Eagles surprise: Juan Castillo will be their defensive coordinator

Philadelphia found their next defensive coordinator in a surprising place: Their offensive coaching staff.

Jeff McLane of the Philadelphia Inquirer reports Juan Castillo will be moved from offensive line coach to defensive coordinator.  Long-time Colts offensive line coach Howard Mudd will take over the offensive line duties.

Mike Nolan once made a similar move from receivers coach to defensive coordinator in Baltimore.  Bill Belichick was an offensive coach early in his career.  With that said, there are few examples of coaches in this day of specialization making this kind of jump.  Castillo hasn’t coached defense since he was at a Texas high school in 1989.

It’s a bold and possible defining move at a tenuous time in Andy Reid’s tenure in Philadelphia.  There will be a ridiculous amount of pressure on Castillo, but the decision is so out-of-the-box that we are want to give it a chance.

UPDATE: The Eagles have confirmed the move.

85 responses to “Eagles surprise: Juan Castillo will be their defensive coordinator

  1. “The offensive line gave us so few points we are hoping Juan can take that with him to the other side of the ball.”.

  2. As an Eagles fan, my only response is: I don’t get it. I don’t hate it, I don’t like it, I just…don’t get it.

  3. Red just sealed his fate….. there’s no fall guy when, not if, this doesn’t pan out.

    Hopefully the timing of it all we just so happen with Johnny “Gumdrops” Gruden or Bill “Chisel Chin” Cowher decide they want back in.

  4. “Our offense only gave up 30 points all season, all of them on turnovers. Juan Castillo was a big part of that.”.

  5. Bringing Mudd out of retirement makes this palatable, but good god, can this be the plan that Reid and Roseman have had all along?

  6. This is a great move for Redskins Fans. And with Stewart Bradley coming back to weaken their already sup bar LB corp. it ensures a head coaching change and rebuilding phase is in the not to distant future.

  7. I’m not done yet.

    If this was the original plan, this announcement would have been made THE DAY AFTER McDermott was released.

    Its now obvious they had NO plan as to how they would move on after they released McDermott.

  8. Just Andy Reid tightening his grip on the team.

    Instead of bringing in someone with their own defensive philosophy that might expect some authority on their side of the ball, he’ll just move a guy into that position who has been with him a long time, is loyal to him, and has no philosophy or ambition of his own.

    Getting Mudd in as OL coach is probably the best news in this story for Eagles fans.

  9. W H A T ? Mark my words, this will be Andy Reid’s last year as the Eagle’s head coach….he has lost his mind…..

  10. Juan has been one of the best offensive line coaches for years,If this doesn’t work you look REAL stupid.I have faith in Juan’s coaching ability but ……..

  11. This once proud team of mine has turned into an absolute sideshow. This man couldn’t even get the offensive linemen playing well and now he’s the defensive coordinator but has only coached defense at the high school level.

    this stinks worse than an Andy Reid Dutch Oven.

  12. here we go. everyone call this his last year, just like when he traded Mcnabb to the Redskins. dude knows what he’s doing and keeps a competitive team year after year. this WILL work!

  13. LOL! What movie is this quote from?…

    “Juan Castillo… went to jail…
    for having sex with a goat.”

    anyone?… anyone?…

  14. I’ve never understood the media fascination with Juan Castillo. I was expecting Troy Aikman and Joe Buck to go sidelines and nut on him one broadcast this season.

    When we had great pass protection we couldn’t run.
    When we can run we NO pass protection.

    I don’t know O-Line theory and all but this is weirder to me than trading McNabb to Washington.

  15. Worst move ever, i hope i eat my words as an eagles fan but I’m as qualified as this guy. Here is another move by the eagles thinking they are smarter than everyone else in the league, theyve been missing in the draft, in the playoffs, and in the super bowl with this line of thought. looks like they miss again, see ya in 2yrs andy. Jeff Fisher as head coach campaign begins now.

  16. WTF

    no surprise.. Andy always puts players out of position

    DTs at FB
    TEs at WR
    RBs at WR
    DEs at LB
    S at CB
    Q at RB
    WR at RB

    wtf is up with this team

  17. I just … what? Seriously? I mean, I hope it works out, but I really don’t see that happening. Castillo hasn’t done squat with the O-Line since having Andrews, Runyan and Thomas almost 10 years ago. The O-Line has gotten worse and worse every year despite having average and higher players.

  18. Holy Cow Mudd to Philadelphia is a story! Seriously that needs looked into a little deeper.

    He was working for the Colts, Polian fired Ryan Lilja and suddenly Mudd isn’t working for the Colts. Colts offensive line sucks this season and now Mudd is working for Philadelphia.

    What the story, morning glory?

  19. What did Reid fall on his head.This goes to show they had no plan at all.Maybe they figured that Juan can teach the linebackers,DBs and linemen to to run through everybody elses line like they did his.

  20. Of all the other 31 teams, and literally hundreds of colleges with defensive assistants, you mean to tell me a man who has been an offensive line coach since 1998, and never got past that title, is best qualified to be the defensive coordinator? Unbelievable…

  21. Good! Now The Raiders don’t have to compete with Philly for a “Real” DC~

    Lol~ Go Raiders!! – W. Moss Or D. Perry will love being back in California.. It’s soo Warm here, enjoy the snow while we go surfing.

  22. On the surface, this move makes no sense at all. It wreaks of desperation on the part of Andy Reid. Andy is either going to come out of this as a genius for making this move, or it will be the move that seals his demise in Philly. If I had to make a wager, I’d be betting on the latter. It sounds to me like Castillo had an offer somewhere that he was about to accept, and the Eagles were not terribly happy with any of the DC candidates that were left for them to choose from, so they decided to take a flyer on Castillo as DC in order to keep him. Oh well…how much worse can the defense be than it was in 2010?

  23. WT-Double-F is going on down in Philly. I supported Reid up until now. This is an absurdly stupid move.
    If Castillo was such a find to justify the upheaval on defense, how come it took the Eagles 16 years to “find” him?

    Reid has completely lost his mind. The good news is that Jeff Fisher can take over next year or maybe Bill Cowher.

  24. Im a eagles fan and though he is so easy to dislike , I always tried to give reid the benefit of the doubt , im out now , This guy gotta GO ! Even if castillo turns out to be great (which I doubt),Reid had no plan in place when he fired mcdermott and thats pathetic! This is the NFL , we cant waste a year to see if this guy is capable to make such a drastic change .

  25. this is one of those moments where andy reid does something so bizarre (or stupid) and you think

    ‘well…he IS a professional coach and has proven himself multiple times….so he must have some master plan here’ but then it all just turns to pudding.

    eagles fans have been dealing with this for what seems like a century. i.e. calling play action on 3rd and 1 when the game is on the line…or kicking a field goal when we need a touchdown and the game is on the line…or calling an onsides kick to start the game…etc.

    its starting to look like SB or bust for andy so look for a big FA offseason.

  26. I’m not going to judge until I see the games.

    Too many people have questioned Andy’s personnel decisions in the past and called him an idiot and many names — only to have him get the last laugh.

    Not saying I agree with many of his gametime decisions, but if you’re a true Eagles fan then you know that Andy knows what he’s doing on the personnel side of the ball 95 percent of the time.

  27. I’ve been saying this for three years, Reid’s got to go! He has taken the Eagles, fundamentally, as far as they can go under his leadership. Let him go wherever McNabb goes. Take his staff with him! You people, asking for Cowher, a run, defensive minded, coach, are out to lunch. Get Dungy, a team builder and Superbowl winner, in addition to sponsoring Vick, to the Eagles, “What more could you ask for?” A coach who can take an aggressive pass-orientated offense, Q/B strong & a team, defensively weak, to the “Big Game.” The Eagle’s don’t need a total makeover, “Just a tweek and a new highly qualified coach.” Eagles to the end…

  28. For those with good memories, “Gruden took Dungy’s team to the S/B.” Did nothing after the fact! Dungy is well versed with everyone in the leagues due to his current stint as a network analyst… His is approving Reids “Scapegoat choices?” Somebody better!

  29. This is a SMART move! Just think about it. Juan is highly respected around the league. It is smart for the eagles to promote him before he is plucked by another team. A good coach is a good coach….Jim Johnson frequently consulted Juan on blitz schemes, coverages, etc. If anyone can make the switch, he can. He already has the respect of his players, so he is already better then McDermitt. It was a great way to keep home grown talent in the fold. Howard Mudd is also a great signing. The Eagles hands down have the best coaching staff in the league. Super bowl within 2 years!

  30. The Eagles have proven once again that they know more than everyone else and are the ‘gold standard’ even though they have never won a damn thing. I am now convniced that they will never win a damn thing in my lifetime.

  31. wow as a packer fan i’m over joyed! one less team to keep us from REPEATING! oh yea you heard it here first, write it down jc1958coo !!!!

  32. birdobeamen says: Feb 2, 2011 5:47 PM

    I’m not going to judge until I see the games.

    Too many people have questioned Andy’s personnel decisions in the past and called him an idiot and many names — only to have him get the last laugh.

    Not saying I agree with many of his gametime decisions, but if you’re a true Eagles fan then you know that Andy knows what he’s doing on the personnel side of the ball 95 percent of the time.

    This exactly. It’s such a strange move that there must be more to the story that we don’t know about. Andy’s taken heat in the past from Negadelphia for a bunch of things that worked out in the end. It’s a head-scratcher, but he’s earned the benefit of the doubt.

  33. Is keeping Juan from becoming an OC w/ Cleveland so important that they need to promote this guy to a coordinator position at which he has no experience? If they fire/demote Marty M. and make Juan the OC, I can accept that a little. At least there’s a basis of competency on that side.

  34. a lot of the eagles OL problems can probly be blamed on reid’s lapsing into pass-all-day mode.

    and their talent has been iffy.

    but if this guy couldnt work that miracle… this one will be too big.

    yes this move smells of desperation. with a side of salsa.

  35. The best history teacher i ever had was an english teacher for 15 years before he took on the history job. Leslie frazier just said when he was on jim johnson’s staff they always ran their defensive game plan through Castillo for his approval. it has also been reported that he was the first interview and nobody else could interview better. but i bet if he is succesfull most of you guys will never admit you didn;t want him hired in the first place. and finally guys he was just hired by the longest tenured coach in the N.F.L. the man must know something. ps: how many of Reid’s coaches are head coaches today?

  36. Huh? Well, I suppose it could’ve been worse — he could’ve hired Childress as D coordinator.

  37. Turn out the lights , the party’s over. But , Juan is arguably one the best Off line coaches in all football. Lets give him a chance.

  38. You are all idiots! Andy had a job for life, or if Lurie sells the team.

    And my other point, wouldn’t it be crazier if a QB coach became a head coach?

  39. This could be great.. Give the guy a shot..
    He can’t possibly suck as much as McDermott

    It’s will be interesting to see the D during Mini Camps and OTA’s should there be any..

  40. It can be a great move if he has the “it” factor. Using the o line knowledge can only help … Right? I hope u know what u are doing Andy!

  41. I learned my lesson last offseason. I was so certain the Vick experiment failed: he was washed up, had no trade value, and then we had the whole b-day shooting incident. I wanted him gone. Seemed like a no-brainer.

    Except as it turned out, the Eagles brass actually had more insight into the situation than I did. Stunner, huh?

    I’ll give them the benefit of the doubt today. And I’m glad to see I’m not alone. Here’s to hoping you’re the real D-eal, Castillo!

  42. Maybe now they’ll bring out the secret potential of Dave Spadaro in developing DBs. He also has maintained the organization’s line for years.

  43. I’m amused by all the miserable armchair Eagle fans who’ve sat down with all the speculative candidates, who more than likely they wouldn’t know unless they predictably were fed the names by the media who’s job it is to speculate.

    However, what do you expect from a fan base that constantly ripped their team’s best QB in franchise history because he had the audacity to get traded by their team.

    I like Andy Reid, but hopefully it’s over soon because he definitely deserves better than the dumbest fan base in football.

    Maybe getting back to those Ray Rhodes/Rich Kotite days is a high priority.

  44. This move comes from the “complete idiot” who signed Mike Vick while writers and other coaches thought he was nuts. This is the moron who got two good draft picks for McNabb and was widely criticized by all the writers, sports broadcasters and former players for trading Mcnabb in the division. Let’s judge this next season.

  45. This is an inspirational story. If you want to see what Castillo is all about go to youtube and view the video titled Juan Castillo – Eagles OL Coach

    I’ll be rooting for the guy.

  46. My first reaction? WTF? That about sums it up. It sounds crazy on the surface. If it blows up, Reid will be toast. But, this is so crazy it just might work. From what I’ve been reading, while JC is/was the offensive line coach, he’s been a part of defensive planning before. We will see.

  47. First of all, Juan Castillo played LB in college and in the USFL, so it’s not like he has zero knowledge of defensive schemes. Second, he may be one of the hardest workers in football and is definitely one of the best OL coaches in the business (the other guy they just hired, Howard Mudd, may be the best). Finally, Castillo will probably wind up being a head coach some day. He is definitely highly regarded amongst other coaches.

  48. Mike Nolan is a poor comparison. He had already been a defensive coach, a defensive coordinator in fact, before he came to Baltimore & took the job of receivers coach as the DC in waiting…once Marvin Lewis retired.

  49. I watched an interview Dave Spadaro had with Andy Reid about an hour ago and Andy was smiling like a little baby… if Juan is such a great hidden treasure we had on our team than why did we even bother promoting Sean McDermott??? Juan’s been here for a while. Did Andy pick up on this during the past season? He said everytime they’d struggle on offense Juan would point out the eyes of the defense.. Hmm…. Andy has lost it. I’m sure Juan is a great guy and an awesome motivator but we need someone who knows defense and how to pick better guys. Trent Cole and Asante Samuel are our only true keepers on D.

  50. Not ping pong balls but King Kong’s balls. Andy Reid may have made the best coaching change of his career?

  51. @toe4… Mudd had already told the Colts that he would leave after last year’s Super Bowl.

    The Colts released Lilja who then became a part of one of the NFL’s best rushing offenses (but I’m not sure how good was Lilja individually).

    If I remember it correctly, post retirement benefits were the main reason that Mudd announced his first announcement after which Manning created a stir in the media by saying that he wouldn’t want to lose Mudd and Tom Moore.

    I read somewhere that Mudd served as a consultant to the Saints in the summer of 2010 but yeah coming back at age of 69 is pretty unheard of.

  52. Give the guy a damn chance!! To you guys who dont know, Juan Castillo is a great FOOTBALL coach. Im sure all of you Eagle haters on here are the same ones who were saying that the Eagles were going to be in the basement of the division after trading McNabb. How’d that work out for you??

  53. Let me start by saying I think Juan Castillo is a fantastic coach and I am for giving him a promotion, but this is like hiring a English major to become your Accountant.

    With the lockout looming, this hire intrigues me because Castillo could potentially have an entire year to work on his scheme before anyone see the field.

    On the other hand, this move could cost Andy “Albus Dumbledor” Reid his job. He tries to outsmart everyone in the league. I believe Andy best serves as an OC and does not call plays. He is clueless when his scripted 10 plays does not work out. When the Eagles are ahead, Big Red is a genius, is able to run the ball and open his “menu” to call any play he would like.

  54. Jim Washburn is around too. He is fully qualified to be a DC, but from what I understand doesn’t wanna be. I’m willing to bet that this will be Wasburns defense, but it will have JC’s name on it. I like the craziness that this is. Its like the Jersey Shore. Go birds!

  55. The reason this took so long was because Reid needed to wait on Howard Mudd to make sure he was on board. Once he got that information, the move was made.

    I think this will work out for the Eagles. They get a hall of fame OL coach and a guy who should have been coaching the defense along time ago.

    With a good draft and a couple of trades we can tighten up our defensive issues.

  56. After hearing some in depth info on the Castilo-Johnson relationship and how they planed together, this might just be a good move. If it works out like Reid’s decesion to bring on Vic….WOW

  57. Look, Juan Castillo is a really, really good coach and I am positive that he CAN coach the Defense… But that’s not what the Eagles need. This team desperately needs a defensive-minded mastermind, not just a guy that can coach up players (no matter how much Castillo claims to be a “defensive guy”). Can Juan Castillo seriously call the plays on Defense? Can he help find the right personnel for his fledgling Linebacker corps or a stud Defensive Tackle? Can he come up with a Defensive gameplan to dominate a playoff game, ala Rex Ryan versus the Patriots? FireTheWalrus.com

  58. Why isn’t Brad Childress coaching for Philadelphia? Didn’t Reid say Childress would be welcomed back with “open arms”?

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.