Skip to content

Voting ends today for Giants, Eagles Mt. Rushmores

New York Giants v Philadelphia Eagles Getty Images

The Pro Football Talk Mt. Rushmore series began Monday, with both the Cowboys and Redskins.

On Tuesday, we continue with another pair of franchises that have storied histories:  the Giants and the Eagles.

Both have generated well over 50,000 total votes, with the Giants currently scraping 60,000.  But the Eagles have produced to date the closest competition for the fourth spot on the PFT Planet-determined mountain.  So we’re re-posting the Philly poll below, and encouraging you to keep voting.

And while we don’t want to reveal the results of the voting, the four-man scrum for the fourth spot comes down to Randall Cunningham, Steve Van Buren, Norm Van Brocklin, and Donovan McNabb.

You can also keep voting for your favorite Giants, too.

Both will be unveiled at 5:00 p.m. ET on NBCSN.

Permalink 10 Comments Feed for comments Latest Stories in: Home, New York Giants, Philadelphia Eagles, Rumor Mill
10 Responses to “Voting ends today for Giants, Eagles Mt. Rushmores”
  1. therealtrenches says: Jun 4, 2013 7:18 AM

    Van Buren was the best player of his time and brought two NFL championships to Philly. No other Eagle can say both of those things. He’s the greatest Eagle of any era.

    An Eagles Mt Rushmore without him would be a monument to youthful fan ignorance.

  2. aaronmushrush says: Jun 4, 2013 7:48 AM

    Chuck Bednarik.
    Brian Dawkins.
    Donavan McNabb.
    Andy Reid.

  3. brocattosbasement says: Jun 4, 2013 8:35 AM

    I’m guessing Florio doesn’t agree with who is currently winning the 4th spot. Keep voting until he does. lol

  4. espfdps says: Jun 4, 2013 10:57 AM

    Brian Dawkins, Reggie White, Van Buren, Chuck

  5. leftygun says: Jun 4, 2013 11:22 AM

    Jerome Brown was poised to become one of the all-time greats at his position. Ultimate tragedy.

  6. ochospantalones says: Jun 4, 2013 12:31 PM

    Cunningham and McNabb were both very good players, but neither was remotely in the class of Norm Van Brocklin or Steve Van Buren.

    Van Brocklin was a great player, but he only played three years with the Eagles. He led the team to the 1960 NFL Championship, which puts him ahead of Cunningham and McNabb, but behind the next guy.

    The clear choice of the four is Van Buren. He played his entire career with the Eagles. He was a seven-time All Pro, and two-time NFL champion. He scored the only points in ’48 NFL Championship game, in a blizzard. He’s in the Hall of Fame.

    The only other player who really merits consideration for the final spot is Jerome Brown. He was already a legend in this city, and has been dearly missed. If there was not a strong candidate for the final spot I would say put him in, but there is.

  7. pnut87 says: Jun 4, 2013 1:15 PM

    As a Giants fan, I have to give a respectful nod to at least Bednarik and Dawkins.

  8. deathmonkey41 says: Jun 4, 2013 3:00 PM

    This list doesn’t have a King Dunlap, or a Jon Harris, or even a Todd Pinkston. What a stupid list.

  9. phillyfan75 says: Jun 4, 2013 3:35 PM

    I’m sorry, but there really is little room for legitimate debate here. The Eagles top four is really clear cut.

    It’s Steve Van Buren, Chuck Bednarik, Reggie White, and Brian Dawkins.

    Steve Van Buren is a Hall of Famer who led the Eagles to two NFL Championships. It’s just stupid to not include him. He should be the first bust on the Eagles Mt. Rushmore.

    Chuck Bednarik is a Hall of Fame two-way player who led the Eagles to an NFL Championship in 1960 and was also on the 1949 NFL Championship team. He’s an absolute no brainer as the second bust on the Eagles Mt. Rushmore.

    Yes, Reggie White left to play with the Packers, but he was arguably the best defensive linemen to ever play the game, and his best years were with the Eagles. He is undoubtedly the third bust on the Eagles Mt. Rushmore.

    Brian Dawkins was the best player and the heart and soul of the 2000 Eagles that dominated the NFC East and went to five NFC Championship games, and is a likely Hall of Famer. There was arguably no other player in the history of the Eagles franchise who was as respected, admired, and loved by the Philadelphia fan base. Eagles fans saw their passion for their team in Dawkins every time he stepped out on the field. Dawkins has to be the final bust on the Eagles Mt. Rushmore.

    Randall Cunningham and Donovan McNabb were terrific players, but neither are Hall of Famers, nor did they win championships or have the deep connection with the fan base like a Brian Dawkins did. Norm Van Brocklin was great, but played for the Eagles for just three years.

  10. phillyfan75 says: Jun 4, 2013 3:43 PM

    I’m sorry, but I just saw the comment about Jerome Brown arguably deserving a spot, and I just wholeheartedly disagree. I loved Jerome – his jersey is one of only two that I own.

    Jerome doesn’t make the top ten candidates for Mt. Rushmore status. He only played five years. He was great, but was not a franchise trans-formative player. I don’t want to take anything away from him, but I think people have exaggerated his presence in the wake of his death, as often happens.

    He may have been one of the most talented and even best players on the Eagles of all-time, but Mt. Rushmore status is more than that. You have to have a long lasting impact on and connection with the franchise and city.

    After the clear cut top four, I would include, at least, McNabb, Cunningham, Ron Jaworski, Andy Reid, Dick Vermeil, Greasy Neale and Tom Brookshier ahead of Jerome Brown.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!