Brandon Jacobs: Jim Harbaugh didn’t know what he was doing

Getty Images

Jim Harbaugh has had success everywhere he’s coached, but one of his former players was not impressed with their time together.

Brandon Jacobs, the retired running back who spent time playing for Harbaugh’s 49ers in 2012, left San Francisco not thinking highly of Harbaugh.

“Jim, I had a lot of respect for Jim when I was there – before I got to know him,” Jacobs said on CBS Sports Radio. “I enjoyed my time there, but we didn’t see eye-to-eye. I knew a little bit more about football than what they led on.”

Jacobs said Harbaugh didn’t have much of a grasp of the Xs and Os of coaching and that the assistants deserved more of the credit.

“Going somewhere where they don’t have route conversions into certain coverages was just absurd,” Jacobs said. “They’re just running routes in the defense, getting people killed. Size and strength is what they had, and that’s why they won. Let’s be real. They had great assistant coaches, but Jim didn’t know what he was doing. Jim had no idea. Jim is throwing slants into Cover-2 safeties, getting people hurt. That guy knew nothing, man.”

Jacobs was injured at the start of his 49ers tenure, a bench warmer once he got healthy, and eventually got suspended by the team and then released for complaining about his playing time on social media. So it’s not exactly a surprise that he doesn’t have fond memories of his time with Harbaugh.

96 responses to “Brandon Jacobs: Jim Harbaugh didn’t know what he was doing

  1. Didn’t expect to see a quote from Jacobs after all this time. Hope he’s still enjoying his ‘fast ass car’. Thanks for the Super Bowl memories!

  2. Sorry, you don’t make the Super Bowl by being a moron head coach with Kaep as your QB. I’m pretty sure Jimmy is at the very least a competent coach.

  3. Yup everyone knows you get to a Super Bowl by pure luck and not knowing x’s and o’s. Jim might be different but a bad coach has never been on is resume. Just look what what he did in his 1st yr at Michigan with a bunch of guys that were under 500 to a double digit win team.

  4. Jacobs and Harbaugh not seeing eye to eye is totally different than Harbaugh not knowing what he was doing.

    Harbaugh’ record in college and the pros speaks for hitself.

  5. “Jim is throwing slants into Cover-2 safeties, getting people hurt.”

    Axe to grind? Sure – but are we sure that’s an invalid point? The comment about not having the option routes for specific coverages, etc doesn’t seem like a bad observation to me

  6. See, now this goes along with my theory that Harbaugh benefited from the great work of Mike Singletary. He took over a great team and we’re still scratching our heads why Alex Smith was benched for Kaep.

  7. Harbaugh came within a stone’s throw of winning the Super Bowl with the second worst starting QB in SB history – the worst being our very own Rex Grossman. So, ya, they guy must know a thing or two.

  8. Judge a man by his results over an extended period of time and you can tell if he knows what he is doing or is “just lucky” (which is what ill-informed losers often say).

    I don’t like Harbaugh, but to say he does not know how to coach is just stupid and says more about you than him.

  9. scrp2 says:
    May 26, 2017 11:31 AM
    See, now this goes along with my theory that Harbaugh benefited from the great work of Mike Singletary. He took over a great team and we’re still scratching our heads why Alex Smith was benched for Kaep.

    ____________________________________

    So what about Stanford, or Michigan? your theory doesn’t hold much water. Also, if Singletary was such a great coach, why is he out of the league for the last 2 years?

  10. This shouldn’t come as a surprise – Harbaugh gets WAY too much credit for SF’s success during his tenure there. It had a roster that was quickly coming together BEFORE he arrived, so he inherited a team on the upswing. At its peak, it had a number of veterans, and a good coach would have helped lead the roster into a transition. Instead, he contributed to it atrophying, and then jumped ship when he saw it would be going down soon enough.

    Arrived at the right time, left at the right time – that’s the only reason it looks like he was the reason for the winning seasons.

  11. When the Jacobs and the Giants played the 49ers in the NFC Championship game, Harbaugh was severely outclassed by Old Man Tom. In a bone-crushing game that was going to come down to which team made the big mistake, Harbaugh used a punt returner with fumbling problems, while Tom had his guy fair catch everything. We all know how that ended.

  12. Brandon Jacobs should just shut up. He has been a disruption for a while, one of the reasons he doesn’t have an NFL job right now. Maybe he took too many blows to the head.

  13. BWAH- HAHAHAHA!!! LOL!!!! “I knew a little bit more about football than what they led on.” HAHAHAHAHAHA!! Oh, please let there be more insightful quotes coming our way from Mr. Jacobs….

  14. Jacobs was supposed to help them score TD in the red zone. Unfortuately it didn’t work out. They continued to lack the ability to score rushing TDs. In fact, they did not try to run the ball when they got close to the end zone in the final drive of the SB. They attempted all passes. The lack of a short yardage back was perhaps the Achilles Heel of Harbaugh’s 4 year run in Frisco.

  15. Even assuming Jacobs was correct a mark of a good head coach is finding top-notch assistants. Harbaugh can be a very difficult guy to like but he knows how to win football games.

  16. Harbaugh definitely knows a thing or two. Whether that thing or two includes converting routes against different coverages… well, maybe he’s not so good for that.

    Another potential argument–he was playing Kaep, would Kaep have known what to do with a converted route? It never sounded like he had the best grasp of the offense to begin with.

  17. The 49ers had the best team in the league for that three-year period. They were in a very strong position to win one Super Bowl, and to get to two others. And they ended up with nothing. That seems to be a coaching issue.

    I think Harbaugh is a good pro coach; I don’t think he is a great pro coach. I think he got greedy with the switch from Smith to Kaepernick.

  18. willyalistentothis says:
    May 26, 2017 11:35 AM
    When the Jacobs and the Giants played the 49ers in the NFC Championship game, Harbaugh was severely outclassed by Old Man Tom. In a bone-crushing game that was going to come down to which team made the big mistake, Harbaugh used a punt returner with fumbling problems, while Tom had his guy fair catch everything. We all know how that ended.

    ————–

    I don’t think that was a big coaching blunder.

    As a side note, that was one of the best games I have ever watched. I think that was Eli’s greatest game.

  19. So how many people died running slants while he was there Brandon? I mean, not to doubt him or anything, Im sure it was a bloodbath, just wondering the exact tally.

  20. Harbaugh’ record in college and the pros speaks for hitself.

    “Might get to the big game, but can’t win it.”

  21. Harbaugh could t make second half adjustments, so the fans made excuses for him and earned their nickname “whiners”. He’s moved on but nothing has changed. Nothing is all they get, this century. Good luck with the rebuild guys.

  22. Not only has Harbs been a winner at San Diego, Stanford, Santa Clara & Michigan – but every single one of those programs was a dumpster fire when he arrived, only to be turned around by Harbs & staff. For some idiot bench warmer who wound up getting suspended for complaining to try to claim (years later no less) that the guy doesn’t know what he’s doing is comedy gold.

    Somehow Kaepernick didn’t get mentioned here, a minor miracle.

  23. Who ya gonna believe? A fat complainer who’s out of football entirely or a successful coach for multiple teams, both college and pro? Harbaugh may be an insufferable jerk but he’s a great coach. He might even be lacking in the Xs & Os department, but he’s obviously an outstanding team leader.

  24. cafetero1075 says:
    May 26, 2017 11:43 AM
    Getting to NFC championship games and a SB with Kaepernick is enough to prove he’s a great coach.

    ——————

    You people forget that Alex Smith won most of the games that season….then he got hurt and was replaced by Kaep. If Harbaugh started Smith in the SB they may have won….

  25. When the Jacobs and the Giants played the 49ers in the NFC Championship game, Harbaugh was severely outclassed by Old Man Tom. In a bone-crushing game that was going to come down to which team made the big mistake. We all know how that ended.
    ——-
    Ahmad Bradshaw fumbled the ball with 1 minute to go on his own 25 yard line. Ref ruled that his “forward progress” was stopped. No fumble. Non reviewable play. Selective memory by the New Jersey Giant’s fans much?

  26. Ha as evidence by the team going to complete trash when he left. Jim is one hell of a coach. Bremen Jacobs had one year over a thousand if I remember correctly and that was it. If he was so intelligent regarding football, why wasn’t his career stats better?

  27. While he clearly has an axe to grind, his criticisms of Harbaugh are pretty specific and make sense from a FB perspective. On the other hand, you don’t win a lot of FB gms because you’re ‘big and strong’. Everybody in the league is big and strong.

  28. Why do people keep mentioning Michigan? All he’s done at Michigan is beat mid-tier Big 10 teams. You can add that to the list if he ever beats Meyer or wins the conference.

  29. Bandon Jacob’s comments were exaggerated but there is some truth to what he said. Harbaugh’s strengths were in motivating his players and assembling a really good staff, particularly on the defensive side of the ball. The team won with a defensive first philosophy and smash mouth football on offense. Harbaugh was also good at working one on one with the QBs also. Harbaugh’s weakness was with X’s and O’s. He was never a coordinator at the NFL level. The team under Harbaugh had issues making second half adjustments and Harbaugh was stubborn in making changes that would improve the offense

  30. Harbaugh could t make second half adjustments, so the fans made excuses for him and earned their nickname “whiners”. He’s moved on but nothing has changed. Nothing is all they get, this century. Good luck with the rebuild guys.

    ________________________________’

    We will, enjoy your coming downfall. We hear the window closing shut all the way down here and you can forget about the next century also

  31. Harbaugh could t make second half adjustments, so the fans made excuses for him and earned their nickname “whiners”. He’s moved on but nothing has changed. Nothing is all they get, this century. Good luck with the rebuild guys.

    _____________________________

    We will enjoy are rebuild. You enjoy your coming downfall. We can hear that window slamming shut all the way down here. The century will be barren for you also. One and done

  32. Always love the hit pieces Florio throws at Harbaugh, because he put two middle fingers up to the league and went back to college. It still bothers the NFL mouthpieces that he would dare CHOOSE another job than The Almighty Shield.

  33. Everyone seems to forget that Harbaugh was not that loved among his players. Virtually nobody defended him when he was fired.

  34. stoolerz says:
    May 26, 2017 12:45 PM
    So what has Harbaugh won at Michigan?
    ————————-
    He took over a middling 5-7 team with an awful recruiting class and promptly went 20-6 and signed two Top 10 classes. But yea, he’s won and done nothing. Dope.

  35. This aligns perfectly with the fact Jim Harbaugh thinks Colin Kaepernick can be a great NFL quarterback.

  36. Don’t get the MI talk either. Last year they almost never played away from home. When they did – they lost. Inflated results based on a stacked deck against poor teams.

    Stanford seems to be doing just ok without him too. Oh, you’ll point to Luck but as a pro – Luck loves him some INT

  37. He won in San Diego, won at Stanford, won in SF, won in Michigan

    I think he knows what he’s doing

    The only thing he can’t do? Beat Ohio State.

  38. Barry Switzer won a Super Bowl in Dallas. Let’s not pretend Harbaugh is some mastermind because he inherited an excellent team and made the conference championship game a few times.

  39. What has Harbaugh won at Michigan? No, they didn’t win the Big Ten this year but had a great team that won a lot of games and almost ended up in the Final Four. The game against OSU was classic. As far as bringing Michigan back from a losing program, you have to consider that this team was Brady Hoke’s recruits. NOW we get to see Harbaugh’s teams. I must say, I think Harbaugh has brought in the most innovative offenses that I’ve seen at Michigan and I’ve been watching since the 50’s.

  40. We will enjoy are rebuild. You enjoy your coming downfall. We can hear that window slamming shut all the way down here. The century will be barren for you also. One and done
    ______________

    I assume you are talking about the Seahawks. From a NFC east fan’s perspective, the Hawks are still scary when healthy. The Niners are a joke even when healthy. Good luck with Blaine Gabbert!

  41. I think Brandon may be on to something, but he makes the wrong conclusion. If Harbaugh doesn’t run option routes and puts his guys in positions to get killed on slants, that doesn’t mean he doesn’t understand football. It means he thinks little of his players and doesn’t care if they get hurt accomplishing his goals.

    So, it really reinforces what we already know about Harbaugh. Successful coach, but not a good guy.

  42. 6250claimer says:
    May 26, 2017 12:02 PM
    Not only has Harbs been a winner at San Diego, Stanford, Santa Clara & Michigan – but every single one of those programs was a dumpster fire when he arrived, only to be turned around by Harbs & staff. For some idiot bench warmer who wound up getting suspended for complaining to try to claim (years later no less) that the guy doesn’t know what he’s doing is comedy gold.
    ____________________________

    Ummmmmmm.

    He won the Pioneer Football League championship at San Diego.

    He won nothing at Stanford.

    He won nothing in San Francisco.

    He has so far won nothing at Michigan.

    Brandon Jacobs is a two-time Super Bowl Champion.

  43. …and almost ended up…

    There’s NutJob in a NutShell for you.

    Almost won an NFC CG in 2011.
    Almost won a SB in 2012.
    Almost won an NFC CG in 2013.
    Almost won enough games to keep his job in the pros in 2014.

    But almost just wasn’t enough…

  44. sn19 says:
    May 26, 2017 11:32 AM
    Harbaugh came within a stone’s throw of winning the Super Bowl with the second worst starting QB in SB history – the worst being our very own Rex Grossman. So, ya, they guy must know a thing or two.
    ———–
    Did someone forget about Trent Dilfer?

  45. Why is it that Coach H got all the credit for what went right in SF, and none of the blame for what went wrong the last two seasons? And if you think nothing went wrong with that team in his last two seasons you really have your head in the sand.

  46. How can someone who’s teams have been amongst the best of their respected conferences not know what he’s doing. He did it in college, he did it not only in three years but his first three in the NFL which landed him in a super bowl, and then went back to college and made his alma mater a 10 in the nation program. Brandon Jacobs is a bitter idiot.

  47. I never liked Jacobs and always thought him a tool but, for those that keep talking about Harbaugh’s trip to the big game doesn’t really cut it. You know Barry Switzer won a Super Bowl so stating that you have to be a very good, to great coach to make the Super Bowl may be a stretch.

  48. So much to answer here, but the obvious mistake Brandon Jacobs is making…Greg Roman was the offensive coordinator, and although Jim may have had final say, he very likely wasn’t calling plays, and if and when he did, how would Jacobs know? He doesn’t have the helmet-com, and he rode the pine almost the whole time there…he stood next to Jim and heard him calling plays? I doubt that. Brandon is whining, and has delusions of grandeur. He was a standard RB…nothing special, and un-missed. He’s a poor man’s Christian Okoye…who was waaayyyy better than Jacobs as a big back.

  49. No you should be saying Jim Harbaugh gave me my last shot in the NFL. I got hurt could not stay on the field and was let go. Thanks Jim best wishes. That would be an example of class.

  50. Jacobs was overrated and actually believed that he was something special.

    Malcontent, disruptive presence on every team he was on.

    Never lived up to the hype or potential and now he’s trying to pile on.

    Not to mention that Harbaugh let his assistants coach and focused on running the team.

    Yeah Jacobs knows something about football but it’s not nearly as much as he thinks.

    Sad.

  51. I’m not sure that Brandon Jacobs’ opinions are totally objective though, seeing that he missed the first 2 months of the season after suffering a knee injury during training camp, and saw limited playing time once he returned. He was active for 3 games and had 5 carries for 7 yards. He was also suspended for the final 3 games of the season following a series of posts on social media stating his lack of playing time, including one which said he was “on this team rotting away.” Jacobs was waived by the 49ers on December 31, 2012.

    Sure, he had a few good seasons with the Giants. But since then, he hasn’t done anything. Meanwhile, Harbaugh quickly made the 49ers into serious contenders and is now making Michigan into a contender.

  52. I used to drive a forklift for Microsoft, before I got fired. I can tell you, Bill Gates doesn’t know anything about software.

  53. Well, it’s possible, but then again, those assistants and players who supposedly did so great have pretty much fallen flat after Harbaugh got the boot, and he’s doing well in his new gig.

    Gonna need more than this to make the case.

  54. “Jim is throwing slants into Cover-2 safeties, getting people hurt. That guy knew nothing, man.”

    So Jim is throwing the passes? I think this probably had more to do with Colin Kapernick’s inability to read defenses. You can’t run option routes when your QB is only able to play in a one-read scheme. Harbs did the best with what he had.

  55. Considering that Jacobs ran for a little over 200 yds the rest of his career after leaving SF, I would say that Jimbo made the smart, obvious decision to cut him.

  56. So who’s the wiser?

    The guy who waits 5 years to pull a scab or the one who got on with his life over the same time period.

  57. Harbaugh came within a stone’s throw of winning the Super Bowl with the second worst starting QB in SB history – the worst being our very own Rex Grossman. So, ya, they guy must know a thing or two.—————–

    agreed but what about that Lovie smith guy??

  58. Brandon Jacobs? Who is he? Apparently you’ll always find an ankle biter on your team if you look hard enough.

    BJ is not HOF material and his opinion is thus worthless.

  59. I’m a Michigan and think it’s a bit premature to declare anything one way or the other. I mean shoot, not only is the jury still out, they haven’t even been convened yet.

  60. Jacobs also broke the story that Cutler hates football but was forced into it by his parents. At the point, I wonder if he isn’t leveraging to sue the league for brain injury. Seems the media will interview just about anyone willing to talk these days.

  61. Harbaugh won close to 50 games with the 49ers in 4 years. Made Stanford a powerhouse. Beat coaches like Sean Payton, Belichick, Pete The Poodle Carrol, and almost ran Mike McCarthy out of the NFL…I think he knows what he’s doing.

  62. Harbaugh’s a winner…sure, he rubs some the wrong way, but that’s life. Just have to wonder how he could’ve done with a GM like Lynch…somebody who’d have worked shoulder-to-shoulder with him. As for Jacobs, he was at the very tail end of his NFL career and really has no room to talk. He wasn’t productive and for me, this is sour grapes a few years too late.

  63. sammievee says:
    May 26, 2017 1:50 PM

    Why is it that Coach H got all the credit for what went right in SF, and none of the blame for what went wrong the last two seasons? And if you think nothing went wrong with that team in his last two seasons you really have your head in the sand.
    _________________________________

    Last two seasons? You mean the one season they went 8-8? Where Kaep lost his novelty as a wildcat QB, and York tried to trade him before the season and ran a smear campaign. A bunch of injuries, add in the fact that Baalke whiffed on quite a few picks and had an all ACL team.

    Harbaugh coached the hell out of the team. May want to get your fact straight

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.