that an “unknown suspect” shot Talib.

The police report quotes a witness that was part of a group of people in a park and heard a single gunshot followed by seeing Talib lying on the ground. The report also says police found a gram of marijuana, but makes no mention of who it belonged to.

NFL spokesman Brian McCarthy told Jones that the NFL is continuing an investigation into what happened and the Dallas police consider it an open investigation as well.

Talib is expected to make a full recovery in time for the regular season.

Permalink 27 Comments Feed for comments Back to top

Mark Davis visiting Vegas regularly while stadium site selection continues

OAKLAND, CA - NOVEMBER 09:  Oakland Raiders owner Mark Davis is seen during warm ups before his team competes against the Denver Broncos at Coliseum on November 9, 2014 in Oakland, California.  (Photo by Thearon W. Henderson/Getty Images) Getty Images

When last we heard from Raiders owner Mark Davis, he reiterated that he is serious about moving the team to Las Vegas if the city can put together a plan to build a new stadium.

Nothing has changed on that front in the last few weeks. Las Vegas Sands senior vice president Ron Reese said that Davis has been to the city “a half-dozen times” in the last couple of months and that his company is continuing to work on putting together that stadium plan.

“It’s a major investment,” Reese said, via USA Today. “The NFL has expressed a strong desire for a public-private partnership. Our organization is taking the lead, working with the Raiders to create public-private support for this.”

The question of the public end of that partnership remains unanswered. There have been proposals calling for contributions of $500 or $750 million raised from hotel room taxes. In the meantime, work is being done to settle on a site for the stadium in Las Vegas.

The Las Vegas Review-Journal reported this week that four sites are under consideration by the Raiders, the Sands and Majestic Realty, which comprise the private half of the partnership.

“We’re much further along in looking at sites than people realize,” Las Vegas Sands exec Andy Abboud said. “We want to be somewhere along the resort corridor along the Las Vegas Strip. I think we can get that resolved by the end of July. We may go forward after July with two potential sites and determine the best one.”

Oakland is still pushing for a plan that could keep the Raiders from moving, although the prospect of the Raiders landing in Vegas may have become more likely this offseason.

Permalink 22 Comments Feed for comments Back to top

Nate Robinson using WR trainer who worked with Odell Beckham, DeSean Jackson

When longtime NBA point guard Nate Robinson tried out for the Seahawks, coach Pete Carroll said it would be “all but impossible” for him to make it to the NFL.

But Carroll also offered some advice on how Robinson might proceed if he wanted a shot — to concentrate on offense.

Robinson’s work with trainer Dwayne Frampton has focused on Robinson learning to play wide receiver. Robinson played cornerback at the University of Washington, but Frampton — who has worked with Odell Beckham Jr. and DeSean Jackson — thinks he has promise as a receiver.

“Nate originally went out to work out for Pete Carroll as a defensive back, but he saw how well Nate was catching the ball,” Frampton said, via Sheil Kapadia of “So Pete said he could be used offensively.

“People have to understand Nate’s already played the game of football. So he’s not blind, he’s just a rookie. We worked on ball drills, getting his feet, polishing his route-running, keeping his shoulder-pad level down. Pretty much just getting him back in the groove of how football operates.”

Frampton said the 32-year-old, 5-foot-9 Robinson has shown ability as a slot receiver, and good strength for his size. But he insisted he didn’t think Robinson was in this just for attention, and that it could work.

“He’s really trying to make it back into football. And he has the willpower and athleticism to do so,” Frampton said. “If he were to get a fair opportunity and not just be known as Nate Robinson the slam-dunk champion, but be known as Nate Robinson, the athlete who’s really trying to make it back to the football world, then I think he’s fine. That’s probably the biggest hurdle, people not taking this as a gimmick.”

Considering how hard it is for 22-year-olds who have actually played wide receiver in college to make it to the NFL, it’s easy to understand why people might think it’s a gimmick. But Robinson appears to be taking his attempt seriously, and should be commending for not quitting.

Permalink 6 Comments Feed for comments Back to top

NFL dismisses Charles Sly’s recanting of PED allegations

al-Jazeera-symbol-Getty-640x480 Getty Images

As the NFL and NFL Players Association continue to harden their diametrically-opposed positions regarding the investigation sparked by PED allegations made in an Al Jazeera documentary, more and more aspects of each side’s beliefs have become clear.

In the NFL’s most recent letter to the NFLPA, which was given to the media before it was given to the union, the league dismisses the notion that Charles Sly’s recanting of the allegations in any way disproves them.

“The fact that statements aired in the report may have been since ‘recanted,’ while potentially relevant to any ultimate conclusions reached, does not extinguish our need to investigate,” NFL senior V.P. of labor policy and league affairs Adolpho Birch writes in his letter to NFLPA counsel Heather McPhee. “And it is hardly remarkable or dispositive that an individual would publicly disavow statements for which he may be subject to criminal or civil sanctions.”

Peyton Manning may disagree strongly with that sentiment, given the P.R. push from Camp Manning that Sly’s about-face proves that his claims are false. Still, the NFL is absolutely right on this point. It’s no surprise that a person who said one thing when he didn’t realize he was being recorded said something else once the syntax hit the fan.

Birch’s comments appear in support of the broader position that the NFL has a right to interview players as part of an investigation aimed at determining whether evidence of PED use exists beyond a positive test.

“[Y]our letters do not dispute that NFL players have an obligation to cooperate with league investigations and may be disciplined for failing to do so — a principle that, as you know, has been repeatedly confirmed in recent litigation between the parties,” Birch writes.

It’s also clear that the league believes it has the power to interview players without sharing any of the evidence that has been compiled against them, regardless of whether that evidence suggests innocence or guilt.

“[W]e are under no obligation to disclose all evidence uncovered thus far as a condition to interviewing the parties,” Birch writes, “which would clearly compromise the investigation.”

Here’s where it’s critical for the two sides to have a clear understanding regarding what the rules are regarding investigations. Neither the Collective Bargaining Agreement nor the PED policy contain language expressly acknowledging the league’s power to interview players as part of the investigation or outlining the rules and procedures that apply when an investigation occurs. In litigation, parties to the dispute aren’t expected to tell their stories without knowing what evidence the other side does or doesn’t possess. In investigations like this one, players shouldn’t be required to do it, either.

The fact that the CBA and the PED policy say nothing about the NFL’s and NFLPA’s rights and responsibilities when the league wants to interview players in connection with a possible PED violation suggests that the players aren’t required to provide any information until the NFL has developed enough evidence to justify discipline — and unless the player appeals the suspension. Even if the NFL has the ability to interview players before imposing discipline, the notion that the league can conceal the evidence and hope to coax the players into saying something that conflicts with other evidence that the league is hiding. absent express authorization to proceed in this way, justifies an effort by the NFLPA to resist making the players available.

With #Deflategate being an exercise in jumping to an uninformed conclusion and then launching an investigation aimed not at getting to the truth but justifying a predetermined outcome, there’s no reason for the NFLPA or anyone to believe the NFL will do anything differently in this case. As a result, there’s no reason for the NFLPA to agree to let the players walk into a potential buzzsaw.

Regardless of how this plays out, the NFL and NFLPA should come up with clear rules regarding the trigger for launching an investigation and the nuts and bolts associated with conducting it.

Permalink 82 Comments Feed for comments Back to top

Jamar Taylor enjoying “fresh start” with Browns

DAVIE, FL - MAY 3:  Jamar Taylor #22 of the Miami Dolphins runs drills during the rookie camp on May 3, 2013 at the Miami Dolphins training facility in Davie, Florida.  (Photo by Joel Auerbach/Getty Images) Getty Images

Among the changes the Browns made to their roster this offseason was the addition of cornerback Jamar Taylor in a trade with the Dolphins.

Taylor was a second-round pick in Miami in 2013, but has struggled both on the field and with injuries since entering the NFL. The Browns haven’t been anything to write home about over the last three years either, which led to their latest coaching and front office reboot and a chance for Taylor to improve on the results of the last three seasons.

“It’s definitely a fresh start for me. For what I went through in Miami, it’s all over. This is a great group of people here, a great organization, a great staff,” Taylor said, via the team’s website. “Nobody knows me, I know nobody. It’s just really new for me. It’s definitely a fresh start, but it’s a fresh start for everybody. None of the coaches really know a lot of these guys so everybody knows they just have to go put it on tape. You are who you put on tape and you are who you are around your teammates.”

Taylor said he’s open to any role the Browns have for him on defense, special teams or anywhere else, which is the right way to approach a fresh start with a new organization. The attitude will only take him so far if his health and performance don’t make a turn in the right direction.

Permalink 6 Comments Feed for comments Back to top