Jim Schwartz: Eagles shouldn’t pre-determine QB competition

AP

As Philadelphia’s defensive coordinator, Jim Schwartz doesn’t really have any say in who wins the Eagles’ quarterback competition. But as a former head coach who was once tasked with determining when a rookie first-round draft pick, Matthew Stafford, was ready to be his starting quarterback, Schwartz has some insight.

And Schwartz’s insight is this: first-round draft pick Carson Wentz should get the chance to earn the starting job.

“Don’t judge him on something else,” Schwartz said, via NJ.com. “And also don’t pre-determine the result of the race. Let him go play. Don’t put extra pressure on him. I can’t speak for Carson. We have enough worries on defense right now. I think when we drafted Stafford, we just let him play. Was he our best quarterback? Was he ready? Unfortunately, he got hurt both his first and second year by holding the ball too long. I think he had the command and he would have been ready to play had it not been for those injuries.”

Schwartz’s boss, Eagles head coach Doug Pederson, has decided not to follow that path. Instead, Pederson has already declared that Sam Bradford will be the starter.

At least, that’s what Pederson is saying now. If Wentz looks good in Organized Team Activities, training camp and the preseason, Pederson may change his mind. Schwartz thinks Pederson should be open to that.

27 responses to “Jim Schwartz: Eagles shouldn’t pre-determine QB competition

  1. Like it or not, Bradford is still the best QB on this team. Still it isn’t saying much. If Carson can hang tight and learn from Bradford and Daniels, that can only be a positive thing. Meanwhile, get the defense fixed !!

  2. I totally agree with Schwartz about not “predetermining” a race, except in this case where Sam has a base salary of 7 million and a signing bonus of 11 million.

    The giving of that amount of money has precluded any unbiased analysis of competition at that position.

    Again though, in principle, I agree with Schwartz 100%.

  3. Just take a look at what Philly traded away to move up to the #2 spot to select Wentz. Does anyone really believe they traded all that for a guy to come in and hold a clipboard? I know Jim Schwartz doesn’t believe it either. Maybe Jim is getting ready to put a bridge on the market and he’s just trying to gauge our intelligence.

  4. Upon hearing this Bradford immediately grabbed his binky and headed for his safe space.

  5. Like it or not, Bradford is still the best QB on this team. Still it isn’t saying much. If Carson can hang tight and learn from Bradford and Daniels, that can only be a positive thing. Meanwhile, get the defense fixed !!

    —————

    Its hard to say that when Wentz hasn’t seen a snap of live NFL play. I honestly think he is the best QB on the team. And I think he will prove it by the end of the preseason.

    I do, however, think it will benefit him to sit out a little while and learn. No need to rush him.

    And please, for the love of all that is good, stop calling him Daniels people…his name is Chase Daniel!!!

  6. Wentz doesn’t strike me as the kind of guy who will just sit back and do nothing because the organization thinks he needs to wait. Also, no real need for him to push the issue because he knows Sammy Sleeves will go down with (another) injury sooner than later. Once Wentz is in he won’t be giving up the job.

  7. tonebones says:
    May 24, 2016 2:57 PM
    Maybe Jim is getting ready to put a bridge on the market and he’s just trying to gauge our intelligence.
    _____________

    If ‘Jim’ is the one getting ready to put that bridge on the market in Philly then he’s trying to do more than ‘gauge our intelligence’, he is getting ready to stage a coup. And if that’s the case he probably shouldn’t be letting Pederson and Roseman know he’s coming for them

  8. Because the guy has A. a point of reference that’s relevant and B. has actually been a head coach in the NFL, which nobody else on the freaking Eagles has been

  9. Jay Gruden declared RG3 the starting QB for the Redskins last preseason and Cousins ended up being the guy. A coach always reserves the right to change his mind…

  10. I’m a longtime Jim Schwartz fan, but that dude needs to stick to defense and keep his mouth shut on this–especially since he disagrees with his head coach!

  11. tonebones says:
    May 24, 2016 2:57 PM

    Just take a look at what Philly traded away to move up to the #2 spot to select Wentz. Does anyone really believe they traded all that for a guy to come in and hold a clipboard? I know Jim Schwartz doesn’t believe it either. Maybe Jim is getting ready to put a bridge on the market and he’s just trying to gauge our intelligence.
    ===============

    This guy obviously doesn’t follow the Eagles. The team is going to its roots. In 1999, when McNabb was brought in, he sat until the 10th game of the season. McNabb had more college experience than Wentz, and Pederson was the only other QB on the team. The current Eagles have a former #1 overall pick as the QB, and are paying him and his backup a bundle.

    If Wentz’ long term development is enhanced by his holding a clipboard for a year or so, so be it. After all, the Eagles did give up a bundle for him, so it would be unwise to screw up his long term development when Bradford is available to start. Very short sighted view.

  12. Schwartz is a tool. Arrogant enough to publicly suggest stuff to his boss through the media. Hey Schwartzy, if you are such a genius, why haven’t you won anything?

  13. The only way that Wentz starts in Week 1 is either if Bradford is injured or gets traded. No way is the rookie going to start over a healthy Sam Bradford who is still on the roster at that point. Wentz may get his chance to start at some point in the season, depending on a combination of factors (not the least of which is the Eagles being in contention for the playoffs), but to start the season…very highly unlikely.

  14. Schwartz admits Stafford got hurt two years running because he held on to the ball to long. That happens when you can’t read a defense, don’t understand the offense in its totality and you have under estimated the speed of pro defenses. So basically what Schwartz did was stupid and Peterson is right taking a slow steady approach with Wentz.

  15. “I think when we drafted Stafford, we just let him play. Was he our best quarterback? Was he ready? Unfortunately, he got hurt both his first and second year by holding the ball too long. I think he had the command and he would have been ready to play had it not been for those injuries”

    Um… sounds like a bad decision to start him. If he had been wearing a red shirt, coaches could have worked on those mechanics without the likelihood of injury.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.