Jeff Garcia wants to coach the 49ers

Getty Images

As the 49ers search for a new coach, one of the team’s former quarterback’s wants a shot at the job. But he’s sufficiently realistic to know he has no chance.

“Let’s be honest with each other. As much as I believe and feel that I am capable of leading a team, people don’t want you to be able to take the shortcut,” Garcia said Wednesday on KNBR, via NBCBayArea.com. “They want you to go through the process — they want you to start as the assistant, they want you to work your way up to the coordinator, they want you to work your way into that head coach position.”

“They” would be, you know, the owners of NFL teams, who believe that it’s important for a coach to have credibility among the players, the staff, the media, and the fan base. That credibility comes from paying dues and learning the craft and developing skills and growing in to the job.

“I tell you what — the 17 years of professional football experience that I have in my backpocket, and the years of growing up around a father who was a head coach and just being around the game — have prepared me to be the leader of a football team,” Garcia said. “And that’s what this team needs — they need a leader of the football team. . . . They need somebody who is gonna come in and is not gonna take any trash; not gonna take any instability as far as the personality is concerned, and understand that this has to be about the team. It can’t be about your individual success, it can’t be about your individual contract; it’s gotta be about the team.”

On one hand, the 49ers couldn’t do much worse with Garcia than they did with Chip Kelly or Jim Tomsula. On the other hand, it would be a risky move for a team that currently is viewed as one of the most dysfunctional in the league.

With a fine line between thinking outside the box and being effin’ nutty, few would assume that the 49ers have suddenly found the next Bill Walsh in the form of a former quarterback who believes he can do the job.

71 responses to “Jeff Garcia wants to coach the 49ers

  1. I actually like the idea. Not just any player could pull it off, but a cerebral, gritty guy like Garcia could probably do better than half the coaches in the League right now. When he played he approached the position like a coach on the field.

  2. “They” would be, you know, the owners of NFL teams, who believe that it’s important for a coach to have credibility among the players, the staff, the media, and the fan base.
    ______________________

    Or maybe in this case “They” would be the owners of the Niners self proclaimed owner. You know, the ones he calls Mom & Dad

  3. Going 2-14 is effin’ nutty, doing everything one can to find the best person possible for the job of achieving maximum team potential is priceless ‘n’ sane.

  4. Why not? The 49ers players showed everyone they’ll follow ANYONE by voting Kaep as their most “inspirational” teammate.

  5. ““They” would be, you know, the owners of NFL teams, who believe that it’s important for a coach to have credibility among the players, the staff, the media, and the fan base.”

    They would also be the coaching fraternity, many of which never played the game or not beyond high school or possibly college, and would be jealous of Garcia.

    There is a lot of nepotism and good ol’ boy network among the coaches, and they don’t like fresh faces. Imagine if Garcia came in and did well in his first season? He would be embarrassing a lot of coaches that had not done well even after “paying their dues”.

  6. Given how specialized the NFL has become over the years (with some head coaches now leaving both their offenses and defenses totally to their coordinators) it wouldn’t be impossible for somebody with good motivational and organizational skills to step straight into being a head coach.

    The opposite extreme of the NFL would be the NBA where guys can retire and be a head coach tomorrow. And it seems like the success rate of those guys is roughly similar to those who have been around a long time paying their dues. Steve Kerr had never coached at all prior to the Warriors and Luke Walton is doing well with the Lakers now after having had minimal experience as an assistant.

  7. Former Qb’s tend to make the best head coaches (in general). Any dude who was a QB in the NFL for 11 years is obviously extremely intelligent when it comes to the game.

  8. How is it any more laughable than ANOTHER Patriots assistant as ANOTHER team’s savior?

    didn’t you know? They all worship BB so when they take these jobs, they intentionally sabotage the job so as to not embarrass the hoodie…

    in all honesty, there is no BB coaching tree. As far as Im concerned, hes still part of the Parcells tree…

    have a few of his assistants actually be good head coaches and that may change

  9. There aren’t a lot of coaching candidates that I’m looking at as “bad” choices, but the worst choice would be one that doesn’t have a unified vision with the GM.

  10. He’s got more passion to win than any other staff member or owner since Jim Harbaugh. Apparently he thinks he’s got it. Give the guy a shot. San Fran loves him

  11. Like the dork that keeps asking out the prom queen and getting rejected. Give it up Jeff. Not that it could be much worse than what we had but I just don’t see Jeff as that guy.

  12. arwiv says:
    Jan 4, 2017 7:57 PM

    Former Qb’s tend to make the best head coaches (in general). Any dude who was a QB in the NFL for 11 years is obviously extremely intelligent when it comes to the game.

    Does the name Bart Star ring a bell? One of the all time great QBs, not so much as a coach.

  13. Yes please give him a chance – I want the 49er’s to spend a few more years in the Loser’s circle.

    Look Jeffy – go be a position coach or a co-ordinater. Look it is not like you are the son of a coach where you are hanging around it at home or the team facility all the time. You are sitting at home out of it for years and you expect to be knowledgeable about what is going on and how they are using technology know, and what teams are doing. Give your head a good shake and you will hear marbles rolling around. The least you should do is go be an assistant or coach in the CFL or college.

  14. Jeff,

    There’s more that goes into coaching than playing experience and leadership. Trust me I know.

    Signed,

    Mike Singletary
    Ex-49ers coach

  15. By the way, Jeff. I want to coach the Packers, too. I have about as much of a chance coaching them as you do coaching the Niners, unless the Niners are even more foolish than I thought they were.

  16. How could he possibly be worse than what they had. Perhaps not leaps and bounds greater. But no way worse.

  17. This is crazy first off the last time we remember this guy with ties to the Niners in the Bay Area he was circling the parking lot of the San Jose State University intoxicated. Second he was an offensive assistant of the LA Rams and look how they did this year.

  18. Happens in the NBA, MLB, NHL (former players getting top job with no previous coaching experience) – but in the NFL, with it’s “we’re better and more important than anyone else” attitude – it will be tough. Does that mean NFL Head Coach is a tougher job than NBA Coach, MLB Manager or NHL Head Coach? Of course not! But everyone involved with the NFL will try to convince you it is. Plus, these guys have, what – 15 assistants? Would love to see the Niners give Garcia a shot.

  19. arwiv says:
    Jan 4, 2017 7:57 PM
    Former Qb’s tend to make the best head coaches (in general). Any dude who was a QB in the NFL for 11 years is obviously extremely intelligent when it comes to the game.
    ======================================

    Then why did so many people rip Jay Cutler for calling out that bloated clown Mike Martz?
    Cutler was getting abused every single game under Martz and I am pretty sure he knew more about being an NFL QB than Martz did.
    He never played QB at any level.
    Ever.
    Martz drifted from school to school every two years until he started doing the same thing in the NFL.
    He was just in the right place at the right time in St. Louis. He has never done anything before or after that stint.
    There are a lot of NFL coaches that have surprisingly weak resumes.
    A clipboard and an extra 60 lbs does not make you some kind of guru.

  20. Blackpool says:
    Jan 4, 2017 9:01 PM

    How could he possibly be worse than what they had. Perhaps not leaps and bounds greater. But no way worse.
    —————————–
    I understand the sentiment that the previous occupants post-Harbaugh were pathetic, that is no reason to hire someone that is unqualified with no prior experience to do the job.
    That is not to say if he is motivated to coach and be a leader of men and wants to start as a quality assistant or QB coach and earn promotions to higher levels he wouldn’t be good at it. I don’t know and neither do you.
    The notion of paying his dues to please the people that came before him is ridiculous as well. If he does well as a position coach he gets promoted or gets hired for a better job elsewhere. Look at the Buffalo RB coach who ended up the HC by season end and now is a hot commodity.

  21. Garcia is such a bad-a@@, he could probably start and outplay both Kap and Gabbert right now.

  22. I like Garcia. I think he was a good QB. I know he knows the game. He’s probably thinking that if Donald Trump could get the job of president with no experience in politics, why can’t he get a head coaching job. It’s worth a shot.

  23. Could be a good coach but he’s not shown a whole lot of interest in the professio before now. I would say spend a couple of years as a special teams assistant move to QB coach for a few and then to a coordinator spot. Then ask for the job. The 9ners will be a few more coaches in by that time.

  24. arwiv says:
    Jan 4, 2017 7:57 PM
    Former Qb’s tend to make the best head coaches (in general). Any dude who was a QB in the NFL for 11 years is obviously extremely intelligent when it comes to the game.
    ===================================
    Not true at all. Of the 5 NFL QB’s that have become head coaches and are in the HOF, only one, Bart Starr, took his team to the playoffs, and that was in the strike season.

    Kubiak and Flores have won Super Bowls.

    There are a lot of QB’s, such as Zorn, Spurrier, June Jones, and others that have done lousy jobs.

    Of the Top 50 NFL Coaches (in regards to wins), only 5 of them were QB’s, and only 1 or 2 of those played in the NFL.

  25. NFCW looks to be garbage for the foreseeable future. The only good team is the Seahawks (for whom I root) and they barely got ten wins this year – they could have easily lost to MIA, ATL BUF and SF. The only reason anyone still has hope for this season in Seattle is because of one great game the Hawks played two months ago in Foxboro. Take that game away and Seahawks would have ended the year around #17 in most power rankings.

    Garcia should try to get signed on as the QB coach. 3 HC in 3 years doesn’t bode well for #4. But if Garcia rides it out and does something to make Colin Kaepernick into an NFL starter, he could be sitting pretty in a couple years and maybe take over a much improved team

  26. Jeff Garcia has been mentoring players and was on the staff for the Montreal Alouettes. I don’t agree that he should be offered the San Francisco HC job but it’s not like he’s just been sitting on the couch since retirement.

  27. dylanjharper says:
    Jan 4, 2017 8:04 PM
    There aren’t a lot of coaching candidates that I’m looking at as “bad” choices, but the worst choice would be one that doesn’t have a unified vision with the GM.
    =====================

    What GM? They don’t have one yet. It’s insane that they are interviewing HC candidates without having one

  28. In a league where Rich Kotite is actually employed as a head coach for more than 1 game, Garcia will never be the worst coach in NFL history.

    That being said, it sounds like he doesn’t want to be an assistant, and that’s not a good look. After these head coaching hires are made, there will be plenty of coordinator and position coaching slots open. Why not apply for one of those and prove you can coach?

  29. Always wondered about Garcia until I read two Playboy Playmates got in a catfight over him. That’s my idol.

  30. Crazy so many want to see it? He’s made it as high as being a QB coach in the CFL. I’d rather have someone with a lot more experience than that.

    The same people saying they want to see it will be the first ones to say “What kind of idiot hires an NFL HC with no experience?”

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.