Bizarre courtroom scenes lead to Greg Hardy conviction

AP

Panthers defensive end Greg Hardy was found guilty last night on two counts of assault on a female and communicating threats at the Mecklenburg County Courthouse.

It just felt like it was on the set of the Jerry Springer Show.

As compiled by Bill Voth of Black and Blue Review, the trial had more than a bit of a circus atmosphere, full of bizarre testimony that made both sides look bad.

Hardy’s accuser admitted to using cocaine the night of the attack, and when defense attorneys asked her about a previous car accident she was in in which police found marijuana on the scene, she replied: “The weed flew out of my car.”

And when defense attorneys asked Holder how she came through an assault from a player the size of Hardy “without breaking a fingernail,” she replied: “Uh, I did break a fingernail, a toenail.”

But she also described Hardy going into a jealous rage when he heard a song from Nelly in the nightclub they were in, since Holder had a brief affair with the rapper who is a minority owner of the Charlotte Hornets.

As it pertains to the Panthers franchised-tagged defensive end, the details in court painted a picture of a bizarre up-and-down relationship, which included him taking Holder to Hawaii for the Pro Bowl, only to surprise her by sending her back to Charlotte while he went to New York for the Super Bowl.

There were also allegations of the guns he kept in his home, with one witness saying  “Oh my God, there’s so many guns,” when she walked into his apartment.

Then there was the bizarre exchange in which prosecutors asked him if he was drinking the night of the assault.

Prosecutor Jamie Adams: “You had alcohol.”

Hardy: “Champagne.”

Adams: “Is champagne alcohol?”

Hardy: “You tell me.”

Adams: “OK we’ll move on.”

While Hardy was found guilty, his lawyers said they’d appeal to a jury trial, which could drag out well beyond the coming season.

How much of that season he plays for the Panthers remains to be seen.

66 responses to “Bizarre courtroom scenes lead to Greg Hardy conviction

  1. Interesting. I still think he beats this. Mainly because of this: ‘And when defense attorneys asked Holder how she came through an assault from a player the size of Hardy “without breaking a fingernail,” she replied: “Uh, I did break a fingernail, a toenail.”’

    So you were choked, slammed into a wall, thrown onto a bed of metal, and thought you were a dead woman, but your worst injury is a broken toe nail? Come on now….

  2. Way to leave us hanging! Is Champagne alcohol or not?! I hear they are doing a sequel on the Maury Povich Show. It’s supposed to be bigger than the Jersey Shore

  3. If the guy from the Cowboys can drink to the point of double the legal limit, then get in a car with a teammate and go 100+mph and end up killing him, then hangout on the sidelines, not get cut by the Cowboys, and possibly still be on the team in the future, then all I’ve got to say is:

    Nothing in this league shocks me anymore. Period.

  4. And when defense attorneys asked Holder how she came through an assault from a player the size of Hardy “without breaking a fingernail,” she replied: “Uh, I did break a fingernail, a toenail.”

    Best part.

  5. Prosecutor Jamie Adams: “You had alcohol.”

    Hardy: “Champagne.”

    Adams: “Is champagne alcohol?”

    Hardy: “You tell me.”

    Adams: “OK we’ll move on.”

    *********************

    That’s gold Jerry! Gold!

  6. It’s pretty clear by now that the IQ of Hardy and Holder combined is somewhere south of 80.

  7. “There were also allegations of the guns he kept in his home, with one witness saying “Oh my God, there’s so many guns,” when she walked into his apartment.”

    “…allegations of the guns…” – what’s that even mean? Of all the terrible, weird things this guy is being accused/found guilty of, owning guns regardless of quantity isn’t one of them.

  8. Not a funny situation but…

    That exchange about champagne was funny as hell. I’ve worked with lawyers for 10 years and I love it when people mess with them.

  9. I think it’s damn near impossible to tell what really happened that night, but I think the only logical conclusion to the trial is to order both these morons to stay away from each other forever. They’re both mentally instable & that shizz don’t mix.

    Is champagne achohol?
    You tell me.

    Classic response. Haha.

  10. If ray rice walked away after being caught on camera knocking a woman out then dragging her out of the elevator, Hardy will have no problem.

  11. That exchange between Hardy and the prosecutor is awesome.

    These two individuals seem pretty well met actually – lets ust hope they don’t attempt procreation.

  12. Somehow human males are hard wired to be goofy around hot females. It is in the genes. Our primate cousins aren’t nearly as stupid. The only critters I’ve seen that are as stupid as us are male dogs. They allow the females to act all nasty and themselves to get bit and they just hang around just in case she changes her mind.

  13. Somewhere Greg Hardy is awaiting an answer if champagne is alcohol…no really, he really does want to know because he doesn’t know himself.

  14. Nothing like a little arrogance on the stand to endear you to the judge overseeing your case. Hardy may be an excellent football player, but common sense seems to be at a premium with him and those around him. When will these young divas realize they’ve been handed a golden opportunity to improve their lives, and the lives of their families, instead of wrapping yourself in bling and attitude? Cut his ass.

  15. Champagne is NOT alcohol. Alcohol is alcohol. Champagne is wine which contains some alcohol.

    Thanks for playing.

  16. andreboy1 says:
    Jul 16, 2014 8:46 AM

    That exchange about champagne was funny as hell. I’ve worked with lawyers for 10 years and I love it when people mess with them.
    ====================================

    Looks like the lawyer got the last laugh. Perhaps he should have been more contrite.

  17. Nelly rocks, poor guy , silly how insecure these big guys can be! Doesn’t he realize that Nelly will always be #1, 2 is not a winner and 3 nobody remembers!

  18. All I can say is, I sure hope these two idiots break up before they have a chance to procreate.

  19. “Is Champagne alcohol”

    “you tell me”

    Yeah, you were guilty right there. Here’s an idea, when you are taking part in a trial without a jury, don’t disrespect the judge and his/her courtroom

  20. What kind of trial was this if they can “appeal to a jury trial”?

    If Hardy’s lawyers took it bench they made a big mistake, juries would not believe for a second the alleged victim after she admits she was doing cocaine and claims she was brutally assaulted with no injury.

    I also am surprised they called Hardy to testify. If she was choked there would have been redness or bruising to her neck. The lack of injury destroys the State’s case. There is no need to subject your client to cross-examination.

    That’s my two cents anyways.

  21. hawkeye592
    Jul 16, 2014, 7:32 AM CDT
    I suppose I would feel like assaulting people as well if they played Nelly at any club I went to.
    ——————————————
    You prefer Nickelback? Not sure how anyone doesn’t like Nelly. You clearly are no fun to hang out with.

  22. That lawyer is an idiot. Why ask for clarification on a question the man answered? I’m pretty sure 99% of the population knows champagne is an alcoholic product.

    Also, I saw the list of guns from Hardy’s apartment and I know people with many more than that. Owning them is not a crime. We are just raised in a society were a lot of people are very uncomfortable with guns at all.

  23. titansbro says:Jul 16, 2014 8:46 AM

    I think it’s damn near impossible to tell what really happened that night, but I think the only logical conclusion to the trial is to order both these morons to stay away from each other forever. They’re both mentally instable & that shizz don’t mix.

    Which means they will be right back together……if they not already.

  24. sumkat says: Jul 16, 2014 9:33 AM

    “Is Champagne alcohol”

    “you tell me”

    Yeah, you were guilty right there. Here’s an idea, when you are taking part in a trial without a jury, don’t disrespect the judge and his/her courtroom
    ________________

    what a retarded question though. he answered the attorney’s question by stating he had champagne. for the attorney to take that any further was simply asking for the response he got.

  25. Owning a bunch of guns is odd but leaving them laying around your apartment (according to testimony they were on the bar, on the bed and scattered around the place) is downright bizarre. I can’t think of any rational reason for that. Its moronic.

  26. He’s gonna be Jovan Belcher 2.0 if North Carolina or the NFL allows him to keep his arsenal.

  27. ugadogs21 says: Jul 16, 2014 10:54 AM

    Their kids will be extraordinarily stupid.

    ————————————————–

    Let’s pray it doesn’t get that far!

  28. I’m not saying these are good people BUT I get the feeling the only reason these charges are being brought against Hardy is that Holder knows the judge will do what many of us on this board have done. Type cast Hardy as a jealous, raging, gun owning athlete monster and declare him Guilty without any real knowledge or evidence. I’m not a Hardy, or even a Panther fan. Ray Lewis, Ray Rice, Donte Stallworth, Aaron Hernandez, Collin Kaepernick the list goes on. It doesn’t matter if your right or wrong, just if your liked or hated. Due process is dead and reality TV rules. Sad.

  29. “…had a brief affair with the rapper who is a minority owner of the Charlotte Hornets.”

    We all know Nelly is black. Can’t he just be an owner, why you gotta call him a minority?

  30. I heard it was a bed full of water cannons filled with Champagne. Sounds like a good time.

  31. Big deal, guys like Leonard Little, and Donte Stallworth we’re let back on the sidelines after DUI vehicular manslaughter charges. This is childs play, if you produce in the league you get more leeway .

  32. Prosecutor Jamie Adams: “You had alcohol.”

    Hardy: “Champagne.”

    Adams: “Is champagne alcohol?”

    Hardy: “”Depends on what the meaning of the word ‘is’ is.”

    Adams: “….”

  33. “mrfrostyj says: Jul 16, 2014 9:41 AM

    “Stop doing stories about us until we get half as crazy as this”

    – signed Josh Gordon and Johnny Manziel”

    Frosty needs to watch Josh Gordon’s DUI video…

  34. floratiotime says:
    Jul 16, 2014 9:22 AM

    Champagne is NOT alcohol. Alcohol is alcohol. Champagne is wine which contains some alcohol.

    Thanks for playing.
    _________________________________

    What is beer then?

  35. As usual where are you at Gödel. You have in the past gave people up to six game suspension and not even arrested. Where are you at Gödel?

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!