Giants memorabilia lawsuit moves toward trial

Getty Images

The Giants still face allegations of memorabilia fraud, focusing on of all people quarterback Eli Manning. The case reportedly is set for trial in March, and a nugget emerged recently regarding key testimony harvested from Giants co-owner John Mara.

Via the New York Post, Mara admitted that, if he had seen an email referring to certain items of memorabilia as “BS ones,” Mara would have done something about it.

“I think if I had seen this prior to the lawsuit being filed, I would have asked about it or asked somebody about it,” Mara testified in a deposition.

Last year, two curious emails emerged regarding the case. In a 2010 message from quarterback Eli Manning to Giants equipment director Joe Skiba, Manning asks for “2 helmets that can pass as game used.” (The Giants have claimed that the email was taken out of context, without elaborating on the context.)

In a 2008 exchange with Skiba plaintiff Eric Isenberg asked whether an Eli Manning game-used helmet and jersey were “the ones eli asked you to make up because he didnt [sic] want to give up the real stuff?”

Said Skiba in response, “BS ones, you are correct.”

In a court document filed Friday, lawyers attacking the Giants and Manning claim that Mara didn’t ask anyone about the “BS ones” email after becoming aware of it within the context of the litigation because he didn’t want to know the answer to the question.

The Giants will need a compelling answer to the question of what those emails meant at trial, or it could end up being a huge mess for the team and for Manning.

For more on that and various other topics, check out Monday’s PFT PM podcast. (And for a free copy of Madden 18 for Xbox One, try this code . . . quickly: T97DF-F649W-MVD3V-D3HQC-PVGGZ.)

11 responses to “Giants memorabilia lawsuit moves toward trial

  1. Conduct detrimental to the league. Draft picks, Fines and
    suspensions are all in order for this fraud.

  2. The first part is not bad “can pass as game used” because they have extra gear they bring but never use in case of damage. So this implies something that was worn on the field…or could be implied.

  3. bartpkelly says:
    February 12, 2018 at 5:55 pm

    The first part is not bad “can pass as game used”

    Looks like fraud to me. It was either worn during the game or not.

  4. Mara will pay someone off and Roger will never do anything against the Giants, right Lisa Friel?

  5. The only fair punishment is what the Pats got for deflategate–steep fine, loss of draft picks, and a suspension of @ least 4 games like Brady got. They have the witnesses, so anything else is BS.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.