A look inside the efforts to build a better football helmet

Getty Images

In a laboratory in Charlottesville, football helmets are put on the heads of crash test dummies, those dummies take hits similar the kinds of hits players take on the football field, and then researchers measure how the helmet reduces the impact on the dummy’s head. This is repeated thousands of times, and researchers draw conclusions about which helmet models best protect football players’ heads.

Peter King visited that laboratory for the latest episode of his podcast, and he also visited the headquarters of Vicis, the company that has produced the top-performing helmet in laboratory testing three years in a row. The result sounds an optimistic note about the possibilities for better helmets making football a safer sport.

No helmet can prevent every concussion, but Dr. Ann Bailey Good at the Biocore lab in Charlottesville said the testing at her lab is significantly more advanced than testing on helmets in years past. While past testing was focused primarily on the kinds of impacts that cause skull fractures, modern testing is more comprehensive.

“We’re looking beyond skull fracture. We’re looking at things like concussion, and we know now from more recent research that rotational kinematics, or the way the head moves in a rotational manner, can influence whether a concussion happens or not. So the testing that is done now is done with a flexible neck and a test fixture which allows us to look at not only linear motion but also rotational motion of the head due to an impact,” Good said. “We’ll test the front, the side, the facemask, the rear, to assess how different helmets will attenuate the energy that goes into the head.”

In lab testing results released by the NFL and NFL Players Association, Vicis helmets have shown the greatest ability to reduce head impacts. Vicis CEO Dave Marver told King that the company studied the way the automobile industry has made cars safer by using materials that will crumple to absorb some of the impact of a crash, and so the Vicis helmet has a pliable outer shell that can absorb some of the impact without being permanently damaged, and a stiffer plastic inner core to protect the player’s head.

“In automotive safety you have cars that crumple,” he said. “So why not put those same things in a helmet? But it has to be done in a way that’s practical — you can’t take a helmet out of service after one collision. So we borrowed those engineering principles.”

We’re far from solving the problem of the perfect football helmet. For starters, it will take decades to determine whether putting better helmets on players today reduces the number of neurological issues that retired NFL players have as they get older. And cost is another issue: Better helmets tend to be more expensive helmets, and King’s podcast indicated that the Seattle Seahawks, for instance, spend hundreds of thousands of dollars a year on helmets — which is fine for an NFL team but unrealistic for a high school team. But on one important issue facing football’s future, progress is being made.

6 responses to “A look inside the efforts to build a better football helmet

  1. NFL players DESERVE the BEST HELMETS available each year, regardless of any sponsorship deals or payments to the NFL. That’s something the NFLPA should insist upon being a requirement every year.

  2. It’s notable that some teams (Seattle mentioned here) are already investing in these technologies, spending for the safer helmets etc. Seattle also has been at the forefront for implementing rugby-style tackling, where effectively the head is removed from direct contact. Point being, it’s easy for teams to say “we need the NFL/NFLPA to take a position”; but these teams have the wherewithal to help protect their players now. The more of them working on safety — hard to argue Seattle’s focus on safety has resulted in less toughness/aggressiveness — the faster we get to solutions.

  3. If the NFL is truly interested in safety, it has to be willing to get away from the hard shell plastic helmet and go to a softer air cushion type of apparatus.
    This would not only save players from concusions ( think of banging 2 bike intertubes together as opposed to 2 of the current helmets banging into each other )
    This would also cutdown on knee injuries as getting whacked in the knee with an airfilled piece of tubing doesn’t do the same damage as hard plastic. The problem would be esthetics .

  4. What the point? If you wear the helmet too loose, as many do. That space between the head and helmet just transfer the energy of the hit to the head. No amount of changes wont change that, if you are wearing a helmet a size or 2 too large expect your chances of concussion to go up logarithmically with the delta of the ‘loose space’ area.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.