Kurt Warner thinks he is. The numbers suggest that he has a better case for it than Calvin Johnson.
Ultimately, the decision will be made as to whether receiver Anquan Boldin gets in to Canton.
But while the voters must wait five years to have the official debate, we can start now: Yes or no, is Boldin a Hall of Famer?
Cast a vote below. Chris Simms and I will argue about it during the 7:00 a.m. ET hour of PFT Live. And then, eventually, one of us will be proven right, and the other will be proven wrong.