McCown with the starters, Manziel with backups at Browns’ OTAs

AP

Browns quarterback Josh McCown has opened Organized Team Activities as the starting quarterback, while Johnny Manziel is working with the second team.

That’s no surprise: It’s been believed from the day McCown was signed that he’s the starter, and that Manziel is second. McCown said after practice that he views the Browns as his team, but he also said he hopes to support Manziel and the other young quarterbacks on the roster.

“I’ve said from Day One, I want to see the Cleveland Browns quarterback position be better than it’s been, and I want to do my part to help that happen on the field, but if something happens and I’m not playing, that whoever is playing, that those guys are productive too,” McCown said.

Manziel didn’t talk to reporters, but Browns coach Mike Pettine said he’s liking what he’s seeing from Manziel.

“He’s been very engaged in the meetings, and it’s good to see a lot of stuff carried over from the meetings onto the field, not just for him but for all the quarterbacks. I just feel much better, from that room a much better sense of urgency and attention to detail,” Pettine said.

Pettine sounds like he thinks Manziel is on the right track. But Manziel is not on track to start.

35 responses to “McCown with the starters, Manziel with backups at Browns’ OTAs

  1. Given the personnel, the word organized in Cleveland’s OTAs should be in air quotes

  2. If Manziel becomes a reasonable starting QB, I wonder how many people will turn around and say I knew he had it in him, I expected him to eventually get it, etc. I saw him score his first TD in Buffalo and he didn’t look awful. On that day, some old geezer in the stands at Ralph Wilson said he could see Manziel becoming a Doug Flutie. As a Browns fan, I would be more than okay with a Doug Flutie Redux.

    Kelly Holcomb remains my favourite Browns QB of the past two decades, which is all I need to say to communicate the sadness. Holcomb gave a couple magical quarters in a playoff against Pittsburgh and I have been holding onto that light for many years now.

  3. Despite Manziel’s ‘rehabilitation’ I still think it’s obvious that he was a wasted draft pick and it’s wishful thinking to generate success by trying to polish a turd. I therefore think that Cleveland will be headed in the right direction if this loser isn’t on the Browns’ roster on opening day of the regular season.

  4. I know it sounds sacrilegious, but maybe letting a quarterback hold a clipboard on the sidelines until they are actually ready to compete in the NFL is a better plan than dumping yet ANOTHER first round draft pick down the drain. There are far more quarterbacks that flame out because they are thrown into action before they are ready than there are quarterbacks who are ready to play from day one.

  5. The Browns deserve to have a QB someday. Would love to see it in my lifetime. No, not a Browns fan, just hate to see their eternal plight.

  6. gedole says:
    May 26, 2015 3:59 PM

    Kelly Holcomb remains my favourite Browns QB of the past two decades, which is all I need to say to communicate the sadness. Holcomb gave a couple magical quarters in a playoff against Pittsburgh and I have been holding onto that light for many years now.

    ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

    I can relate. And I feel for you. I’m old enough to remember the Packers misery of the 70’s and 80’s. Oh man, it was a tough, tough time to be a Packer fan. Oddly enough, I and everyone else I knew also grabbed onto little bits of sunshine wherever we could, just as you mentioned above.

    Keep the faith. It will turn around eventually. And Manziel might just be the guy that leads the way. Of course he may not be, either. It’s way too early to tell. I do think the Browns are playing it smart by not throwing him to the wolves right away. I think a lot of the “bust” quarterbacks of late busted because they got thrown out there too early and their confidence got destroyed.

  7. As it should be. And that’s coming from someone who is now pulling for Manziel. If he’s going to become the starter, he needs to earn his way up the depth chart. (Frankly, if they start him out as the third or fourth string QB, that’s even better in my opinion.)

    – Titans Fan

  8. “only this year he has competition for the most talked about backup QB”

    Tim Tebow takes exception to that comment!

  9. “I can relate. And I feel for you. I’m old enough to remember the Packers misery of the 70’s and 80’s. Oh man, it was a tough, tough time to be a Packer fan. Oddly enough, I and everyone else I knew also grabbed onto little bits of sunshine wherever we could, just as you mentioned above.”

    I lived that horror also brother…dark days. But, it was not just bringing in #4 to bring success, it also involved a sweet combination of Ron Wolf and Mike Holmgren. Without that type of mixture…the Browns or any franchise will have a tough time with success.

  10. Spin one: See headline above.
    Spin two: Browns will run ball.
    Spin three: Defense will win games.
    Reality: No winning QB on roster. Can’t run with eight in the box. Lose a lot of games 13-10 early in the year. Gets worse as Defense wears down.

  11. What a bust huh? I mean they couldn’t have swung harder and missed by more than what they did when they used their #1 on this guy.
    I really enjoyed watching him in college but I had serious doubts about his ability in the pros and my doubts were founded.

  12. @hammerofcheddar-

    I’ve always been of the opinion that signing Reggie was maybe the biggest part of it all as that made other guys in the league (or in the draft) think that maybe coming to Green Bay wasn’t such a bad thing. The salary cap and revenue sharing also had a lot to do with it. If not for those two things, the Steelers might still be dominating the league year after year.

    Getting back to players wanting/not wanting to play in Green Bay, here’s a sad but true story. I’m sure you remember Terdell Middleton (the last 1,000 yard rusher the Pack had before Edgar Bennet). My older brother went to college with him and he says that as the draft was approaching, one of their professors asked him where he hoped to end up; Terdell answered “Anywhere but Green Bay.” Oof da!

  13. They obv don’t believe Johnny can play. The writing is on the wall. They would be sharing equal reps if thought otherwise. If He can’t beat a career backup for the starting job I would say that’s a very bad sign.

  14. @flaccosmoustache-

    I’m not sure about that. They may very well be just letting him learn before throwing him out there. Putting up with a couple years of McCown or another career backup might be very wise in the end. That said, I’m not necessarily disagreeing with you either.

    Quarterback in the NFL is said to be the toughest job in all of sports, mentally speaking. It’s also the only position in the NFL where people seem to expect first-round rookies to start right away. When did that happen? If a first-round rookie DB or WR doesn’t start right away from day one nobody bats an eye; but if that first-round rookie is a QB and he doesn’t start from day one, a lot of people want to hang the “bust” label on the guy. I’m not saying that you’re trying to hang a label on Manziel, I’m just saying that many, many people do.

    It seems like very few rookie QB’s that start from day one succeed. For every Andrew Luck there’s a dozen guys that fail miserably. And I can’t help but wonder if maybe those guys wouldn’t have failed had they gotten a little “seasoning” holding the clipboard before getting thrown to the wolves.

  15. Worst team in the history of the NFL, and yet another wasted #1 round pick.

    Pathetic 1st round pick for a pathetic franchise.

    How bad is it that you need to move out of state just to be good?

  16. Two points to make here

    1. Josh McCown is a horrible QB; I don’t expect him to be any different this year. He fits the Browns perfectly.

    2. Johnny Manziel had about as bad a season as any rookie QB ever had; can Mr Party Guy get his life under control and concentrate on football and become an NFL quarterback? Time will tell. I’m not holding my breath.

  17. Brian Sipe is available…

    Ahhhh…Red Right 88…shut up…shut up….shut up…!

  18. Once again the comments complain about a QB position on a team that lead the league in RUSHING touchdown percentage in 2014 and lead their division for over half the season doing it.

    If you don’t get it yet here’s the transcript from McCowns interview

    Farmer: Hey Josh, great to meet you… So can you hand the ball off to three different running backs for an hour?

    Josh: Sure..

    Farmer: Great.. You’ve got the job.

    Josh: Awsome but will I ever have to pass.

    Farmer: yeah we do one pass to Manziel a game but thats it.

    Josh: One pass a game? I’m going to love it here!

  19. I’m not exactly sure what happened in Tampa, but McCown was solid for Chicago during the 2013 season. He’s streaky, but he’s also tough. Pretty good athlete too. He’ll set up and throw quicker than JM.

    I’m pulling for the Browns and Bills. Who else is sick of the same six AFC teams qualifying for the postseason every year?

  20. What’s the over/under on Johnny keeping up the boy scout routine?

    Once Browns start 1-3, they will have to go to Johnny. NFL defenses will make Johnny beat them from the pocket — which is something that this pixie cannot do — and Johnny will be out of the league in 2016.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.