Marijuana policy for “voluntary” workouts could be a fair trade

Getty Images

The NFL has a ban on marijuana around most players successfully navigate. The NFL also has voluntary offseason workouts in which most players choose to participate. Those two concepts could provide the basis for a fair and sensible tradeoff in the next labor deal.

The swap would be simple: The prohibition on marijuana use ends, and the “voluntary” offseason workouts become fully or mostly mandatory. It’s a win-win that removes from the sport a pair of currently nonsensical policies that are widely ignored.

Players smoke marijuana, and the smart ones know how to legitimately beat the once-per-year testing process. Players also show up for voluntary offseason workouts, in such numbers that the exceptions generate significant attention and, in some cities, scorn.

It’s an easy trade, with a couple of meaningless and irrelevant policies going away for good, giving each side something to give up, even though neither side is really giving up all that much.

As PFT reported earlier this year, the NFL wants to get away from policing marijuana use by players. If the league is looking for something in return — and if the players are willing to give up anything — voluntary workouts that are voluntary in name only make the most sense.

42 responses to “Marijuana policy for “voluntary” workouts could be a fair trade

  1. Good idea. The players could be required to be at a percentage of
    voluntary workouts with flexibility the key.
    It is also time to stop the hypocrisy over marijuana.
    It is legal in many states and esssentially decriminalized
    in all states. For a player to lose his whole season
    over marijuana is absurd. Hit a woman 4-6 games,
    Hit a joint, lose 4 games. ( After 2 bad tests)
    Needs to stop.

  2. The NFL definitely needs to stop punishing players for cannabis, especially since it’s legal in many states and most states have legalized medical use of cannabis. Many players prefer it to opioids for pain relief. Better to vape a little weed than become dependent on pills.

  3. So are you suggesting that a majority of players use marijuana? Otherwise, how/why would those players vote for this exchange? Non-users would get nothing in return for having to work several more weeks per year.

  4. I bet the NFL is smarter than this. I’ll wager the players will give away far more than this to drop the marijuana testing. Why would the NFL care about voluntary workouts wherre more often than not the player is pilloried for not attending?

    Why should the NFL settle for the lowest hanging fruit?

  5. People smoke mj if it’s legal or not. I don’t believe for one second though football players use it for pain relief. I believe it’s more of the rockstar personality they want to live and just be high. I was for legalization until I was a parent and thought about what it does mentally to you. It makes you lazy honestly and stalls you from reaching your potential as a person.

  6. How is this a win – win?
    Most players probably don’t smoke pot, so it’s not a win for them.
    Older players want some time off to recover, it’s not a win for them.

    I can see rookies or first year players having the workouts.

  7. Then wouldn’t the players give up their workout bonuses written into their contracts?

    Most guys get an extra payout for showing up voluntarily.

  8. I wish my employer would let me do whatever the hell I wanted for six months a year. Damn unions!

  9. You point out that voluntary workouts really aren’t voluntary and then suggest that the league give the players something in exchange for the voluntary workouts. If the league is going to give on marijuana then it can and should demand something big in return–not something that it effectively already has.

  10. While I agree the current marijuana policy needs to be abandoned, I don’t know if expressly trading it for labor is the way to go. As marijuana becomes legal in more places it can be argued the policy cannot be enforced as written. I foresee a future in which the policy is abolished and the workouts stay voluntary.

  11. I always thought the NFLPA would have to agree to an 18 game schedule to get marijuana products accepted by the league.
    If the players can get cannabis decriminalized by Goodell for workouts that they are doing to do anyway, that would be an amazing win for the NFLPA.
    I guess the owners are finally getting a clue about the relatively harmless benefits of cannabis versus the long term negative effects of pain pills and cortisone injections.

  12. >>If the players can get cannabis decriminalized by Goodell for workouts that they are doing to do anyway, that would be an amazing win for the NFLPA.

    It would be a loss, not a win, since more and more states are decriminalizing Pot.

  13. Or they just drop the stupid marijuana policy altogether and make voluntary workouts mandatory for rookies thru 3 yr veteran players and for an entire team if your team has hired a new coach. Other than that, leave it voluntary. Players who use cannabis and players who skip voluntary workouts are minority populations, so I wouldn’t make sweeping changes to two completely unrelated issues for the entire league.

  14. Great idea Florio. You should have been a lawyer. I would just give the discretion to show up for the workouts to the team. The teams could choose to excuse absences as they see fit.

  15. Players smoke marijuana
    ==========================================

    Putting that smoke in your lungs like an idiot is a great thing you constantly promote. Pot head.

  16. Except this isn’t a fair trade for players who don’t smoke. And I imagine there are far more players that don’t smoke than those that do.

  17. Why would the players go for this? If the system is so easy to beat I’d leave it in place and ask for something else in exchange for making the workouts mandatory

  18. I think this is a GREAT idea, but with a couple of provisos

    1. I would add HGH as a legal OFF SEASON healing drug when it’s proscribed by a team physician and is out of the player’s system by July 1. All players would bet tested on 7/1 for HGH

    2. Veteran players with so many years in the league, say 6 or more, or pick another number have the OPTION to miss the mandatory mini camps their younger teammates have given back in the new deal.

    3. TC is now a joke. full pad days should be added to camp (say 5 more)

    MJ doesn’t give a player a jot of an advantage. It would be SO much easier to administer league operations if they unburdened themselves of this task.

  19. ZebraThrowsFlagGreatCall says:
    April 21, 2019 at 4:26 pm
    People smoke mj if it’s legal or not. I don’t believe for one second though football players use it for pain relief. I believe it’s more of the rockstar personality they want to live and just be high. I was for legalization until I was a parent and thought about what it does mentally to you. It makes you lazy honestly and stalls you from reaching your potential as a person.

    ______ _______

    I take it your an NFL football player dealing with injuries and forced to take opioids to deal with the pain? Let me see….Opioids in one hand vs Pot in the other..humm Hope your kids dont want to become a football players when they get older!

  20. Stupidest thing I have ever read. Give athletes freedom to consume a psychoactive drug just because it has become politically and societally popular and YOU comsider it “safe” and because “they use it anyway.”

    Reminds me of the reasoning liberal idiots use to advocate giving condoms to Junior high kids. “They are gonna have sex anyway, you can’t stop it, so lets just condone it and make it “safe”…

  21. MTLighthouse69 says:

    Has there been any studies on the long term affects of marijuana use?
    ==================================================

    It cures cancer and ends wars. According to the pot heads.

  22. Smoke causes global warming and accelerates climate change…smoke is harmful for humans to breathe and harmful to the atmosphere…but we should all do as much of it as we can since we only have 12 years left to live anyway…

  23. Some responses are absurd. Have there been studies on long term
    marijuana use….yes, just ask medical coroners and ER physicians
    they see far worse medical problems from alcohol.
    To compare the use of condoms in teenagers to use of
    marijuana by adults is absurd. Perhaps you should compare the use
    of painkillers like Vicodin or Percocet and the instance of addiction
    in all ages to the addiction of marijuana.
    By the way the use of painkillers in high schools is epidemic, which
    then leads to the use of heroin.
    I’m not condoning the use of marijuana wholesale, but I don’t believe
    it should result in a player losing his livelihood. The use of marijuana
    doesn’t give the player an advantage and does not endanger a fellow
    player in the course of his employment.
    I’m sure a player of two has played high, and we don’t know the
    effect, but I would think that a player who abused marijuana would
    be out of a job sooner than later. Safe and reasonable use should be
    allowed.

  24. Not a good trade, at all. Unless of course people want to see players getting winded running routes and dropping easy passes because they are playing high as a kite because hey, they feel entitled to smoke illegal drugs at their leisure.

    The NFL needs to stop softening the drug test standards and take them more serious, not less.

  25. ZebraThrowsFlagGreatCall says:
    April 21, 2019 at 4:26 pm
    People smoke mj if it’s legal or not. I don’t believe for one second though football players use it for pain relief. I believe it’s more of the rockstar personality they want to live and just be high. I was for legalization until I was a parent and thought about what it does mentally to you. It makes you lazy honestly and stalls you from reaching your potential as a person.

  26. Ok. This proposal assumes that every player smokes marijuana. Even if it doesn’t, what do you propose the NFL do about the states where this is still illegal?

  27. ZebraThrowsFlagGreatCall says:
    April 21, 2019 at 4:26 pm
    People smoke mj if it’s legal or not. I don’t believe for one second though football players use it for pain relief. I believe it’s more of the rockstar personality they want to live and just be high. I was for legalization until I was a parent and thought about what it does mentally to you. It makes you lazy honestly and stalls you from reaching your potential as a person.

    =======================================

    simply not true.

  28. ZebraThrowsFlagGreatCall says:
    April 21, 2019 at 4:26 pm
    People smoke mj if it’s legal or not. I don’t believe for one second though football players use it for pain relief. I believe it’s more of the rockstar personality they want to live and just be high. I was for legalization until I was a parent and thought about what it does mentally to you. It makes you lazy honestly and stalls you from reaching your potential as a person.
    ———-
    Proof that there should be a law against all people having children. Alcohol has done far more damage than marijuana, and I don’t smoke. Medical science says MJ is a superior pain manager to many addicting pharmaceuticals. Let me guess, you don’t believe climate change is real either.

  29. Not a fair trade – what percentage of players smoke marijuana?
    Is it half?
    Is it more or less than that?

    They should keep voluntary workouts voluntary because certainly some players do not smoke weed and don’t want to give up the workouts being voluntary…

    They should stop making weed punishable since it’s legality is based on where you are. Smoking in Washington State where you live Friday , then traveling to another state and getting busted is not fair and equitable.

    Just stop making marijuana use punishable.

  30. The players and owners need to spend more time thinking about the fans and less about themselves. Fans will start to tune out if the quality of play continues to diminish. When the professionals can’t execute the basics like blocking and tackling it’s time for a change. Just look what has happened to MLB and the NBA.

  31. They are 2 stupid policies – but I see no reason why would concede anything for the marijuana policy.

    The large majority of the players are not hurt by the policy. Its worse for the owners than for the average player.

  32. We’re talking about an individual’s right to consume marijuana legally without persecution. This is right which through drocainian measures has been taken away by the ruling class. It’s not theirs to give back or otherwise negotiate with. Stop all ridiculous persecution and testing of marijuana NOW and apologise for what you have done. The voluntary workouts stay voluntary. That’s a fair a compromise.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.