Calvin Johnson on catch rule: Took them seven years to figure out what we knew

Getty Images

The NFL has changed the language of the catch rule this offseason and it caught the attention of a player who was closely linked to the past definition.

Calvin Johnson was playing for the Lions in 2010 when he went for a pass in the end zone in the opening weekend of the season. Johnson grabbed the ball, got his feet down and then lost the ball when his right hand hit the ground. The ball was ruled incomplete after a conference by officials, leading many to grumble about the call and foreshadowing other apparent catches wiped out because the player was not judged to complete the process through going to the ground.

The language of the rule now reads that a ball is caught when the player has control, two feet or another body part down, and makes a football move while making no mention of completing the process.

“Like I say, it just took them seven years to figure out what we knew on Day 1,” Johnson said, via the Detroit Free Press. “… I think you [have to take the human element] into account. Yeah, slow motion can show every bitty frame, but you have to also take into account what actually happened in real time, I feel like. You take it slow mo and that easy catch can turn into, ‘Dang, he bobbled it a little bit.'”

Johnson quipped that they “ought to add [the 2010 play] to my stat sheet.” That won’t happen, but the next player in a similar position should get to celebrate a score.

11 responses to “Calvin Johnson on catch rule: Took them seven years to figure out what we knew

  1. This isn’t a new rule….. it was implemented earlier this year in the Super Bowl….. it gave the Eagles 2 TD’s that previously, thruout the entire 2017 season, were considered non catches….. but hey, who cares that the rules were changed for the most important game of the year, afterall, it was against the Patriots so it’s all good…..
    Trump & the League deserve each other…. BOTH CORRUPT, SELF SERVING ENTITIES that are wrecking the things we love……

  2. I guess it takes the Rog Regime 7 years to get things right.

    No anthem issues by 2025 – you heard it here first!

  3. I still think you should have to control the ball to the ground. I don’t like the idea of someone connecting with the bal for a split second only for it to tumble away and be given a TD

  4. As a Bears fan, this game was against the Bears, it was a catch. He lost the ball getting up to celebrate. Wont forget that one because even though it gave the Bears the win, I was shocked they overturned the catch

  5. kissbillsrings says:
    June 5, 2018 at 10:55 am
    This isn’t a new rule….. it was implemented earlier this year in the Super Bowl….. it gave the Eagles 2 TD’s that previously, thruout the entire 2017 season, were considered non catches….. but hey, who cares that the rules were changed for the most important game of the year, afterall, it was against the Patriots so it’s all good…..
    Trump & the League deserve each other…. BOTH CORRUPT, SELF SERVING ENTITIES that are wrecking the things we love……
    ——————————
    Coming from a salty Pats fan that has had many beneficial calls from the officials and replay booth over the years.

  6. “Johnson grabbed the ball, got his feet down and then lost the ball when his right hand hit the ground.”

    He absolutely did NOT “lose” the ball. It’s obvious he chose to place the ball down on the ground because he knew, along with everyone else watching at home, that it was a touchdown. It may have been kinda showy, in the same manner of guys running into the endzone on a long touchdown run and immediately dropping the ball as they cross the goal line. But he didn’t “lose” control of the ball… it was clearly voluntary, which made the ruling so much more infuriating.

    Had to get that off my chest. 🙂

  7. kissbillsrings says:
    June 5, 2018 at 10:55 am
    This isn’t a new rule….. it was implemented earlier this year in the Super Bowl….. it gave the Eagles 2 TD’s that previously, thruout the entire 2017 season, were considered non catches….. but hey, who cares that the rules were changed for the most important game of the year, afterall, it was against the Patriots so it’s all good…..
    Trump & the League deserve each other…. BOTH CORRUPT, SELF SERVING ENTITIES that are wrecking the things we love……
    ——————————
    Coming from a salty Pats fan that has had many beneficial calls from the officials and replay booth over the years.
    ————————————————————-
    LOL….. your commenting is too funny, your posting name is nothing but another butt hurt fan of a team the Patriots probably have owned for the last 18 years!!!!!
    & I’m not salty, just stating a FACT….. congrats to the Eagles
    But they know as well as you know that my earlier post is spot on….beating a really good team & then throw in the corrupt league to boot is next to impossible….. Pats ALMOST pulled off a miracle…..
    I sometimes wonder how much better the Pats would be if they hadn’t had the 2 1st round picks & 4th rounder STOLEN from them….

  8. They’re so busy looking at control, that in some cases the ball didn’t even hit the ground and they still call it incomplete. It’s a mind boggling lack of common sense. We never had this issue playing in the back yards as 9 year olds, it’s pretty clear what is and is not a catch.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.