PFT’s offensive player of the year

Getty Images

Determining the 2014 defensive player of the year?  Easy.  Figuring out the 2014 offensive player of the year?  Not as easy.

Several players had performances worthy of consideration for the best offensive showing of the year.  The Steelers had three:  running back Le’Veon Bell, quarterback Ben Roethlisberger, and receiver Antonio Brown.  So did the Cowboys, with running back DeMarco Murray, quarterback Tony Romo, and receiver Dez Bryant.

Bell had more than 2,200 yards from scrimmage.  Brown caught 129 passes, the second highest total in NFL history.  Roethlisberger tied Drew Brees with 4,952 passing yards, while throwing 32 touchdown passes and nine interceptions.

In Dallas, Romo had a league-leading passer rating of 113.2, with 3,705 passing yards, 34 touchdown passes, and nine interceptions.  Bryant had 1,320 receiving yards and 16 touchdown receptions.

Then there’s Packers quarterback Aaron Rodgers, who threw 38 touchdown passes and five interceptions while racking up 4,381 yards through the air.

But DeMarco Murray also had more than 2,200 yards from scrimmage — 2,261, precisely.  And he scored 13 touchdowns.  And he suited up for all 16 games, playing the last two after surgery to repair a broken bone in his hand.

So the winner is Murray, who ultimately may be defending the award with a new team in 2015.  He’s due to become a free agent, and if the Cowboys end up using the franchise tag on Bryant, Murray will hit the open market.

And now comes the part where you hit the button next to the name you think is most deserving of the recognition.

84 responses to “PFT’s offensive player of the year

  1. Congratulations to all the candidates, but Murray was in rare air this season. If you’re old enough to remember watching Jim Brown, it was pretty special seeing Murray pile up yards like he did. Especially without the “student body left or right” O-Line Brown ran behind. These Dallas young guns are seriously good.

  2. surprised the Ravens Defense isn’t on that list. They helped a lot of O’s this year.

  3. How does Gronk not get a mention? He is hands down the top tight end in the league. Blocking, routes, YAC, I mean cmon considering the injury he came back from his “slow” start surely should not be held against him. Compared to others in the league that start was still above average, and since week 4/5 he has exploded. He deserves a mention.

  4. How is Gronk not up for consideration? The dramatic effect he has in the Pats offense is undeniable.

  5. Seems to me the fact the Cowboys and Steelers have 3 candidates each means Rodgers should be the guy.

  6. Murray had a fantastic year but he doesnt belong in the same sentences with Jim Brown. Brown put up monster numbers with just 14 games per season. Give Jim Brown the 2014 Dallas offensive line and 16 games , he would rush for over 2500 yards.

    My vote – A. Rodgers

  7. No love, or even a mention for Odell Beckham Jr? Really? 1305yds, 12 TD’s, avg 14.3 in 12 games?

    I dont expect him to be mentioned over Murray or Rodgers, for example, but at least mention him. Imagine if he played in all 16…you guys would be falling all over yourselves

  8. Catching 129 passes all year double covered is really impressive. Especially for a guy who struggles to break 5’11. My vote would go to Brown.

  9. Surprised there isn’t more recognition of Romo’s recent back surgeries/injuries in the conversation of MVP votes. He get’s my vote.

  10. It’s Gronk and then a pile of mediocrity. Three members of a team that lost to the dysfunctional Jets and at home to the hapless, #1 overall pick Bucs ? Not even in the same league.

  11. Marshawn Lynch led the league in touchdowns with 17 (13 rushing 4 receiving) and is the first RB since LaDainian Tomlinson to lead the league in rushing touchdowns in consecutive seasons.

  12. big ben never has got any credit and never will. and that is ok. he doesn’t need respect, he will just keep on earning it. that’s what he does. is it me steeler fans. or when you see someones username that has like ihatesteelers or pittsburghsucks or comments that indicate they hate the steelers fans, city and team. I just absolutely love the hate. I think most steeler fans feel the same way as I do. haters think it hurts our feelings, but in reality we laugh and think how great it is to be hated, because it means we live rent free in your heads and it means we are a great organization. and you are just jealous! either way keep it coming!

  13. Not to take away from Murray at all because he was awesome, but he also has a very solid OLine and passing game to back him up.
    Rodgers is the best offensive player, Watt is the best defensive player.

  14. Wow brandonj21, that might be the dumbest comment of all time. So what if he’s not as good as Jim Brown? That doesn’t detract from the year he had. Would it make sense to say Rodgers shouldn’t be player of the year because he didn’t throw for as many yards as Marino or win as many Super Bowls as Montana?

  15. Before posting a winner you should use the results of the poll instead of a biased opinion.

  16. Not saying Gronk should have won but he should have been included. He was a monster this year and the Pats are an entirely different offense when he’s on the field.

  17. odel beckham is r.o.y. for sure. murray and bell were beasts but rodgers was just carving up most defenses. yes he had a few down games but for most of the season he was a baller. and 3 of rodgers 5 int’s were balls that hit receivers hands and went up in the air.

  18. Not saying gronkowski doesn’t deserve respect, he is great and all, but brown did have 40 more receptions! That is quite a few

  19. The continued ignoring of Matt Forte is a complete joke. 1800 plus total yards, 10 Tds, and an NFL RECORD 102 catches by a RB.

    This is not to remove anyone from the list, but I believe Forte should be included as well.

  20. might as well call this a packers board really? rodgers? romo had just as good numbers even a higher passer rating. everyone said cowboys would be 8-8. romo exceeded expectations

  21. Rodgers, by his own admission, had the worst game of his career just a few weeks ago. If you want a quarterback, Romo has played lights out all season, especially in December, even with a broken back. He doesn’t go running into the locker room in the middle of a game with a strained calf. But it’s well deserved by DeMarco.

  22. I would have to say Antonio Brown deserves this more than anyone. He never had below 5 catches in a game all year and also had an eight game streak of 8 catches or more in every game, he is a beast!

  23. People that say Rodgers deserves it are crazy. Hell. Teddy Bridgewater played better than him the last 5 games of the season….

  24. Everybody will give it to Aaron Rodgers because the league loves this clown. He is a great regular season quarterback but has won as many Super Bowls as Trent Dilfer and Brad Johnson. So he did have one great postseason run and everybody loves him since then. They say he is playing the quarterback position the best it has every been played. Apparently people didn’t watch football in the 80’s and 90’s. At best he barely makes it in a top ten list.

  25. pervyspankspackfans says: Jan 3, 2015 9:59 AM

    People that say Rodgers deserves it are crazy. Hell. Teddy Bridgewater played better than him the last 5 games of the season….
    ———————————————————–
    This is not the ONION

  26. So Murray’s stats are:
    2,261 total yards
    13 TD’s
    5 Fumbles

    2,215 total yards
    11 TD’s
    ZERO Fumbles (First ever to have 2,200+ yards without fumbling)

    Yes, Murray had more rushing yards, but I think Bell’s receiving yards are more important. So many times he was out there down the field catching a 3rd and long….

    But I understand the elite national media must choose Dallas players.

  27. Have to cut pervyspankspackfans some slack. He thinks the offense player of the YEAR award is only considered for the last 5 games of the season.
    Minny LOL

  28. as that ad with joe montana shows. doesnt he have 5 rings? lets see, rodgers won 1 in 7 years of playing, so he only has to play 28 more years to get 4 more rings like montana did.

  29. If teams are getting multiple nominations, Jordy Nelson and Randall Cobb deserve to be in the list.

    That’s Randall Cobb as in drafted long after the Vikings selected Canton-bound Christian Ponder instead.

  30. pervyspankspackfans says:
    Jan 3, 2015 9:59 AM
    People that say Rodgers deserves it are crazy. Hell. Teddy Bridgewater played better than him the last 5 games of the season….
    ———————————————

    Viking fans are delusional, we get that, but please don’t insult Aaron Rodgers by mentioning him in the same sentence as Teddy Bridgewater.

  31. Well, at least there is consensus it isn’t Bryant. No love for him in the comments yet.

    It’s also clear that most people are essentially homers. They root for the players they like and against the players they don’t. I’m a Steelers fan so I’d obviously point out where Bell, AB and Big Ben all deserve it. However, I have to throw some love at some other guys too – a healthy Gronk makes a world of difference to the Pats, if I was going to start someone at QB in a winner take all game it would be Rodgers, Romo has put up big numbers with a balky back and there aren’t many players you love to watch run the ball more than Marshawn Lynch.

    If you are a fan of any of these players, good on ya’. Those are some high quality ballers. And much to my delight, none of them are named Flacco, Dalton, Manziel, etc. 🙂

  32. dukeearl says:
    Jan 3, 2015 7:30 AM
    Not much bias here, 3 out of 7 are Cowboys.
    ——-

    3 out of 7 are also Steelers too. You do know the definition of biased, don’t you?

  33. briangraydon says: Jan 3, 2015 10:05 AM

    Well brandonj, if you give Brees or Brady Lacey, Nelson and Cobb they would have 6000 yards passing.
    ————————

    If Rodgers hadn’t been benched in the third or fourth quarters so often this year due to huge leads, he likely may have gotten very close to 6000 yards.

  34. I’m thinking Montana was a chief when young won the 49ers 5th SB. I think the only player who has 5 is Charles Hayley ( who is still not in hof ). I could be wrong. I didn’t see Montana’s name on this list don’t know why he’s even in the discussion. Maybe because there are no 49ers on the list and their fans only have the past players to fall back on. Go Cowboys!!!!!!

  35. Aaron Rodgers leading the pack? I can live with that.

    Personally, I voted for DeMarco. I will be the first to admit, I’m biased. I’m a Cowboys fan. {as I quickly hide behind whatever I can find so you don’t throw rocks at me}

    I will tell you what drives me crazy. How the owner of the Cowboys and some of the fans can run around saying that Romo should be MVP! Romo isn’t even the MVP on his own team. I’m not a Romo hater like most and I think he is a good QB, but DeMarco had an amazing year. Yes, he had more opportunities, but I think he did more with those opportunities. I guess you could even say that the offensive line should be the Cowboys MVP…

  36. imsmarterthanyou says:
    Jan 3, 2015 9:40 AM
    The continued ignoring of Matt Forte is a complete joke. 1800 plus total yards, 10 Tds, and an NFL RECORD 102 catches by a RB.

    This is not to remove anyone from the list, but I believe Forte should be included as well.
    ——-

    How valuble is he if his team finished below .500 and they are eliminated from the playoffs with 4-5 games to go in the season?

  37. The Romo-nites are going to want Romo to get it but Murray is very deserving of the title. Without the running of Murray, teams could have gotten after Romo a lot more and he wouldn’t have had near as good of a year.

    Bottom line is Murray’s contribution would have been the hardest to replace.

  38. Murray had a very good season.

    From a purely production assessment his yardage and touchdowns were half of Aaron Rodgers.

    Other than production and statistics, what criteria was used in your determination?
    The blocking of Murray’s offensive line which provided lots of clear space through which he merely ran?
    or
    that he is less likely to get the franchise tag this off season as an offensive teammate?

    Oh why bother, Mike Florio never allows my comments.

  39. There are several Quarterbacks who had more productive seasons than Rogers. How is he even in consideration? The NFL continues to foster an element of professional wrestling with the help of a complicit corporate media. If you don’t see it, you’re part of the problem.

  40. leatherface2012 says:
    Jan 3, 2015 9:45 AM
    might as well call this a packers board really? rodgers? romo had just as good numbers even a higher passer rating. everyone said cowboys would be 8-8. romo exceeded expectations
    ———————-
    Might wanna reread the article. Rodgers threw for 700 more yards, 4 more TDs, and 4 fewer picks. And that’s with being pulled from several games. His passer rating was one point less than Romo….throw out Buffalo and its not even close.

  41. Can’t wait for Dallas to go to Greenbay. All year haters have been doubting Dallas. ” oh they want beat the Saints or they want beat the Texans or the Seahawks or anybody for that matter. Now here we are NFC EAST CHAMPS and still know believers. You guys must love CROW, cause you keep stuffing your faces with it. Get ready for another bowl full Sunday in Detroit. LOLOLOL!!!!

  42. I think ARod is winning this vote for two reasons:

    1. He isn’t a Cowboy

    2. He isn’t a Steeler

  43. Sorry if rodgers is considered the mvp how is he not automatically the winner of this? If you’re not the best offensive or defensive player of the year, surely you can’t be the mvp then.

  44. 88xfactor, your entire comment loses meaning with the statement that the game is in detroit, i believe a real fan would know the game is in dallas. nice try at trolling

  45. I think the Offensive Player of the Year should be the Cowboys offensive line (yeah, give it to them as a group). Murray and Romo have never looked this good and it’s because they have a dominant offensive line.

  46. Why does nobody mention Rodgers’ offensive line? Last I checked their pretty darn good. Aren’t they the best pass blocking Oline in the league?

    I don’t think it should be a knock on Romo, Murray, or any player for that matter if they happen to play with other great players. Considering Romo leads the league in Passer Rating, Total QBR, Yards per Attempt, and Completion % clearly showed he’s made the most of his opportunities.

    Also, considering Rodgers and Romo are neck and neck as far as QB play, and Murray ran for 484 more yards than the next closest guy, while breaking the record for most consecutive 100 yard games to start a season.

    I think Murray deserves OPOY, while Rodgers gets the MVP.

  47. Thanks for askin…. Should be beast mode … Yeah….
    Not only his best year but provided some very scrumtralescent interviews for all to enjoy!!!!
    GO HAWKS!

  48. I’m surprised Luck didn’t get more consideration for this and MVP. Luck, the last two years, was the MVP. That team is nothing without Luck who puts up great stats with a below average defense, no running game and the worst offensive line in the league. Sure he has a good WR and TE but Luck makes them good. Take Luck off that team and they’re a 5 win team at best.

  49. Murray was really good this year. I hope he is in another team’s uniform so I don’t have to root against him next year. But Rodgers was the best offensive player all year. He wasn’t exactly shooting laser beams from his eyes, but it was pretty close.

  50. Fumbles flip the field. Got to be worth at least 30-40 yards each. Taking that into account Bell’s production on a net basis was superior to Murray’s.

  51. These individual honors and stats do not mean much. The two best TEAMS, Seattle and New England, are not represented. Wilson, Brady, Revis, Sherman, Gronk, and Lynch would much rather win the game. Let’s hope they each make it through to the Super Bowl so we can see one for the ages.

  52. Fantasy football scoring — using our league’s performance based, non-PPR system — can be illuminating…

    QB

    252 — Andrew Luck
    248 — Aaron Rodgers
    227 — Peyton Manning (310 in 2013)

    RB

    174 — DeMarco Murray (Jamal Charles 197 in 2013)
    172 — Marshawn Lynch
    162 — Le’Veon Bell

    WR

    158 — Antonio Brown
    154 — Dez Bryant
    147 — Jordy Nelson

  53. pervyspankspackfans says:
    Jan 3, 2015 9:59 AM
    People that say Rodgers deserves it are crazy. Hell. Teddy Bridgewater played better than him the last 5 games of the season….

    _____________________

    This is so absurd, it makes you look very foolish. All you Rodgers / Packers haters are so jealous!!

    Once again — the Packers have more championships than any other NFL franchise.
    And once again, Rodgers is the highest rated QB in NFL history.

    Anything else you need to learn?

  54. bigbenownsthenfl – There will be no tears from this guy – I’m an NFC fan. I just have no disrespect for an overrated team that harbors a QB that would be in prison if he wasn’t an NFL player. Disgusting people with a bad team.

  55. Rodgers, by his own admission, had the worst game of his career just a few weeks ago. If you want a quarterback, Romo has played lights out all season, especially in December, even with a broken back. He doesn’t go running into the locker room in the middle of a game with a strained calf. But it’s well deserved by DeMarco.

    -////-

    Rodgers had the flu that week man, easy, he also only played 3 quarters or less in a few massive blowouts. I would think week 17 shows why he is truly the league MVP and offensive POY. The Packers are the NFC #2 seed and it took three Cowboys and three Steelers respectively playing outstanding offense just to make Wildcard Weekend. Just sayin’.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.