Report: Rams won’t be penalized for Keenum concussion debacle

AP

Last Sunday’s early games included a troubling moment in which Rams quarterback Case Keenum obviously had sustained a head injury but somehow wasn’t taken off the field. The NFL has now determined that nothing will be taken from the Rams.

Adam Schefter of ESPN reports that the Rams won’t be penalized for mishandling the concussion protocol.

There’s no explanation provided regarding why the Rams won’t be punished. A trainer went onto the field to check Keenum, but the trainer didn’t remove Keenum for an official concussion evaluation.

Ultimately, the NFL may have decided that, with the ATC spotter now having the absolute ability to stop the game, the bulk of the blame should rest with the person whose primary job is to look for potential head injuries and to ensure that those players are out of the game.

The fact that the league thereafter convened a conference call with all head athletic trainers suggests that the NFL will be expecting more from the teams going forward. The lack of punishment for the Rams implies that the previous procedures weren’t sufficiently clear to justify punishing the Rams in this case.

So, basically, the situation that unfolded on Sunday in Baltimore perhaps was less about the team not following the rules and more about the NFL still not having sufficiently clear rules in place.

44 responses to “Report: Rams won’t be penalized for Keenum concussion debacle

  1. Why would they? It’s supposed to be up to the independent neurologist to buzz the training staff to stop the game and get the injured player off the field. From what I’ve read, they didn’t buzz down, and the trainer went on his own and asked if he was good. The NFL can’t get refs to make correct calls, they can’t get neurologists to pay attention for games (I wish I could get paid to sit in a press box of a NFL stadium and press a button and have someone ELSE check on a NFL player to see if his bell is rung).

  2. How about the NFL punishing itself? After all, who provides the ATC spotter? Someone within the NFL office needs to be held accountable. Oh wait, that’d be the first time ever.

  3. I’m shocked that “Mr Integrity” decided not to punish golden boy Jeff Fisher , who will undoubtedly be welcomed to continue to manipulate league rules to his advantage on the competition comittee.

    After all, draconian punishments in Goodell’s NFL are saved for the Patriots and whatever other unfortunate franchise becomes unpopular with his group of jealous owners (Irsay, Jones, and company).

    #noleadership

  4. But player safety is really important, just not as important as writing a message on your eye black, wearing unapproved shoes or being generally aware of an equipment violation which science proves never actually happened. Got it.

  5. No, it’s more about the NFL screwing up just as much as the Rams. And they don’t want to admit that.

  6. Jeff Fisher & the goon crew are an embarrassment to the sport. Get the boogers out of your mustache Jeff

  7. I’ll tell you why the Rams won’t be punished.

    Fisher holds a seat on the NFL’s competition committee (or whatever it’s called) and serves as its mouthpiece for when the NFL makes their stupid rule changes that are designed to keep the lawyers happy more than anything else.

    Fisher’s a company man, and that has its privileges.

  8. More than half way through the season and the NFL still has no clear concussion rules in place. But remember this is a top priority per the lying commish. Integrity!

  9. Of course they won’t
    Fisher is Godell’s darling
    Putting that miscreant on the competition committee, no way he gets a fine

    #integrityoftheganeBS

  10. Jeff Fisher needs to be OFF the competition committee. His team is dirty, even to its OWN players. What they did to Keenum was borderline criminal and the league lets them off scot-free. Nice. I guess only certain teams get punished by the league.

  11. The ATC spotter was led to believe that the Rams were taking care of the situation when he saw the trainer going out on the field, which is why he did nothing. If anything, the trainer should be held accountable for letting Keenum continue after examining him. After that, any implied understandings in the behavior of team officials and/or players themselves falls on the Head Coach, who establishes that standard.

  12. So if you can carry a towel over your shoulder and ask a guy if he is ok, you are qualified to be a trainer in the NFL.

  13. So…to recap:

    1. It’s obvious to the anyone watching the replay of Keenum’s head smash against the turf, and his punch drink appearance immediately afterwards, that he needed to be removed right then and there to check for a concussion.

    2. Head coach Fisher, who also happens to be on the competition committee, says/does nothing.

    3. The ATC guy does nothing.

    And nobody is held accountable.

    Yup. That’s about par for the course for the 2016 NFL.

  14. The “spotter” aside, are the Rams asking us to believe that their entire coaching staff, including the guys on the sidelines, and those watching the game from a booth with TV monitors and binoculars, were unable to see what all of us did on TV?

  15. From what I see ATC is not an anagram although the letters DO stand for the 3 word title: Certified Athletic Trainers. Assuming no one wanted to be the “CAT” that had to stop the game during the heat of battle, and realizing that the ATC rules were unclear/unenforcable, now is the time to rename the position to not only define but compel officials to disallow persons in the condition which Case Keenum found himself in to continue by calling it simply: ACT ! Just sayin.

  16. Imagine the outcry if the Pats had done this with Brady ?

    Goodell’s double standard

    Goodell is vile

    Goodell must go

  17. That’s the question, right — who, ultimately, is bottom line responsible for taking a concussed player off the field. Before the league added the spotter, it was pretty clear that the buck stopped with the team. Now (at least from a fan’s perspective, and in light of the NFL taking no action against the Rams for screwing this up)? Not so clear.

  18. RegisHawk says:
    Nov 29, 2015 9:29 AM

    The ATC spotter was led to believe that the Rams were taking care of the situation when he saw the trainer going out on the field, which is why he did nothing. If anything, the trainer should be held accountable for letting Keenum continue after examining him. After that, any implied understandings in the behavior of team officials and/or players themselves falls on the Head Coach, who establishes that standard.
    ————————————————————
    This is the only logical explanation I’ve read. The spotter must have thought it was bizarre that Keenum stayed in, but at that point would have had to rely on the trainer’s up close evaluation an conclusion that the player could continue.

  19. So, the NFL agrees with what everyone saw – that everyone failed Keenum and because they care so very much about player safety, the only thing they can possibly do to make it right is absolutely nothing.

  20. Pink under the eyes? Fined.

    Wrong colour shoes? Fined.

    Possible equipment violation that science proves didn’t happen?
    Explodegasm of fines.

    Smashing another players head against their helmet?
    No biggie.

    Blatant concussion, left to stay on the field by training staff, ATC guy and head coach on the competition committee?
    Whatevs.

    Goodell: “player safety is of utmost importance!”

    I feel like someone isn’t actually doing what they are saying here. Not that I expect anything different from him at this point. Good thing the Commish is a man of “utmost integrity and should that ever be brought into question, they should be fired” (obviously not word for word, but the general idea is true)

    lololololololol

  21. It was obvious to everyone that Keenum was concussed….the NFL is at its peak…besides the gimmicky rule changes(xp), the fact the millennial have other interests, and that parents are barring their sons from playing football..you can kill the golden goose….Cuban was spot on

  22. The Rams may have just thought he got his bell rung🔔, and in the words of Taylor Swift, he just needed to “shake it off, shake, shake…”

  23. carloswlassiter says:
    Nov 29, 2015 11:01 AM

    RegisHawk says:
    Nov 29, 2015 9:29 AM

    The ATC spotter was led to believe that the Rams were taking care of the situation when he saw the trainer going out on the field, which is why he did nothing. If anything, the trainer should be held accountable for letting Keenum continue after examining him. After that, any implied understandings in the behavior of team officials and/or players themselves falls on the Head Coach, who establishes that standard.
    ————————————————————
    This is the only logical explanation I’ve read. The spotter must have thought it was bizarre that Keenum stayed in, but at that point would have had to rely on the trainer’s up close evaluation an conclusion that the player could continue.
    —————————

    I have no idea what rules govern the ATC Spotter, but anyone that sees a player get picked up off of the field literally like a rag doll, then stumbling around and holding their helmet, and doesn’t do whatever it takes to get that player to the sidelines, deserves to get fined, suspended, and/or fired.

  24. Jeff Fisher has an outsized influence within the league. He continues to have an unfair advantage when it comes to application of the rules because he is helping to write them. It is such a blatant conflict of interest that only the most inept and/or corrupt organization could let it go on unabated for years.

    Oh, wait, this is the NFL. Never mind.

  25. “The ATC spotter was led to believe that the Rams were taking care of the situation when he saw the trainer going out on the field, which is why he did nothing.”

    ATC spotter has the ability to contact team trainers directly. Along with the independent neurologists and game officials. He can also call a medical timeout if a player needs to be removed, and he had a better view of Keenum than anybody.

    There’s simply no reason this kind of assumption or misunderstanding should be happening.

  26. The Rams wont be penalized but Keenum will be penalized for wearing the wrong color socks and wrong color mouth guard.

  27. RegisHawk says:
    Nov 29, 2015 9:29 AM
    The ATC spotter was led to believe that the Rams were taking care of the situation when he saw the trainer going out on the field, which is why he did nothing. If anything, the trainer should be held accountable for letting Keenum continue after examining him. After that, any implied understandings in the behavior of team officials and/or players themselves falls on the Head Coach, who establishes that standard.
    =======================

    Um……yeah. That’s not the way it’s supposed to work. The ATC spotter was specifically given the authority, beginning this year, to overrule team trainers. That was highlighted by the league as a major step forward in player safety.

    He/she had access to the replays that showed Keenum struggling to regain his feet. He/she had no responsibility to defer to the trainers, in fact he/has has been ordered by the league to act INDEPENDENTLY of them.

  28. The trainer is more at fault than the spotter but the spotter should have ensured a thorough exam happened based on what he could see. A cursory “you OK?” doesn’t cut it on this one. Anyone who saw that play and his actions immediately after knew he was most likely concussed and it doesn’t take a medical degree to make that conclusion. The spotter should be a fail safe/safety net/backup not a replacement for the on field staff. There are plenty of people to blame here. The referee, trainer, spotter, head coach and even the players that tried to help him get up. They all failed. This is a tricky and touchy circumstance because of the impact on the game and the players’ career opportunity but this case was quite obvious. Hell, even the guys in NYC watching on TV could have called. It is hard to blame the player in this case because he could have easily been incapable of sound judgment but if a player is cognizant enough to knowingly hide it they share blame as well.

  29. Goodell needs to go. Anyone watching that game could see Keenum staggering and the Rams training and coaching staff, on field officials and the NFL’s spotter all missed it?

    All should have been punished. That they weren’t shows how arbitrary Goodell’s and by extension the NFL’s punishment policies are.

    If this had been Tom Brady does anyone doubt this would be known as concussion-gate? With BB and the team being fined plus other punishments levied?

  30. Goodell and the owners do not care about player safety and by not holding anyone accountable they are proving that. They care about making money and winning games. I’m sure Goodell has told ESPN to not report it to death like they did with Deflategate.

  31. styro1 says:
    Nov 29, 2015 12:43 PM

    If this had been Tom Brady does anyone doubt this would be known as concussion-gate? With BB and the team being fined plus other punishments levied?
    ——————————–

    Brady would have never been out there if he had been picked up like a rag doll.

  32. “Concussions? Never heard of them. Hey, you. Stop with the messsages on your eye black.”
    – Rog

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.