Dolphins tie stadium renovations to getting a Super Bowl

Getty Images

The NFL won’t promise a Super Bowl to a city that is building a new stadium or renovating an existing one.  The Dolphins have found a way around that obstacle.

The Dolphins will accept public funds for a renovation of Sun Life Stadium only if Miami secures the right to host Super Bowl L or Super Bowl LI.

“We have great confidence that South Florida will be awarded a Super Bowl on May 22,” Dolphins CEO Mike Dee told reporters, via the Miami Herald.

Dee said that a majority of the league’s owners support awarding either game to South Florida when the owners reconvene in two months.

Though acknowledging that the move constitutes a “risk,” Dee believes it’s not a huge gamble.  “I don’t think it’s a Hail Mary,” Dee said.

If either game comes to the region, the “core” activities will be conducted in downtown Miami.  For Super Bowl XLIV, the media center and other key events were located in Ft. Lauderdale.

The gesture to tie the funding of the renovations to getting a Super Bowl won’t hurt the effort to finagle public funds.  Still, voters eventually will have to approve the measure at the ballot box.

15 responses to “Dolphins tie stadium renovations to getting a Super Bowl

  1. Let’s see if I have this right. The league has to promise Miami the game in order to get public funding for the renovations, and the stadium has to have the renovations in order to get the game.

  2. Fat chance they get Miami citizens to give more public funding after getting screwed by the Marlins ownership.

  3. It’s nice to know where the priorities are for the Dolphins’ front office. Don’t worry about your own team playing in a Super Bowl or anything. Hosting a SB will keep Dolphin fans content, right?

  4. I don’t understand why people approve of a scam like that. All the time. The owners should pay for that crap. Not all the people who couldn’t dream of affording a game ticket. Scum for even putting it out there.

  5. Broward makes more money off the SB than Miami Dade and they want no part of this. Unless somehow Broward gets ZERO money going their way then I’m voting ‘NO’

  6. Thanks Mr Ross. putting up 200 million of your own money to upgrade the stadium and doing whatever you can to make the Dolphins better. You truely are appreciatead no matter what happens with politics of this.

  7. Super Bowls should be held in San Diego, Miami, Tampa, Los Angeles (when they get a stadium), Arizona, New Orleans & Atlanta.

  8. Owners of NFL teams make between 50M to 100M per year! Pay for you dam stadium yourself!!! The city of Miami is broke, schools are falling apart, and taxes are through the roof. You bought the team at a bargain knowing full well the condition of Sun Life stadium so pony up or sell the team.

  9. The stadium proponents are low-balling the amount the stadium renovation will cost. The actual amount has been reported as high as $684 million. That money would be spent in addition to the $225 million spent a few years ago on the last renovation. That’s a whopping $909 million on a 24-year old stadium, which is privately owned but built on public land. The Dolphins pay $3 million a year in property taxes for the stadium. Of course, the Dolphins get a $2 million dollar rebate from sales tax for the last renovation and are asking for an additional $1 million as part of this renovation.

    The Dolphins are asking for the taxpayers of Miami-Dade County to award them an additional 1% bed tax to pay for “half” of this renovation. A bed tax or transient rental tax is a way for local governments to raise taxes without incurring the wrath of voters since, by definition, the people paying the tax are “out-of-towner’s” who don’t vote in local elections. The bed-tax will provide the team with an additional $10 million per year of income, at the expense of so-called tourists who are in reality anyone renting a car, booking a room or eating at a hotel, motel etc. bed tax. These taxes can even apply to housing rentals with contracts of less than six months. In reality, greater bed taxes in Miami-Dade County mean that lower bed taxes in Broward and Palm Beach Counties make their businesses more competitive than the Dade businesses.

    The NFL wants you to think that Sun Life stadium is a bad place to watch a football game in February at the same time that they have awarded the next game to New York. Goodell claims that he got rained on down here! I can’t wait to hear about those wonderful brisk half-time shows performed up north! Why hasn’t the BCS told us that Miami has too harsh of a winter for their bowl game? Think back to Super Bowls played in Dallas, Detroit, and Minneapolis before you swallow that line! Even New Orleans is cold in February. Say, I have an Idea! Come in to New York City a week early and go golfing, maybe take a short cruise or shoot down to Atlantic City for some gambling! If you are smart, you will come to South Florida and do all of those things before you watch the game on TV while you get a tan. Now they all but promise to give us another Super Bowl in exchange for hundreds of million of tax dollars.

    The NFL and the Dolphins claim that they will in turn provide hundreds of millions of dollars for our local economy. This is just not true! The Wall Street Journal did an analysis and showed that at lest half of the Super Bowl hosts lost money and about 15% came closer to breaking even than showing a substantial profit. This is mainly due to the amount of services the hosts have to comp. The study did show that Miami was one of the top profiting venues though. I did some math and came to a $6 million average net profit. Now, if you understand economics, you know that this money circulated through South Florida’s economy three for a grand total of $18 million dollars; $5 million more than the $13 million we will be giving the Dolphins if we agree to Mr. Ross’s plan.

    The Dolphins keep hinting to a five year span between hosting Super Bowls her in Miami. But I have not heard about any done deal with the NFL to accomplish that. Cities compete against each other to host these games. There are no guarantees that our stadium renovations will bring one game here to South Florida. The NFL and Steve Ross are now implying that we will get a Superbowl soon or Ross will pay back the money for the renovations. Okay, when will you do that Mr. Ross?

    For arguments sake lets assume that we do get a Super Bowl every five years. The citizens of Miami-Dade County would have paid about $65 million to reap the approximate $18 million of profit. That means that the Orange Bowl and any other BCS games played in Sun Life Stadium must bring in about $3.1 million per year, if we are to assume that this money will also circulate three times and provide us with the equivalent of $9.4 million in net profit per year. So, I will concede that we might break even if we get a Super Bowl every five years and no further renovations are needed to the old stadium.

    Another big problem with these speculative numbers is the fact that contrary to what the NFL says, South Florida is a great place for a winter vacation. February is normally booked at 80% occupancy down here! Now, to be fair, we have to deduct $14.4 million from that $18 million we might generate from Super Bowl. That leaves only $3.6 million of actual profit. Remember, the Wall Street Journal’s numbers came added up to $6 million. The other venues that showed a profit were New Orleans, Phoenix, Tampa and San Diego. These are warm weather venues that everyone knows are great winter vacation destinations. Oops! Could the NFL have over estimated the potential profit from Super Bowl?

    Our tourist taxes need to be spent on keeping South Florida businesses at 100% occupancy from November 15 through March 15 and at 80% year round. It might not hurt to use some of that money advertising to Canadians and Yankees alike. We need for everyone to believe that South Florida is a great place to vacation and retire. No income taxes, low personal property tax, wonderful safe schools, great services for seniors and low crime. These are the same services that create the lifestyle we, the taxpayers, want to enjoy. More tourists and snowbird residents translate to increased tax revenue as opposed to NFL welfare. Increased tax revenue allows us to hire more cops, more teachers and improve our public healthcare workers. Let’s lure all of those frozen retirees to our beaches, golf courses and condominiums! Those tourists and snowbirds actually pay taxes rather than ask for handouts!

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!