With the top two picks in the 2015 NFL Draft, Jameis Winston and Marcus Mariota, immediately installed as starters for their respective teams, it’s easy to assume that there’s been outside interest in young quarterbacks already on those rosters, Mike Glennon of the Bucs and Zach Mettenberger of the Titans.
In a league with more teams than quality starting quarterbacks and even fewer legitimate backup options, Matt Flynn and Michael Vick, just to name a couple, have recently found work. So a player like Mettenberger, for example, who’s in his second season and has shown he shares at least some traits with successful starters across the league would and should draw outside interest.
Earlier this week, Titans coach Ken Whisenhunt sounded like Mettenberger isn’t going anywhere.
“In the league today it is very hard for one quarterback to make it through the whole season, so you better have a plan in case your starter doesn’t go,” Whisenhunt said. “So we certainly feel very fortunate that we have Zach, and what Zach brings to the table.”
While the Browns and Jets and Bills, possibly among others, might have good reasons to explore possibilities for boosting their quarterback stables over the next week or so as rosters are trimmed and decisions are made, history says teams don’t trade quarterbacks at this time of year, at least not good ones.
Ryan Mallett was traded last Aug. 31 from the Patriots to the Texans. Mallett started two games last season before getting hurt, then no-showed a practice this week after it was announced he’d lost a training-camp battle with Brian Hoyer for the starting job in Houston.
There have been nine August quarterback trades in the last 15 years. The vast majority of them involved journeymen such as Kelly Holcomb, Sage Rosenfels, John Beck and Brooks Bollinger. The Packers trading Brett Favre to the Jets in 2008 stands out as an exception, but that was a soap opera all its own after Favre, then 38, basically refused to report to the Packers.
Going back to last winter, Glennon rumors started swirling as soon as it became clear the Bucs would use the No. 1 pick in the 2015 draft on a quarterback. The Bucs ended up cutting Josh McCown and keeping Glennon, who’s been playing as the No. 2 behind Winston.
Speaking of McCown, he was traded from Miami to Carolina in August 2008. With Johnny Manziel injured and likely done for the preseason, Thad Lewis moves to the No. 2 spot behind McCown with the Browns. Lewis was traded in August 2013 from Detroit to Buffalo.
So, these August movers do not form an elite club. And though there could be talks and even a few calls made over the next week to 10 days, what Whisenhunt said about the Titans keeping Mettenberger has generally been the rule. The same reasons teams would be interested in a young quarterback are the same reasons his current team would have an awfully high asking price.