Kaela Carpenter sort-of apologizes for Richard Sherman castration tweet

Getty Images

The wife of Bills kicker Dan Carpenter insisted she’s not a racist, while offering the anticipated non-apology apology for saying Seahawks cornerback Richard Sherman should be castrated for running into her husband during a sports game.

Kaela Carpenter has since deleted the original post, which showed a bander, the implement used to remove testicles from farm animals by putting a tight rubber band around them until they shrivel and fall off.

You know, the one when she referred to Sherman as an animal, and suggested the tool be used on him.

“I know what we do on the farm when a male can’t control his own rage. #LuckyImNotThere #Sherman #ActLikeAnAnimalGetTreatedLike1,” the original post read.

Today’s had a much different tone.

“My attempt at humor during a heated and highly controversial NFL game has not been received the way I intended,” she wrote. “When I saw the out of control nature of the events that happened on the field, I jokingly wanted to relate it to life on the farm, where I grew up, and how it would have been handled there. Unfortunately, I did not realize that a tone of racism would dominate the response to what I intended to be a lighthearted defense of my husband. Regardless of the narrative that has been attached to my post, it was never intended to be related to race, or the disgusting hatred that creates the basis for racism.”

It carries a tone of racism, because castrating black males as punishment was a common tactic of racial terrorists during the Jim Crow era, and someone with a passing knowledge of the history of our country might have realized it was a horribly inappropriate joke to make. But by putting the responsibility on people who didn’t receive it in the way she intended — ha, ha, mutilating people like farm animals is funny, y’all — it falls short of being an actual apology.

To his credit, Sherman has taken the high road throughout, posting a reply to the initial message.

Maybe he’s laughing because he didn’t even get a 15-yard flag for it, much less a more painful penalty.

37 responses to “Kaela Carpenter sort-of apologizes for Richard Sherman castration tweet

  1. Or maybe Sherman is laughing because he, like anyone with common sense, understands her tweet was not racist.

    This whole “if you say anything remotely negative about a person with different colored skin it’s automatically racist” bullcrap is ridiculous and lame.

  2. I took it exactly how she intended it to be. From yesterdays comments it seems nearly everyone took it how she intended it to be taken. It took quite a leap to turn that into a racist tweet.

    What I did take mild offense too was how the media divided all of us Americans last night into segregated groups of voters instead of see each vote as just “and American Vote.” They had to divide us by race, gender, education and religion. None of that stuff matters at all. A vote is a vote. An American is an American. Hypocrites that are too blinded by their own personal missions.

  3. If Sherman was white (or brown, yellow, green, whatever), it wouldn’t have been funny either.

  4. This sort of thing is exactly what people are so sick of they voted for Trump.

    Political correctness disease where everything anyone says is viewed through a glass colored by racism, sexism, other isms and the desire to be offended.

    Enough. People are not perfect and no matter how hard the pc thought police try they aren’t going to change that. Everyone must have latitude to be human beings, including saying stupid things that offend people sometimes. We’re all human beings. We all make mistakes and say silly things at times.

  5. I don’t think she meant it to be racist. She later realized that it could be considered to be racist and clarified that she had no such intent. It’s good enough for me. Let’s move on.

  6. You’re conflating two ideas…

    1) it was a pretty despicable thing to say
    2) it’s a racist statement

    These are not mutually exclusive, but that doesn’t mean that they are both accurate. You’re adding your own bias to this story.

    It was a horrible thing to say, but you can’t fairly someone a racist when they have said nothing to indicate racism, and then fall back on broad history of other people.

  7. He’s just a kicker Kaela, but you should know that people playing professional football actually do get hit sometimes.

  8. It carries a tone of racism, because castrating black males as punishment was a common tactic of racial terrorists during the Jim Crow era,
    ————————————–

    it’s also been a common tactic throughout history to people of all races for punishment, and stopping young boy’s voices from changing, and keeping roman slave’s in line, etc etc etc.

  9. Can we please stop interjecting racism where it is not? Anybody who took what she said and tried to twist it into being racist is part of the problem. Quit creating controversy and trying to divide people. What’s the motivation behind that? What are you looking to accomplish?

  10. “someone with a passing knowledge of the history of our country”

    Of all of the assumptions being made about Carpenter’s wife, this is easily the dumbest. Anyone with a passing knowledge of our failing educational system might have realized that high school and even some college graduates lack a passing knowledge of our history.

    Want an example?

    I had a friend who was convinced the US Civil War took place after WWII.

    Think about that for a minute. This friend was certain that we dropped atomic bombs on the Japanese and then put those away and broke out wagons and muzzle loaders in order to fight one another in the 1960s. And then unpacked all of the advanced weaponry for the Gulf War.

  11. If someone gets pulled over it was racially motivated. If a cashier at a store is ignorant to you, they gotta be a racist. If someone don’t get a job, the company is racist. Maybe you did something wrong to get pulled over, maybe that cashier is having a bad day or is just an ass, maybe the company found a better candidate for the job…… Or maybe it was racially motivated, but just don’t call someone a racist because you don’t agree or accept the outcome of a situation. I’m not saying there is no racism in this world, I personally don’t understand how anyone could not like someone because they look different than yourself. But when people cry wolf or are just too sensitive & pull the race card it just takes away from real issues. Everything doesn’t always have to be about race. All this hate, for what? Life is too short.

  12. I seriously doubt anyone that spells their name Kaela is old enough to understand who Jim McMahon is much less Jim Brown or Jim Crow.

    What was funny is the kicker’s wife sticking up for him! I did not see racism. That is such a stretch that I find it lacks credibility. I saw a PO’d, cute, country girl wife. My guess is she does know Jim Beam from field parties. Not that there’s anything wrong with that.

  13. sweetnlow44 says:
    Nov 9, 2016 2:44 PM

    … Quit creating controversy and trying to divide people. What’s the motivation behind that? What are you looking to accomplish?
    ~~~~~~~
    Get elected as president?

  14. Anyone making her comments to her is, “A Fire Starter!’ Amazing how some love to twist words to start a fire. Anyone with a brain KNOWS she wasn’t going racist AT ALL. Look at the thumbs down here…it’ll tell you how many FIRE STARTERS there are on this board day after day.

  15. “…someone with a passing knowledge of the history of our country might have realized…”

    And someone with a passing knowledge of farm girls might have realized that in one regard farm folks aren’t all that different from city folks. You can take the girl out of the farm but you can’t take the farm out of the girl.
    Everything isn’t always about something else. Even Freud accepted sometimes a cigar is just a cigar.

  16. She probably didn’t mean it to be racist. I’m not sure it was the best way to try to make light of the situation. She could have chosen another way to make her point.

    Kudos to Sherman for not making an issue of it.

    At least she didn’t do what almost every other person who gets in trouble does–claim her twitter account was hacked.

  17. … Quit creating controversy and trying to divide people. What’s the motivation behind that? What are you looking to accomplish?
    ~~~~~~~
    Get elected as president?
    *********************

    Didn’t work for Hillary

  18. She still has not apologized for the subsequent “These refs wouldn’t be fit to work at Mc’Donalds” tweet.

  19. Maybe she should have tweeted this about the white refs who are at fault and should have blown the whistle on the play, instead of Sherman, whom like her husband, was just out there doing his job.

  20. scrp2 says:
    Nov 9, 2016 3:19 PM

    She still has not apologized for the subsequent “These refs wouldn’t be fit to work at Mc’Donalds” tweet.
    ————————-

    Apologize for what?

    The days of everyone apologizing for everything little they say ended early this morning.

  21. Why does race have to be forced into every comment any person makes?? And why cant a writer just write a story without adding his or her opinion into the story?? Mr Trump you have your work cut out for you….between the media and people’s ignorance this country is heading in the wrong direction.

  22. I’m as far from conservative/right wing as you can get and am very sensitive to racism as a minority. Many of the posters here will never experience racism or know what it’s like to be a minority and experience discrimination and bigotry. However, I saw absolutely no racism in that tweet by the kicker’s wife.

    Perhaps a muzzle would be best for Dick Sherman since he just.won’t.stop.talking. The guy has the biggest mouth in the league.

  23. sweetnlow44 says:
    … Quit creating controversy and trying to divide people. What’s the motivation behind that? What are you looking to accomplish?
    ~~~~~~~
    Get elected as president?
    ———————————————
    It sure worked well in 2008 and 2012

  24. “What I did take mild offense too was how the media divided all of us Americans last night into segregated groups of voters instead of see each vote as just “and American Vote.” They had to divide us by race, gender, education and religion. None of that stuff matters at all. A vote is a vote. An American is an American. Hypocrites that are too blinded by their own personal missions”

    **************************************************

    What you took as “mild offense”, I took it as an outrage! I am sick and tired of the media throwing racism out at everything that THEY THINK is racist if it is a white and black situation. The media thrives on that. If you watch the news channels regularly, take away the stories with a racial undertone, you would have about half of the stories missing. The reason this nation is so divided, while other technically advanced countries isn’t, is because the press keeps jamming it down our throats.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.