The subject became the topic of a debate on PFT Live. It didn’t start out as a debate, but once I started to talk it through I realized that Willie Colon, who sat in with us for a second day, had it wrong.
Which of us do you think had it right, or wrong? Listen to the arguments, cast a vote below, and then drop a thought or two in the comments.
But before making a final decision, consider all factors. Including whether one guy has had a two-time Super Bowl winning quarterback, and whether the other has had a revolving door of mediocrity throughout his career.