Jaworski on Jameis: A lot of on-field flaws, I wouldn’t take him No. 1

AP

Ron Jaworski has some advice for the Tampa Bay Buccaneers as they consider picking Jameis Winston with the first overall pick in the NFL draft: Don’t do it.

Jaworski said on Mike & Mike that he simply doesn’t think Winston is a good enough passer to make him worth going No. 1 overall.

“I’ve studied a lot of him, I think Jameis Winston has a big upside in the NFL, but there are some real flaws to his game,” Jaworski said. “Quite honestly, I would not take him at that No. 1 pick.”

Winston has had off-field troubles as serious as a rape accusation, as trivial as shoplifting and as stupid as getting suspended for screaming obscenities on the Florida State campus. But Jaworski made clear that his problems with Winston are about the way he plays the quarterback position.

“I’m not talking about the off-the-field stuff. I have no comment on that because I’m not privy to that kind of information. But there are certainly mechanical flaws in his game that are troubling to me,” Jaworski said.

From all indications, the Buccaneers are leaning toward taking Winston first overall, but their evaluations aren’t over. Jaworski thinks that the more they look at Winston’s film, the more flaws they’ll find.

123 responses to “Jaworski on Jameis: A lot of on-field flaws, I wouldn’t take him No. 1

  1. Please….

    Jaws is the same idiot who also said that Kapernick will be one of the greatest QB’s of all time. And Kapernick will be out of the league and selling insurance by this time next year. :rolleyes:

    So on that statement about Kapernick, Jaws has proven he knows nothing about quarterback evaluations.

  2. Great, the guy who said RG3 would be the best QB to ever play in the NFL still knows nothing.

    It’s better to not write a story than publish garbage

  3. I have been watching film for approximately 84 consecutive hours and that’s why I truly belieeeeeve Jameis Winston could beeeeeee….. One of the worst draft choices EVER.

  4. Colin Kaepernick will eventually become the best qb ever.
    –Ron Jaworski. I wouldn’t take Winston at number 1 either but consider the source.

  5. All he said is that he wouldn’t take him No. 1. Is that such a crime if he thinks Winston is the 3rd or 5th or 10th best player in this draft?

  6. Jaworski’s comments fly directly against everyone else’s that I’ve read.

    The problem with the ESPN guys is that they go for controversy rather than analysis.

  7. There really is no consensus number 1 overall. Way to go out on a limb Jaws. I’d like to know who he would take because I’m sure many fans wouldn’t take him 1st overall either.

  8. Jaworski , remember when you had that one great year in 1980 and parlayed it into owning golf courses….that was awesome.

  9. Jaworski’s credibility as an evaluator of quarterbacks is ZERO after claiming Kaepernick has a chance to be the greatest quarterback ever!

  10. Didn’t Jaws also say that Manziel was not worth a 1st round pick as well this time last year?

  11. Jaws also said he’d want Foles over Russell Wilson and “its’ not even close.”

  12. Didn’t Jaworski say that Colin Kaepernick could be one of the best quarterbacks ever? Just take that in while reading this article.

  13. Jaws is annoying and insufferable but he’s 100% right when it comes to this bum.

  14. But Kaepernick is headed for the Hall of Fame, and he’d rather have Nick Foles over Russell Wilson, lol. Those are just the last 2 off-season bold predictions. In other words, his opinion matters why?

  15. I’ll be sure to tune in and learn exactly what is wrong…..

    The more serious question is can the flaws be fixed? If you don’t think he’s a number 1, then you are saying he’s already reached his ceiling. I find that difficult to believe. FSU is not known for developing pro QBs.

  16. I do not have a strong opinion about the QB. I would not let Jaworski pick a meal a McDonalds let alone evaluate NFL talent.

    He is horrible at it, was he not saying that Bridgewater shouldn’t be a first round pick last year?

  17. Wow…right after renouned scout Greg cosell gave him the same analysis last week. If you can’t beat em join em Jaws

  18. How does this guy still have a job?

    He wasn’t great when he played, and he’s even worse at analyzing players, and he’s ESPNs QB guru…

    ESPN why are you such a joke?

  19. Almost every quarterback has flaws. That doesn’t mean he isn’t worth going #1 overall because his position makes him more valuable than a “flawless” guy at another position.

  20. I’m oddly pleased that I can’t recall a single Jaws quote that I bothered to even remember. He’s like the teacher in Charlie Brown, just mumbling away in the background.

  21. Jaworski on Jameis: A lot of on-field flaws, I wouldn’t take him No. 1

    with that being said….when I here that “Jaws” is going to be guest on the radio I make sure I turn the station.

  22. Who here is confident enough in Jameis to bet your job on him? Personally, I make a safer choice. Preferably somebody that hasn’t had at least 3 character “incidents” while at college.

  23. The thing is, Jaworski has zero credibility. But even a blind squirrel sometimes finds a nut.

  24. Just so we are clear, “From all indications…” which are those indications from the media. Not Tampa Bay.

  25. Lovie had success with Rex Grossman (Super Bowl berth/loss) and with Jay Cutler (Conference Final). Do not think Winston has the mental fortitude to be a winner. The National Championship versus Auburn was a fluke — Auburn had them beat until the final minute. Winston lost the Rose Bowl to Mariota (Rose Bowl MVP). Winston is not worthy of being taken No.1. T-Bucs had better scoop up Leonard Williams, instead.

  26. Jaws = Former Eagle. Eagles want Mariota. Bucs need a QB. Bucs interested in JW at #1. Kelly working phones on a trade with Bucs. Jaws discredits JW says Foles much better. Kelly trades Foles and boatload of picks for the #1 pick. Eagles get Mariota. Simple.

  27. Jameis already advised everyone to “trust me”…isn’t that enough, Jaws?! Heh-heh-heh…

  28. Not privy to that kind of information? Does he live under a rock? And didn’t Todd McShay say Winston was the best QB prospect in recent past since Luck? ESPN is wack. PFT for life! P.S. love the “sever” head trauma comment. Classic.

  29. So let me get this straight
    Jon Gruden, Mark Dominik, and Jaworski won’t take Winston with the #1 overall pick? Looks like it’s a sure thing for Winston to go number one now.

  30. I think we can all agree that Ron Jaworski has a lot of on-camera flaws, and I, personally, wouldn’t take him in a draft of ESPN analysts. For me, its just his on camera mechanics are not there, and his football intelligence is simply lacking. Overall, I would NOT take Jaworski number 1 overall, or even at all for that matter…

    ps. i remember watching his qb list segments and just being like what is this bafoon saying!!! kaepernick being the GOAT….get this guy off the air please!!!

  31. wallabear says:
    Mar 4, 2015 4:37 PM
    Lovie had success with Rex Grossman (Super Bowl berth/loss) and with Jay Cutler (Conference Final). Do not think Winston has the mental fortitude to be a winner. The National Championship versus Auburn was a fluke — Auburn had them beat until the final minute. Winston lost the Rose Bowl to Mariota (Rose Bowl MVP). Winston is not worthy of being taken No.1. T-Bucs had better scoop up Leonard Williams, instead.

    not an fsu fan even in the slightest…but your argument of “auburn had them beat until the final minute” (is that the final minute where jameis threw the winning td pass?) uhhh….

  32. Jaws has made some ridiculous statements about QB’s before, so his evaluating credibility is questionable. I somewhat share his opinion on this though. (I have no evaluating credibility except as a long-time fan)

    The thing is maybe in another draft class he isn’t number 1, even without the off the field stuff. But if you are in desperate need of a QB and you have the number 1 pick, who else are you going to take? Mariota has serious questions about playing under center in a pro offense and has several “mechanical flaws” as well. Nobody is a lock to be a star QB in this draft.

  33. Sorry Jaws, but your Kaep statement was a huge blunder. Even I knew he had flaws on the field and off the field to prevent him being a great QB. He has to go back and work on some basic skills that every NFL QB should know.

  34. This is a tough call for the Bucs. Texans were in the same position last year with no QB worth a number one overall pick. Clowney remains a question mark but at least they didn’t bite on Johnny.

  35. It’s funny how many of you want to discredit an ex-pro who watches more game film than you do.

    People talk about a quarterbacks mechanics and their inability to succeed. Philip Rivers has some of the worst throwing mechanics of any quarterback and he’s a 100 million dollar quarterback.

    Collin Kaepernick can’t hit target to save his life, 100 million dollar quarterback.

    Jay Cutler is bad in every way, he made the most money at QB last year.

    All Jameis has to do is NOT get arrested until the draft and he will be going #1 regardless to who.

  36. Just another ESPN hype machine like Dilfer, Young, Lewis etc. They think if they say it with enough body language and over emphasis it makes it true. I think the E in ESPN should be capitalized and the rest in lower case.

  37. If only we knew he would get decent coaching and we are not sure of that at all.

  38. I think people need to give Kaepernick a lot more credit, and I’m not even a fan. All QBs have down years.

    Anyone that doesn’t want Winston is called a hater…by the same people that will call people idiots when Winston ends up a bust.

  39. If you sit down and talk to him and like him, you almost have to take him.

    He seems like a royal jerk to me, but the tools are as good as you see.
    You could be passing on Micheal Jordan.

  40. An average player at best and I don’t dislike the man but Jaws’ best attribute is talking EMPATHICALLY. That and he throws in that he watches an unimaginable amount of film.

    In all seriousness, I should do this at my day job…good tactic and I would get promoted.

  41. Jaws should donate his brain for CTE study. Does he have to be dead first, or can he do it right away?

  42. The most difficult part of being a bad team is being in this position. When the Hawks took Wilson in the third, they had the ability to wait because the rest of their team was solid. I say let someone else make a moron out of themselves and trade out of the #1. If the rest of your team is great, you can make it with a B level QB you get later in the first or second.

  43. Ron “Jaws” Jaworski, I’m from Philly & part of my early childhood was watching you help the Eagles become contenders again. I’m a fan but I do have to say for I think Jamies is a great #1 pick for Tampa. I know he’s not a true #1 on many peoples “Big Board” he might be # 3 or #4. His mechanics have already greatly improved after working with George Whitfield before the Combine. It was clear to me that his throwing motion has become more compact, leading to a quicker release & less like a pitcher. He tends to rely on his upper body strength too much. This is all coachable. He is a great, confident player & players seem to be drawn to him. He comes off as a guy who players will follow into battle. He has an NFL ready arm. He has a very high football IQ. The kid is a football player, he loves to compete. I think he is a no brainer for Tampa. When Tampa drafts him he will be able to start game 1. Tampa can’t afford not to draft him.

  44. You idiots act as if Kaepernick is out of the league. He can still be a great QB. Idiots on this site!!!

  45. This time last year Jaws was telling us how Bridgewater was the 4th best QB in the draft behind Bortles, Mettenberger, and Manziel. He’s a block head who doesn’t know anything about evaluating quarterbacks or any other position for that matter. You might as well ask Skip Bayless what he thinks of Winston. You’ll get a similarly educated opinion.

    The Bucs are gonna suck no matter who they take, so it doesn’t much matter to me what they do anyway.

  46. Jameis is going to be hugely successful. So what if there are mechanical issues? Those can be worked out. Several evaluators have said he’s the smartest QB they have interviewed since Peyton. He needs to mature, but if he can do that the sky’s the limit.

  47. Remember Jaws said Johnny Football was a day 3 pick & all the other pundits said he was a top ten talent? Hate on him all you want and say he is a block head but JFF looked more or less like a guy who shoulda went undrafted and the only person who said he wasn’t the next big thing was JAWS.

  48. “I’ve watched 7200 hours of film on Jameis in the last two days and can definitely say, he is not the greatest ever!”

    Jaws????

  49. I like jaws…but if he was so good at what he did, why hasnt a team hired him to scout/gm?

  50. omg jaws was wrong before. Who hasn’t been? Technically he said Kaep had “the tools” to be greatest, and he does…physically. Mentally he’s regressed.

  51. Funny the comments on this board about anyone from ESPN, or anyone who is an analyst who is NOT:
    1) A person of color
    2) Young
    3) An ex-player
    4) Doesn’t say “Ath-a-leet”
    5) Doesn’t say “I Axed him”
    6) Doesn’t say The Buffalo “Bealls”

    Jaworski actually is one of the better, more informed analysts.

    What do you expect? Every “prediction” to be 100% correct?

    Too funny..

  52. Since 1970 there have been 20 QBs drafted first overall. Only 6 have won the Super Bowl.

    There are no guarantees at QB in the draft.

  53. Jaworski might be a little credible if He hadn’t stated one time that He had over 50 concussions in the NFL. Why is this guy even on TV? He is just awful!

  54. Last 10 QB’s taken #1 Overall in the NFL draft:

    2012 Andrew Luck
    2011 Cam Newton
    2010 Sam Bradford
    2009 Matthew Stafford
    2007 Jamarcus Russell
    2005 Alex Smith
    2004 Eli Manning
    2003 Carson Palmer
    2002 David Carr
    2001 Michael Vick

    Total of 67 years played in the NFL so far.
    Total of 13 Pro Bowl Selections

    HOF locks: 0
    HOF potential: Andrew Luck (1) out of 10

    QB’s taken in round 2 or later of the same 10 draft classes as above qbs:

    Russell Wilson, Andy Dalton, Colin Kaepernick, Kyle Orton, Derek Anderson, Matt Cassel, Drew Brees

    I think you can damn near make a case that there has been as much talent in the 2nd round and later as there has with #1 picks and they come with a LOT smaller cap numbers and risk if you miss.

    The problem with the way qb’s are drafted, is terrible teams pick early (see: no qb) and reach with the pick. Sometimes it hits, sometimes it misses.

    Worst move ever: (trade multiple picks to take a qb #1: see: RGIII).

    While Jaws is an idiot…. I think most will agree to that. A blind shot in the dark would tell you, based on history, that he has at minimum a 50% chance of being correct on Jameis.

    Of the last 10 SB winning qb’s:

    Roethlisberger – pick 11
    Brady – pick 199
    Wilson – pick 75
    Flacco – pick 18
    Brees – pick 32
    Rodgers – pick 24

    In fact, Eli and Peyton are the ONLY #1 overall picks that have won a Super Bowl over the last decade.

  55. Colin Kaepernick has enjoyed more success this early in his career than any QB I can remember (except Joe Montana). He’s led his team to a Super Bowl and an NFC Championship game in only 2 1/2 years as a starter. He’s done this with zero WRs. So Jaworski looks like a genius when he raves about Kaepernick. Winston threw 18 interceptions against college DBs last year. It doesn’t take a genius to see those flaws. If the college DBs could catch, he’d have thrown 30 ints. Who knows. Maybe Winston will have more success against NFL DBs than he did in college. If Tampa Bay wants to take that risk at #1, go for it.

  56. I’m not defending Jaws but there is no way I would draft Winston #1 and probably not in the first 3 rounds.

    Reason – I can’t name ONE single QB that has been worth the #1 overall pick that had serious off-field issues while in College.

    It takes a special person to be a really good QB. Someone who is dumb enough to cause trouble when they are staring at an opportunity like this does not have the mental or character makeup to be a great QB in the NFL.

    Mariota > Winston

  57. With assessing QB’s, I think you need to start with what’s between the ears. This guy has character issues and the way he carries himself is usually a good indicator what’s between the ears. Prepare for JaMarcus Russell Part II.

  58. Yeah and Phil Simms said that Andrew Luck can’t fit balls into tight windows. How did that work out.

    I can judge the tape as well as Jaworski here – Winston is as good of a QB prospect on the field as there has been in the last 10 years, including my favorite player Andrew Luck. I’m sorry but that’s just being objective.

  59. Kaepernick has accomplished more than any young QB since Montana because he took his team to 1 NFL championship and 1 Super Bowl? You realize other teams exist besides San Fran right? There’s this guy named Russell Wilson who has accomplished more in the last two years. Hi, I’m earth.

  60. tonebones says:
    Mar 4, 2015 7:25 PM
    Colin Kaepernick has enjoyed more success this early in his career than any QB I can remember (except Joe Montana). He’s led his team to a Super Bowl and an NFC Championship game in only 2 1/2 years as a starter. He’s done this with zero WRs. So Jaworski looks like a genius when he raves about Kaepernick. Winston threw 18 interceptions against college DBs last year. It doesn’t take a genius to see those flaws. If the college DBs could catch, he’d have thrown 30 ints. Who knows. Maybe Winston will have more success against NFL DBs than he did in college. If Tampa Bay wants to take that risk at #1, go for it.

    ——————————————————

    Kaepernick “led” that same team that Im sure you would say “carried” Alex Smith.

    Zero receivers?
    Boldin, Stevie Johnson, Michael Crabtree, Ellington/Patton (if you believe in Baalke…)

    While Smith literally had practice squad receivers, plus Crabtree in his time in SF.

  61. There isn’t a first-round quality QB in this draft. Jaws is no genius but it doesn’t take one to see that.

  62. Everyone should cut Jaworski some slack. Isn’t he the QB Lawrence Taylor sacked the most in his career?

    Too many head shots to Ron have affected his ability to be rational. And then there’s those glasses!

  63. Cont’d from the post above….

    Quote from LT about sacking Ron Jaworksi:

    “He doesn’t see you coming and you drive your helmet into his back so hard, he blows a little snot bubble,” LT wrote.

  64. Where Jameis should be picked and where he must be picked are two different things.

    It’s determined by where other QB needy teams are picking.

    Jaworski has a ten cent brain.

  65. The smartest move that Tampa Bay could make would be to court the Eagles and trade the #1 pick.
    Take Nick Foles and the lion’s share of Philly’s draft this year. Foles has 46 touchdowns and 10 interceptions in 28 career games. He’s 6’6″ 243. He’s gold and proven.

  66. What a clown. He was talking up Captain One Read (Kaepernick) as the potentially greatest QB in NFL history.

    Even though in reality, he showed none of the important aspects of QBing as he played the role of Tim Tebow 2.0. Run, Kap! Run!

  67. I can see where he is coming from….. I wouldn’t draft JW no earlier than the 4th round…. He is a major risk, the poster child for red flags and could still be interested in baseball….

  68. I’m sure Jaws thought the same thing about the young QB that took his job on the Eagles by he name of Randall Cunningham. Go back and look at the expressions on Jaw’s face !! It was hilarious. lol

  69. Winston will be in custody before he takes his first NFL snap. Tallahassee Police protected him, Hillaborough will not be so kind.

  70. Question: Is Ron Jaworski saying that Glennon is a better starting Qb than Winston (or Marriota), and they should draft no one? Or that a free agent QB is better to start?

    It is not a question if he has flaws right now (like a lot of INTs for a first pick QB – Winston has more than any other in NFL history except Jim Plunkett). The question Tampa should be asking is “Is he our best bet for our starting Qb in the future?” If the answer is no, none of the other options are better, Winston should be the pick.

    Looking at this in a vacuum saying he is not a #1 pick is not so useful – looking at a team’s current Qb situation and seeing if this would be a big improvement in potential definately is.

  71. I think Winston will be a great NFL QB and I hope the Bucs draft him. Having said that, I kind of get what Jaws is saying. Ideally I would like to draft him in the first round but not literally the #1 pick (too much money and attention involved). However, the Bucs need a QB and unless they’re willing to trade down and take the chance that another team won’t draft him before their number’s called, they really don’t have a choice but to draft him #1.

  72. I worry about the wind up throwing patter (baseball) that Winston has like Byron Leftwich who continuously had blocked passes due to his wind up throwing pattern. At the combine they commented to Winston that it looked like he shorten his wind up and Winston stated he had recently since concentrating on football. But what happens when pressure is on and reaction comes into play, you go back to that same old throwing pattern (ask Tim Tebow). Also when Winston was asked if he plans on continuing with baseball he stated “I can’t talk to that” , that comment also makes me feel the throwing pattern will never change.

    Mariota on the other hand is learning the 3, 5 and 7 step drop back for the first time so under pressure he won’t know anything else but what he just learned.

  73. “All indications point to Buccaneers taking him 1st overall” what indications? You mean like at the combine when Lovie Smith and Buccaneers GM both separately said “we like Mike Glennon, a lot” and the indications 2 seasons ago when Glennon stepped in for Freeman as a Rookie without Mike Evans, no O line & did just fine? Or last year when he did better than McCown and the Buccaneers realized they never should have brought him in? You mean those indications? I’d be very surprised if Buccaneers take a QB first overall Winston or anyone.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.