New replay rule shows up in Patriots game

Getty Images

Brian Hoyer led the Patriots on successive touchdown drives in the first half of Thursday’s preseason game against the Jaguars.

Both scores were reviewed, but there weren’t any challenges used.

For those who stayed away from PFT this offseason, there is a new rule this year where a replay assistant from the NFL can ask for any scoring play to be reviewed.  (Just like in the final two minutes of a game.)

We know there is confusion regarding the rule  because the CBS crew on the game said every scoring play is reviewed regardless.  (It’s only when the assistant says it’s necessary.)

Both scores were very close and worth looking at again.  Stevan Ridley, New England’s hard-charging rookie running back, ran over Jaguars linebacker Daryl Smith to just get over the goal line on the first touchdown.  Ridley made an impressive run to the outside earlier in the drive.

Patriots wideout Taylor Price barely got his feet down with possession of the ball on the second touchdown, an 11-yard score.

Patriots backup quarterback Brian Hoyer has looked very sharp thus far.  The Patriots lead 16-9 in the second quarter.

18 responses to “New replay rule shows up in Patriots game

  1. Oh, its a replay assistant? The announcers for this preseason game have been saying EVERY score is reviewed, and I thought that was an awful rule. This makes more sense

  2. If Hoyer played for the Eagles, some desperate front office would be on the phone now offering a second rounder and starter for him.

  3. All I want is the right call. Tho I dont want to have to watch an extra hour of football because they do this every TD….

  4. Hm. That arm motion that Hoyer is making is a little too reminiscent of Brady in the Tuck Rule Game. Now I know that wasn’t a scoring play, but makes you wonder about replay in football from now on.

  5. Well, the way I understand it, the announcers are mostly correct. The refs apparently have a pager/signaler on them and a replay assistant up in the booth will re-look at every scoring play and then alert the refs either “review” or “confirmed”. Obviously, if someone breaks open and goes in uncontested the communication will be quick and easy so only the dicey calls should matter.

  6. Pretty sure this happened in the Eagles/Ravens game when an incomplete pass from QB Mike Kafka was ruled a fumble and ran the other way for a score. It was overturned.

  7. I agree with kairn42. I think the way it works is that the replay assisstant is looking at every scoring play in the booth. If it is something that is a no doubter they just go on with play. But if it’s a play that is close or could be worth another look, they signal down and and the officials on the field then stop play and review it. In essence every scoring play is being “reviewed”, but it’s by the replay assisstant in the booth and not by the officials on the field.

  8. Replay and review all you want.

    Bottom line: Patriots 47 Jaguars 12 – Jags starters against Pats second/third string even in first half.

  9. I liked the gamesmanship surrounding the old rule, but this is probably for the best.

    When was the last time the Pats had 4 rushing td’s in a game? Just for trivia?

  10. The booth guys are right. They are all reviewed just not all will go under the hood. Just because the game is not stopped does not mean it was not looked at by the assistant.

  11. Is there a new Replay Czar to oversee all of the replayers, and have they started a new Replayers Union?

  12. This means that, by default, ALL “close” plays should be called a TD and then reviewed, rather than called not TDs and forcing a coach to challenge. In the Philly/Balt game, there was a close play in the end zone that was called not a touch down, but Reid had to throw the challenge flag to get it looked at.

    Isn’t the point of reviewing every single one to prevent coaches from having to do that? Just like they’re by default not supposed to blow the whistle on a fumble/non-fumble play, they should be calling these TDs immediately and then following up to make sure.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.