NFL’s replacement officials would include first female ref

If anything nudges the NFL and the locked out NFL Referees Association back to the bargaining table, it might be this weekend’s replacement clinic in Dallas.

Referred to as the “scab clinic” by NFLRA officials last week, it’s a collection of refs who’ve been working lower-level football, some retired officials and others who aren’t currently working at the Division I level.

If the league’s confident what they have gathered is a competent bunch, it will only embolden their stance. If they realize they have a disaster on their hands, it may make them much more agreeable to negotiate from the current position.

Not much is known about the makeup of the replacements, other than the fact the NFLRA considers them sub-standard.

But if they are put in play, a bit of NFL history will be made. According to Sam Farmer of the Los Angeles Times, one of the replacements is Shannon Eastin. She’s worked Mid-Eastern Athletic Conference games, but would be the first woman to work an NFL game as an on-field official.

Whether the league wants to put her on the field should have nothing to do with her gender. If she was qualified enough to work her way up the ranks to an NFL gig, no thinking person would have a problem with her presence. But the fact their replacement plan doesn’t include even the Triple-A quality refs from the college ranks would seriously diminish the accomplishment of a barrier being broken.

(Photo credit:

14 responses to “NFL’s replacement officials would include first female ref

  1. The only concern with a female ref would be, that amazing moment we all enjoy when a ref gets light up.

    But if these withered dinosaurs that currently ref can take the hit, a woman born this side of the civil war should be just fine.

  2. Good for her. Hate for her to have to sneak in the back door like thus but it’s a good first step regardless.

  3. I’ll go for that. How’s she look when she’s running, anything like Baywatch?

  4. Oh no! This is terrible news! Although women can be pretty sharp, might make more accurate calls. This is wonderful news!

  5. Having viewed life from the “3 score and ten” perspective, each time there is a significant breakthrough, I find it interesting how we all eventually conclude, “Hey, we could’ve been doing this all along.” Hopefully, here we go again.

  6. not the way I want to see that barrier broken. people will look back on it with a “yeah but” or an asterisk. its a shame for her to have to hear that but that’s just the way society is. alot of people will say she didn’t earn it but it was an circumstance of opportunity. it’d be great if she could do well and actually get hired to stay on and legitimize her presence. no reason why she can’t do the job. I wish her the best.

  7. i say give the replacements a shot.women included.the quality of officiating seems to have gone downhill the last few years anyway (though granted it is a tough job).who knows,just maybe some of the replacements could be more than adequate and even better than some already doing the job.

  8. That call they made on Calvin Johnson in Chicago any body can do better than.
    I wish the young lady the best step in and do well it well be better than they are doing now.

  9. Soulman45 says:
    Jul 23, 2012 12:59 AM
    That call they made on Calvin Johnson in Chicago any body can do better than.
    I wish the young lady the best step in and do well it well be better than they are doing now.

    The call was to the letter of the rule…which has not changed. The correct call was made. Whether you like the rule or not is a different story.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.