Report: ESPN, FOX both trying to sign Peyton Manning as prime time analyst

Getty Images

Two of the marquee NFL color commentary jobs are available, and Peyton Manning has his choice of either one of them.

ESPN’s Monday Night Football booth hasn’t found its replacement for Jon Gruden, and FOX hasn’t said who will call its new Thursday Night Football package. But Manning would be the top choice for both networks, according to the New York Post.

The report indicates that if Manning wants the job, he could command several million dollars a year for it. The only question is whether he wants the job. So far, Manning has shied away from doing television in retirement, other than appearing in commercials.

Who would Manning’s on-air partner be? It sounds like he’d be given the opportunity to have some input in that decision. Sean McDonough is ESPN’s play-by-play guy, but he could be replaced with someone like Joe Tessitore, Steve Levy or Dave Pasch, according to the report. FOX has not said who its play-by-play voice on Thursday nights will be, but if Manning gets the commentary job he’d likely have a say in who would join him in the booth.

Manning is said to covet a job running a team’s front office. Seeing John Lynch successfully transition from TV analyst to General Manager of the 49ers may make Manning more interested in working TV while he looks for the right NFL job.

If Manning does want to work on TV, he has the opportunity to have a Tony Romo-like impact in his first season, and instantly become one of the most popular analysts on television.

71 responses to “Report: ESPN, FOX both trying to sign Peyton Manning as prime time analyst

  1. Tessitore is as annoying as Sean McDonough. Whatever you do, no Beth Mullins or any other deep voice. ha

  2. I’d watch just so I can relish the opportunity to watch him stumbling and dancing for words analyzing The True GOAT.

  3. OMG, I’d take Gruden and The Pope calling plays before I could ever stomach mush-mouth Peyton Manning in the commentators’ booth. Please, Peyton, please, stick to your stupid insurance and pizza commercials as you plunder sponsors on your way to your first billion.

  4. If it means he won’t make anymore Nationwide commercials I’d be all for it. At least then I can choose not to listen to him.

  5. It seems below Peyton to be a color commentator.

    It’s fine for someone like Tony Romo, but not for one of the greatest players of all time.

  6. If they’re high enough on Kevin Burkhardt to put him ahead of Kenny Albert on Sundays, I see Fox using Kevin on Thursday nights. As for Mondays, the best thing Disney could do is put MNF back on ABC where more people will watch. ESPN is no longer the license to print money; once Tirico bolted for NBC as heir-apparent to Al Michaels, ESPN had no NFL-grade PBP announcer left. Being on ABC might attract someone to jump ship from CBS or Fox.

    As for Peyton… it’s a coup if any network gets him, but I don’t see it. He won’t put himself in position to fail, and he may not believe he has the right skill set for the booth. I admit to being pleasantly surprised as to how good Romo was this past season with his pre-snap reads that no one else was doing. But unlike the original “Fox Box” with the clock and score that everyone copied, I don’t see too many analysts wanting to do it like Romo, especially if it’s been a while since they’ve played.

  7. No way he takes the job. The most likely path for him is what Elway did. Gain experience in real world business then come back in some form of leadership role for an NFL team either as a part owner or in the front office.

  8. I’m more interested in seeing snoozer Sean replaced.
    NFL Football is a LOT more exciting than how he calls it.

  9. This just in: Kaps lawyers want to question Peyton Manning and his yet to be known on air partner.

  10. NOOO! Peyton has the single most annoying voice I’ve ever heard, he says smart things about football but sounds like he has an IQ of 4. Please don’t ruin my Sundays by having to listen to that goober for 3 hours at a time.

  11. I like Manning but he’s pretty laid back to be a commentator. I for one like his commercials, especially with Brad Paisley.

    I can see him in a front office role with the right team.

  12. Would be better than Romo? Romo is a very good watch if you actually want analyzation about what you’re watching. Energy is good, he can get a little carried away at times but his excitement is refreshing. For the record, I hate the cowboys but Romo is a damn good watch

  13. Dillon Pauls says:
    February 16, 2018 at 11:01 am
    Peyton needs to replace Collinsworth

    Amen to that. His calling of the SB was horrendous. And I hate hearing his voice when my kids play Madden. He just isn’t very good.

  14. the guy made $248 million in salary without his business and endorsements. The networks need him more than he needs them. I think he holds out for ownership and stays away from the ESPN Political dumpster fire. Manning is funny and liked by most. Why associate with a network that more than 50% of country hates politically?

  15. holy crap I cant listen to Beth Mullins, my team is the Broncos, and she worked 2 or 3 games for them, I could not watch at all, turned it to Redzone

  16. spartanlegend says:
    February 16, 2018 at 12:07 pm

    It’s news to me that Tony Romo is one of the most popular analysts on television

    __________________________________________________

    Well, considering you’re so out of touch with your own team it’s very clear that this is news to you.

    LOLions!!

  17. There is no guarantee that he would be better than Romo. Romo isn’t perfect, but he understands the average fan and how to articulate complex football concepts to them. It’s not a given that even someone as natural when the camera is rolling as Manning is would be better than Romo. Romo also has a good rapport with Nantz.

  18. spartanlegend says:
    February 16, 2018 at 12:07 pm

    It’s news to me that Tony Romo is one of the most popular analysts on television

    ________________________________

    Coming from a delusional Lions fan that claims his team was going to win the Superbowl for the past 6 years, this comes as NO surprise….just like the Lions losing in every playoff appearance during that time frame.

  19. “If Manning does want to work on TV, he has the opportunity to have a Tony Romo-like impact in his first season, and instantly become one of the most popular analysts on television.”

    Popular? Yes. Good? Not sure. An effective analyst isn’t afraid to criticize when criticism is warranted. It’s part of the reason Romo is so good. I suspect Manning won’t be willing to be critical, and thus, he would not be as good as people think. The reluctance to criticize old pals, former coaches, ex-teammates, etc. is one reason why there are very few good analysts out there right now.

  20. If he does do announcing, by the end of his first year he will have raised the ratings of whatever network he joins to pre-kneeling numbers… guaranteed.

  21. Like most people I’d probably find him as bad as the rest of the talking heads and network yes men.
    But if it means getting rid of Chris Collinsworth I’m all for it.
    Hearing him whine about the refs not rigging the Superbowl for the Patriots like they’d done all season, even going back to cry about replays of old plays was intolerable.

  22. “The report indicates that if Manning wants the job, he could command several million dollars a year for it. The only question is whether he wants the job”

    He’s made over 1/4 of a billion dollars. Why would he ever want to work another day in his life? Its laughable that his name keeps getting brought up for GM for different teams and as a broadcaster.

    If anything he most likely has philanthropical work he does and that’s how he wants to spend any work time.

  23. He would have to be a step up from Chucky, although his Nationwide and his Papa John’s commercials have a high annoyance factor.

  24. Funny how no one wants to talk about what Peyton Manning did to Dr. Jamie Naughright. After a US Senator was forced to resign for taking a comic photo where he pretended to grope sleeping NFL cheerleader (shot before he was a Senator), you’d think Manning’s career on tv would be long over. But nope. Manning is still Mr. Wholesome.

  25. In the heightened day of awareness,will the #metoo movement stop a guy who had an unsettled battle of sexual misconduct at UT? He’s also the guy whose wife ordered HGH, that most people know was for Peyton.

    Why would he get a pass?

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.