Charlie Whitehurst could have rough introduction to NFL

Facing the Giants in his first NFL start was going to be hard enough for Seahawks quarterback Charlie Whitehurst. 

Facing it with huge question marks all along the offensive line could make it a disaster.

One tackle — Russell Okung — is “as doubtful as you can get” Pete Carroll confirmed on Friday, according to the Seattle Times.  Another tackle, Tyler Polumbus, is a gametime decision with a knee injury.

Guard Chester Pitts, who has battled back from his own serious knee injury, will slide over to protect Whitehurst’s blind side.  The team also lost guard Ben Hamilton for the season last week.

Whitehurst got some good news when receiver Mike Williams returned to practice on Friday. Williams will be ready to go.

The Giants have had a penchant for knocking out quarterbacks this season.  If they drove Whiehurst from the game, the Seahawks will have to turn to rookie Zac Robinson, who has been on the team’s practice squad all year.   If Robinson got hurt, the Seahawks are stuck.

Their “emergency quarterback” Michael Robinson is also hurt.

42 responses to “Charlie Whitehurst could have rough introduction to NFL

  1. These people have all spent years learning about and playing the game of football.
    It’s not the end of the world. You make protecting your QB your #1 priority. Run the ball, double tight end sets, max protect, etc.

  2. The Giants have not been especially kind to QBs this year. I don’t see any way that Whitehurst or Robinson makes it through the game intact.

  3. looks like charlie whitehurst will be taken away from qwest field in a white hurst … ba da bum!

  4. This is one of those games that appears to be lopsided, but somehow the Seahawks keep it close. The Ravens were a double digit favorite against the Bills and that game went to OT. And the Browns went to Nawlins and actually won.
    Whitehurst is very intriguing. I’ve always thought Hasselback was a good QB, but it seems like he can’t stay healthy in recent years. The Seahawks gave up a high pick for Whitehurst, so it’s show and prove time.

  5. Why? The almost half of the Giants sacks have come against Cutler and the Bears offensive line. Take away the inflated numbers from that game and you’ve got a pretty average pass rush.

  6. I’m still amazed that Mike Williams returning to practice is actually a good thing.

  7. Average pass rush?
    Yes they did accumulate a ton of sacks against the Bears. However, other teams saw that and had to game plan against the pass rush. The Giants have a great pass rush.

  8. Tyler- with all the injuries to the Hawks O-Line, the Bears O-line may actually be better. If he can get a bit of time, at least CW offers the chance to stretch the field with his arm..something Hass can’t do.
    Ganggreenguido–its “HEARSE”….silly Jets fan..anything longer J-E-T-S and they can’t figure it out.

  9. Yep, “any QB is better than bith-ass Eli.”
    I guess if you discount Passing Yards (8th in NFL), TDs (4th in NFL), QB Rating (14th in NFL), and Completion % (5th in NFL), then yeah, ALL the others are better than Eli.
    Like, oh say… Matt Hasselbeck. Passing Yards (20th in NFL), TDs (tied for 26th in NFL), QB Rating (28th in NFL), and Completion % (27th in NFL). Yeah, those numbers look a LOT better.
    And yes, I didn’t forget, Eli DOES lead the league in interceptions. Tied for 1st with Drew Brees and Brett Favre (11 Ints.).
    Fans from all the other teams can laugh all they want at the “bitch-ass” QB from the Giants. We Giant fans are just fine with it, thanks.

  10. Kevin C says:
    November 5, 2010 7:00 PM
    Any QB is better than bitch-ass Eli. He’ll get knocked out before Charlie does.
    ——————————————-
    That comment made absolutely no sense. Sounds like someone is just a wee bit jealous. But that’s okay, you wear it well- it amuses me.

  11. # Tyler says: November 5, 2010 7:01 PM
    Why? The almost half of the Giants sacks have come against Cutler and the Bears offensive line. Take away the inflated numbers from that game and you’ve got a pretty average pass rush.
    Gotta love this argument. And if you take away their loses they are undefeated. Take away your one brain cell and shut the F up.

  12. Tyler says:
    November 5, 2010 7:01 PM
    Why? The almost half of the Giants sacks have come against Cutler and the Bears offensive line. Take away the inflated numbers from that game and you’ve got a pretty average pass rush.
    ——————————————-
    I will put my money on that “average” pass rush any day. They have knocked 5 QBs out of the game already, would have been 7 if Stanton and Clausen weren’t saved by the bell.
    What makes you think that the banged up Seahawk line is going to protect Whitehurst? He had more sacks against than rushing yards at Clemson.

  13. Before we jump to any conclusions……. Let’s see how the Giants handle the 12th man thunder crowd noise.

  14. Chicago Giants Fan says:
    November 5, 2010 8:26 PM
    Fans from all the other teams can laugh all they want at the “bitch-ass” QB from the Giants. We Giant fans are just fine with it, thanks.
    That’s cause you are all a bunch of bitch-ass fans. Perfect fit. Haha!
    @JohnnyLikesBallsack
    I’m sorry you are having trouble making sense of the English language. It means Eli is a pussy. Hope that helps.

  15. The Seahawks are +8 in turnovers at Qwest so far. The Giants are -5 on the road. Eli won’t sleep on Saturday night or succeed on Sunday.

  16. Kevin C says: November 5, 2010 9:13 PM
    That’s cause you are all a bunch of bitch-ass fans. Perfect fit. Haha!
    ———————————–
    Well, at least we now know what the C in your name stands for
    You must be a Jests fan. The inferiority complex that you guys like to wear with pride is quite amusing. Keep it up, Guido.

  17. @ Kevin C
    Go root for your sick animal torturing & killing, herpes spreading, poor excuse for a human you have at QB down there in Philly.
    Go give him a standing ovation while you all boo & throw snowballs at Santa, cheer opposing players being brought of the field on body boards & intentionally throw up on opposing fans kids.

  18. You all were saying the same thing about Colt McCoy’s first start against the Steelers and he ended up throwing for almost 300 yards and a td. And no matter what the stats are, James Harrison and Lamar Woodley are scarier than Tuck and Osi. Whitehurst is a reasonably athletic qb who should find a way to extend plays. Not saying he’ll be great, but don’t write him off just yet.

  19. Seattle’s pass defense has struggled overall, but no defense in the league has held opposing quarterbacks to a lower passer rating in the red zone this season.
    NFL quarterbacks have a 92.7 rating in the red zone this season, but the figure is only 56.3 against Seattle, ESPN Stats & Information notes.

  20. Whitehearst played well here in Sandy Eggo whenever called on. If I remember right, he came in for Rivers against Indy (in Indy) and helped beat them in the playoffs. The Gmen may put a hurtin on him without any offensive linemen, but I’ld take Whitehearst over Eli anyday.

  21. @Kevin:
    Sorry, we are a bunch of “bitch-ass fans” that have to resort to statistics, not name-calling to support our argument. How immature of us.
    Calling Eli and Giants fans names has done nothing to support your statement that “Any QB is better than Eli.” Can you show ANY statistic that can support this argument? Are you seriously saying that Charlie Batch is a better QB? How about Matt Leinart? Max Hall? Todd Collins?
    Those are all active NFL QBs that have played this year, so I guess you are saying that those 4 (and every other QB in the NFL) is better than Eli.
    Can you PLEASE submit some statistics (and no, calling him a “pussy” is NOT a statistic) that would prove your point?

  22. Hey FW Brodie. I think you are short changing the Hawks. By my count, they are +9 at Qwest. They are recovering a lot of fumbles.
    And the Giants have been turning the ball over at an uncomfortable rate. The one thing that Giants fans can take solace in is knowing that they can overcome adversity, like in the Dallas game. A 20-7 disadvantage after 2 quick picks, and scoring 31 straight points warms the heart of ALL Giant fans.

  23. Kevin C wrote: “I’m sorry you are having trouble making sense of the English language. It means Eli is a pussy. Hope that helps.”
    —————–
    Right, cause the guy that is third in the NFL behind Brett Favre and Peyton Manning for consecutive starts among active QB’s must be a pussy……
    Do the rest of us adults here a favor and take your 3rd grade level insults back to the playground.

  24. Ahh, the trolls from the little fishing village known as Seattle are crawling out from under their rocks. Let’s say you’re right. Seattle wins this game. That gets you what, now? You’ll still have the same number of Lombardis – ZERO. You”ll still have the same chance to win one this year – ZERO. Hey, any given Sunday, so sure it’s possible that Seattle can pull out a win. Still doesn’t change that you live is rain soaked village awaiting it’s extinction from a tsunami and your football team has accomplished nothing and shows no sign of being able to accomplish anything within the next five years. Enjoy YOUR Super Bowl this Sunday. It’s as close as you’ll get.

  25. Eli Manning is hated just because he’s Eli Manning…and even though he has good stats and is a good QB, just looking at him makes you just want to kick the s**t out of of him for no reason.

  26. FumbleNuts says:
    November 5, 2010 9:09 PM
    Before we jump to any conclusions……. Let’s see how the Giants handle the 12th man thunder crowd noise.
    ——————————————–
    That 12th man may help noise and force a timeout or jump, it will not stop the freight train that will jump all over Whitehurst.
    @Kevin C- I have no trouble with understanding comprehensible sentences…but you are grasping at straws. Eli has started every game since he got the job. He gets better every week. I understand that makes haters mad, but get over it. There is nothing you can do about it. I will take our “pussy” any day. He will get a lot further than your team will. Good luck in the draft!

  27. @Brodie- lets look at those numbers again on Monday morning. The numbers look good when the ‘Gawks are playing SF and Arizona with Max Hall. But this game will tell the story for where your season is going. Let’s see what you have to say Sunday night.

  28. JamesTKirk says: November 5, 2010 11:47 PM
    I’ld take Whitehearst over Eli anyday.
    —————
    You’ve been beamed up one time too many

  29. @JamesTKirk:
    Whitehearst (sic) played well here in Sandy Eggo (sic) whenever called on.
    http://www.cbssports.com/nfl/players/playerpage/423552/charlie-whitehurst
    Link is to Charlie Whitehurst career stats. Total of 3 regular-season games played (not started) in 4+ years. Has NOT attempted a pass, has rushed twice. I am not sure how many times he has handed off to running backs in those 3 games (maybe they had Tomlinson rush it 60 times in each), and he may have handed it off REALLY WELL.
    However, I am having a hard time with “whenever called on” as 3 games out of 64 is not really “called on”. And, without seeing those games played, I don’t know how well he really could have played to help “Sandy Eggo” win.
    According to NFL.com:
    http://www.nfl.com/teams/statistics?season=2009&team=SD&seasonType=POST
    Charlie Whitehurst has never attempted a pass or a rush in the Post Season. Again, this does not take into account if he handed the ball off in any games.
    Please feel free to explain further exactly what Whitehurst did in these games to help San Diego win, especially the Indy game. Believe me, it wouldn’t be the first time I was corrected.
    And, of course, all of this arguing/debating is a moot point is Whitehurst goes out on Sunday, lights it up, and the Seahawks win. Hey, any given Sunday.

  30. Lets see….The last time the Giants played in Seattle, they committed about 9 false start penalties and missed 3-4 field goals. Hopefully it will happen again!!! But this time we wont get to look at that little sissy Shockey cried and throw a fit. GO SEAHAWKS!!!!

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.