NFL reviewing application of concussion protocol on Matt Moore hit

Getty Images

After questions were raised about why Dolphins quarterback Matt Moore was cleared to return to Sunday’s game just minutes after taking a helmet-to-helmet hit, the league has decided to review the matter.

The NFL said today that it is reviewing the application of the concussion protocol after Pittsburgh’s Bud Dupree hit Moore, drawing a roughing the passer penalty.

The Dolphins said the team medical staff treated Moore on the field and an independent neurologist examined him on the sideline, and once he was cleared, he was allowed to return to the game — having missed just one play.

That didn’t sit right with many observers, who thought it seemed impossible that Moore could be OK to return so quickly after such a hit. The league plans to review video of the play and the treatment Moore received afterward, as well as interview everyone involved.

“This review reflects the seriousness with which we take our obligation to ensure the health and safety of our players,” the league said in a statement. “It is important to note that initiation of this process does not mean that we have drawn conclusions as to whether the protocol was followed.”

Moore said after the game that he was OK.

56 responses to “NFL reviewing application of concussion protocol on Matt Moore hit

  1. He is one tough SOB.
    Probably should not have been allowed back on the field; man he took some nasty hits out there.

  2. MONSTER HIT.. I SAW IT Live, and thought omg no way does he come back in…then he comes back in 85 seconds? they didn’t check crap. now they have to cover their backsides

  3. Are they gonna review the Seahawks for how they handled Thomas Rawls in concussion protocol as well. Seemed to me he just threw a fit and was allowed to go back in immediately after

  4. He’s a tough kid. Give him credit for laying it on the line. He gained a lot of respect league-wide with his return. Unlike Cameron Newton jumping backwards with a world championship on the line

  5. NY Times has an interesting brain injury article up right now that suggests a front hit to the jaw would not be as bad as a blow to the side of the head. This is in part because the two hemispheres of the brain are connected by a fibrous tissue that causes deeper intracranial flexing, and presumably injury, on side impacts that flex both halves from side to side like Jello. Also, I am not a doctor.

  6. Although he is a gamer and probably felt as though he could perform there is no chance he was good to go after one play off. But it was a playoff game so…

    In 5yrs when he’s out of the league he will sue NFL for letting him go back in the game and causing irreversible brain damage.

    In order for the NFL to protect itself, it must first protect the players from themselves.

  7. It’s really not that hard. Why not have a guy up in the replay booth whose job is to watch the telecast and determine right then if he has to come off the field? We all saw it and it looked bad. Make it so that the concussed (allegedly) player has to be evaluated and miss either the rest of their series or 10 minutes (whichever happens first) at a minimum. Sure, a few guys who aren’t concussed will complain legitimately, but as we’ve all seen, we have to save these guys from themselves.

  8. Not all hard hits to the head are concussions. I whacked my cheekbone hard with a hand truck handle and was a bit dizzy and nauseous for a couple days but no way was it a concussion.

    That said– I was surprised to see him back out there too! Bet he’s one sore dude today.

  9. Maybe the NFL should investigate how Moore can be decapitated and then Dupree, the guilty party, is barely breathed on and Dolphins end up with a first and 25.

  10. It amazes me that Moore took that illegal helmet to helmet hit and after the play Ajayi shoves a Steeler player and the Dolphins next play is a 1st and 25.

  11. Did Moore feel comfortable going back out on the field? Than let him. These are adults (well, all of them except OBJ and Joey Porter).

  12. A brain jarring game eating itself and arguing about how not to injure the brain.

    It’s over.

  13. Moore sounded pretty good in the press conference afterwards. Could be, he was okay.

    What is not okay is how the net-net was a 1st and 25 for the Dolphins. What is not okay is how Dupree wasn’t ejected on the spot for that hit. And I couldn’t care less about either team.

    Officiating this weekend was pretty poor. Perreria has it right, keep the crews together.

  14. Seriously, Moore said his jaw and back were hurt. Both the Fins and an NFL guy questioned him and said he was good to go. Go ahead, investigate all you want. We’ll see you in the playoffs next year.

  15. 305phinphan says:
    Jan 9, 2017 4:21 PM

    It amazes me that Moore took that illegal helmet to helmet hit and after the play Ajayi shoves a Steeler player and the Dolphins next play is a 1st and 25.
    ————————————————————
    The NFL at it’s finest.

    Obvious unnecessary roughness, but this is only called when it’s another team hitting a Steeler player.

  16. schmokes says:
    Jan 9, 2017 4:24 PM

    Did Moore feel comfortable going back out on the field? Than let him. These are adults (well, all of them except OBJ and Joey Porter).

    oh for gods sake..if u are concussed, u cant make that decision yourself.. did he feel comfortable? grow up

  17. The NFL is a joke.
    Every time there is an obvious head hit, the league has to review its policies. The league just doesn’t care about it’s players all it cares about is it’s image( $$$$$$$$$$$$$$ ).
    Roger Sucks!

  18. hit looked what-used-to-be-clean, but now looked like targeting. although the head was clean on the chin, it did not appear that the impact was directed at the head.

  19. He didn’t lose consciousness. The NFL doctor asked him some questions on the sideline and apparently he answered them all successfully to be allowed back onto the field. Q’s such as “What is the score?” What’s the problem?

  20. “The Dolphins said the team medical staff treated Moore on the field”

    Um, what? How do you “treat” a concussion while the guy is still laid out on the field?

  21. So, and admission that it was a helmet-to-helmet hit, but it’s the Dolphins being investigated?

    Sounds about right.

  22. kindapumpkin21 says:
    Jan 9, 2017 4:21 PM
    Maybe the NFL should investigate how Moore can be decapitated and then Dupree, the guilty party, is barely breathed on and Dolphins end up with a first and 25.

    This x1000. They should be trying to figure out how Dupree for the 2nd time tried to maim the qb and was allowed back in the game. Garbage play from a garbage team. Looking forward to watching them get smoked next week

  23. kenberthiaume says:
    Jan 9, 2017 4:33 PM
    no penalty on the play of course.
    ________________

    Didn’t watch the game, didn’t read the article or both?

    “The NFL said today that it is reviewing the application of the concussion protocol after Pittsburgh’s Bud Dupree hit Moore, drawing a roughing the passer penalty.”

  24. Dupree should be banned for life for that dirty hit. Another cheating Steeler. Disgusting.

  25. Dupree was flagged for a 15 yard penalty, for a foul that happened during the play. Ajayi got flagged for a personal foul after the play. The Dolphins moved forward 15 yards and a 1st down for the foul on the play. They proceeded to move back 15 yards to make it 1st and 25 for a foul that happened after the first penalty was assessed. That is how fouls that happen during the play and dead ball fouls work.

    Complaining why Dupree wasn’t ejected? Did the NFL add a targeting rule? Was that his second unsportsmanlike conduct foul? Are you implying there was an intent to injury? The hit would’ve been legal had Dupree not make contact with Moore’s head.

  26. The hit shouldn’t even have been flagged Moore was out of the pocket running forward and Dupree didn’t lead with hit helmet he lead with his hands.
    Next there was a considerable delay from the time of the hit till the time Moore went back out because of the scrum that followed.
    Moore didn’t appear woozy or rattled possibly because saw the hit coming.

  27. mark4steelers says:
    Jan 9, 2017 4:11 PM
    Clean hit, shouldn’t have drawn flag.

    ————————————–

    Hi Warren Sapp! So cool that you have the free time to interact with fans on a message board.

    Your pal, Chad Clifton

  28. yeah… they claim they’re going to review it every time a QB gets ko’d. But nothing happens cuz it’s the starting QB.

  29. The Steelers were head hunting for the entire first half. So how does Burfict get 3 game suspension for the hit on A Brown but none of the cheap shot artists on the Steelers get a suspension? Be ready KC, because the Steelers are out to head hunt all game if you keep it close or are winning!

  30. “many observers… thought it seemed impossible that Moore could be OK to return so quickly after such a hit”

    An independent neurologist examined him on the sideline. That neurologist determined him to be fine. Those observers were not there examining him directly, asking questions, checking physical and mental responses. They can go pound sand.

  31. Pretty good strategy. A couple of D men could make an on-field decision to disrupt the opposing team’s QB play deciding between them to eat the cost of a fine and then at an opportune moment make a helmet to helmet hit on the QB and thus enact concussion protocols. Takes the opposing QB out of play for at least 3-5 plays the first time. Twice, and QB is probably gone for the game. Might be tempting for an over matched team like the Texans.

  32. Dolphins CHEATED the protocol to get him back in. What a sorry excuse of a franchise to CHEAT with a player’s health.

  33. “This review reflects the seriousness with which we take our fear of being sued by the players again,” the league said in a statement. “It is important to note that initiation of this process does not mean that we are worried about anything but our own bank accounts, you all know we care zero about actual player safety.”

    There, that’s what the league statement really means.

  34. These guys are grown men being paid millions of dollars to do this. To me, it’s up to them. If a player feels like he got his bell rung and needs to take a series or a game off, then I support that 100% but if he wants to go back out and play the game knowing the repercussions, I support that too.. They play this game knowing the risks and are given the opportunity to be cautious if they need to. Let them manage their lives and stop telling these guys how they should play the game.

  35. The hit was ABSOLUTELY the definition of roughing the passer — launched himself with the crown of the helmet into Moore’s head. The biggest question for the officials and the NFL is why wasn’t the earlier hit by Dupree flagged? It was the same illegal launch and helmet to helmet contact.
    That being said, I’d like to see the same hits against Brady if they play each other.

  36. mark4steelers says:
    Jan 9, 2017 4:11 PM
    Clean hit, shouldn’t have drawn flag.
    metalman5150 says:
    Jan 9, 2017 4:39 PM
    …although the head was clean on the chin, it did not appear that the impact was directed at the head.
    ———————————————————-
    Only Steeler ultra-homies would defend that hit. And it wasn’t just illegal because the helmet hit Moore’s chin, but also that Dupree clearly charged with his head down and helmet first when he could just as easily shoulder-charged and/or wrapped the guy. You just can’t head-charge a player like that. Dupree should get a huge fine – and if I was commish, banned from next game for a couple of recent dirty hits.

  37. NFL Concussion Protocol. What a joke! It is a mere weak spin to mitigate the lawsuit damages that have yet to come. Bottom line, the NFL players are paid well but they are fungible assets, replaceable at moments notice, and the Big House doesn’t really care as long as ownership checks clear. Matt deserved better from the “NFL Protocol.”

  38. i dont see what the big deal is. the kid got his bell rung, just a small brain nick, no biggy. it was obvious for all of us watching at home that the INDEPENDANT doctor on the side line conducted himself profesionaly. people need 2 stop being so sensative!

  39. The guy was dizzy, and two steps slower after that hit. So what exactly does the League need to review again?

  40. The steelers are a hard hitting team not a dirty team. But if being called a dirty team gets into a teams head that’s half the battle. Pittsburgh has always had physical teams and once in a while someone gets hurt.

  41. Moore was out of the pocket and a runner at that point. Runners have helmet-to-helmet contact all the time and no penalty applies to that contact. No penalty should have been called on DuPree. Several experts, analysts and players have stated that since the hit.

    As for Moore retuning so quickly…This is nothing new to the Steelers. In Wk 16 versus the Bungles, Burfict was clearly concussed but was allowed to get right back in the game as well.

    NFL officiating is in a state of confusion spiraling downward.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.