Eli Manning: Giants “definitely” a playoff team

Getty Images

The Giants have missed the playoffs for the last four seasons, which is a big reason why Ben McAdoo is the team’s new head coach and why they spent heavily on free agent additions for their defense.

The changes on defense matched with the continuity on offense that was ensured with McAdoo’s promotion from offensive coordinator has one key member of the team feeling like the end of the playoff drought is ripe. Quarterback Eli Manning was asked on Wednesday whether he thought the 2016 Giants are a playoff team.

“Yeah, definitely,” Manning said, via the New York Post. “We added some great players in the offseason. We were aggressive in free agency, but still have a lot of our core guys, especially on offense, back and I think we made some good moves on defense. We’re getting some guys back healthy. It’s just a matter of, hey, the talent is there, can we put it together, can we find a way to win the games and play our best football when we need to?”

Manning ran through a couple of reasons why the Giants might not be able to translate that talent into success, including injuries and “how you’ll respond in critical situations in games.” Both were sore spots in the last few years of Tom Coughlin’s run on the sideline and changing things on those fronts could prove to be as crucial to the team’s hopes as any of their offseason maneuvers.

75 responses to “Eli Manning: Giants “definitely” a playoff team

  1. I’d take Big Ben’s 2 rings over career over Eli’s. At least with Ben you know you’re good for double digit wins annually.

  2. The offense will be great as usual. Adding Sterling Shephard and Harris having his 2nd year should be an improvement.

    I also like the 2 Tight ends we have in Donnell and Tye, then add in the rookie who can block very well.

    The Running back competition will be interesting to watch.

    The Giants never have problems scoring points..

    They lost 7 games last year after having the lead in the 4th..

    If the defense can be middle of the pack, this is a 10 -11 win team.

    Cant wait for the season to start.

  3. Injuries happen but over time they should balance out among all 32 yet somehow the Giants have managed to be among the leaders in man games lost the last 5 years running. Beyond Reese’s penchant for broken pieces at some point it goes beyond coincidence and bad luck and the training staff has to be called to account

  4. If they make the playoffs, watch out. Eli is usually money in the playoffs. I should know, he destroyed my Patriots twice in the SB.

  5. Eli should have said the Giants are definitely a playoff team if he doesn’t throw 25 interceptions.

  6. No you aren’t!

    This is the most disappointing division in football and your team is one reason for it always doing so.

    What’s so good about your team when you do what Skins are known to do by winning the SB in March?

    Also, What’s so good about Dallas and Washington with their flaws?

    Based on the division being one by the forgotten team, ever since 2011, the Giants have a shot of losing the division to Philadelphia. It was 7-7 with Sam Bradford, is not doing anything Chip Kelly would want, and improved with additions by subtractions (Kelly & Murray).

    Btw, what Spags done since leaving the Giants in Jan 2009?

  7. jerryyouradisgrace says:
    Jul 7, 2016 10:28 AM
    Until you throw 25-30 INTs for the season

    ________________________________________

    That joke is played out..

    Eli played in Giilbride’s “High risk, High reward” system.

    Eli had 6 potential routes that EACH WR could run for every play.

    When the receiver (Randle, Manningham, Barden, Moss, Jernigan) dont have the ability to master the offense it leads to a lot of interceptions.

    Since Gilbride has retired ELI is playing his ass off.. Anyone with ANY football knowledge can attest to that.

  8. Eli stats for the season…whether or not the Giants make the playoffs again with him is the only stat that will matter.

    This is what holds him back in the eyes of the public. Great quarterbacks overcome mediocre team play to get into and advance in the playoffs. He just hasn’t done it enough in his career to be considered above “good”

  9. You only make the playoffs if you win enough games … talk means nothing …

  10. What else is he going to say? “No, we will be terrible, please don’t buy tickets and just do something else with your time.”

  11. Eli stats for this season over 37 TD’s under 13 int’s over 4600 yards passing 67 comp % 10 wins or more

    —————————–

    I am a fan of Eli, even though I root for a division rival. But there’s no reason to believe that any of that will happen.

    In his past 10 seasons he averages 26.4 TDs/17.3 INTs and 3938 yards. Also, he’s never thrown more than 35 TDs, and he’s thrown for less than 14 INTs in a season only one time, and that was in 2008. No disrespect to Eli, he is a good player, but those stats aren’t realistic with his history and the talent around him. He throws way too many balls up for grabs to have that kind of TD/INT ratio. And their OL still stinks.

  12. Eli stats for this season over 37 TD’s under 13 int’s over 4600 yards passing 67 comp % 10 wins or more

    —————————–

    I am a fan of Eli, even though I root for a division rival. But there’s no reason to believe that any of that will happen.

    In his past 10 seasons he averages 26.4 TDs/17.3 INTs and 3938 yards. Also, he’s never thrown more than 35 TDs, and he’s thrown for less than 14 INTs in a season only one time, and that was in 2008. No disrespect to Eli, he is a good player, but those stats aren’t realistic with his history and the talent around him. He throws way too many balls up for grabs to have that kind of TD/INT ratio. And their OL still stinks.

    _______________________________________

    But their O Line doesnt stink..

    They have 3 very good pieces.. Right Tackle is an issue, but can be masked with a good play action game.

  13. So, the Giants are going to win the division…….well, that now makes 4 teams that think they will win the worst division in football

  14. ikeclanton says:
    Jul 7, 2016 10:48 AM

    This is what holds him back in the eyes of the public. Great quarterbacks overcome mediocre team play to get into and advance in the playoffs. He just hasn’t done it enough in his career to be considered above “good”
    _______________________________________

    What else could ELI have done last year?

    He left the field with the lead 7x in the 4th Quarter, and 5x with less than 2 minutes to go.

    Last year he played his ass off..

    The defense let the team down.

  15. Football Offense 101 – Before an offense can be successful, the offensive line must block well to create running lanes and to prevent your QB from getting flattened.

    Um, Eli, this might be a problem…

  16. Eli Mannings Stats the last 2 years: 4,432 yds, 35 TDs, 14 INTs.. 4,410 yds, 30 TDs, 14 INTs. That’s with a brand new system, a subpar offensive line, and no Cruz. The money that we have spent on Defense and the return of Cruz/drafting of Shepard makes it pretty realistic to believe they can make the playoffs. Especially because our defense blew the lead with 2 mins or less 5 times last year. But keep being delusional I suppose. I guess a leader of a franchise should just say “eh probably not” when asked if they believe their team is a playoff contender.

  17. jjb0811 says:
    Jul 7, 2016 10:25 AM

    I’d take Big Ben’s 2 rings over career over Eli’s. At least with Ben you know you’re good for double digit wins annually.
    ————————————————-

    Yeah and Ben has had a better team around him. Their 6th round draft pick turned into a great WR. While the Giants picks after the 1st round have done nothing. You don’t spend millions on your defense if you can draft well. the Giants haven’t drafted well the past 5 years.

  18. patsfan4lifesbchamps says:
    Jul 7, 2016 10:33 AM
    If they make the playoffs, watch out. Eli is usually money in the playoffs. I should know, he destroyed my Patriots twice in the SB.
    ________________

    The Jets fan pretending to be a Pats fan can’t even get it right when trying to twist the knife on 2 of the most painful losses to Pats fans. Eli didn’t destroy the Pats, it was worse than that. The Giants won by 3 in the first and 4 in the second, those games were there to be won making it all the more painful than getting destroyed. Not taking anything away from Eli, he came up huge when he had to, but the Giants D won those games. Every Giants fan knows it and so does every Pats fan, jests fans not so much

  19. illogicalvoicesinmyhead says:
    Jul 7, 2016 10:34 AM

    You can’t spell “mediocre” without “eli.”

    ————————————————————-
    Ah you must be a fan of another team in the NFC East, because how dumb are you to realize mediocre doesn’t have an L in it………

  20. @ jmuller516,

    “The offense will be great as usual”.

    Wow. The blue kool-aid has been seriously spiked and wholly over-consumed yet again, and this time with a plethora of Kentucky moonshine, apparently.

    The Panthers had a TRULY great offense, and what are they remembered for in 2015? Losing the SB.

    The Giants are grasping for any help they can get, as evidenced by the $140 Million + in guaranteed $ in FA contracts (the only other team higher is the Eagles at double that amount). So, the Eagles, Giants, and Redskins are the top 3 FA spending teams in the NFL. ALL 3 are trying to pull a Steinbrenner (or a Dan Snyder) to spend their way to the SB. We all know it doesn’t work. Almost always, the largest FA contracts are a waste of money, and history absolutely supports this.

    The Giants O-line has been horrendous (although “better” in 2015, they were still ranked 20th by PFF). The running game has been anemic (5 rushing Td’s in 2015). Spending $140 million in FA money won’t change this, nor will it do much for the win column.

    But keep on drinking that blue kool-aid. At least you won’t be sober when the season turns out to be a huge disappointment.

  21. jjb0811 says:
    Jul 7, 2016 10:25 AM
    I’d take Big Ben’s 2 rings over career over Eli’s. At least with Ben you know you’re good for double digit wins annually.
    ————————————————————————-

    LOL! Maybe that’s because the Steelers manage to win games with 2nd & 3rd string QBs while Big Ben is on the sidelines.

    Seriously, those SBs Ben won, he won with the number 1 & 4th ranked defenses. He never won the SBMVP.

    Eli is a 2xSBMVP, one of only 5. He is the only QB in NFL history to throw for over 4900 yards and win the SBMVP the same year while breaking the record for most 4th quarter tds.

    It’s cute that you like Ben’s career over Eli’s, but give me a break with “the double digit wins annually” when Ben misses games annually and the Steelers STILL WIN.

    I knew Eli Manning made Patriots and Cowboys fans massively insecure, but when did Big Ben fanboys join the party? Lol

  22. troylok says:
    Jul 7, 2016 11:12 AM
    Football Offense 101 – Before an offense can be successful, the offensive line must block well to create running lanes and to prevent your QB from getting flattened.

    Um, Eli, this might be a problem…
    ____________________

    26.3 PPG in ’15 was successful enough to rank 6th overall. They were the only team in the top 10 for scoring that failed to make the playoffs. Offense was not the problem.

  23. Hahaha, apparantly the players are drinking the kool-aid along with the fans. I saw a poll on a Giants blog the other day that had 87 percent of voters saying the Giants would make the playoffs. It had almost 4000 votes. 87 percent!

  24. The Jets fan pretending to be a Pats fan can’t even get it right when trying to twist the knife on 2 of the most painful losses to Pats fans. Eli didn’t destroy the Pats, it was worse than that. The Giants won by 3 in the first and 4 in the second, those games were there to be won making it all the more painful than getting destroyed. Not taking anything away from Eli, he came up huge when he had to, but the Giants D won those games. Every Giants fan knows it and so does every Pats fan, jests fans not so much

    —————–

    The Giants’ defense was ranked 25th and 17th in 2011 and 2007 respectively. Not sure how anyone who knows football can say those defenses won the SB. If anything Brady choked but it certainly wasn’t the Giants’ defense that won the SB. You know which defense won the SB? The Patriots defense in 2001, 2003, and 2004. The Patriots defense was ranked 6th, 1st, and 2nd respectively for those championships.

  25. LOL looks like the fans aren’t the only ones drinking the kool-aid. I saw a poll on a Giants blog the other day that had 87 percent of voters saying the Giants would make the playoffs. There was almost 4000 votes too. 87 percent!

  26. Really depends on how the Cowboys and Giants come out of the first four games. If the Cowboys win three of their first four then the Giants can kiss the postseason goodbye. If the Giants go 3-1 and the Cowboys go 1-3 or 2-2, then it will be a real race to January.

  27. themage78 says:
    Jul 7, 2016 11:24 AM
    illogicalvoicesinmyhead says:
    Jul 7, 2016 10:34 AM

    You can’t spell “mediocre” without “eli.”

    ————————————————————-
    Ah you must be a fan of another team in the NFC East, because how dumb are you to realize mediocre doesn’t have an L in it………

    You must be a Giants fan, because how dumb are you to not get the joke?…..

  28. Two things.

    One, what do you expect him to say? “Oh, we are a 7-win team at best.”

    Second, the Giants are not a playoff team. Last I checked, you have to earn your way to the playoffs in the regular season. They haven’t earned anything yet.

  29. patsfan4lifesbchamps says:
    Jul 7, 2016 12:02 PM
    The Giants’ defense was ranked 25th and 17th in 2011 and 2007 respectively. Not sure how anyone who knows football can say those defenses won the SB.
    ___________________

    What??? Did you even watch those games? The Giants D absolutely owned those games. In SB 42 they held the best offense the game had ever seen to FOURTEEN POINTS. In the playoffs they held the #2 scoring Dallas offense to 17 in Dallas and #4 GB to 20 in Lambeau. What do regular season rankings have to do with playoff performance?
    If you knew anything about football you’d know it is played between the lines not on some ranking list. Brady didn’t choke in those games, he was beaten to pulp. Tuck commented afterwards he couldn’t believe Brady just kept getting up and coming at them.

  30. Why would you say this? Hows about we wait until we make it through the preseason and don’t have half our team on IR as we have the past 3 seasons before you make any predictions. I believe we’re a playoff team too…IF we can stay healthy, which considering we are three-peat IR champions, is a pretty tall order.

  31. patsfan4lifesbchamps says:
    Jul 7, 2016 10:33 AM
    If they make the playoffs, watch out. Eli is usually money in the playoffs. I should know, he destroyed my Patriots twice in the SB.

    —————

    Enough with the facade. Your team is the Jets and that haven’t sniffed a SB since the 60s. And they won’t any time soon.

  32. the NFL season always seem to find a way to make the Giants & the New York media market relevant, even if the teams are rotten

    i’m no giants fan, but I wouldn’t be surprised if the giants end up 10-6, or better this year

  33. If Cruz comes back to form and OBJ keeps tearing it up, The Giants will be tough to beat…

    If Sheppard plays as good as the players say he can and the Giants OL gets even better with experience… we may be a top 9 team this year

    If the Defense plays better as it should on paper and everyone stays healthy… The Giants will roll into the playoffs with 12 plus wins…

    Thats a lot of ifs though… The Gmen were terrible last year but were still close to winning half their lost games until the last two minutes

  34. I think if he can get those footballs rubbed, scraped, kneaded, deflated, inflated, oiled, and baked over the next few months, just the way his hands need them to be in order to throw the ball, they can be a playoff team. Not that it’s against the rules or anything….

  35. The offense was pretty good last year. The defense was terrible. If the defense is merely mediocre the they should win 10-11 games.

  36. Love how Eagles fans say 1 playoff appearance in 7 years. That might make your sorry rear ends feel better at night but deep down you know it kills you to have to admit that the Giants have won the most Super Bowls in the last decade.

  37. lanman11 says:
    Jul 7, 2016 2:56 PM

    I think if he can get those footballs rubbed, scraped, kneaded, deflated, inflated, oiled, and baked over the next few months, just the way his hands need them to be in order to throw the ball, they can be a playoff team. Not that it’s against the rules or anything….
    —————–

    It isn’t against the rules.

  38. 8oneanddones says:
    Jul 7, 2016 1:12 PM
    One playoff appearance in the last 7 seasons.
    =================

    And yet in just that one appearance they netted more playoff wins than the Iggles in the last 10 years, the Cowboys in the last 20 years and the Skins in the last 25,
    while also earning one more Lombardi trophy than the Iggles…ever. All in one lone playoff appearance in the last 7 seasons.

  39. RWR Odell Beckham Jr is a force by himself. He makes up for four dropped passes per game for most other teams. Victor Cruz is listed as the #3 LWR. Okay … give me the Giants. We are talking Eli here, people: a proven clutch qb.

  40. jmuller516 says:
    Jul 7, 2016 10:47 AM
    jerryyouradisgrace says:
    Jul 7, 2016 10:28 AM
    Until you throw 25-30 INTs for the season

    ________________________________________

    That joke is played out..

    Eli played in Giilbride’s “High risk, High reward” system.

    Eli had 6 potential routes that EACH WR could run for every play.

    When the receiver (Randle, Manningham, Barden, Moss, Jernigan) dont have the ability to master the offense it leads to a lot of interceptions.

    Since Gilbride has retired ELI is playing his ass off.. Anyone with ANY football knowledge can attest to that.

    71 43
    ==================================

    you got it right on. gilbride sucks. Buddy Ryan, May he RIP, had it right on with his opinion of gilbride. as a Pats fan I have mad respect for Eli and his desire to win!!

  41. jsrdc says:
    the Eagles, Giants, and Redskins are the top 3 FA spending teams in the NFL.

    ———————————————————-
    the top 3 spenders in FA this year are
    1. Giants
    2. Jaguars
    3. Raiders

    although the Eagles did spend a lot of $$ on locking up THIER GUYS for a Few years .just sayin .

  42. The NFL network top 100 (as chosen by the players) has Eli Manning as the 10th best quarterback in the league (#47 overall), ranked somewhere between Philip Rivers and Blake Bortles.

    Sounds about right.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.