Skip to content

Some scouts are concerned Bridgewater will never become a starter

Teddy Bridgewater AP

With the bizarre disconnect between the media’s pre-Combine love of Teddy Bridgewater to the pre-draft belief by some of the most plugged in draft experts that Bridgewater will slide out of round one entirely, we’ve decided to try to figure out what teams think of the guy.

And while the reality is that every team could have a vastly different view of a player, with some loving the player and others hating him (or 31 hating him and one loving him enough to make him a first-round pick), some scouts are concerned that Bridgewater may never become a starting quarterback in the NFL.

(I generally avoid sharing opinions from anonymous scouts before the draft because of the potential for bias and agenda affecting the scout’s opinion.  The rule of thumb remains that scouts who love a guy will be inclined to knock him in the hopes of having the player fall to their team, and that scouts who hate a guy will be inclined to say good things about him, so that another team will waste a pick on the player.  I’m making an exception in this case because:  (1) the conflicting views on Bridgewater have become frustrating to the point of maddening; (2) I’m convinced that the scout who shared this information isn’t trying to grease the skids for Bridgewater to slide to his team; (3) the scout is sufficiently experienced and knowledgeable and proven in his work to make his views reliable; and (4) the biggest problem I have with the use of opinions from anonymous scouts is that reporters who share the information typically don’t provide this kind of background or disclaimer, making it impossible for the audience to even begin to assess the reliability of the information.)

With all that said (and if you’re still reading this, you get a free one-year subscription to PFT), the thinking is that Bridgewater has the will to become a great quarterback.  He’ll work hard, and he’ll do everything that is asked of him.  He’ll never create a single problem for the franchise, being a good teammate and a model citizen.

Physically, however, the thinking by some is that Bridgewater simply lacks the attributes necessary to make him one of the rare men who can be starting quarterbacks in the NFL.  Bridgewater isn’t particularly big, he’s not particularly fast, his hands aren’t particularly large, and he doesn’t have a particularly strong arm in comparison to other starting quarterbacks.

He’s also viewed by some as a player who won’t take control of an offense.  The young quarterbacks who have thrived right away have that trait; they take over immediately, and it’s undeniable that they deserve the job.

While there’s a perception that young quarterbacks who become starters immediately are in some way anointed by their teams, the blessing often comes not from the coaching staff or the front office but from the players, who won’t follow or respond to a quarterback in whom they don’t believe.  With Bridgewater, there’s a concern that Bridgewater won’t take over in the way that he needs to take over.

So why did the teams and the draft experts have such a different view of Bridgewater?  One reason could be that teams spend more time scouting seniors than underclassmen during the season, since it’s typically not known which of the underclassmen will be available in the draft.  Every player has a ceiling at some point between college football and the Pro Football Hall of Fame; it seems that the draft experts’ assessment of Bridgewater’s ceiling has been much more favorable than the assessment that has occurred by the folks whose jobs depend on their ability to divine the potential of future NFL players.

Obviously, Bridgewater’s one and only open workout specifically for NFL scouts didn’t do much to convince teams that he’s ready to rise to the occasion and bust through the ceiling that would allow him to be an effective NFL starter.  With so many future NFL quarterbacks — franchise players, busts, and all in between — consistently having stellar Pro Day workouts, Bridgewater’s was glaring, and it reinforced the opinions that some already had.

With two extra weeks to go until the draft and some owners showing a willingness to take advantage of that extra time to display more interest in the process, current questions like, “Explain to me why you’re interested in this guy again?” eventually could become, “Explain to my why you draft this guy again?”

Which eventually could become a decision by the owner to have someone else do the drafting.  Which has resulted in the most plugged-in draft experts coming to the conclusion that Bridgewater has become destined to slide out of round one.

Permalink 71 Comments Feed for comments Latest Stories in: Rumor Mill, Top Stories

Jets get three picks signed

CLEMSON, SC - NOVEMBER 17:  Juston Burris #11 of the North Carolina State Wolfpack intercepts a pass intended for Sammy Watkins #2 of the Clemson Tigers during their game at Memorial Stadium on November 17, 2012 in Clemson, South Carolina.  (Photo by Streeter Lecka/Getty Images) Getty Images

The Jets will hold their first rookie minicamp practice on Friday and it’s pretty good bet that most of the focus during and after that session is going to be on how quarterback Christian Hackenberg fares in his first workout since being selected in the second round.

There was time to focus on other members of the draft class on Thursday, however, and the Jets used it to sign three other players to their first NFL contracts. The team announced that they have signed fourth-round cornerback Juston Burris, fifth-round tackle Brandon Shell and seventh-round punter Lachlan Edwards.

Burris was a three-year starter at N.C. State and adds good size to a Jets cornerback group that said goodbye to 2015 starter Antonio Cromartie as the offseason got underway. The Jets traded up to get Shell, who is the great nephew of NFL Hall of Famer Art Shell and who started at both right and left tackle during his time at South Carolina.

The Jets moved on from Ryan Quigley at punter, leaving Edwards and undrafted signee Tom Hackett as the only punters currently on the roster.

Permalink 0 Comments Feed for comments Back to top

Patriots price Seahawks tickets as this year’s “elite” home game

Super Bowl XLIX - New England Patriots v Seattle Seahawks Getty Images

The Patriots have one “elite” opponent on this year’s home schedule, and that honor goes to the Seahawks.

New England is one of the many NFL teams that uses variable ticket pricing, charging more money to attend the more expensive games. On this year’s schedule, the Week 10 home game against the Seahawks on Sunday Night Football is labeled as “elite” and costs the most, with tickets ranging in price from $111 for the cheap seats to $275 for lower level tickets near the 50-yard line.

The Patriots also label two games as “marquee.” Those two games, against the Dolphins and Bengals, range in price from $90 to $245.

The other five regular-season games range in price from $77 to $199, while the two preseason games range from $37 to $95.

The Ravens are on this year’s home schedule for the Patriots, but that is one of the five regularly priced games, an argument perhaps that Joe Flacco is not elite.

Permalink 3 Comments Feed for comments Back to top

Will Smith’s widow attends ceremony to receive his graduate degree


Wiping away tears and sitting in a wheelchair, the widow of former Saints defensive end Will Smith accepted his graduate degree from the University of Miami on Thursday.

Will Smith was shot and killed in New Orleans on April 9. His wife Raquel was shot in both legs in the incident and is still recuperating, but she was able to attend the graduation ceremony for the University of Miami’s Executive MBA program for artists and athletes.

The Saints tweeted a video of the graduation ceremony, showing Raquel being pushed across the stage in her wheelchair as the crowd applauded the announcement that she was accepting the degree, which was being awarded to Will posthumously.

Smith played his college football at Ohio State and received his undergraduate degree in criminology in 2005.

Photo via New Orleans Saints.

Permalink 0 Comments Feed for comments Back to top

PFT Live finishes the week with a flourish


If you’re up early and looking for something to do (other than the thing that got you to get up early), listen to PFT Live on NBC Sports Radio for three hours of football talk and analysis and debate and maybe a few off-topic discussions depending on where the caffeine from the coffee takes me.

Today’s show takes us (by phone) to Arizona for a chat with Cardinals G.M. Steve Keim, to Oakland for a visit with Hall of Famer Rod Woodson, to Miami for a conversation with Dolphins executive V.P. of football operations Mike Tannenbaum, and then to Charlotte for a sit-down (I’ll be sitting; the guest technically could be standing) with Panthers G.M. Dave Gettleman.

So dial up Sirius 213, XM 202,, the NBC Sports Radio app, or any of the various terrestrial stations that carry the show.

You can also subscribe to the podcast at iTunes or audioBoom.

Permalink 0 Comments Feed for comments Back to top

Texans sign three draft picks

San Jose State running back Tyler Ervin (7) runs with the football while playing against Hawaii in the first quarter of an NCAA college football game, Saturday, Nov. 21, 2015, in Honolulu. (AP Photo/Eugene Tanner) AP

The Houston Texans managed to get half of their draft class signed to contracts on Thursday.

According to Aaron Wilson and John McClain of the Houston Chronicle, the Texans signed fourth-round running back Tyler Ervin, and fifth-round picks, safety K.J. Dillon and defensive tackle D.J. Reader, to their four-year rookie contracts.

The trio were the final three picks of the draft for Houston. Wide receiver Will Fuller, center Nick Martin and receiver Braxton Miller remain unsigned.

Per the reports, Ervin’s contract is worth $2.877 million with a $547,568 signing bonus, Dillon’s deal is worth $2.574 million with a $234,936 signing bonus and Reader’s contract is worth $2.55 million contract with a $215,380 signing bonus.

Permalink 0 Comments Feed for comments Back to top

Two-Time Division II player of the year among Jets’ 13 undrafted free agents

In a Sept. 13, 2014, photo provided by Ferris State University, Ferris State quarterback Jason Vander Laan, a Harlon Hill Trophy finalist, looks to pass during an NCAA college football game against Northwood in Midland, Mich. Vander Laan is one of the top players in The Associated Press Little All-America team, honoring the top players in Divisions II and III and NAIA. Vander Laan is responsible for 50 touchdowns (30 TD passes and 20 touchdowns rushing) and led Ferris State to the Great Lakes Athletic Conference championship. The Harlon Hill Trophy, which goes to the top player in Division II, will be presented Friday, Dec. 19. (AP Photo/Ferris State University) AP

Jason Vander Laan, a two-time winner of the Harlon Hill Trophy (Division II Heisman), as a quarterback at Ferris State was signed to play tight end by the New York Jets.

Vander Laan (pictured) became the first player in NCAA history to pass and run for 1,000 yards in four consecutive seasons. His 5,953 career rush yards are the most for a quarterback in NCAA history. The Jets are attempting to convert the 6-foot-4, 244 pound athlete to tight end for his jump to the pros.

Vander Laan is among 13 undrafted free agents signed by the Jets.

The Jets have also added Temple wide receiver Robby Anderson, Penn State nose tackle Tarow Barney, Iowa State wide receiver Quenton Bundrage, Temple center Kyle Friend, Utah punter Tom Hackett, Ohio State wide receiver Jalin Marshall, Duke kicker Ross Martin, Western Carolina defensive end Helva Matungulu, Appalachian State safety Doug Middleton, Texas A&M defensive end Julien Obioha, USC defensive end Claude Pelon and Michigan State defensive end Lawrence Thomas.

Permalink 0 Comments Feed for comments Back to top

Colts sign four more draft picks

IOWA CITY, IA - NOVEMBER 14: Offensive lineman Austin Blythe #63 of the Iowa Hawkeyes waits to take the field before the match-up against the Minnesota Gophers on November 14, 2015 at Kinnick Stadium, in Iowa City, Iowa. (Photo by Matthew Holst/Getty Images)

The Colts announced Thursday that they’ve agreed to terms with four more members of their 2016 draft class. They signed first-round pick Ryan Kelly on Wednesday.

Thursday, the team finished deals with fourth-round defensive tackle Hassan Ridgeway, fifth-round offensive tackle Joe Haeg, seventh-round linebacker Trevor Bates and seventh-round center Austin Blythe.

Ridgeway had 3.5 sacks and two fumble recoveries last season at Texas. He was the only defensive line pick in a Colts draft class heavy on offensive linemen. Haeg was a two-time All-American at FCS national champion North Dakota State, while Blythe was a finalist for the Rimington Award and a key member of one of college football’s best offensive lines at Iowa.

Bates had 7.5 sacks and returned a fumble for a touchdown last season at Maine.

Permalink 0 Comments Feed for comments Back to top

Dolphins finalize contract for 7th round QB

BOWLING GREEN, KY - NOVEMBER 27: Brandon Doughty #12 of the Western Kentucky Hilltoppers passes against the Marshall Thundering Herd in the first half of the game at L.T. Smith Stadium on November 27, 2015 in Bowling Green, Kentucky. (Photo by Joe Robbins/Getty Images) Getty Images

The Dolphins have agreed to terms with rookie quarterback Brandon Doughty, the Miami Herald reported Thursday.

The Dolphins drafted Doughty in the seventh round last weekend, with pick No. 223. The 6-foot-3 Doughty led the NCAA in passing yards in each of his final two college seasons at Western Kentucky. He’s a native of Davie, Fla., where the Dolphins conduct their day-to-day operations.

Doughty is the first quarterback the Dolphins have selected since drafting Ryan Tannehill in 2012.

Teams across the league have been busy signing draft picks. The Falcons signed their entire draft class Thursday, becoming the first team to do so.

Permalink 4 Comments Feed for comments Back to top

Falcons become first team to sign all their draft picks

BATON ROUGE, LA - OCTOBER 24: Linebacker Deion Jones #45 of the LSU Tigers looks to sack quarterback Brandon Doughty #12 of the Western Kentucky Hilltoppers on October 24, 2015 at Tiger Stadium in Baton Rouge, Louisiana. (Photo by Michael Chang/Getty Images) Getty Images

The Falcons have become the first team to sign every member of their 2016 draft class to their rookie contracts.

Atlanta got the ball rolling with safety Keanu Neal on Wednesday and announced on Thursday evening that they have secured deals with their other five picks. At the rate that rookies have been signing around the league, they shouldn’t be the only team with every pick signed for too long.

Second-round linebacker Deion Jones, third-round tight end Austin Hooper, fourth-round linebacker De’Vondre Campbell, sixth-round guard Wes Schweitzer and seventh-round wide receiver Devin Fuller joined Neal as Falcons selections this year.

Jones is slated to play middle linebacker, where he could push aside incumbent starter Paul Worrilow and bring some speed to a defense that needs it. Hooper could also see a lot of playing time early after showing at Stanford that he can make plays as a receiver and can use size to be an effective blocker.

Permalink 2 Comments Feed for comments Back to top

Tom Benson again points out “ingratitude” of family members

Tom Benson AP

On Thursday, the members of Saints owner Tom Benson’s family who continue to hope to overturn his desire to exclude them from ownership of the Saints or the NBA’s Pelicans claimed that “the truth will come out” about Benson’s health condition, urging that anyone “with relevant information” about Benson’s alleged capacity “should continue to come forward.”

The allegations come thee days after the Louisiana Supreme Court refused to consider an appeal of the latest ruling upholding changes to Tom Benson’s will that froze out his daughter, Renee Benson, and grandchildren Rita and Ryan LeBlanc. Although the challenge to the new will seems to be over, the comments from the family members reveal that hard feelings remain.

Tom Benson has fired back with a statement that further underscores the acrimony among the family members.

“We are in Louisville this week where my wife’s GMB Racing operation will start Mo Tom and Tom’s Ready this Saturday in the running of the 142nd Kentucky Derby,” Tom Benson said in a statement issued by the Saints. “We had the privilege today to discuss potential business relationships with a number of horse farms in the area.

“Gayle and I could not be more excited in our preparations for the Kentucky Derby. And equally so — we are thrilled to bring this excitement to everyone in New Orleans. We are blessed to have a great team of loyal executives and friends. Our three trainers are from New Orleans and our two jockeys come from Louisiana. This is important to me. We are having the time of our lives here in Louisville.

“While certain members of my family continue to harass me with negative threatening statements, I continue to plan for the future. Nevertheless, the ingratitude shown by certain members of my family, despite the vast financial and other benefits I have given them, is very hard to accept.”

Tom Benson issued a statement in February that made similar points regarding his estranged family members.

As it now stands, Gayle Benson will assume control of both the football team and the basketball team after Tom Benson passes. Subject, of course, to further changes to the will. It’s safe to say Tom Benson won’t be changing his will to bring Renee Benson, Rita LeBlance, or Ryan LeBlanc back into the picture.

Permalink 12 Comments Feed for comments Back to top

Andrew Luck loses big in annual slow-time player poll


With the draft over, the only dead spot on the calendar is approaching for the NFL. What better way to fill the void than to devote 10 weeks to a made-for-TV player poll that is sufficiently flawed to fulfill the objective of generating conversation?

NFL Network’s annual “Best Players Of [Same Stuff, Different Year]” poll debuted last night, with the unveiling of No. 91 through 100. Coming in at No. 92 was, somehow, Colts quarterback Andrew Luck.

Luck fell a full 85 spots from 2015.

The Colts currently intend to make Luck the highest-paid player in the history of the sport, if/when team and player can agree on how much more he should be paid than anyone else ever has been paid. But he’s regarded as the 92nd best player in the NFL.

How does that happen? The explanation is surprisingly simple. Unless NFLN has changed the procedure for compiling the list (and if it ain’t fixed, why break it?), the 100 names came from a stream of players who, while passing through the NFL Media car wash over the past several months, at some point scrawled onto a piece of paper a knee-jerk list of the best 20 players in the NFL.

With Luck out of sight for much of last season due to shoulder, rib, and kidney injuries, he would have been out of mind on most of the ballots. Which resulted in Luck nearly being shunned entirely.

Of course he’s better than No. 92. And of course the fact that he landed there is further evidence that the entire process is a waste of time.

But there’s plenty of time to waste between now and the start of training camp. If the goal is to waste that time with stuff that people notice (even if they notice it for the wrong reasons), there’s only one thing to say: Mission accomplished.

Permalink 15 Comments Feed for comments Back to top

Chargers sign fifth-round linebacker

SAN DIEGO, CA - MAY 11:  NFL Rookie Ladarius Green #89 of the San Diego Chargers holds his helmet at arms length after participating in drills during a minicamp workout on May 11, 2012 in San Diego, California. (Photo by Kent C. Horner/Getty Images) Getty Images

Count the Chargers among the teams that have started signing their draft picks.

Linebacker Jatavis Brown, a fifth-round pick, signed a four-year deal with the Chargers on Thursday.

Brown was not invited to the Scouting Combine last February but was the 2015 Mid-American Conference Defensive Player of the Year at Akron. He set school records last season with 20 tackles for loss and 12 sacks.

Brown grew up in Belle Glade, Fla., with new Chargers wide receiver Travis Benjamin.

Permalink 1 Comment Feed for comments Back to top

Lawyer wants to see Manziel and ex-girlfriend “kiss and make up”


It’s a football career that has induced plenty of cringes in the last 24 months. So it makes sense that the lawyer representing unemployed quarterback Johnny Manziel would offer up a sound bite on Thursday that induced even more cringes.

Asked by reporters to identify the preferred outcome of Manziel’s pending criminal case involving allegations of assaulting his ex-girlfriend, attorney Robert Hinton said he hopes that “[e]verybody would kiss and make up.”

And that wasn’t even the most problematic thing Hinton said. He added that Manziel likely would return to Los Angeles at some point. Which provides further proof that Manziel isn’t willing or able to make the changes he needs to get back to the NFL. Indeed, it shows he still hasn’t recognized that changes are even needed.

Permalink 7 Comments Feed for comments Back to top

Junior Seau’s nephew among 19 undrafted players signed by Rams

TUCSON, AZ - DECEMBER 29:  Defensive end Ian Seau #8 of the Nevada Wolf Pack sits on the bench during the Nova Home Loans Arizona Bowl against the Colorado State Rams at Arizona Stadium on December 29, 2015 in Tucson, Arizona. The Wolf Pack defeated the Rams 28-23. (Photo by Christian Petersen/Getty Images) Getty Images

The nephew of one of the greatest players ever to play college football at the Los Angeles Memorial Coliseum will get a chance to play pro football at the Los Angeles Memorial Coliseum.

Ian Seau, a defensive end who played his college ball at Nevada-Reno, has signed as an undrafted free agent with the Rams. Seau is the nephew of the late Junior Seau, who played at the Coliseum as a star linebacker for USC and then had a Hall of Fame career in the NFL.

The Rams also announced that they’ve signed 18 other undrafted free agents: Texas A&M K Taylor Bertolet, Wake Forest LB Brandon Chubb, Colorado State-Pueblo DE Morgan Fox, Arkansas S Rohan Gaines, TCU RB Aaron Green, Pitt LB Nicholas Grigsby, Vanderbilt LB Darreon Herring, Missouri Western DB Michael Jordan, Washington LB Cory Littleton, Iowa FS Jordan Lomax, Southeast Missouri State WR Paul McRoberts, Northwestern State OL Pace Murphy, Tennessee WR Marquez North, Washington State LB Kache Palacio, Tennessee S Brian Randolf, New Mexico State CB Winston Rose, Colorado WR Nelson Spruce and Kentucky OL Jordan Swindle.

Two tryout players, LS Jeffrey Overbaugh and WR Jimmy Worton, will get a shot to show what they can do at the Rams’ rookie minicamp.

Permalink 5 Comments Feed for comments Back to top

Buccaneers get deals done with a pair of their draft picks

Tampa Bay Bucaneers v New England Patriots Getty Images

The Buccaneers joined the pick-signing party, reaching deals with a pair of their own.

The team announced they had signed fourth-round defensive back Ryan Smith, and agreed to terms with fifth-round offensive lineman Caleb Benenoch. The Bucs have five more picks to sign, and there’s no reason to think it’ll be complicated.

Smith, from North Carolina Central, was his school’s all-time leaders in tackles and kickoff return average, adding some speed to the Bucs secondary. They plan to try him at safety, and he should have a chance to help on special teams immediately.

Benenoch was a three-year starter at UCLA, and could offer depth at tackle and guard.

Permalink 1 Comment Feed for comments Back to top