Giants paid $22.5 million for one year of JPP, a third-round pick

Getty Images

The Giants traded away Jason Pierre-Paul today, just one year after signing him to a four-year, $62 million contract.

That contract had a $20 million signing bonus, a $1.25 million salary in 2017, a $1 million roster bonus he received last year, and a $250,000 workout bonus he received for last offseason’s workouts. That means the Giants paid $22.5 million to Pierre-Paul.

That sounds like an awfully bad contract: If you’re going to pay a guy $22.5 million for one year, you want that player to be a major piece of a Super Bowl contender. Pierre-Paul was good but not great last year, and the Giants went 3-13.

But by trading Pierre-Paul today, the Giants picked up a third-round draft pick from the Buccaneers. That’s an important asset, one that will bring a young, inexpensive player to the Giants to replace the older, expensive Pierre-Paul.

Is a third-round pick worth $22.5 million? Probably not. But that the Giants were able to get something of value in a trade for Pierre-Paul indicates that the contract wasn’t as bad as it might have looked.

54 responses to “Giants paid $22.5 million for one year of JPP, a third-round pick

  1. The Giants also received JPP’s services for last season. 22.5 million is quite likely worth JPP for one year plus a 3rd round pick.

  2. It ISN’T a bad contract for the bucs since the Giants just picked up half the tab already!… Thanks for everything except all the off-field drama he brought and lack of leadership when the team was DYING for a defensive leader after Tuck left… Great trade for the rebuild need to get young and find a way to pay Collins and OBJ.

  3. Trying to clear up money for OBJ huh? Love it when teams make bad deals and it kills their cap. Keep it coming Giants. FYI, Vernon’s deal wasn’t that much better.

  4. “But that the Giants were able to get something of value in a trade for Pierre-Paul indicates that the contract wasn’t as bad as it might have looked.”

    Not really. They were able to get something of value because they paid the 1st year & took the cap hit making the last 3 years ($40m with a $0 risk after this season)not as bad if you’re Tampa. Unless that pick becomes the 2nd coming of LT it remains every bit as bad as it looked if your the Giants.

  5. Dude. Come on.

    They got to take an albatross contract, belonging to a player who has struggled with injuries and doesn’t fit in the scheme, off of their books… and they get a 3rd round pick?! That’s fantastic.

    Now there’s less stress around dealing with OBJ and LC – and even Eli – in 2019.

    Getty killed this one. $22.5mm is a sunk cost. Move on.

  6. Let’s see, they have hired a new HC and moved some dead wood now it’s time to move on from OBJ. Although an exceptional pass receiver also an exceptional head case who wears that team down. Just move on New York.

  7. $7.5 million for JPP last season.
    $15 million for an extra third round pick this season.
    $0 in future cap hits.

  8. Giants are taking Chubb. The only question will be is it at #2 or #3?

    If they can get another QB in the later rounds they probably should.

  9. Love people commenting who weren’t stuck watching that albatross of a contract for 16 games. signing him to that deal was one of the reasons why reese was eventually fired. his cap hit was insane and his play didn’t justify even making 10mm a year.
    his run stopping ability has diminished a great deal due to his accident, and the 8.5 sacks are a mirage. since 2011, he has literally racked up his sacks over the course of 2-3 games and typically against the worst teams in the NFL. this might have been gettleman’s best move to date dumping that contract. after this year, his cap hit if he was cut was over 20mm i believe.

  10. Sigh – questionable logic in that analysis.

    * The contract that was signed was not a 1 year contract
    * He is not out of the league, he has been traded to a new team
    * Where his signing bonus was paid in year 1, the actual value of the signing bonus is prorated over the course of the contract.

    Would it have been better for the team to hold onto him for another year or so in order to reduce the per annum cost of signing him?

    In a league where player trades rarely occur, getting a 3rd round pick for anyone is a decent return.

    Now personally, i thought he was overpaid on that contract, and since he will not fit as a DE in a 3-4, i think they got a windfall back for him

  11. Why do Bills fans keep saying they did this because they are gonna trade for Shaq Lawson or Hughes? it’s delusional. Why in the world would the Giants trade for those two when they could trade with the Broncos or the Jets and get Bradley Chubb + more picks.

  12. It’s ok, they still have their franchise QB for 5-7 more years. Even if that QB is ranked 13th out of 16 NFC starting QBs, atleast they still have him!

  13. New regime and new defensive scheme that JPP doesn’t fit into. Better to cut bait than to spend more team resources on an expensive guy who doesn’t fit the scheme.

  14. they weren’t paying him for his draft status.. they payed him for what he proved to be a very good DE.. you on the the other hand would still be a 3rd rd pick as a writer

  15. I honestly cant believe that we were able to not only shed the contract for a player who is clearly declining, but that we also netted a fairly high pick to boot. JPP was once very good but that was a long time ago. He was a shell last year despite that misleading sack total. Regardless, he was a big part of our last SB…I wish him well in TB.

  16. Wait… Didn’t I just read a series of articles about how bad the contract is for Richard Sherman that he just signed? And now we’re talking about how bad the contract is for the Giants that JPP signed?

    Are there ANY good contracts? You know, ones that are good for both sides?

  17. firerogergoodell says:
    March 22, 2018 at 2:04 pm
    How many bad contracts do the Bucs have now? Won’t end well.

    ———————————————-

    It’s not the quantity, it is the quality. I do not know which is worse, a no hand DE, or a no leadership QB. Either way, that team is going nowhere.

  18. Ok, so if you want to go by this logic, the Redskins essentially paid Kirk Cousins $24 million for last year, got to watch the playoffs on the couch, and didn’t even receive a 3rd rounder for it. Cool story.

  19. The Giants have the Super Bowl champs in their division and a Dallas team that will be hungry to get back to their success from 2016. 3rd place and missing the playoffs for the Giants.

  20. People cry about the Pats not overpaying players, and this is a fine example of why teams should have a cap model they stick to if they want to be competitive.

  21. Thank God he chose NY over AZ. Cards got Chandler Jones instead! Dodged a bullet there! Cards should send the Giants front office some candies and flowers.

  22. bkinacti0n says:
    March 22, 2018 at 1:25 pm

    $7.5 million for JPP last season.
    $15 million for an extra third round pick this season.
    $0 in future cap hits.

    or explained another way.
    2017 cap hit 7.5 million
    2018 NYG trade him for 2018 3rd pick and take a dead cap hit of 15 million
    that clears the books on JPP for NYG

    spotrac is a wonderful tool

  23. Compared to the $19.7M for a QB they had to bench partway through their 3-13 season, meh, not too bad. They’re on the hook for even more than that this year for Eli.

  24. mikejune says:
    March 22, 2018 at 4:12 pm

    Who cares? The Giants had tons of cap space last year. It’s not like they’re losing money.

    ++++++++

    Because it’s now “this” year. And the Giants have 10% of their capped spending flushed down the toilet. It’s like money they lost. For this year.

  25. The old saying, “Its better to get rid of a player one year too early rather than one year too late” comes into play in the decision to trade him. Forget what they paid him last year, there are no refunds in pro football. The Giants need to look ahead and obviously, they felt like he wasn’t worth the contract in the second year of the deal and decided to recoup something from an already bad situation. A third round pick is better than just cutting the guy.

  26. asixthlombardiforthehaters says:
    March 22, 2018 at 2:00 pm
    Well done, JPP. Give him a hand.

    That should read a high 3.5!

  27. “Who cares? The Giants had tons of cap space last year. It’s not like they’re losing money.

    ++++++++

    Because it’s now “this” year. And the Giants have 10% of their capped spending flushed down the toilet. It’s like money they lost. For this year.”

    People seem to forget that when the Giants signed Pierre-Paul to this deal, they were coming off a 12-4 season and Super Bowl contenders. Therefore, giving him the big bonus in the first two years not only filled cap space they weren’t planning to use last year, but gave them an out in years 3-4. If the people who gave him this contract still had their jobs, JPP would probably be a Giant today. The Giant’s old front office actually did a great job with those big deals two years ago, front loading them and using the cap space they had available in those years without hamstringing themselves in the long term. So yeah, you can cry about $7.5 Mil in dead money this year, but after that they are off the hook and free up tons a space for the next two years. You can say that $22 M is way too much for one year, but you have a cap and your going to spend that money anyway. Keep in mind, of course, that the dead money comes after the big-spending phase of Free Agency, so it probably is not going to have a big effect on the Giants’ plans for this upcoming season.

  28. I don’t think they did this to sign OBJ, I think they plan on drafting Chubb and feel like JPP isn’t worth it when they’re gonna have a young stud out there.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.