Reports: Giants “closing in” on deal with McAdoo

Getty Images

The Giants are “closing in” on a deal with Ben McAdoo to make their offensive coordinator their new head coach, per multiple reports.

Art Stapleton of The Record cited a source in saying the the Giants and McAdoo were closing in on a deal. A similar report from Ralph Vacchiano of the New York Daily News said the same but added “it’s not a done deal yet.”

Stapleton’s report called McAdoo “an internal favorite from the start.” McAdoo, 38, has been the Giants’ offensive coordinator for the past two seasons.

The job is open because Tom Coughlin stepped down earlier this month. McAdoo also interviewed with the Eagles.

The Giants were set to interview Hue Jackson Thursday but Jackson accepted the Browns’ head coaching job on Wednesday.

52 responses to “Reports: Giants “closing in” on deal with McAdoo

  1. Oh thank god. See ya, Mike Smith. Later, Marrone.

    Now please — FIND A DECENT DC TO FIX THE LEAGUE’S WORST DEFENSE!!!!

  2. Was really hoping they would pick up a proven coach if even only for 2 or 3 years. THEN promote McAdoo.

    I sure wish I could go from “supervisor” to “CEO” in a matter of 2 or 3 years.

  3. Why was this guy so sought after? Anyone watch the Giants offense this year? It kind of sucked and was always taking delay of game penalties. OBJ threat is what made that offense somewhat relevant.

  4. Most of you don’t watch enough football to even comment. McAdoo coached Rodgers to a championship, and had receivers that wouldn’t start on most teams in the NFL, and the Giants were still in 14 of 16 games. That will change, and theyou will be a force if they can fix the other side of the ball.

  5. No sense in praising this move and no sense in killing this move…..anyone who claims they know how good or bad Mcadoo will do as a head coach is full of it. As a Giants fan I’ll let it play out and hope that we just found the next Parcells as opposed to the next Ray Handley.

  6. As a Giants fan, this is such a horrible move!!! Let’s replace a 2 time SB winning coach with a 2 year OC who finally decided after 15 games that maybe he should stop rotating the rbs every other play! And they are stating that Spags is supposedly staying as well so everything has changed but stayed exactly the same. UGH. Another mediocre season ahead with a GM who will go pick up linebackers at the local grocery store.

  7. key2heat says:
    Jan 13, 2016 8:30 PM
    Great now that junk offensive scheme is permanent. Guess we get to watch Eli throw 25 pics every year until he is retired.
    ________________________

    The offense hasn’t been the problem. That ‘junk scheme’ has been pretty successful. In McAdoos offense Eli has thrown 14 INT’s each of the last 2 years, tied for his career 16 game low and had 2 of his 3 lowest overall INT percentages. Try to keep up

    The issue remains Reese’s pieces, that badly under manned defense and year in year out the most woeful training staff in the league.

    Was really hoping for a defensive minded head coach that would keep McAdoo on. If they do make McAdoo HC he will probably keep Spagnuolo. Spags did fine in his first stint as Giants DC but that D was pretty well stocked, it may have lacked bodies this year but it was also vanilla.

  8. The Giants currently have the 6th most cap space in the NFL (43 mill) which will increase once the official cap is set and guys like Beason and probably cruz are cut….it will ultimately be about 60 mill. They have a top 10 draft pick. They have a franchise QB who is very good (despite the unfounded abuse he gets). They have an all-world receiver.

    The Giants are hardly in as bad a spot as most nervous-nellies are making them out to be in. The 2nd most injured team in the NFL won 6 games and lost 5 that they had leads in in the last 2 minutes of the game. Going forward I think I can coach this team to 9 wins next year.

  9. One of Eli[te]’s best passing seasons (2.5:1 TD/INT ratio – 35 TDs/14 INTs) and yet the team goes 6-10? That’s a problem with the offense/McAdoo. Two steps back, Mara & Tisch lol

  10. This was the right move. Young and transformed the Giants o to a top 10 ranked offense both years. Aside from 2 lineman had a makeshift o line, zero weapons aside from OBJ at Wr and can potentially turn will tye into a stud TE.
    If the Giants had a 27th ranked D as opposed to the 32nd ranked D they would have made the playoffs. They have tons of money to spend and a top ten pick. Giants will be fine. If they bring in philbin as the OC ( good OC and bad HC) this will end up being a nice move.

  11. key2heat says:

    Guess we get to watch Eli throw 25 pics every year until he is retired.
    ====================================

    As long as they aren’t nudie pics.

  12. key2heat says:
    Jan 13, 2016 8:30 PM
    Great now that junk offensive scheme is permanent. Guess we get to watch Eli throw 25 pics every year until he is retired.

    ———————————-

    Eli just had one of the best seasons of his entire career. But okay.

  13. n0hopeleft says:
    Jan 13, 2016 8:46 PM
    Most of you don’t watch enough football to even comment. McAdoo coached Rodgers to a championship, and had receivers that wouldn’t start on most teams in the NFL, and the Giants were still in 14 of 16 games. That will change, and theyou will be a force if they can fix the other side of the ball.

    _______________________________________

    I’ve watched football for 25 years so to assume that people that comment don’t watch enough football? How the hell would you even know? McAdoo was the QB coach in Greenbay so pretty sure he didn’t coach Rodgers to a SB, that would be McCarthy. His offense was fine and that’s great as an OC, but that doesn’t mean you are qualified to be a successful head coach. He’s only been an OC for 2 years and now to jump to head coach, keep Spagnoulo as DC and keep Reese. All it points to is the Giants have squarely slapped Coughlin in the face and said it was all his fault.

  14. So let me get this straight… The Mara/Tisch ownership structure came to the conclusion that Coughlin, McAdoo Spags and Reese picking players was inferior to McAdoo, Unamed OC, spags and Reese? That can’t make sense to them… it simply can’t.

  15. Now hire Jim Schwartz as Defensive Coordinator. His record in Buffalo was outstanding and the Giants run a 4-3 Defense. Then when he is released sign Mario Williams after the Bills release him. He will make the defense respectable early.

  16. No way to know what McAdoo will do. But I prefer this to just recycling some undersuccessful former HC.

  17. Love all the Giant fans who say they should have hired a proven commodity yet they can’t name that person. Unfortunately they cannot resurrect Vince Lombardi and Bill Parcells looks like he’s retired for good.

  18. With the Dolphins hiring the talented but green Adam Gase, and the Giants, Eagles and Bucs settling for status quo “don’t rock the boat” type guys like McAdoo and Koetter, it sounds like the Cleveland Browns aka Worst Franchise in the NFL will end up with the best hire.

  19. All of you people who say the Giants offense has been pathetic the last few years are forgetting the amazing, star-making one handed catch Ben McAdoo had about a year and a half ago.

    You don’t get on the cover of Madden for nothing, I’m sure the Giants will be just fine.

    Yours Truly,
    Mr. Mara

  20. wallabear says:
    Jan 13, 2016 9:00 PM

    One of Eli[te]’s best passing seasons (2.5:1 TD/INT ratio – 35 TDs/14 INTs) and yet the team goes 6-10? That’s a problem with the offense/McAdoo. Two steps back, Mara & Tisch lol

    They were leading in the 4th quarter of more than half those 10 losses. The defense couldn’t make the final stop to preserve the lead and the win. They were tied with the Panthers 35-35, and a defensive stop would have meant overtime. The offense primarily lacked a short-yardage running game (horrendous on 3rd/4th-and-short or inside the 5). I was also not happy with Wing as the punter, who would hit 40 yard pop flies when the Giants were backed up instead of getting a leg into a 50+ yarder.

  21. I’m grateful that the richest NFL Owner had the sense to hire the Best Football Minds and let them preform wonders. WOW! That the ‘oldest coach in the league’ creates a Team Esprit d’Corps which few teams can rival, least create. At this time of the season, Coach Carroll has to fall back to a Coach Chuck Knoxism; “We have to play the hand we are dealt.”… Two Great Coaches!

  22. I think the Anti-Eli Manning comments are totally in poor taste. Eli Manning is just getting over a very emotional time, have some compassion. Also his offense, stinks, no one protects him, and his wide receivers suck. They could not catch a ball if they had crazy glue in their gloves.
    I agree that getting rid of Tom Coughlin was a stupid move but at this point, unfortunately, it cannot be undone. Yes Ben McAdoo has made some stupid errors, poor clock management, and dumb decisions, but he is the only thing they have after Tish and Mara messed up. At least McAdoo is someone that Eli Manning is familiar with and its less adjustment than someone from the outside. Personally I think Reese, Tish, and Mara all need the boot.

  23. I despise the giants, but if memory serves they lost a lot of very close games, some of which was due to questionable coaching decisions. They were probably the best team in the division (which isn’t saying much) but I do find it amusing they hired a guy that may have been responsible in part for those questionable coaching decisions

  24. What a great hire!

    and Phlibin as the OC, even better!

    keep up the good work Giants!

    signed,
    another NFC east team

  25. The Giants had 3 games they scored 30 or more points and lost. So I wonder at the people who are putting the blame on the offense.

Leave a Reply