Joshua Garnett was inactive for his first NFL game

Getty Images

Monday night’s game between the Rams and 49ers featured a first overall pick in street clothes. Another first-rounder also didn’t dress for the contest.

49ers guard Joshua Garnett, whom the team traded back into round one to acquire, was one of the inactive players for his NFL debut.

“Josh is extremely close and is as close to playing as he is to being inactive just because we’re dressing seven,” coach Chip Kelly told reporters on Monday. “The difference between Josh Garnett and Marcus Martin right now is that Marcus Martin can play center and guard where Josh has just been exclusively trained at guard, just because he just got here. So our emergency center after Marcus was [Zane] Beadles. Beadles has taken minimum snaps there, just like our emergency quarterback is [tight end] Blake Bell. If we’re down to our third center or our third quarterback, we’re going to be drastically different just from a practice standpoint. You don’t get a lot of reps for all those guys. But, Josh is a lot closer. I think people see, ‘Well, he was inactive.’ But he’s pushing to be a starter. The issue is we can’t dress him because when we dress seven, he doesn’t have the center background to be able to go in there and be the center. So it’s just one of those deals where the numbers, when you’re only dressing 46 on game day then you’ve really got to kind of cut someone and that’s really the decision we made going into this game. That doesn’t mean later on down the road that that’s not going to change.”

Regardless, whenever a first-round pick doesn’t dress in his first game for reasons other than injury, the situation invites questions regarding whether the team made the right move, especially when the team moved up. It’s still a long season and Garnett has four total seasons to fulfill his potential. While the situation is noteworthy, it’s too early for the 49ers to panic.

10 responses to “Joshua Garnett was inactive for his first NFL game

  1. Now that was classic ‘Coach Speak’… he ought to get the Coach B award for speaking without saying anything prize.

  2. Panic?
    Why Panic? Old Chipper’s response was actually easy to understand and made perfect sense. Besides a few rookie mistakes Garnett looked good in the preseason.

  3. Considerable difference between adding a fourth round pick to move up into the late first round than trading away all your premium picks to 2020 for the first overall pick, though. I have a lot more confidence in Josh Garnett who is stuck behind a suddenly very deep 49er O line than Goff who is stuck behind a couple players who look like they’d be challenged to start in the CFL.

  4. What a difference a year makes

    Last year we probably had the least talented o-line in all the game, with no depth on top of that

    Now we go two deep at all positions

    Josh will be fine, AD could quit again and he could easily beat out Beadles or Tiller in the near future

  5. Ifedi was taken after Garnett and he would be starting were it not for his injury. A first round pick ought to start. Garnett is a bust.

  6. osiris33 (bandwagon since 1976) says:
    Sep 13, 2016 8:51 PM

    Speak for your own team’s O-Line.
    And pray for Wilson if he plays against the Rams.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.