Eagles nearly traded Evan Mathis during the draft

Getty Images

In lieu of cutting running back LeSean McCoy, the Eagles found a trade partner. They almost did the same thing with guard Evan Mathis.

Per a source with knowledge of the situation, the Eagles nearly traded Evan Mathis during the draft.

While it’s unclear whether it was part of an effort to get quarterback Marcus Mariota or another deal, it didn’t happen. Which makes the eventual release of Mathis even more surprising.

According to the source, no serious efforts were made to trade Mathis before releasing him this week. But it would have made sense to try to get something of value in return for a two-time Pro Bowler. Even if he’s not happy with his contract, another team could have secured dibs on negotiating a deal Mathis would deem to be acceptable — such as the offer from last year that Mathis contends was pulled from the table in 2015.

With the details reported by multiple media outlets on Tuesday (roughly $1 million more per year in 2015 and 2016), any interested team could have initiated the process of securing Mathis pursuant to a deal in that range in exchange for a low-round draft pick. Or the Eagles could have done the same thing.

Ultimately, coach Chip Kelly opted instead to dump Mathis abruptly, a possible manifestation of Kelly’s fast-talking impatience. It’s also a possible reflection of Kelly’s attitude toward the crapshoot that is the draft. For him, keeping Mathis around any longer wasn’t worth it, even if it meant coaxing a third-day selection from the team that eventually signs Mathis.

87 responses to “Eagles nearly traded Evan Mathis during the draft

  1. I mean didn’t he give Evan and his agent 2 years to try to find a trade partner and had 1 nibble at the draft that amounted to nothing. At what point do you say no one is going to trade for a 34 year old with a 11.5 million dollar 2 year contract that was a journeyman until the last 2 years with chip when he was a pro bowler?

  2. Man,does Chip Kelly run the Eagles ship or what! Not a Eagles fan (other than the rock band) but it will be interesting what happen with the team this year! We’ll know by seasons end if he knows what he doing. good luck!

  3. It appears all these moves from Chip are a pissing contest with the former GM who brought them in. Failure is in the air in the air.

  4. “Per a source with knowledge of the situation, the Eagles nearly traded Evan Mathis during the draft.”

    Yeah, this was widely reported at the time. Rosenhaus flat out said it in an interview. The interested team drafted a lineman instead.

    “According to the source, no serious efforts were made to trade Mathis before releasing him this week.”

    Same interview, Rosenhaus said he’s been shopping Mathis for 2 years.

    So basically, no one wanted to give anything up for Mathis and his current contract. Also, seems pretty clear “the source” is Rosenhaus…

  5. Everybody in that locker room is on board with that’s going on. That’s what Chip has done.

  6. The man was unhappy playing for his 12 million over the next 2 years. If he remained unhappy what kind of effort were you going to get. Many people that are not happy with their pay find it difficult to perform at a high level. Better to let them go and play the happy guy. Maybe Mathis will be happier playing for 7 mil over the next 2 years. At least Rosenhaus gets a cut of that money and there is where the problem occurs.

  7. I’d guess 6-10 if they’re lucky. He inherited a solid roster that I could’ve coached to 10 wins. That being said, he’s getting rid or not resigning others who were huge parts of his 10 win teams. Just because some of them aren’t “his kinda guys” (lol), he gets rid of them, even though the roster isn’t strong enough to play at the same level with the secondary replacements who are now going to have to contribute. This guy is a complete idiot.

  8. AS an Eagles fan for over 60 years I have seen a lot. While I understand and even agree with most of Chips actions his year, the Mathis one hit me in the gut yesterday as he was one of my favorites…

    However, the following made me realize that sometimes I fall in love with a player and just hate to see him go… Maybe this was the best move after all for the Eagles given this analysis:

    Mathis played in nine games: the season opener, when Nick Foles was the starting quarterback, and the eight games that Mark Sanchez started. Over the seven games that Mathis missed, the Eagles averaged 122 rushing yards a game. Over the nine games he played, they averaged 127. The difference was negligible.

    It wasn’t when it came to protecting Foles or Sanchez. Foles threw 311 passes last season, Sanchez 309. But Foles, who started seven games without Mathis, was sacked on just 2.8 percent of his pass attempts. Sanchez, who didn’t start a game without Mathis, was sacked 6.9 percent of the time. That’s 21/2 times more frequently than Foles.

    “You can say that disparity was based largely on Sanchez’s tendency to hold the ball, or Foles’ to get rid of it. What you can’t say is that Mathis made the Eagles’ pass protection, or their run-blocking, significantly better last season. Chip Kelly definitely wouldn’t, and as everyone learned again Thursday, his is the only opinion that counts.”

    Quote from column by: Mike Sielski, Inquirer Columnist in Philadelphia

  9. As a close friend of the organization, my PR peers are disappointed at the constant slandering of Chip’s management style, however, they are not surprised as any knowledgeable person who follows the NFL understands that anything not adapted to the social norm/out of the box will always be met with reluctance until success.

  10. eagles r my second fav team – I’m getting worried that this kelly guy is nuts

    oh well, maybe my fav team will pick up mathis we could use him

  11. sharrerwwonka22 says:
    Jun 12, 2015 10:37 AM
    I’d guess 6-10 if they’re lucky. He inherited a solid roster that I could’ve coached to 10 wins.

    Then you should be coaching in the NFL, because Andy Reid got 4 wins out of that “solid roster.”

  12. Kelly may be smart but he’s also a tyrant. He wants a team of robots who just say yes sir to everything he says.

    He may have gotten rid of a few jerks, but he also seems to have gotten rid of a few guys who just tried to give input.

    Kelly believes his system is perfect. He does not seem to think he needs top talents except at RB.

    I think Kelly only has 1 win vs a team with a winning record. Just like at Oregon, his system is great for beating bad teams, but when matched against even talent, he loses.

  13. No need to bash Mathis, he was a good player for us and a good guy. It came down to bad decision making on the part of him & his agent Drew Rosenhaus. Shoulda took the offer when it was proposed. Now he’s a yr and a half older and wants the same deal? Good luck finding a team willing to pay 5M this yr & 6M next year for a 33-34 yr old lineman.

    Chip coulda handled it differently, yes…but the fact remains, Mathis signed a new deal in ’12, Chip got here in’13. Complaining for a new contract to the new coach makes you look like a headache to the new regime, and you’ve only had 1 yr of top level play.

    I wish him luck. Wish Bradford or whomever is our starting QB even more luck…they’re gonna need it.

  14. …it’s another hole that needs to be filled by a younger guy…..I can only speak for myself, but I can’t WAIT to see how all these moves pan out. Logic says we take a step down but dang, Chip gets players to play up to thier potential. I say the Eagles get into the playoffs…………………..” In Chip we TRUST”

  15. corporatemediaprostitute says:
    Jun 12, 2015 10:34 AM
    Crapshoot sounds like a great way to describe Kelly’s personnel management style. Eagles are in for a total rebuild.

    Uhhh I think that’s pretty much what Chip’s been doing the past 2 years. Pay attention!!

  16. Like McCoy and Jackson before him, Mathis will end up earning more money from a new team than was left on the table in Philly. Be happy, Evan. You’re out of that train wreck being driven by a high school coach.

  17. As an Eagles Fan, I’m thinking there are two likely outcomes. Either Chip knows exactly what he’s doing, he’s gotten rid of all the people who didn’t buy in and they’ll have another 10+ win season. Or the whole ship will go up in flames, Chip gets fired, and the rebuild will start in earnest with a new coach. Realistically, the results are more contingent on the health of Sam Bradford (ugh) than any of these offseason moves, but that’s not the way people will see it.

    Until then…In Chip We Trust : )

  18. So glad we didn’t trade the Mariota pick for the Eagles roster.

    – Titans Fan

  19. It’s Chip’s way or the highway……..might work in college with scholarships and he can run his program like that…………but keep this up in the NFL and you will have yourself an empty roster and nobody will ever want to play there.

  20. Chip didn’t make Mathis. Howard Mudd made Mathis; under Andy Reid.

    Regardless, this is a good move. Mathis was disgruntled.

    Now he’s free to get the money he thinks he deserves. It’ll be interesting to see the value of his next contract.

  21. Maybe the Eagles, and 31 other teams, decided a 34 year old guard owed $6 mill a year – wasn’t worth it?

    With the salary cap, teams need to make decisions. $6 mill a year on a guard, is $6 mill a year less for the QB, LT, pash rushers, corners, WR, etc. If you replace Mathis with a guy making $2 mill a year, how much of a drop-off is there?

    Ross Tucker wrote a great article for SI years ago when Faneca and Hutchinson were getting $7 mill a year. Tucker made the point that the difference over a mid-level player at the same position, was about 1-2 plays a game, for about $5 mill a year more.

  22. No time for malcontents. This is a business. Here’s our offer. Don’t like/want it? Go look for a willing partner. Didn’t find one? You have a few days to get here and play out your contract since you didn’t take Roseman’s restructure….You know what, nevermind. Thanks for your years of service and good luck on the open market because we’re saving 11.5 mil now. …That’s not impatience, that’s a football and business mind that thinks fast and knows where he wants to go and how he wants to get there. “Buy in” or “Bye Bye”

  23. Nobody was going to trade for a journeyman guard that’s being overpaid, and wants a raise. You throw in the fact he’s going to be 34, and everything points to a release. Especially after his teammates didn’t support him.

  24. Chip is going scorched earth here. Will be interesting to see if it works out or blows up in his face spectacularly.

  25. I think Kelly only has 1 win vs a team with a winning record. Just like at Oregon, his system is great for beating bad teams, but when matched against even talent, he loses.
    ————-

    Patently false. They beat the Colts, Cowboys, Cardinals and Packers over the last 2 years.

  26. I don’t get the hate for Chip. Yea, he’s made some bold moves but the eagles were a disaster at the end of Reid’s tenure and Chip turned them around. Even made buttfumble Sanchez look halfway decent this year. So he’s cut some big name guys and doesn’t take any flak from over valued players and cuts them. Kind of reminds me of the guy coaching my team and he’s done pretty well for himself.

    Give the guy a chance Philly fans

  27. Overall the issue I have with Chip is not simply cutting Mathis….or simply cutting DeSean Jackson for that matter. The issue I have is that I am not so sure his long range plan is all that well thought out.

    Lets start with Mathis. They cut Herremans outright before the draft and did not draft any Offensive Linemen for the past two years. In hindsight, wouldn’t it have been the smarter move to keep Herremans as an insurance policy or at least spend a draftpic or two over the past two years to restock the OLine? Instead we are down two starting guards. Poor overall strategy if you ask me.

    Same goes with the DeSean Jackson move. Wouldn’t it have made better sense to keep him around for just ONE more year? Maybe you would have gotten something for him. Maybe it would have meant Maclin was easier to resign because his numbers wouldn’t have been so inflated this year. Instead, the Birds got zilch for two pro bowl wide receivers in their prime. Again, poor overall strategy.

  28. I can’t knock or fault what Chip has done recently. Not long ago the Patriots were tested this way by Logan Mankins and look how that turned out(albeit a different position, but same business). Chip knows he has to drop the hammer and has the guts to do it; as a fan I like that no matter who the team is. Actions like this speak volumes in more ways than one in a positive direction, in this salary cap era. When the hammer falls, whoever got it knows they got it from Chip and why. Whoever enters the system willingly accepts and embraces, eventually all on the same page to win. If you get stupid within a year and challenge as a player what Chip is doing(his goal is to win a Super Bowl, mind you), you get the backswing from that hammer. I like it. Take your agent with you.I

  29. Eagles suck. No explanation of how is needed or worth typing. An embarrassment to the division that only serve to make Washington fans think “it could be worse we could be Philly fans.”

  30. Y’all amuse me with the Chip is a mad man nonsense. I don’t know if Chips moves will work out or not, but in the first 18 months that Pete Carroll and John Schneider were in Seattle they made over 250 roster moves. It can work.

    You can’t walk in to someone elses roster built with players acquired for one system and expect success running a separate system.

    The fact that Chip has had double digit wins both his first two seasons, with a roster not built for his system, and questions at qb, should tell you what you need to know.

  31. It’s all well and good to make some sort of “statement” and cut a guy who doesn’t fit in to your “plan”… except when you don’t really have solid alternatives for replacing that guy. The Eagles O-line had question marks with Mathis, now they just have more. At a certain point, trying to create a locker room of only “your” guys who buy into “your” system risks not putting the best or most talented football team on the field. Cohesion is important, but so is talent.

  32. one player was not at ota and that player with the blessings of his teamates was cut,id say chip kellys philosphy of team building culture is working well in philly,that along with the fact that mathis was a soon to be 34yr old,coming off injury,over paid made this move to easy to call

  33. Chip Kelly’s master plan for world domination disappeared in a puff of “We aint fallin’ for it” from the rest of the league.

  34. No team wants him at that contract, especially when he was clearly not even happy making more than his worth. Now that that excessive contract is out of the picture, a team will sign him for probably $3m a year.

  35. On field, Kelly may be an innovator. Off the field, he’s proven to be in over his head.

  36. wiitrainingcamp says:
    Jun 12, 2015 10:45 AM
    sharrerwwonka22 says:
    Jun 12, 2015 10:37 AM
    I’d guess 6-10 if they’re lucky. He inherited a solid roster that I could’ve coached to 10 wins.

    Then you should be coaching in the NFL, because Andy Reid got 4 wins out of that “solid roster.”
    ——————————————————
    Oh please. By his track record, Andy would have had this team in the playoffs, just like Chip. He had a nightmare year in 2012, with injuries and his imminent firing. Further, Reid’s final draft (2012) was a big chunk of the talent that has played for the past few years. So, you can’t even compare. Chip has yet to show himself to be as good as Reid.

  37. Eagle fans keep talking. There is just no way you are a better team without:
    D Jackson
    J Macklin
    S Mc Coy
    N Foles

    It’s not going to happen. As for all the talk about “Chip’s System”, GREAT coaches coach the talent they have & switch up their system to accommodate the talent base they have & WIN with it. The team Chip inherited has been to an NFC championship game just a couple of seasons before with much of the same talent & a lot less injuries. The difference was a qb & injuries. Andy’s real failure was he believed he could make Vick a qb. Another season for him to develop Foles & that team would be in a better place with Andy winning playoff games again. Before the Kelly era is over, the Reid era will be sorely missed.

  38. If he gets more than $2.5MM/yr as a free agent I’ll be surprised. Mathis really screwed himself out of the kind of money most people won’t make in a lifetime by being a baby.

  39. Chip Kelly just spent $21 million in guarantees to bring Murray to Philadelphia because Kelly wants a runner who will just hit the hole. Murray does that—certainly more than LeSean McCoy, anyway. But Murray doesn’t do it with nearly the regularity a man of his build and skill set should. Murray’s strength is his ability to get square downhill, even off contact. His weakness is in his hips, which are a little stiff, and his feet, which are sometimes too heavy to maintain balance when changing direction. But based on some of the decisions Murray made last season, you wonder if he even knows these things about himself.

  40. bleedgreen says:
    Jun 12, 2015 11:34 AM
    I think Kelly only has 1 win vs a team with a winning record. Just like at Oregon, his system is great for beating bad teams, but when matched against even talent, he loses.
    ————-

    Patently false. They beat the Colts, Cowboys, Cardinals and Packers over the last 2 years.
    ________________________________
    Beyond embarrassing you are going back and addressing wins over a 2 year period.

    How many playoff wins?

    Who cares if he came into a team that won 4 games, every single unbiased fan saw the talent they had. If they had Belicheck they would have made a playoff run even with a subpar defense.

    You put up with a bad coach and organizational decisions and have 0 superbowls

    Whats the definition of insanity again?

  41. Eagle fans keep talking. There is just no way you are a better team without:
    D Jackson
    J Macklin
    S Mc Coy
    N Foles

    You mean that same bunch that went 3-13 with Andy Reid?

  42. The Bucs do not get first crack at him as he wont hit waivers. His vet status excludes him.

  43. officialgame says:
    Jun 12, 2015 1:53 PM
    Eagle fans keep talking. There is just no way you are a better team without:
    D Jackson
    J Macklin
    S Mc Coy
    N Foles

    You mean that same bunch that went 3-13 with Andy Reid?
    —————————-
    Huh? No on both counts.

  44. Lol Andy took a 2 win team and made them an 11 win team in just 1 year. He has the same record as Chip in the first 2 seasons. Eagle fans are hilarious.

  45. haleyistheman00 says:
    Jun 12, 2015 2:28 PM
    Lol Andy took a 2 win team and made them an 11 win team in just 1 year. He has the same record as Chip in the first 2 seasons. Eagle fans are hilarious.
    ———————–

    And won playoff games

  46. Patently false. They beat the Colts, Cowboys, Cardinals and Packers over the last 2 years.

    ———————————————-

    Packers was with Tolzein at QB, not Rodgers.

    Cowboys was on Thanksgiving, short week and Romo had an injury. Dallas beat them down a few weeks later.

    Arizona was without their leading rusher, and they weren’t very good anyway.

    Colts is like his only win vs an actual good team that was healthy.

    Point remains. Kelly has not done well vs good teams.

  47. CHIP inherited a 10 win roster. And decided 10 was as good as it gets. To win a SB , you need to win > 10. I still think he is all hat and no cattle. Choked on the big game.

  48. Eagle fans keep talking. There is just no way you are a better team without:
    D Jackson
    J Macklin
    S Mc Coy
    N Foles

    You mean that same bunch that went 3-13 with Andy Reid?
    ——————————————————————-

    What is
    Bradfords career record in starts?
    How many games has Demarco Murray averaged before last season.
    How many career wins did Sanchez have his LAST 2 years in NY?

    You all would have had a better chance if you had a coach that could have gotten the best out of:
    D Jackson
    J Macklin
    S Mc Coy
    N Foles

    As Andy would have done the next year with less injuries. Andy won playoff games, has Chip?

  49. Florio just doesn’t get it. A 34 year old Guard, coming off a season in which he missed 7 games due to injury simply won’t have an 11.5M/2 year market.

  50. At 33, he wouldn’t have garnered much. Logan Mankins (a very good guard) at age 32 barely garnered a backup TE and a 6th rounder. Optimistically, we’ll call that a 5th rounder.

  51. There are without doubt various opinions about this, and the fact is it’s too soon to know who’s right or wrong until it plays out. What most interesting to me that I haven’t read yet, is all the early chatter about Chip being a racist. How many ex players ran their mouths he wanted to get rid of all the black players. Seems a pretty darn good white player just got removed. So hopefully this at least puts an end to that non-sense.

  52. What I see is that Kelly finds it unacceptable for professional football players with negative energy on his team. Jackson: negative energy. McCoy being upset about Jackson being traded: negative energy. Etc. Complain about your contract in the media: negative energy.

    Hell, Kelly is 100% Eagles football. Why surround yourself with complainers? The question I have is why do so many teams put up with this crap from replaceable players? Players need to shut their pie holes and do their job. If they want to bitch and grumble to the media, goodbye.

  53. GerryBertier says:
    Jun 12, 2015 10:34 AM
    Everybody in that locker room is on board with that’s going on. That’s what Chip has done.

    THEY BETTER BE, OR AT LEAST SAY THEY ARE!

  54. You can find a good guard on the top of Sanchez’s head. Or as the wise Cordarelle Patterson once said, “It’s that easy.” Thank goodness for hockey.

  55. Sorry myopic Eggles fans and those that write for Peter King’s SI “football” site: The end is nigh.

    This entire story is nuts. Most “fans” wanted Reid out because he was “too controlling.”

    You have one more year to be relative in the NFL. Better go for the big one.

  56. hmmm.. but Chip said they had NO offers for him in two years? lying thru his teeth to save face. giving this guy full control was the biggest mistake the Eagles ever made.

  57. Hope the Rams at least make Mathis a reasonable offer . He’d be a good vet to bring in to try & teach all those young rookie linemen that they just drafted! If not a starter, then a good back-up & a good locker room guy who could have a veteran presense .

  58. You’d think with all the dysfunction in Claraville, they would have snapped him up immediately.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.