NFL suspends side judge over clock mistake

AP

The official who failed to correct a clock mistake late in Monday night’s Steelers-Chargers game has been disciplined by the league.

Side judge Rob Vernatchi has been suspended for one week with pay, a source with knowledge of the situation tells PFT.

The NFL has not yet responded to PFT’s request for comment, and the NFL Referees Association could not be reached. Vernatchi is expected to file a grievance.

The NFL released a statement on Tuesday, acknowledging a clock error had taken place on Monday.

“Because of an error by the clock operator, the game clock was incorrectly started before the Steelers’ first play from scrimmage following the touchback. That first down snap came with 2:38 left to play instead of 2:56, a difference of 18 seconds,” the league’s statement said. “The official game time is kept on the stadium scoreboard, but it is the responsibility of the side judge to supervise the timing of the game. Had the side judge or any of the other six on-field officials noticed the timing error, they could have corrected it.”

This week was the second consecutive Monday night in which an official made a significant mistake late in a close game. The week before, an illegal bat penalty that should have been called on the Seahawks was overlooked, potentially costing the Lions the game.

107 responses to “NFL suspends side judge over clock mistake

  1. Where is the $5 million investigation? Surely the opposing QB was generally aware that the clock was running. Integrity of the game!

  2. Was the official who did not throw a flag on the illegally batted ball suspended too? I don’t think he was.

    And I don’t want the NFL to say the illegal bat was a judgement call because it was very clear to everyone except the official the ball was intentionally batted out of the end zone.

  3. Suspended? And what about the guy that didn’t call the batted ball in the Hawks Lions game?

    No integrity in this league whatsoever.

    WWE has better rules enforcement. And is less scripted.

  4. The person who should be suspended is the Chargers DC. That dude’s defense gives up too many huge plays EVERY week. Been like that for far too long.

  5. He might get to do the super bowl if he keeps this up.

    5 1

    ======================
    Seriously, that was an awesome comment. There is always an element in truth in good humor.

    Who in their right mind could possible down vote it?

  6. This was the supervisor, what about the actual clock operator?

    Can’t stay alert for 3 hours with a 15 minute break?

    Start and Stop buttons are one too many and too complicated?

    Clock Operators Union more powerful than the officials union?

  7. At what they get paid he’s probably taking his family to Hawaii for a few days and laughing about how stupid the league office is all the way there and back.

  8. Roger Goodell is excellent at his job. Making sure the owners make a ton of cash. Someone else should be in charge of the actual game of football. Someone who cares about football. The job is too big for one person. There is very little common sense being used. I’m not saying everything is easy. But there are a lot of smart people in this country. Right?

  9. “A week suspension with pay? How is that punishment?”
    ————————

    That, my fellow fans, is the result of a union contract. Only a union member would consider a day off with pay a punishment.

  10. Geeze – when Walt Anderson failed to write down the PSI of the footballs in the AFC Championship they didn’t suspend him – they suspended Brady

  11. Sammy Sosa thought that was an illegal bat – how this guy gets a week paid off but that ref has nothing happen is beyond me…

  12. “Vernatchi is expected to file a grievance.”

    Only in the NFL front office could a week off with pay be considered a disciplinary action. And only an NFL official would appeal A PAID VACATION.

    You can’t make this stuff up

  13. Seems like a minor error compared to the others we’ve seen that did not draw a suspension. Maybe there’s something more to it, maybe not. But if there is something, and that something is gambling related, lord help that puppet Goodell and all his lackeys.

  14. If this particular official files an appeal about getting one week off with pay………he should be fired!!!

  15. If the NFL VP of Game Operations, kensil, wasn’t so busy looking for a bathroom scale to weigh the footballs, maybe NFL personnel would do their jobs competently.

    Fire Goodell and all the ex Jets trash with him. Clean house of that scum and bring integrity back to the NFL.

  16. What about the guy that watched the Seahawk player bat the ball out of bounds and didnt call it? He should have been suspended too.

  17. Terrible and incompetent officials blew 2 fumble calls in the Ram favor in the Cards loss. Ignorant and uninformed officials blew the batting ball call that gave a freebie and undeserved win to the Seahawks and robbed the Lions of a win they earned and deserved to win.

    Did the NFL fire or suspend these incompetent officials to preserve the Integrity of the Game? If not, why not? Its time the owners fire Goodell and his corruption of the game.

  18. The reason he’s filing a grievance is because he demands equal punishment with Brady. Four weeks suspension, minimum – but with pay, of course

  19. If I were the suspended official, I’d file a grievance to… it should be a minimum of one month paid suspension with airfare/hotel/rental car paid for hms and his families trip to Hawaii. And dont get me started on the pain & suffering.

  20. On top of the week off with pay, he has to spend the week in Bora Bora with all expenses paid. Harshest penalty the NFL has dished out by far IMO.

  21. Social media wants people fired for mistakes. They always the highest punishment, usually FIRE ‘EM! Whether it is a referee who made the wrong call or no call, teacher with a misled lesson plan or whatever. No says “Learn form your mistakes” anymore on social media.

    He made a mistake – he is suspended. Move on. Don;t go back in time to bring up all the other instances of blown calls. The NFL did the right thing here and people are still upset?

  22. Wow. 45 comments. 45 jerks.
    The mistake didn’t alter the game you know. And yes, this will cost him money. They get graded out every week. And those grades determine who works the playoffs.

    But hey, as long as you all get your blood and pound of flesh, that’s cool. The only conclusion I can come up with is, all of you are miserable in your own lives.

  23. The bat penalty is one thing. Most didn’t know that it was a rule vs those who did, and are soon going to forget. It’s the result of there being too many rules to keep track of however this is inexcusable.

  24. This should be an ongoing thing.. Worst referee each week gets punished with a week long paid vacation. There’d be some serious competition.

  25. suspended for one week with pay

    Dean Blandino needs to go along with Goodell. What a crock. And to all of you bashing the Seahawks, we know it was a missed call. We got a break. Get over it. As you can see it happens all the time. Eventually every team gets a break. The Referee For Life system has got to go.

  26. This is a significant error BUT it didn’t affect the outcome of the game. I understand that calls are missed all the time but the non-call on the bat was potentially a game altering play. When refs miss blatant calls, that impact the outcome of the game, they should be suspended.

  27. Vernatchi is only suspended because the error was not responsible for the result of the game. If the Steelers had run out of time, the league would have found some screwy way to stand by the official while claiming that he did not make a mistake. Meanwhile, I’m trying to figure out a way to get suspended with pay from my job too.

  28. “Where is the $5 million investigation? Surely the opposing QB was generally aware that the clock was running. Integrity of the game!”

    Clever and original…

  29. I have no problem with the referee being suspended for making a mistake provided we also suspend linemen for missing a block, receivers for dropping a pass, quarterbacks missing wide open receivers, offensive coordinators calling a poor play, and all blown coverages in defense.

    And of course, if you, the people making posts, have ever made a mistake at your job, you ABSOLUTELY must go, too!

  30. NFL is a joke. One week off with pay is called a vacation.

    Fire Goodell and take the extra 44 million per year salary and hire full time Refs and redo the replay system like colleges do.

    With all the money you have left over you could end poverty in the word.

    Again, fire Goodell.

    OMG

  31. Times like these I like to sit back and just…. Imagine the uproar… The pressers and the hot takes… The think pieces and weeping analysts…
    If this or anything like it happened at Gillette stadium.

  32. The NFL should suspend, or better yet FIRE, Goodell over the “Deflategate” mistake.

  33. Could we step it up and do some investigative journalism here instead of parroting news stories? Find out who the clock operator was. Was he trained by the NFL? Was he fired after this game? Did money exchange hands? Is Vegas involved? Who really cares that the side judge gets a week’s vacation. How about asking some real questions and finding out the real answers.

  34. Love the NFL/WWE comparisons. I guess the NFL is holding officials responsible starting now? That’s good but I still think someone should deliver tombstone piledriver to Goodell’s career as commissioner

  35. If the NFL truly wanted to improve their product they would forget about 18 game seasons and London and focus on hiring qualified professionals to officiate games and make sure every game is covered by state of the art cameras and angles. I don’t get the impression they care about these weekly game altering mistakes and games bogged down with 20+ subjective penalties.

  36. That’s like telling a kid he is suspended from school, doesnt have to do any home work, automatically gets A’s while he is out and his parents take him to hawaii to “teach him a lesson”.

  37. redeemerac says:
    Oct 14, 2015 7:36 PM
    Investigation for everybody else….except for Roger Goodell…he gets a pass.
    ————————

    Right. Because Roger Goodell has something to do with the clock operation at a random October game in San Diego. The main reason that legitimate issues will never get addressed is because certain casual fans and media voices override any reasonable discussion about addressable issues with tired narratives and misplaced agendas, thereby giving the opponents of change all the ammunition they need to paint the entire group of people proposing change as uneducated crackpots. But yes, by all means, let’s suspend the commissioner of the NFL for a clock snafu that was primarily the fault of a pay-by-the-day scoreboard operator and a random side judge. Also, while you’re at it, I noticed that the grass was a little brown in some spots too. Why hasn’t goodell been forced to answer for this yet? What is he hiding?!?

  38. “That first down snap came with 2:38 left to play instead of 2:56, a difference of 18 seconds,” the league’s statement said.

    Isn’t that 16 seconds???

  39. Partbkelly said it best and conormacleod you’re correct too! He is getting suspended, ( thank God) but he does have Union and that Union has a CBA with the NFL… Most anti-union dopes are PRIVATE sector workers that CHOSE the bigger CASH $$$ grab/position/jobs over the MUCH much lower paying Union-Civil-Service/position/jobs and the Pension and Security “UNION” that it comes with- your bad! An you all were prob The first ones screaming to have the SCABS fired and the “NFL Officials” to come up with a new “Labour Agreement” with the NFL? Can’t have it both ways!! Stop hating on Unions- it was your choice to be in one? or not…!

  40. The NFL needs to stop fixing Packer games while their at it.
    3 players EJECTED in the last 9 games ( 1 in 3) in Lambeau. 1 ejection in 48 games played around the rest of the league.

  41. The NFL has yet to be confronted on the bleeding of the clock on what was (should not have been) the game’s last play. SD was deprived of a kickoff (granted the conspiracy theory would be that the final two seconds were erroneously ticked down so that the visitors could not use their final time out to kick a game tying field goal). In any regard, the whistle blew and the ref’s arms were raised with two seconds on that clock, and not dealing with that during the review of the score has been swept under a carpet that was already plenty lumpy.

  42. So, the ref that cost the poor hapless Lions a game gets re-assigned and this ref gets suspended! Looks like the League is making some “subjective”, bad judgement calls!

  43. These are the occupants of the same clown car that sold eager haters on the notion that someone might have let air out of a football. How many who bought that hook line and sinker have now abandoned these fools?

  44. An error was made. I assume the penalty for the error is covered in whatever CBA the NFL and the officials have agreed to. And I assume that was the penalty that was imposed.
    May not appear fair to those of us reading about it that don’t enjoy a CBA. But I much prefer that a penalty that’s been agreed upon be charged rather than Goodell again trying to apply his own brand of justice.
    Hopefully, as it becomes clear that the officiating needs to be improved and that it is something that affects every team, this is an issue that the owners will get behind.
    Fire Goodell, put in a commissioner that is capable of managing all aspects of the business and lets get the integrity back.

  45. rootpain says:
    Oct 15, 2015 9:23 AM
    An error was made. I assume the penalty for the error is covered in whatever CBA the NFL and the officials have agreed to. And I assume that was the penalty that was imposed.
    May not appear fair to those of us reading about it that don’t enjoy a CBA. But I much prefer that a penalty that’s been agreed upon be charged rather than Goodell again trying to apply his own brand of justice.
    Hopefully, as it becomes clear that the officiating needs to be improved and that it is something that affects every team, this is an issue that the owners will get behind.
    Fire Goodell, put in a commissioner that is capable of managing all aspects of the business and lets get the integrity back.

    With all due respect, and to be completely honest, when exactly were the halcyon days of “integrity”? If the twitterverse and unlimited access to replay videos had existed in the 50’s, 60’s, 70’s, 80’s or 90’s we’d be having these same arguments. One need look no further that Ben Dreith’s Phantom Roughing call on Ray Hamilton for proof. Either those complaining now aren’t old enough to have seen what I seen or are misremembering.

  46. Just to get this straight, there was a public outcry for punishment, the league acted swiftly and decisively, and that still isn’t good enough? Seems like some of you don’t seem to think that a minor punishment is reasonable for a first offense. It would be like if at your job you improperly filed a travel receipt. You’d get a memo, and possibly a personal improvement notification. They wouldn’t tie you to a tree and execute you.

    I’m sure this move was also difficult to negotiate, seeing as how it now sets a precedent that I’m sure the Official’s Union does not want established.

    I actually think that the NFL releasing a statement that the error was noted, the official’s grading would reflect it, and moving forward additional training would be given to all the responsible parties would have been more than enough. Everything else is just PR pandering to an “outraged” fan base that will be outraged about something else after this weekend’s games.

  47. @Steelerben: what exactly is this officials punishment? So he can’t ref a game but he still receives his compensation? Is that really a penalty/punishment?

  48. @nopepper123: get ready for another one and done in January. The game will mean something and we all know how Andy Dandy performs in those types of games.

  49. The other officials are now quaking in their boots. They know if they screw up they’ll get vacation too!

  50. jsabatine29 says:
    Oct 15, 2015 10:47 AM
    @Steelerben: what exactly is this officials punishment? So he can’t ref a game but he still receives his compensation? Is that really a penalty/punishment?

    ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

    It is, because a suspension is on his record. This will effect his future assignments and it will be more difficult for him to be assigned to high profile games which will slow the progress of his career. It is the equivalent of a verbal warning, only with a bit more pizzazz to try and satisfy the bloodthirsty fans and media, which apparently failed.

    What sort of punishment would you suggest for a first offense that was not noticed by any of the other six officials, either coaching staff, the entire broadcast team, and a vast majority of people watching at home and that ultimately had no effect on the outcome of the game?

  51. The league has done nothing to address the poor officiating that seems to get worse each and every year. Game sare no longer won by the players….poor officiating has been dictating the outcome of games and it needs to stop.

  52. Suspended “with pay”? Seems more like a reward than a punishment.

    Players get fined $5,700.00 for showing tribute to parents that died of cancer and this guy gets a free pass. Prime example of all that’s wrong with the NFL…

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.