Report: Manning doesn’t want to play for the Redskins

Getty Images

The Washington Post reported Wednesday that the Redskins would make an “aggressive effort” to sign free agent quarterback Peyton Manning. The feeling would have to be mutual for Manning to actually become a Redskin, of course.

According to Chris Russell of ESPN 980 Washington, it isn’t.

Russell appeared on SportsCenter Thursday and, citing multiple sources, reported that Manning doesn’t want to play in the nation’s capital and has already informed the team.

“A couple of different sources inside the organization have told me that Manning’s camp made it pretty clear to Redskins officials he doesn’t want to come here,” said Russell. “… There’s lots of reasons for that. His brother Eli, the colder weather, the whole situation down in Miami and so on and so forth. But unless that changes — and I’m taking my sources at their word — I don’t think Manning’s coming here to D.C.”

This is the first formal report that Manning doesn’t want to play for the Skins, though that reality has been commonly speculated for the past several weeks.

Russell, who hosts a popular radio show in D.C., believes the Washington fan base would prefer Baylor quarterback Robert Griffin III over Manning, anyway. If Russell’s report is accurate, the fans stands a much better chance to get their wish.

96 responses to “Report: Manning doesn’t want to play for the Redskins

  1. “There’s lots of reasons for that. His brother Eli, the colder weather, the whole situation down in Miami and so on and so forth”

    Sure glad that it’s warm here in NYC during the winter months!!

    Come and join us Peyton in the city that never sleeps!

    Why would you go to Miami??? Only old, kranky people live there!!

  2. Why would he want to? Firstly I don’t think he would want to play in the division against his brother but beyond that why would he want to work for a terrible owner/organization that Snyder runs?

  3. There’s lots of reasons for that. His brother Eli, the colder weather, the whole situation down in Miami.

    That says it all. Welcome to South Beach Peyton.

  4. Manning is his own offensive coordinator. Why in the world would he want to but heads with the Shanahan family? Too many cooks in the kitchen.

  5. His brother Eli, the colder weather, the whole situation down in Miami and so on and so forth.
    ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
    What does “the whole situation down in Miami and so on” mean??

    No way he goes to DC, just too close to Eli. Skins need to stick with Grossman…

  6. This one never made sense to me – from the Redskins side, sure. But playing in the same division as his brother? Not sure anyone in the family would be able to take it.

    NFC East is not a good division for “win now” approaches. The Giants have played it the most smartly, and see how they’ve done compared to the other teams.

    Redskins should go for the best QB they can get in the draft. RG3 would be smart, if the offense can support him. They need a long-term alpha QB. The other 3 teams in the division will all be better next season (assuming no bumps ahead for NY), so Washington has to make some good choices to not be left out, again.

  7. Of course he wouldn’t want to be a Redskin, in the same division as Eli. That’s not news. I doubt he’ll go to any team in the NFC. The weather in Washington for sure is a factor as well. Truly believe the only possible serious suitors for him to consider will be from the AFC. The potential for a Manning SuperBowl relies on AFC vs NFC. Hope it happens.

  8. That place never made sense to me and I think its safe to say you can eliminate all NFC teams. Its going to be Miami, Denver or the Giants little brothers the “lil jets”.

  9. hopefully Peyton wont retrospectively regret burning that bridge. He probably wont be able to turn his head to look back anyway roflol

  10. Why would anyone want to play for the Skins other then to get paid? Manning knows he will get paid and he doesn’t Need the money. Here hoping the skins can’t get griffin and shanny continues to have to stake his reputation to grossman and beck

  11. All of these interested teams have their 2004 eyeglasses on and see the 2004 Peyton Manning. The problem is they’ll end up with the 2012 model. Caveat Emptor. The Swamp Boy is done.

  12. I think I speak on behalf of ‘Skins fans everywhere when I breathe a heavy sigh of relief.

    Just hope that his desire not to play for us will turn away prospective draft picks, like RG3. The last thing we need is an Eli Manning/Elway situation.

    And for godsakes, leave Matt Flynn for Miami.

  13. 1st Russell doesn’t host a popular show here in DC…

    2nd – CBS reported it’s down to Miami, Washington and Denver as his choices

    3rd- I wish you friggin reporters would get rid of these so called sources…everybody’s sources are telling all these different stories…

    4th – The cold? Does he really believe every game will be played indoors in the warmth? And Denver weather isn’t any better…and this thing about not wanting to play against baby brother because neither wants to knock the other out of the playsoffs…that’s so lame, what happens if they had to play against one another in the Super Bowl which isn’t going to happen!

  14. Gee, what a surprise. Forget Eli and the weather. It’s Shanahan. Peyton doesn’t strike me as a masochist.

  15. I’m not sure I get why everyone sees Miami as the lock here!?!?! They have a soso runningback (one complete season in his entire career), one good received (when he shows up), a terrible line and a mediocre defense. That team is NOT one step away from a title. Not to mention he would have to play the Jets (Revis Island) and Tom Brady twice a year.

    Arizona, San Fran or Jets make most sense.

  16. We don’t want someone else’s retread. We are building, not looking to go all in this year. Guaranteed Redskin nation rejoices. And all the other comments from people who are from Cincy and what not, show us ur rings and then u can talk trash.

  17. Thank you Peyton for saving the Redskins from themselves… RGIII is coming to DC!!!! Browns aren’t going to give up their 3 picks in top 37 when they have Colt McCoy in place… In any other scenario that doesn’t include the Browns, I believe the Redskins will not be outbid for St Louis’ pick.

  18. RG3 would definitely be a better way for the redskins to go he would be younger cheaper and way more athletic…peyton will wind up in miami

  19. Good call. If hes gonn play anywhere Im think Miami, AZ, or Seattle… My gut says MIA

  20. You see how many people have responded to the “whole situation down in Miami” statement?

    Perhaps you should explain that in detail. There’s also that whole situation in Denver, Seattle, Arizona, etc.

  21. Redskins are better off with rg3. In three years he will be an all pro and manning will be ready to retire. Make the trade happen already.

  22. He only won one Super Bowl with Harrison, Wayne, and a solid O-line. I’m a Skins fan, but there’s no way on earth he could do that with the sorry collection of “talent” currently in DC.

  23. Still think this comes down to Miami and KC, wild card being the Jets.

    KC IMO makes the most sense. Bowe and charles are big time weapons (wherever he goes Wayne is likely to follow so throw him in). The defense is under rated and MOST IMPORTANTLY….look at the division! About as easy a path to the playoffs as you can find…one thing the Fins and Jets cannot offer.

    At the end of the day Peyton knows the most important thing is getting to the dance…KC offers the best chance of making the playoffs.

    He won’t go to an NFC team

    I could see the Jets, if they convince him the aspect of having a Manning/Manning NY duo, and simply put the mass amount of money he can make being in NY with his brother.

  24. Even tho im pretty sure it wont happen, id like to see manning go to a nfc east team. You get brother vs. brother twice a year. Gotta admit it would be awesome.

  25. the situation down in Miami

    thats it right there. Don’t worry Zona you have Kolb.

    Jet fans, I’m sure sanchize will turn it around and him and Holmes will sit around the fireplace singing Koombya

  26. Manning is going to stay in the AFC. I would love to see an AFC South team like the Jags creep into the mix (if they have the cap space) and give Indy and Irsy heartburn. Nothing against Indy or Irsy, but Jags/Colts games would become mighty interesting…

    The Peyton led Dolphins giving big boy Rex heartburn and the Pats would be good too. Of Course, Peyton as a Cheif or Donk terrorizing Raider fans would make life a little sweeter for me around the office here in the bay…

    Just hit me, but random…so awesome that we have a real off-season this year!!

  27. he should go to the seahawks or cards. even with the niners, either team would probably be the favorites of the division with manning on the team. its probably his easiest route to get into the playoffs….and once in anything can happen.

    the dolphins or jets? why would he want to have to deal with the pats being in the same division?

  28. There’s lots of reasons for that. His brother Eli, the colder weather, the whole situation down in Miami and so on and so forth.

    and so forth means the Shanahan’s.

  29. As a Baltimorean and an Orioles fan, the Redskins almost make the O’s almost look good.

    Almost.

    Wait a minute, what am I saying? I think I just had a senior moment. Nobody’s an bad as the Birds.

    That said, of course the Redskins would do well with Peyton. But they’re two drafts away from being Super Bowl serious and, with that o-line the Skins have, Manning will just get killed in the process. Go with RG3. He’s faster and more nimble.

  30. “… There’s lots of reasons for that. His brother Eli, the colder weather, the whole situation down in Miami and so on and so forth. But unless that changes — and I’m taking my sources at their word — I don’t think Manning’s coming here to D.C.”

    So he does not want to face his brother two times a year. But would like to possibly face him in the super bowl. Understandable.

    Cold weather, good for the Redskins, not to mention they play on grass.

    The whole situation in Miami. What does that have to do with the Redskins?

    Redskins go after RG III. Good for them.

    Miami, he faces Belichick twice a year, and Ryan Twice a year, and Gailey twice a year. Not to mention the fact that he has to go up to those places atleast once a year. I guess that does not help with the not liking the cold weather.

    So pretty much the only place he wants to go to is the AFC/NFC south or west. And I would cross the Seahawks and Denver off of those lists. Not to mention him not going back to the Colts. The Saints would be an interesting place for him to land. If he went there where would Brees end up?

  31. Why would you go to Miami??? Only old, kranky people live there!
    ————————————————-
    Really Goobs, obviously you haven’t been to Miami.

    No surprise Peyton doesn’t want to play for the Deadskins. Daddy doesn’t want Peyton and Eli duking it out for 2 or 3 times a year and Daddy Manning still controls his middle age sons.

  32. Chris Russell is an idiot and is wrong about 90% of the things he reports and “deduces”.

    Until Peyton signs ANYWHERE, don’t believe any reports.

  33. A Bengals fan looking down at the Redksins? Hmm…Zero Superbowl titles and more player arrests than victories over the last 15 years. Good one.

    Peyton was never going to DC. Skins were not going after him either. Only people to report ‘strong interest’ were the Post writers. They have not been right on anything since Cerrato left.

    Other than the McNabb trade, Skins have not signed anyone over 28 since Shannahan/Allen took over. Why go older with Manning?

    Oh, and if it were Dallas or Philly, answer would be the same. Manning was never going to chose his brothers division.

  34. Why would Skins fans want Manning?

    They are a few more players away from SB with or without him

    He is 36 yrs old and after a year off will never be the same…

    He is not as good outside a dome…

    Not good in cold weather…

    Good Riddance

  35. That is fine with me, he would be used for nothing more than merchandising here anyways. Not like Manning instantly makes the Redskins a Super Bowl contender.

  36. I love how Skins fans don’t want one of the greatest QBs of all time. Even with 173 neck surgeries over the past year or two, he’s better than anyone the Skins have had since Theismann.

  37. Russell is a beat reporter (and the worst ever) for the skins. Hosts a weekend radio show for yahoo. Listened to by tens of people!! Don’t think PM is coming here but wouldn’t trust his info.

  38. as a bills fan i pray to god that arizona do what is neccesary to get manning signed. i do not want to see him in a dolphins uniform. please god, dont do me like this

  39. It’s still mind boggeling me that the 49ers aren’t the front runner in all of this. I love my team, but I feel they are being unbelievably stubborn on this one. We are set up currently to have a strong run for the next 3-5 years without Manning. Add him to the team and we are going to win Superbowls in those years. This is making me sick.

  40. Skin Fans act like they already have RGIII. They better hope the Browns aren’t bluffing because they have more ammo to get him than they do.

  41. Wonder how Mike Jones of the Washington Post feels now that his seemingly baseless article has been shot down. What fabrication will he come up w/ next?

  42. I would have to think that the Skins will put a bounty on him.

    What they left half done in 2006, they may have to finish sometime soon.

  43. cardiovascularendurance says:
    Mar 8, 2012 2:56 PM
    I love how Skins fans don’t want one of the greatest QBs of all time. Even with 173 neck surgeries over the past year or two, he’s better than anyone the Skins have had since Theismann.

    ————-

    100% truth!

  44. Who would want to play for the Redskins. The franchise is just treading water and the whole city is swarming with politicians….

  45. All these Skins fans knocking Bengals fans about no rings etc.? You tards haven’t a ring since the 1st Bush was in office, how many of you talking smack were even ALIVE? Then you’re going to talk about the Bengals’ arrest numbers? REALLY? It’s DC, no city on earth has more criminals moron. Didn’t the Lions beat you the last TWO times you played them, including a 2 win year to follow up their 0-16 campaign? LMAO @ the deadskins

  46. Think about it. If you were possibly one hit away from being in a wheelchair for the rest of your life, wouldn’t the odds of that one hit coming your way be pretty high for whoever plays behind the Redskins offensive line?

    Also, I’m sure Manning didn’t want to “learn” the secrets of playing quarterback and be taught hidden gem of knowledge that is “the system” run by Megamind and his 32 year-old kid.

  47. Not only does he not want to deal with the Shanahans, he doesn’t want to deal with whatever has-been Shanny gets replaced with when Snyder cleans house after another success-free season.

    Washington is a great place to go if you’re a big ego looking for a huge payday (like Haynesworth), but if you’re a serious football player who wants to actually win something, not so much. Not since Snyder took over.

  48. Has nothing to do with not wanting him, but at this point we need to continue to build, and develop a QB, which is not something that would happen if we signed him.

  49. As a skins fan, I don’t think Manning is a good fit. I am sick of us getting a veteran with a few years left. We need great draft picks and a few free agent signs of players that have a good 7 years in them.

  50. Too cold? With Miami’s division opponents in NYC, NE, and Buffalo, he’s gotta play at each a total of three times a year. If he wants to stay warm, he sure as hell isn’t going to Seattle, either.

    If I were him, I’d pick Arizona. Domed stadium. Warm. Larry Fitzgerald.

  51. Just imagine what Manning will do with the Fins receivers…

    He’ll have Marshall and Wayne as the 1st and 2nd option.
    He’ll have Hartline and Bess in the slot, and they’re numbers will explode.

    Maybe they can grab Landry or another good Free Agent. Draft best player available with the 8th pick and a TE in the second round.

  52. I live in the DC area. You have no idea how many of these poor fans were talking about getting Manning AND RG3. Hopefully this report will help their delusional souls get off the Manning train.

    Still gonna suck to hear them slobber all over RG3. That is, until the Rams trade that pick to some other team. At which point I’ll laugh!

  53. All of these interested teams have their 2004 eyeglasses on and see the 2004 Peyton Manning. The problem is they’ll end up with the 2012 model. Caveat Emptor. The Swamp Boy is done.
    ———————————————–
    *2010* Peyton Manning stats:
    4,700 Yds, 33 TD’s. 17 Int’s, 91.9 Passer Rating, 77% Completion %

  54. Why does no one consider this interest in Peyton a smokescreen coming from the smokescreen master, Shanahan?

    All these sources “familiar with the situation” were probably the ones telling all the Post writers that the Beckinator was a shoo-in to start out of the preseason.

    Hail

  55. cardiovascularendurance says:
    Mar 8, 2012 2:56 PM
    I love how Skins fans don’t want one of the greatest QBs of all time.
    —————————————-
    THIS Skins fan wanted him, and is sorry he is not interested. Do not understand anyone who would prefer Skins spending 6 draft picks to get RGIII, when you could have Manning, his whole entourage, and spend the picks on other upgrades, and a later round developmental QB.
    But alas, c’est la guerre.

  56. Also, I’m sure Manning didn’t want to “learn” the secrets of playing quarterback and be taught hidden gem of knowledge that is “the system” run by Megamind and his 32 year-old kid.
    ——————————————–
    Mike Shanahan is not a good evaluator, but ask Steve Young if he knows how to coach QB’s. All it would take is a guarantee to Manning from Shanny that Mike would be the coach and Kyle would gofer coffee.

  57. Least unexpected rumor about Manning are reports he wants no part of playing for the Redskins. Obviously he would prefer not to play in the same division as Eli. Even though he respects Shanahan, I’m sure he would scoff at being tutored by the little Shanahanling. Biggest reason of all is nobody who has “eff you” money would ever willingly become Danny Snyder’s shiny new toy.

  58. And being a Manning, if he doesn’t wan to – he won’t! Not sure why that didn’t get posted when a guy farther up wrote “Dick”! Did I hurt the feelings of someone “sensitive” in the office?

  59. musicman495 says:
    Mar 8, 2012 5:19 PM

    Do not understand anyone who would prefer Skins spending 6 draft picks to get RGIII, when you could have Manning, his whole entourage, and spend the picks on other upgrades, and a later round developmental QB.
    ——————
    I could write a laundry list of cons that outweigh the idealistic pros of bringing in Peyton.

    Either way, I just don’t see Shanahan abandoning this rebuild to try and brush the dust off the ole’ Colts gang.

  60. The same Chris Russell that thinks beck could be great? The same one who’s sources told him brandon banks would be cut last year? That idiot is the biggest goof on the radio and whoever thinks he has a hit show needs their head checked

  61. Too bad Mr. Silva didn’t triple check his sources before he broke this story as do many preemptive media outlets do. Manning did not say out of his mouth that he would not play for the Redskins but the scenario is unlikely. Twisting around facts is a good way to make yourself look less credible than you already do.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.