NFL morning after: The joy of the fat guy touchdown

Getty Images

Is there anything better in sports than a fat guy scoring a touchdown?

There are so many speedy receivers, powerful running backs and skillful quarterbacks who get most of the attention in the NFL, but there’s nothing more exhilarating than seeing one of those 300-plus pound linemen getting into the end zone. Those are the guys who do the dirty work on most plays, and seeing them getting to score is just plain fun.

It’s also a lot of fun to see those fat guys running because we feel like we’re seeing someone run the way we’d run on a football field: Noticeably slower than everyone else out there. (Although, truth be told, even the fattest NFL lineman is a good enough athlete that he could beat the average American in a 40-yard dash.) You don’t see guys with big bellies excelling in other sports the way you do in football, and when a guy with a big belly crosses the goal line, guys across America with big bellies can celebrate with them.

Dontari PoeI was thinking a lot about fat guy touchdowns yesterday because Chiefs defensive tackle Dontari Poe scored one. With Kansas City facing fourth-and-goal from inside the 1-yard line at San Diego, Poe lined up at fullback. Everyone figured the Chiefs had brought him in to serve as a blocker, but he surprised the Chargers by taking the handoff and plunging in for the touchdown.

With that one-yard touchdown, the 346-pound Poe became (according to the records at Pro Football Reference) the heaviest player to run for a touchdown in NFL history.

That record has stood for three decades. It was set by the godfather of the fat guy touchdown, William “The Refrigerator” Perry, who was listed at 335 pounds when he scored three touchdowns for the 1985 Bears. NFL players have gotten bigger through the years, but none of those bigger guys had run for a touchdown until Poe did it yesterday.

samadamsThe heaviest player ever to score a touchdown was the former defensive tackle Sam Adams, a 350-pounder who scored two touchdowns in his NFL career. Adams had a 25-yard interception return for a touchdown in 1998 and a 37-yard interception return for a touchdown in 2003. The 1998 season was a banner year for fat guy touchdowns, as 348-pound Chargers defensive tackle Jamal Williams also had an interception return for a touchdown. Yesterday Poe became the third-heaviest player, after Adams and Williams, to score a touchdown — and the heaviest player ever to score on offense.

Poe may not have that record for long. Baylor senior tight end LaQuan McGowan, who at 410, outweighs Poe by a whopping 64 pounds, has caught three touchdown passes in his college career and may be in the NFL next year. McGowan makes Refrigerator Perry look like nothing more than a hefty fullback.

But for now, Poe is the biggest player ever to score an offensive touchdown. What better time than Thanksgiving week, when Americans will watch football and stuff their faces, to celebrate the joy of the fat guy touchdown?

Here are my other thoughts on this week’s NFL action:

Aaron Donald is a bad, bad man. Donald, the Rams’ star defensive tackle, picked up Ravens running back Justin Forsett and slammed him to the ground, breaking Forsett’s arm. It was a perfectly legal tackle by Donald, but it was also brutal and likely ended Forsett’s season. Donald is, like J.J. Watt, the kind of defensive lineman who can inspire fear in opposing teams.

Tony Romo is back, and Dallas wonders what might have been. The Cowboys beat the Dolphins yesterday in the return of Tony Romo from a broken collarbone in Week Two. Dallas is now 3-0 this year with Romo and 0-7 without him. Over their last 28 games, the Cowboys are 16-3 when Tony Romo starts and 0-9 when he doesn’t. At 3-7, it’s probably not realistic to think the Cowboys can reach the playoffs, but they have to feel like they’d have a good chance of doing some damage if they could get there. With Romo, the Cowboys are one of the best teams in the NFL. Without him, they’re one of the worst.

Maybe Chip Kelly isn’t cut out for this. Kelly was given total control of the Eagles this offseason, and the results speak for themselves: Philadelphia is 4-6 after yesterday’s 45-17 beatdown at the hands of the Buccaneers. The NFC East stinks, which means the Eagles still have a chance to reach the playoffs, but the reality is Kelly’s team isn’t very good. It might be time for Kelly and Eagles owner Jeffrey Lurie to mutually agree that Kelly should go back to coaching in college. Kelly was great at Oregon and could win a national championship at a place like USC, Miami or LSU. It’s not working in the NFL.

Jameis Winston is coming on strong. After struggling early this season as the No. 1 overall pick, Winston is playing some great football for the Buccaneers right now. Yesterday Winston became just the third rookie in NFL history to throw five touchdown passes in a game. (The other two were Matthew Stafford with the 2009 Lions and the little-remembered Ray Buivid with the 1937 Bears.) Winston is a rookie of the year candidate, and the 5-5 Buccaneers are wild card contenders.

Case Keenum or Nick Foles, the Rams’ passing game is horrible. The Rams benched Foles and started Keenum yesterday, but it didn’t make any difference in their 16-13 loss to the Ravens. Consider this: Both the Buccaneers and the Panthers had five different players catch touchdown passes yesterday. The Rams have only had four different players catch touchdown passes all season. The Rams have a young star at running back in Todd Gurley, but they simply must find a franchise quarterback. Neither Keenum nor Foles is the answer.

Andy Reid is a coach of the year candidate. A month ago, it would’ve been easy for the Chiefs to pack up and quit on the season. They were 1-5, and their best player, Jamaal Charles, was lost for the season. But after yesterday’s blowout win over the Chargers, the Chiefs have won four straight games, all by double-digit margins, and at 5-5 they’re right in the thick of the AFC playoff race. Reid deserves an enormous amount of credit for keeping the Chiefs on track. And he also deserves some credit for giving the ball to his enormous defensive tackle yesterday at the goal line.

33 responses to “NFL morning after: The joy of the fat guy touchdown

  1. MDS, this is always my favorite read when I get into work Monday morning and sit down to eat my generic home made raisin bran but dude, Andy Reid is a bum. Just wait… with a playoff game on the line and with the ball at the 20, down by 4 and 2 minutes and 3 timeouts left, he’ll screw it up. Andy Reid is the most overrated coach of all time. Slightly ahead of Bill Cowher.

  2. Fat guy touchdown? I find that offensive!! I want the president of PFT to step down, the president of NBC to resign and I want the president of the United States to personally apologize to every “fat” person in the country. (Doing my best impersonation of society today)

  3. Andy Reid as coach of the year candidate for a 5-5 team!? Reid is mediocre at best and will be fired sooner rather than later.

  4. Hey Chip, you’re a genius ! However as smart as you are you are trying to defy one axiom of sports.
    The team with the most talented players usually wins. You can’t send away players like LeSean McCoy, DeSean Jackson, Evan Mathias and Jeremy Maclin and think that your brain power is going to make up for the talent vacuum.

  5. As a former lineman, I love it when a big man scores. In 2010, B.J. Raji had a pick six in the NFC Championship game. I am pretty sure he had 1 or 2 TDs while lined up in the backfield during the season.

  6. jppsblownofffingers says:
    Nov 23, 2015 6:54 AM
    Fat guy touchdown? I find that offensive!! I want the president of PFT to step down, the president of NBC to resign and I want the president of the United States to personally apologize to every “fat” person in the country. (Doing my best impersonation of society today)


    The irony, someone being offended by all the offended people. That’s my impression of society today.

  7. at 5-5 they’re right in the thick of the AFC playoff race.
    Let me get this straight; You want to give “Coach of the Year” to a guy whose team is a mediocre 5-5, just because they’re not 2-8????

    I’m sorry ….. I thought a coach actually needed to have, you know, a winning season, before he was considered “COTY”.

    Silly me.

  8. Appropriate Movie Quote ……….

    “I love to see a fat guy score.


    Because first you get a fat guy spike, then you get the fat guy dance. ”

    Name that Movie !!

  9. “Touchdowns by players afflicted with obesity.”

    There…. that makes it sound like it’s not the player’s fault that they’re fat.

  10. What, no mention of Vince Wilfork?
    Vince had his INT’s but he didn’t score on them. This was about big men scoring TD’s.

  11. Too early on Chip. Offensive line has been a disaster this year. That’s not a scheme issue, that’s just personnel.

    2 10-6 seasons and now 1 bad one and you’re saying this “obviously” doesn’t work? That’s a bit overreaching. If they were swinging and missing in all their draft picks I’d be more concerned.

    It’s not like they’d be winning more games if McCoy or MeShawn were on the field. I’m a Packers fan but I think the jury’s still out.

  12. “You don’t see guys with big bellies excelling in other sports the way you do in football”

    John Kruk
    Cecil Fielder
    Mo Vaughn
    Bartolo Colon
    David Wells

  13. After all of these years, people are finally starting to realize Romo is the only reason the Cowboys haven’t been one of the worst teams in the league over the last ten years.

  14. So everybody’s ready to throw in the towel on Chip Kelly now, eh? I find that amusing. It wasn’t so long ago that seemingly everyone in the national media was lining up to crawl under this guy’s desk….

  15. It’s hard to believe that Chip Kelly won’t be coaching in college somewhere next year. The Eagles have been a colossal disappointment this year, and Kelly’s reputation is, at least in college, that he’s a brilliant coach.

    There are going to be too many open positions at the collegiate level for him to turn down the offers he’s going to get. My guess is he ends up at one of the two USCs.

  16. The Cardinals are in first place and lead the second place Seattle Seahawks by three games, after mercilessly defeating the Seahawks in Week 10 in Seattle. Seattle blames the refs for every single one of their losses, which is very telling about their high level of immaturity.

  17. If you want to celebrate fat guy TDs, the most proficient fat guy scorer in NFL history is Mike Tolbert. No, he’s not the fattest, but he is quite fat, and he scores pretty regularly.

    And Coach of the Year? Ron Rivera, by a mile. Everyone in the media thought this team would have a losing record with Kelvin Benjamin out, and now the Panthers are 10-0 and rolling toward the #1 seed in the NFC.

  18. @wheresmyjuice:

    I agree with you that a lot of it is personnel. So fire the personnel man. Oh, wait …

  19. @romophobic :
    Just out of curiosity, how exactly is Bill Cowher ‘overrated’? I think 90% of all owners and fans would like to find a head coach that can generate hist kind of productivity over 15 years.

    “In Cowher’s 15 seasons, the Steelers captured eight division titles, earned 10 postseason playoff berths, played in 21 playoff games, advanced to six AFC Championship games and made two Super Bowl appearances. He is one of only six coaches in NFL history to claim at least seven division titles. At the conclusion of the 2005 season, the Steelers had the best record of any team in the NFL since Cowher was hired as head coach.”

  20. Wasn’t quite a touchdown sadly, but the legendary Dan Connolly kickoff return completely changed what until then had been looking like an easy Packers win over the Patriots. And also made Chris Collinsworth giggle uncontrollably like a 2nd grader.

  21. Im so glad the Lions passed on Donald for Eric Ebron, especially when they knew they y would probably lost Suh at the end of that season…sarcasm implied

    That esponsible have been fired…

  22. factschecker says:
    Nov 23, 2015 8:57 AM
    What, no mention of Vince Wilfork?
    Vince had his INT’s but he didn’t score on them. This was about big men scoring TD’s.
    Er, Vince did score a TD v Skins in 2011 after they fumbled.

  23. I bet there are a lot more people rightfully offended with idiots calling people fat than there are Native Americans offended by the Redskins team name.

  24. Calling a large guy “fat”, when he can embarrass you athletically in any sport you chose, is probably not a good way to go. Just saying.

  25. Poe isn’t as fat as he is just BIG. Wilfork is fat. Raji is fat, Poe is big. Watch him in his tights running his sub 5 second 40 yard dash, and tell me how fat he is. 346 lbs and is as fast as a LB. That’s not a fat man.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.