Alex Smith’s leg injury brings back bad memories for Joe Theismann

Getty Images

Former Washington quarterback Joe Theismann was at FedEx Field on Sunday when current Washington quarterback Alex Smith broke his right fibula and tibia. Theismann already had his career-ending injury on his mind before Smith’s injury as it happened 33 years ago to the day.

“I saw a pile of people go down, and then I saw Alex’s leg in the position it was in. And I turned away after that. It brought back vivid memories,” Theismann said, via The Associated Press.

Theismann tweeted the comparison between his and Smith’s injuries.

Both happened on Nov. 18. Both happened at the 40-yard line. Romeo Crennel was an assistant coach on the opposing sideline of both games. Washington won the 1985 game 23-21; Houston won Sunday’s game 23-21. Theismann finished his season with 301 attempts; Smith entered Sunday’s game with 301 attempts and finished his season with 328.

“This date has always been a day in my life that I’ll never forget,” Theismann said. “. . .My immediate thought was that my heart went out to him. I feel so bad for him. I know the road ahead. We’re somewhat similar in age [when the injuries happened]. He’s not 25 or 26 years of age. I was 35; he’s 34. How long will it take to come back? What is the severity?

“I worry less about Alex and his football career than I do Alex and wanting to be able to do the things in life he wants to do.”

Theismann never played again after Lawrence Taylor’s hit fractured his right tibia and fibula. He hopes Smith’s career continues, wishing the quarterback well.

31 responses to “Alex Smith’s leg injury brings back bad memories for Joe Theismann

  1. Watching players legs or arms get snapped on live TV, is never a good thing.

    Brutal.

    Wish him the best on the recovery!

  2. That’s got to be some crazy cosmic NFL alternate-universe anomaly with dimensions overlapping one another. All of those numbers, the score, the injury on the same date 33 years later, on the 40 yard line? What are the odds? Can Romeo Crennel tell us?

  3. I was in the fifth grade on 11/18/85 and it was the first time my dad met me stay up late to watch a game. When I saw the injury over and over again on replay, I felt like maybe I should have gone to bed.

  4. I saw Theismann’s injury live and on one replay and I never watched it again. Same with Alex; I don’t plan to watch that one again either. That is about as brutal as football gets.

    Hang in there Alex and get well soon!

  5. .
    wow that is crazy how many things matched both incidents…
    never say something is impossible, the universe will prove u wrong

  6. chinahand11 says:
    November 18, 2018 at 11:43 pm
    I saw Theismann’s injury live and on one replay and I never watched it again. Same with Alex; I don’t plan to watch that one again either. That is about as brutal as football gets.
    Hang in there Alex and get well soon!

    ————–
    I remember wondering why LT jumped up waving frantically at the Redskin’s bench – then I watched the replay, once. It changed the way I watch games. I turn my head on all injury replays and wait to hear the reaction of the announcers, then I know how careful I have to be to avoid accidently seeing it.

  7. Theismann’s leg was broken by 3-time DPOY Lawrence Taylor. Smith’s by 3-time DPOY JJ Watt. They are the only 3-time DPOY award winners in NFL.

    Theismann’s Redskins finished the day with 6 wins, the Giants with 7.

    Smith’s Redskins finished the day with 6 wins, the Texans 7.

    Johns Riggins started in the backfield w/ Thiesmann and was 2nd among active players in career rushing yards (Walton Payton).

    Adrian Peterson started in the backfield w/ Smith and is 2nd among active players in career rushing yards (Frank Gore).

    AP began the day with 103 rushing TDs. He scored the 104 and 105th TDs of his career today, passing John Riggins.

    Guess which game Riggins scored #103? Nov 18, 1985 vs New York.

  8. These fibula injuries arent that gruesome to me. Or that career threatening in this day, just look at Paul george in the NBA…Knee injuries, on the other hand, those are gruesome and will end careers. Knee dislocations, hyperextensions, think Napoleon McCallum, Marcus Lattimore.

  9. Alex Smith finishes his Redskin career with more wins than Doug Williams’ Redskin career. Guess we will see his name in the ring of fame and a front office job for life for him too.

  10. Theismann’s bone was sticking out of his sock. It was the most gruesome scene in sports. I certainly hope medicine has improved in 33 years to see Alex back on the field. If not, we totally understand. Much Respect!!

  11. I remember how classy it was for them to show Joe T’s leg snap over and over and over. Guess it was the love affair with a player everyone loved for God knows what reason who was fueled by cocaine. Must be comforting for Joe to know his career was ended by a druggie. Now we understand those wide eyed close ups through the facemask. That man was not in control of his dilated pupils or any other body part for that matter.

  12. The Smith injury was gruesome, but the Theismann hit was even worse, I think because it was more clearly visible and his leg was planted and going in a direction it shouldn’t go. I can remember Lawrence Taylor almost in a panic, waving to the Redskins bench to get medical help.

  13. “Theismann’s leg was broken by 3-time DPOY Lawrence Taylor. Smith’s by 3-time DPOY JJ Watt. They are the only 3-time DPOY award winners in NFL.

    Theismann’s Redskins finished the day with 6 wins, the Giants with 7.

    Smith’s Redskins finished the day with 6 wins, the Texans 7.

    Johns Riggins started in the backfield w/ Thiesmann and was 2nd among active players in career rushing yards (Walton Payton).

    Adrian Peterson started in the backfield w/ Smith and is 2nd among active players in career rushing yards (Frank Gore).

    AP began the day with 103 rushing TDs. He scored the 104 and 105th TDs of his career today, passing John Riggins.

    Guess which game Riggins scored #103? Nov 18, 1985 vs New York.”

    Ok I can’t believe this. Way too creepy.

  14. I still remember Taylor running to the Redskins sideline imploring the medical staff to get out there!

  15. Can’t even believe the coincidence here, that’s nuts. I’d imagine Smith can come back if he wants though. It’s 2018 with exponentially improved medical treatment. I think Theismann’s injury was a compound fracture, and I think Smith’s was not, so the risk of infection isn’t the same. I don’t know, unless he’s just not up for the rehab, we should see him on a field again.

  16. Feel really bad for Smith – he was in a great situation, leading the division and likely could have kept starting there for a few more years. Hopefully he’ll come back next year and do exactly that. He deserves a good, stable situation for being one of the steadiest and most reliable QBs in recent memory.

    The number of coincidences related to the injury is just astounding, if not unnerving. I hope that in some sense he can laugh at the absurdity of it.

    Keep his seat warm for him, Redskins, he’s your best bet!

  17. I feel bad for Alex Smith …

    HOWEVER, Joe Theismann is elated to return to the 24 hour news cycle.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.