Mike McCarthy on fixing Packers: I’m a highly successful NFL coach

Getty Images

The heat has been turned up under Packers coach Mike McCarthy’s seat by four losses in five games that have left the Packers with a 4-5 record on the season.

Quarterback Aaron Rodgers said Sunday that the situation calls for an increased urgency around the team, but McCarthy sent a somewhat different message when he met with the media on Monday. McCarthy said that he’s seen things that need to improve, but that he’s neither “worried about the football team” nor planning major changes.

“I’m not into shock and awe or torch the landscape,” McCarthy said, via Rob Demovsky of ESPN.com. “I’m a builder. I’m a developer. You build a culture, you invest in the culture. We look to adjust and tweak on a daily basis.”

McCarthy also made it clear that he’s not doubting his ability to make the necessary adjustments.

“Let’s state the facts: I’m a highly successful NFL coach,” McCarthy said. “With that, I’ve never looked at the ride to this point as smooth.”

There’s no doubt that McCarthy has had great success as the head coach in Green Bay. That doesn’t make his job a lifetime appointment, however, and others who have been to the highest peaks in the league have lost their jobs when the success stops coming. The next seven games will determine whether that happens, but a 9-12 record over the last 21 games doesn’t do much to support the idea that McCarthy is a particularly successful NFL coach right now.

114 responses to “Mike McCarthy on fixing Packers: I’m a highly successful NFL coach

  1. LOL. McCarthy did nothing but ride on the back of a “highly successful” QB….who isn’t highly successful anymore.

  2. “I don’t know how to put this, but I’m kind of a big deal. People know me. I’m very important. I have many leather-bound books and my apartment smells of rich mahogany.”

  3. Mike needs to understand that the Packers kicked Vince Lombardi to the curb.

    MM is no Vince Lombardi.

  4. Yes, he’s has a mediocre record at about the halfway point.

    We should definitely fire him immediately.

    #HotTaekAnalysisSucks #StopDoingIt

  5. It’s easy to look like a genius with back-to-back HOF QBs, excellent WRs and TEs. Throw him into the Browns dumpster and see how good he looks.

  6. That is always the sign that someone who has been successful is slipping – when they have to remind you, with their words, instead of their results, that they are successful. It is a hollow move that smart people see through.

  7. Mike, I believe you are a good man but just be honest. BIG changes NEED to be made. The Packers are past the point of changing just to change. They are at the point of needing to change. It’s not always a bad thing. Stubbornness gets you nowhere. Look where it got the Dems in the election.

  8. When you have to verbalize something while being faced with tough questions, it usually means there is doubt within one self. Has he ever ‘head’ coached without a top 5 QB?

  9. “Let’s state the facts: This offense has under-performed all season, and most of last season too. Our defense has been just good enough, never great. Lately they’ve been bad. We can’t tackle. But we’ll look at the film and clean it up.”

    Yup. Sure you will. This team has quit. I’ve always supported the McCarthy/Thompson tenure. I think that changes now. It really looks like the team has quit on coach, and Thompson really is proving to be a great scout but not necessarily a great GM. He’s done some really good things, but I don’t know it’s enough to get them back to the superbowl. I think a new GM, with his own coaching hire, might not be a bad idea. I’m fine with waiting until the end of the season to see that happen. But these and other recent comments by McCarthy just scream of arrogance and ignorance.

  10. He can only do so much with the players he has. Rodgers still isn’t 100%. Jordy Nelson isn’t either. The defense is terrible. There are practice squad guys at cornerback. The Packers could be the third most talented team in the division right now.

  11. McCarthy was gifted a highly successful quarterback, so patting himself on the back doesn’t mean much. That’s like Grigson saying he rules when Luck is all that separates him from annual 3-13

  12. The offense is stagnant, and the defense just stinks. McCarthy has to take a hard look at himself and his staff right now. The offense has been bad since Edgar Bennett took over as OC. That’s a fact. The defense has been inconsistent and predictable since Dom Capers took over. That’s a fact. Unless the Packers have a highly unlikely turn around and make the Superbowl McCarthy is going to have to replace his coordinators in order to keep his job. Preferably with people outside the Packer organization to bring a fresh look in.

  13. Correction: You’ve benefited from having an all time great QB. And now that he’s taken a dip in performance, well, your flaws as a coach are blinding.

  14. Compare his (active) playoff appearance streak to anyone else. This coaching staff is top-tier, and lest we would like a decade or more of losing, we need to be patient.

  15. Now see…that’s arrogance leakage from Aaron Rodgers spilling over into your HC there…
    ——
    Your qb blamed one of his int’s on god, so maybe you shouldn’t judge ole Arod.

  16. Are you kidding me Mike?!? You’ve had two 1st ballot HOF QB’s (11 years I believe) and you’ve won 1 SB (congrats way to go) and made it to two NFCCG’s. One of those NFCCG you produced maybe the biggest choke in the history of sports. You have consistently been out coached by Harbaugh, Coughlin and Carroll in every single game that’s actually mattered. You haven’t changed your offense the entire time you’ve been in town. It’s time to hit the road.

    Let me guess – we also said they will watch the tape, be true to themselves, get those pad levels lower, execute and everything will be just fine.

    The problem is MM and TT only answer to themselves. There is zero accountability in that organization. None. Zilch. Mark Murphy sure isn’t lighting a fire under anyone’s butt.

    #WindowSlammedShut

  17. No, you are more like a mediocre coach who was blessed to ride the coatails of one of the best qb’s of his generation. The fact that you have only one trophy and appearance in the big dance is borderline humiliating. Every season for the past 6-7 years, Green Bay is commonly picked as a Super Bowl representative by many experts and yet you almost never deliver. Whether its your questionable play calling, poor decision making at critical points of important games or your ambivalent attitude that allowed your franchise running back to blow up like a whale during the season the team needed him most. I’m sure there are many other things that have led to the nonchalance of your quarterback. Make no mistake, this team has mailed it in. Still very talented, but no longer want to play for it’s coach.

  18. LOL. McCarthy did nothing but ride on the back of a “highly successful” QB….who isn’t highly successful anymore
    ——
    Wouldn’t say that….he’s still third in the league in TD’s and still capable of a good scramble and of throwing a great ball. Problem is he has no supporting cast. Doesn’t matter how good the qb is when the receivers can’t get open, the running game is non-existent and the defense is terrible. Ironically Casey Heywood is leading the league in INT’s. Good job Ted.

  19. gtodriver says:
    Nov 14, 2016 1:55 PM
    Mike needs to understand that the Packers kicked Vince Lombardi to the curb.
    —————————–
    Revisionist history. Lombardi felt he had done as much as he could in GB, and left to take a lucrative job as Coach and gm of the Redskins.

    You must be thinking of Dan Devine

  20. Note to Mike,

    The only reason you have been this successful are 2 Gentlemen by the names of Favre & Rodgers.

    Trust me it’s not because of your dynamic Iso Route scheme.

  21. I’d love to say something snarky, and MM deserves snark for that lame statement, but my team sucks now too.

  22. The offense has been bad since Edgar Bennett took over as OC. That’s a fact.
    —–
    Ding ding ding….we have a winner!!

  23. Over all he is a highly successful coach. His record of 116–65–1 gives him a win % of .640 that puts him in the all time top 20. And none of that matters right now. A GM is supposed to provide players that can succeed and coaches are supposed to have them ready to go and put them in the best position to succeed . No matter how successful they have been in the past no one can say either Thompson or McCarthy is being very successful at this exact moment and this moment is the only one at hand.

  24. MM is a little delusional. The Packers aren’t playing great football by any means.

    AR is AR, but you cannot expect an inconsistent offense to keep up with a defense that allows 30+ a game. No running game, no deep threats, no defense. Recipe for further disaster. Keeping the norm is not the type of attitude we want to see.

    I believe in the team and AR, but the game plan has not worked for the past 1.5 seasons.

    -GB fan

  25. Mr. Potatohead, your message rings hollow to most fans and you’ve obviously lost your team.

    The Packers should promote Eliot Wolf to GM, and I think Josh McDaniels has earned another opportunity at a head coaching job.

  26. bigd9484 says:
    Nov 14, 2016 1:55 PM

    Please take TT with you on the way out, thanks. Been asking for this for 5 years
    ———————————————————–
    Right after they won a super bowl you wanted them fired?

  27. Does this mean the Packers are not in decline?
    Or that Mike is not the problem?
    And he’s wearing his bus driver’s hat now?

  28. gtodriver says:
    Nov 14, 2016 1:55 PM
    Mike needs to understand that the Packers kicked Vince Lombardi to the curb
    /////////////////////////////////////

    Do you ever tell the truth about anything? You’re a liar. You’re nothing but a trouble-making liar.

  29. pkrlvr says:
    Nov 14, 2016 2:24 PM

    The offense has been bad since Edgar Bennett took over as OC. That’s a fact.
    —–
    Ding ding ding….we have a winner!!

    =================================

    Are you two kidding me? You can’t be serious. You’re seriously going to blame Edgar friggen Bennett for the decline of MCCARTHY’S OFFENSE which is his baby and he calls all the plays. I’ve now seen all the excuses possible. Good grief!!!!

  30. Hey guys! All we have to do is fire Edgar Bennett. HE’S THE REAL PROBLEM! Fire him and we are back to putting up 30 points/game. SMDH…..

  31. …..Mike is getting HIS ‘message’ out there to prospective teams he’ll be interviewing for in 2017. Not a bad idea while you have the media at your disposal. The day after he gets released a half dozen teams will be calling his agent……

  32. Guess what, Mike? You’re not highly successful this year. Luckily, your division is tight, so you may just have enough time to get your team back to winning.

  33. Are you two kidding me? You can’t be serious. You’re seriously going to blame Edgar friggen Bennett for the decline of MCCARTHY’S OFFENSE which is his baby and he calls all the plays. I’ve now seen all the excuses possible. Good grief!!!!
    ——————————————————————–

    He’s certainly a big part part of it. McCarthy has proven great offensive mind, but he’s become predictable. My guess is Edgar Bennett (who was brought along by McCarthy) doesn’t ever question McCarthy or challenge the offense to do anything different. You can’t have “Yes men” in the coordinator positions when things are this off. I’m not opposed to replacing McCarthy after this year, but we NEED to replace our coordinators.

  34. Pretty good record over his tenure albeit with 2 QB’s to envy. Mediocre to poor record for selecting assistant coaches. One of the poorest in-game coaches I have ever witnessed. Spotty overall decision maker (ie giving up play calling last year when its his offense). To his credit he has a charter member of the Cheap Hall of fame in Thompson as a GM. Plus talking to media and fans is beneath Thompson.

    In balance I give him the rest of this year – but he needs to recognize the obvious and verbalize it, and make some changes – not stick his head in the sand. I’d probably start by demanding some help from Thompson or telling Thompson he can go coach the team.

    Lastly McCarthy has always had a bit of a vibe that he does not himself believe that he is worthy. I think players pick up on that.

  35. What an arrogant ass. That quote right there is what will get him fired! He has become to predictable, doesn’t make change during the week or during game play, And we get the same old rhetoric every week and then he says this! Wow! Has made some poor coaching decisions as of late and it is time to go! #MakethePackersgreatagain!!

  36. And soon to be “Highly successful unemployed NFL coach”

    In Green Bay, the standard is higher and when you are given a team that Vegas gave the best odds to get to the Superbowl at the beginning of the season and you are 4-5 halfway thru, it’s hard to blame anybody but the coaches.

    He might not want to embrace that the chair he is sitting in is getting hot but claiming to be a successful coach when you are under .500 is not the right PR strategy.

  37. I’m a highly successful coach…who has had an all time great as my QB .

    Take Rodgers off that team and they’d be back to the crapfest that were the 70s and 80s Packers.

    Mike is such a chump.

  38. He might have well yelled, “I drive a DODGE STRATUS!” — Will Ferrell

    I’ve been a supporter of Coach MM. He does have an impressive record. It’s been a good run.

    However, it’s time. They are no longer listening inside the locker room. It’s just time.

    Packer fans, this is deja vu. Yes, it got this bad or worse a decade ago. All-Pro quarterback starts tuning out coaching (justified or not). McCarthy’s discipline re-focused Favre. But it will be 2017 soon; now a new coach needs to refocus Rodgers.

  39. I have what lost little respect I have for Mike McCarthy and the Packers. This tool seriously just pulled the Jeff Fisher card. Nobody cares what you did in the past. Bottom line is that today you suck. Jeff Fisher has only been good in 1999,2000,2002, 2003, 2007,and 2008. In those 6 years he is 72-54. Taking those anomalies aside he is 100-107 in his coaching career. He is a mediocre coach. In 16 of his 22 seasons he has been 8-8 or worse. That means he has only had a winning season 27% of the time. Just as it is asinine for Jeff Fisher to say he is a good coach. So too is it asinine for Mike McCarthy to say he is a good coach.

  40. Yes, the only reason McCarthy is successful is two Hall of Fame QBs, excellent personnel management, lack of a meddling owner, great play calling, unyielding fan support, and two generations of quality football. Otherwise he sucks!

  41. “I’m a highly successful NFL coach,”

    If you have to remind people of something then it probably isn’t true any longer. He’s 1-4 in his last five. Nothing successful about that and downright alarming to hear him sounding like everything is just great.

  42. Pride growth before the fall, mcstuffin. As you once told hof gb Brett Favre, the train has left the station, yours is warming up. If you want to see a highly successful coach look at a picture of bill belichick.

  43. “Look, we’re in a crappy division, are only one game out of first place, and believe it or not are still in mathematical contention for home field advantage. No need to panic in this crappy year.”

  44. I have to deal with “dear in headlights” Caldwell, but at least Caldwell doesn’t get up to the podium lauding his efforts in the past.

    NFL is a “what have you done for me lately” league, Mickey, might not want to beat your chest when you’re down.

  45. not sure why everyone is surprised…the packers have been a 1 player pony for years now

  46. glac1 says:
    Nov 14, 2016 2:12 PM
    The Packers are a patient organization and one the most successful. Remember that.

    ********************************************************

    Actually the Steelers have 6 Lombardi trophies. The Packers are not the most successful franchise. Deal with it.

  47. gtodriver says:
    Nov 14, 2016 1:55 PM
    Mike needs to understand that the Packers kicked Vince Lombardi to the curb.
    —————————–
    Revisionist history. Lombardi felt he had done as much as he could in GB, and left to take a lucrative job as Coach and gm of the Redskins.

    You must be thinking of Dan Devine
    **********************************************
    C’mon guys!
    Lombardi RETIRED from coaching following Superbowl 2 in February of 1968 and remained as the Packers GM through the 1968 season and until spring of 1969. He then resigned as GM to return to coaching and took the job as Head Coach and GM of the Redskins. He coached the ‘Skins’ for one season and died of colon cancer on Sept 3, 1970. Nobody ever “kicked Lombardi to the curb”!
    You know, if you don’t really know the facts, there is this thing called “Google”, try it sometime!

  48. McCarthy has had all his success largely because of the QB play of Brett Favre and Aaron Rodgers.
    I think McCarthy is a good coach, but he’s far from a great one. The meltdown the Packers had in that infamous choke job against Seattle in the playoffs was a prime example of McCarthy failing to gather the troops and get control of his team.
    He can trump his horn all he wants, but he has plenty of shortcomings as a HC. He has never been a good game day coach. I’ve seen tons of games where he doesn’t make adjustments that are obvious to everyone.
    He is also very stubborn and I would think he is very boring to listen to from his player’s standpoint. He recites the same things over and over — “pad level too high”, etc….
    McCarthy is feeling the heat and it’s deserved. Injuries or no injuries, they have played like garbage the last two weeks against two mediocre teams.
    I am firmly reversing my opinion and I want McCarthy gone at the end of the year. The Packers and Aaron Rodgers deserve better, and so do the fans.

  49. Just like their fans.. in the face of adversity, repeat back to previous success. They deserve each other.

  50. i’ve said it before, but the best way to keep your job in the nfl is to beat women, and /or cut children’s scrotums with a stick.

    i didn’t decide this it is just the facts. period.

    free alshon.

  51. Mike McCarthy on fixing Packers: I’m a highly successful NFL coach
    —–
    Yea just like P. Manning’s QB coach in Denver is the most successful QB coach ever.

    Ever wonder why packer fans fall in love with what their team did decades ago regardless of how bad they are today?

    Their coach is the same way.

  52. So the Packers have had a struggle or two, but they’ve been one of the best teams in the league over the last 20 years or so. It doesn’t always mean they’re being outcoached. Coaches get way too much blame when things go bad, and way too much credit when things go good. Other than Jim Harbaugh, who are you going to hire that’s any better? Nobody!

  53. Boy did McCarthy get ripped on local and national sports talk radio. He really came off as a buffoon with the “highly successful head coach” statement. Why did he feel the need to give us his resume’? His days at Green Bay are numbered. If this incompetence continues he’ll be out the day after the end of the season. It’s time for Thompson to ride off into the sunset also. These two might be highly regarded by the NFL establishment but this team needs new blood. I think Rodgers needs it more than anyone.

  54. In Teddy We Trust says:
    Nov 14, 2016 2:40 PM
    As a Viking fan, it’s nice to know that the Packers can fill the entertainment void during the current losing streak.
    ———————
    First thumbs up I’ve ever given you Teddy

  55. The Almighty Cabbage says:
    Nov 14, 2016 8:18 PM
    If McCarthy is so bad, what does that say for Zimmy The Chimp?
    ——–
    Really? That’s what you got? Getting desperate. Hey, let’s see your QB get hurt and see if you can finally win a game. Seriously. 9-12 in your last 21, with a supposed hall of fame QB.

  56. “Hey, let’s see your QB get hurt and see if you can finally win a game.”

    The Vikings fans have multiple legit injuries to use as an excuse, but the upgrade at QB isn’t one of them.

  57. Kinda puzzled why he said that. Generally this coach articulate his words wisely but this could doom him or be great substance of R-E-L-A-X

  58. Mike, have you looked at the players lately? They look uninspired, they have zero fire and at times they look positively sad. Not even that kind of weird sad that Eli Manning has looked his whole career, but just downright cannot-care-less sad. That’s on you and your staff. Oh, and the atrocious play-calling, all three phases…? Yeah, that’s not helping either.

  59. onebones says:
    Other than Jim Harbaugh, who are you going to hire that’s any better?
    —-
    It’s a GM’s job to know who the next suitable guy should be, not the casual fans’. There are no Bill Belichicks sitting unemployed, waiting for a call, but there are potentially good coaches in the college ranks or among the coordinators in the league. Did anyone think John Harbagh would win a Super Bowl when he become a head coach in Baltimore after only being a special teams coach previously?

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.