Skip to content

For quarterbacks, no one knows if they can do it until they do it

Brady Getty Images

As the weeks of throwing footballs against a defense made up of Lennay Kekua and 10 of her family members yields to throwing footballs with a red no-touchy jersey against a bunch of other rookies and assorted slappies to throwing footballs with a red no-touchy jersey against veterans, rookies, and assorted slappies, we’re no closer to knowing whether any of the rookie quarterbacks can play effectively at the NFL level.

That point was reinforced last night upon tripping over the excellent NFL Films documentary regarding “The Brady 6″ — the six quarterbacks drafted in 2000 before the Pats scrawled Tom Brady’s name onto the 199th card submitted.

The chip that blossomed on Brady’s shoulder was nurtured in part by underwhelming performances at Michigan, which opened the door for Drew Henson to take reps during Brady’s senior season, and pre-draft workouts from a slow, ungainly athlete who did nothing to stand out.  But when it was time to play against live NFL competition, as the calm eye in a storm of bodies and movement and drawn-up plays that disintegrate when exposed to a full-speed defense, Brady didn’t simply survive but thrived.

Others couldn’t.  The much-hyped Giovanni Carmazzi, taken by the favorite team of Brady’s boyhood, flamed out for the 49ers.  Former coach Steve Mariucci attributed the failure to Carmazzi’s first NFL appearance, coincidentally against the Patriots in the Hall of Fame game, as planting the doubt that resulted in Carmazzi never playing in a regular-season game.

Ditto for Tee Martin, the Peyton Manning successor who never was able to do enough with his limited opportunity to catch the eye of the coaches in Pittsburgh.  In the end, Brady became the latest Hall of Fame quarterback the Steelers could have snatched, but didn’t.  (They once cut John Unitas and passed over hometown hero Dan Marino.)

But it’s hard to blame any of the teams that passed on Brady.  There was scant evidence that he’d perform at a high level at the highest level of the sport.

And that makes this year’s — and each year’s — class of quarterbacks inherently intriguing.  While it’s easy to lament the absence of can’t-miss prospects like Andrew Luck and Robert Griffin III from the 2013 collection of signal-callers, there could be one of more Russell Wilsons lurking among the likes of EJ Manuel, Geno Smith, Mike Glennon, Matt Barkley, Ryan Nassib, Tyler Wilson, Landry Jones, Zac Dysert, or any of the undrafted players.

We simply won’t know what they can do until they do it.  Which will make things interesting not in May or June but in late July, August, September, and beyond.

There’s definitely a Carmazzi and Martin among that group.  But there also could be a Brady or a Wilson.

Permalink 39 Comments Feed for comments Latest Stories in: Buffalo Bills, Denver Broncos, Home, New York Giants, New York Jets, Oakland Raiders, Philadelphia Eagles, Pittsburgh Steelers, Rumor Mill, Tampa Bay Buccaneers

Rex Ryan shrugs off Bengals’ criticism of his late blitzes

Rex Ryan AP

Andy Dalton routinely lights up the Jets anyway.

But the next time they see each other, the Bengals have another reason to play their best.

Bengals offensive line coach Paul Alexander took exception to Rex Ryan’s blitz calls late in Saturday’s game.

Notice he didn’t bring that stuff when our starters were out there,” Alexander said, according to “We’d have scored quicker. If he wants to put his starting defense out there and blitz all that garbage against our third-stringers, if he feels good about it, then all the power to him.”

Ryan wasn’t fazed by the criticism at all.

“I don’t know why they’d be shocked,” Ryan said, via the New York Daily News. “I don’t worry about their team.”

The Jets eventually came back to win the game, but not until Andy Dalton strafed them, going 8-of-8 for 144 yards and a touchdown.

Sadly, the two don’t play in the regular season, but it feels like this one has the legs to last until the postseason, or into future seasons.

Permalink 13 Comments Feed for comments Back to top

Brandon LaFell creating a niche for himself in New England

Brandon LaFell AP

Brandon LaFell is becoming more and more comfortable with Tom Brady, and the Patriots are envisioning more and more of a role for their new wide receiver.

Via Chris Mason of the Boston Herald, Patriots coach Bill Belichick has been impressed with the former second-round pick.

I think he’ll be able to carve out a role for himself here,” Belichick said. “Might be a big one. He’s finding different ways to contribute, whether it’s blocking, receiving or special teams. He’s done whatever we’ve asked of him, and he’s done it well. He’s gotten better at it.”

At the moment, that might include special teams, where LaFell was never really a factor for the Panthers. But he’s a physical receiver who is willing and able to block, which helps make up for hands that are unreliable at times.

But after spending time in Carolina with the improvisational genius of Cam Newton, he’s had to adjust to working with Brady, a completely different kind of quarterback.

“He expects you to be exactly where he wants you to be on every route,” LaFell said of Brady. “Not a yard off. Not a yard too deep. Not a yard too short. He expects you to be exactly where he wants you to be, because he’s going to put the ball placement exactly right.

“I’m feeling way more comfortable. Just being in the huddle with Brady, hearing him call the plays and stuff like that. I’m way more comfortable.”

He’ll have to catch the ball consistently to stay in Brady’s good gracces, but for now, the Patriots sound pleased with an under-the-radar acquisition.

Permalink 13 Comments Feed for comments Back to top

Jairus Byrd expected to make Saints debut on Saturday

Jairus Byrd AP

The Saints signed safety Jairus Byrd this offseason in a bid to improve their defense to a level that will allow them to compete for a Super Bowl, so they decided that it was better for him to have back surgery in May than to try to play through a disk injury during the season.

That meant Byrd would have to spend a spell on the sideline watching his teammates practice instead of being on the field with them, but that period has come to an end. Byrd took part in his first full-contact practice since joining the Saints on Tuesday and coach Sean Payton said that he expects Byrd to take another step forward on Saturday when he takes the field against the Colts.

“This is an important game, because he hasn’t been able to play in the first two,” Payton said, via “Now, we’ll be smart with the reps we give him and the amount we give him, but I don’t think you can just throw the ball out there and play.”

Byrd had 22 interceptions and 11 forced fumbles while he was a member of the Bills and the Saints would love to see his takeaway skills make the trip with him to Rob Ryan’s defense in New Orleans. If they do, it will fill in a piece missing from last year’s team and make the Saints an even tougher out than they were in making it to the Divisional Round last season.

Permalink 12 Comments Feed for comments Back to top

Short on QBs, Kendall Wright would love a chance to throw

Kendall Wright AP

With Clipboard Jesus resting (what has it been six days?) with a hand injury, the Titans might be down to just two quarterbacks Saturday night.

But even if Jake Locker and Zach Mettenberger could handle the load with Charlie Whitehurst out, the Titans do have another option.

According to Jim Wyatt of the Tennesseean, wide receiver Kendall Wright would be the emergency quarterback if it ever got to that point.

I’d put Kendall back there in the shotgun and let him run around with it,” Titans coach Ken Whisenhunt said. “He can throw it, too.”

Wright was a high school quarterback in Texas, and sounded excited about the chance.

“I’d be ready,” he said. “If he needed me to do that, I’d do it immediately for him, preseason game, regular season game, any game. … And I think I’d be pretty good back there. I think I could make something happen.”

Whitehurst is apparently dealing with a pinkie finger injury, since that’s what has been taped since last Friday’s game. He hasn’t talked to reporters, and there’s no sense that it’s a long-term injury.

He could probably rise and be fine in a few days, but in case they need him this weekend, Wright will be ready for the call.

Permalink 11 Comments Feed for comments Back to top

Browns say Brian Hoyer will start, Johnny Manziel will sit

Cincinnati Bengals v Cleveland Browns Getty Images

Brian Hoyer is the Browns’ starting quarterback.

Browns coach Mike Pettine announced this morning that Hoyer will start the Week One game against the Steelers, and Johnny Manziel will be the backup.

“He was the clear leader from the beginning,” Pettine said of Hoyer. “We’ve maintained all along that if it was close, I would prefer to go with the more experienced player. Brian has done a great job in the meeting rooms and with his teammates on the practice field and in the locker room.”

Neither Hoyer nor Manziel has played particularly well in the preseason, but Pettine suggested that Hoyer is the safer, more stable pick.

“I think Brian’s been very poised,” Pettine said. “I think he’s handled the situation well. He’s had a lot of things going on.”

Manziel may be the Browns’ quarterback of the future, but he hasn’t done enough to prove he deserves to be the quarterback of the present. For right now, Hoyer is the quarterback of the Cleveland Browns.

Permalink 100 Comments Feed for comments Back to top

Von Miller: If I had to take my pick of 2011 draft class, I’d pick myself

Von Miller AP

There were several star players in the 2011 draft class, including Cam Newton, Von Miller, Patrick Peterson, A.J. Green, J.J. Watt and Richard Sherman.

That makes for an interesting barroom debate about which player you’d take first if you could have your pick of all the players selected that spring with the knowledge of how they’ve developed once they hit the NFL. Miller was the second pick in the draft, but the Broncos linebacker said Tuesday that he’d bump himself up a slot if he was given the chance to make such a selection.

“I spend a lot of time with myself, and I am most familiar with myself,” Miller said, via Mark Kiszla of the Denver Post. “If I had to make a pick, it would be me.”

Kiszla writes that Miller was laughing as he said it and it’s hardly a shock to hear a professional athlete express confidence in himself even if last year’s suspension and torn ACL make it difficult to see Miller as having provided the most return on investment from his selection.

With DeMarcus Ware now installed across from him, Miller could put up a strong counterargument to that this season and it would come at a very advantageous time. Like Watt, Miller is looking for a contract extension that boosts him to a bigger paycheck and a full return to form this year would be an excellent way to do that.

Permalink 34 Comments Feed for comments Back to top

Vikings coaches see value in keeping Christian Ponder

Christian Ponder AP

Apparently the Vikings have not been overwhelmed with trade offers for former first-rounder Christian Ponder.

So now they’re talking him up, and trying to salvage his value to their organization.

Clearly buried behind Matt Cassel and the latest savior Teddy Bridgewater, Ponder didn’t even play in Saturday’s preseason game against the Cardinals. But that doesn’t mean they don’t have a plan for him.

I don’t think there will be just two quarterbacks,” Vikings coach Mike Zimmer said, via Matt Vensel of the Minneapolis Star-Tribune.

Offensive coordinator Norv Turner knows — after blowing through Brandon Weeden, Brian Hoyer and Jason Campbell last year in Cleveland — how quickly things can change.

“I was obviously very disappointed in the opening game the way our fans reacted to Christian because I think he’s done everything he can do,” Turner said. “He’s working his butt off. I think he’s a guy who is going to be valuable to our team.”

That value might not be tangible, but Ponder has at least handled this the right way, and hasn’t turned into a distraction such that they’ll be glad to get rid of him. And while his prospects are dim, he did lead (or handed them off) them to the playoffs two years ago, so they may be hoping they can find that spark of acceptability again.

Permalink 49 Comments Feed for comments Back to top

Odell Beckham says no setback with hamstring, but he won’t play this week

Odell Beckham AP

Giants wide receiver Odell Beckham missed practice on Tuesday, keeping his string of not completing a full training camp practice alive.

After the session, Beckham and the Giants said that the wide receivers injured hamstring was sore but they insisted that he didn’t suffer a setback in his recovery from the initial injury. He has, however, been ruled out

“We have progressively built up my workload. I was sore this morning, and I didn’t work today because we didn’t want a setback, and I don’t consider this a setback. I see it as another step in getting back to full strength,” Beckham said, via the team’s website.

Coach Tom Coughlin said something similar regarding it not being a setback, although Beckham was making progress toward his preseason debut after returning to practice in a limited fashion last week so it seems like a setback to have that taken off the table. Semantic quibbles aside, Beckham’s extended absence seems certain to have a negative impact on what he’s able to do during his rookie season even if he’s healed up in time to join the team for the start of the regular season. For a team with a scuffling offense, that’s not good news however you choose to frame it.

Permalink 9 Comments Feed for comments Back to top

Joe Flacco on Johnny Manziel: I think we’ve all seen the middle finger before

Johnny Manziel AP

Titans safety Bernard Pollard’s sensibilities were offended by Browns quarterback Johnny Manziel unleashing his middle finger at the Redskins bench during Monday night’s game, but one of Pollard’s former teammates with the Ravens thinks Pollard and other critics of Manziel’s gesture are making much ado about nothing.

Ravens quarterback Joe Flacco said he has flashed the offending digit over the course of his career, including at Terrell Suggs during a recent practice, because people react emotionally when they’re hearing trash talk on the field. While Flacco says “you want to limit to the point where no one else sees it,” he also thinks that those expressing outrage about Manziel’s gesture should take a deep breath.

“I think we’ve all seen the middle finger before,” Flacco said, via “We should get over it.”

Manziel’s use of the finger would have been a story regardless of how he played against Washington and there’s no doubt that a quarterback has to keep his composure under fire, but the reaction would have been a lot less intense if Manziel had played well during the game. Then the majority of the discussion would have been on giving Manziel the starting job, which suggests that Manziel’s immediate focus should be on performing better rather than questions of on-field decorum.

Permalink 36 Comments Feed for comments Back to top

Panthers settle on Byron Bell as their new left tackle

Byron Bell AP

The Panthers appear to have settled their most pressing preseason competition, and head coach Ron Rivera might have picked up a little French this summer.

According to Bill Voth of Black and Blue Review, Byron Bell has distanced himself from the competition, and made the left tackle job his own.

“He’s done such a good job. I’m going to say it; it’s a fait accompli,” Rivera said. “He and I will sit down and have a conversation about it. I’m going to sit down and talk with the coaches and make sure we’re all set, confident and comfortable.”

Comfortable might be a relative term, since that position was manned by the rock steady Jordan Gross for the last decade. But as shaky as Bell looked on the right (where he started the last three years), he seems more comfortable himself on the left.

“He’s done some things on the left side that he didn’t do on the right side that have been impressive,” Rivera said. “But the biggest thing we keep forgetting is, he’s a natural left-hander.

“His punch is a lot better, and his first step is a little bit better. Again that’s because he’s working off his left side. Having seen that, I have confidence that he can do the job for us.”

Now all the Panthers have to do is find a right tackle. They began looking at converted defensive tackle Nate Chandler there, but he’s struggled with a knee problem and has looked mostly like a guard in his time there. They subbed in always injured Garry Williams there last week, and Williams might end up winning that job if Chandler can’t get well and improve.

Permalink 3 Comments Feed for comments Back to top

Tony Gonzalez: Temptation will be there if a contender calls during season

Atlanta Falcons v Carolina Panthers Getty Images

Tony Gonzalez has taken a job with CBS for the coming season and he’s making the transition from being on the field to being in the studio.

He’s making big predictions for 2014, including a possible undefeated season for the Broncos and a victory for Denver in a Super Bowl rematch, but none of them include a return to playing at the moment. Gonzalez said that he’s already heard from teams interested in a comeback and said no while acknowledging that it would be more difficult to turn down overtures from a contender during the season.

“The temptation would be there, but I don’t know what the gain would be,” Gonzalez said, via Newsday. “I’ve always wanted a ring. That’s been my main goal as a player over the last 15 years of my career. You’re really trying to get that ultimate goal. But I’d be a mercenary to come in and get a Super Bowl ring, play with a team for, what, six, seven weeks? And even if I got the ring, it wouldn’t be the same as going through the fight with the team from the beginning to the end. I don’t think that will happen. The temptation will be there, but I’m 100 percent happy with my decision.”

Gonzalez says he wouldn’t want to go back on his “good luck” to retire on his own terms, although nothing he said will stop teams from making a call to see if Gonzalez feels differently in a couple of months. It seems like a long shot that there will be any change, but the opportunity to increase your chances of winning a Super Bowl can lead teams to try such shots.

Permalink 18 Comments Feed for comments Back to top

Peyton Manning thought the Broncos “stunk” against Texans

Peyton Manning AP

Listening to Broncos quarterback Peyton Manning yesterday, you’d think his teammates tried to buy Gatorade without breaking a sweat.

Manning was not pleased with the way his team worked during their joint practice with the Texans, and made that clear afterward.

I thought our offense stunk today. I thought their defense kicked our butt,” Manning said, via Troy Renck of the Denver Post. “We will learn from the film, and hopefully we come out tomorrow and do a better job from a players standpoint and execute.”

(You can hear Broncos coach John Fox’s opinion by tuning into to the Dan Patrick Show at 9:30 a.m. ET, since our own Mike Florio’s hosting this week. Steal us something good, Mike.)

Manning said the Texans defense “kicked our butt,” in the shorts-and-shells practice.

Asked what upset him, Manning replied: “”Were you watching? Bad.”

“I kind of call it like I see it,” he said. “When you have a pretty below-average practice, you have to call it a below-average practice. I think this team does a good job of being even-keeled. I don’t think we are overexcited about beating a San Francisco team that didn’t blitz us one time and played a vanilla scheme. I think we have a humble attitude about what we have done so far.”

Maintaining that kind of edge, and keeping that kind of perfection in front of him is what drives Manning. And he’s not going to hold his teammates to a different standard.

Permalink 8 Comments Feed for comments Back to top

Kaepernick’s 2013 foot injury was more serious than he let on

Kaepernick Getty Images

For much of last season, Colin Kaepernick’s foot put him on the 49ers’ injury report. But Kaepernick always played through it, and he said at the time that it wasn’t a big deal, joking that it was just a hangnail. Now Kaepernick says it was much more serious than that.

In fact, Kaepernick told the Sacramento Bee that he actually suffered a chipped bone on his forefoot and a ruptured capsule in the ball of his foot during a Week Two game against the Seahawks. Kaepernick said that slowed him down for most of the rest of the season.

“It was something that was always there,” he said. “Never spoke about it, never said anything about it because you’re a football player; you play through pain. Unless you’re being carted off, you should be on the field. If it’s something you can play through, that’s what you do.”

Kaepernick said he views the injury as just part of football.

“I think that’s the kind of players we have on this team: You’re not going to let something that’s minor, that’s not a true injury, keep you off of the field,” he said. “You’re going to hurt, yes. You’re going to have tweaks and problems. But you’re a football player; you can play through those.”

Kaepernicke played through the injury last year, and played well.

Permalink 35 Comments Feed for comments Back to top

Wednesday morning one-liners

NFC Championship - San Francisco 49ers v Seattle Seahawks Getty Images

Said Bills DT Marcell Dareus of the team’s response to his off-field problems, “It’s been great. The team has been so supportive. The coach has been outstanding. This is a great atmosphere to be around.”

Dolphins coach Joe Philbin says his team needs to block better.

Patriots coach Bill Belichick shared some thoughts about the NFL expanding practice squads.

Here’s the Jets’ guide for fans attending this week’s preseason game.

Ravens QB Joe Flacco says critics of Browns QB Johnny Manziel should “get over it.”

Among Manziel’s critics is former Bengals QB Boomer Esiason.

In the Bengals’ weight room, the most important exercise is the squat.

Said Steelers G.M. Kevin Colbert of experimenting with cameras in players’ helmets, “When we tape football, we do it from an end zone, the sideline and a high angle, and none of that is what a player sees. To be able to tell a quarterback where he should be, to be able to show a defense what an offense looks like at ground level would be great. That would be more realistic.”

The Texans’ defense made things difficult for Peyton Manning during a joint practice with the Broncos.

Colts coach Chuck Pagano says his defense is better now than it’s been at any point in the last two years.

The Jaguars may put QB Ricky Stanzi on the practice squad.

The Titans want to put more pressure on opposing quarterbacks.

The Broncos’ website says LT Ryan Clady handled Jadeveon Clowneywith relative ease” in the joint practice with the Texans.

Chiefs RBs Knile Davis and Cyrus Gray got a chance to show what they can do while Jamaal Charles was held out of practice.

The Raiders are still waiting on CB D.J. Hayden to get healthy.

Chargers CB Jason Verrett is getting healthy at the right time.

Cowboys QB Brandon Weeden is still viewed as a work in progress.

Giants WR Marcus Harris is standing out in training camp.

Training like Navy SEALs has made a difference for the Eagles.

Washington special teams coach Ben Kotwica draws on his military experience in his coaching.

The Bears think former first-round pick Shea McClellin is making strides after changing positions.

Said Lions coach Jim Caldwell of WR Calvin Johnson missing the first two preseason games, “I know he’s been itching to get in. Maybe the humblest individual that I’ve ever been around, and not only that, maybe the hardest worker. He’s a tremendous person, and he’s just tireless in terms of his efforts to get on the field and help his team.”

The Packers expect Julius Peppers to improve the run defense in addition to rushing the quarterback.

Former Vikings QB Todd Bouman is making an impression in his new career in coaching.

Falcons DT Corey Peters says he battled depression after suffering an Achilles injury last year.

Panthers S Anderson Russell is working to make a name for himself.

Here’s a look at some of the Saints’ female fans.

The Buccaneers’ offensive line seems to be making progress, but there’s plenty of work left to do.

Said Cardinals K Jay Feely of another training camp at age 38, “I’m grateful that I get another opportunity. I’m going to out there and keep getting better and get ready for September. That’s always my focus. I could care less how I kick in June; I’m always focused on the beginning of the season — that first game of the season.”

The Rams have Greg Robinson working double duty on the offensive line.

Said 49ers QB Colin Kaepernick of the team’s needs on offense, “Establish a rhythm. I think that’s the biggest thing we need to do right now.”

Erin Andrews regrets the abrupt way she ended her infamous interview with Seahawks CB Richard Sherman.

Permalink 0 Comments Feed for comments Back to top

Larry Fitzgerald says Cardinals must overcome injury to Darnell Dockett

Larry Fitzgerald AP

In the NFL, injuries are an unavoidable occurrence.

No matter how lucky a team gets on the injury front in a given year, they are bound to lose someone to injury at some point during the season.

The Arizona Cardinals lost defensive lineman Darnell Dockett to a torn ACL this week. Dockett has been a stalwart of Arizona’s defense for years and his loss will create a sizable void to be filled this season.

Receiver Larry Fitzgerald said it’s something the Cardinals still must be able to overcome.

“It’s something that happens far too often in our game and teams have to weather it,” Fitzgerald said, via “The Drive” on FOX Sports 910 in Phoenix. “Coach [Bruce] Arians talked about it yesterday in our night meeting that no team has even won a Super Bowl that starts the season with the same 11 or 22 guys that finish the season when they win the Super Bowl. Even when we made our Super Bowl run, there are guys that went down, there was guys that stepped up to the plate and we’re going to need guys to come in and perform and fill those big shoes that he’s leaving.”

The Cardinals defense was among the league’s best last season. Arizona ranked 6th in total defense and kept the Cardinals in every game they played over the final three months of the season.

If it was just the loss of Dockett, the Cardinals may have very well been able to overcome his injury. However, Arizona has also lost linebackers Karlos Dansby to the Cleveland Browns and Daryl Washington to suspension. Replacing that many pieces may be too much for the Cardinals to overcome.

Permalink 6 Comments Feed for comments Back to top