J.J. Watt says official told him “I saw him hold you, but I didn’t throw the flag”

Getty Images

There were 5.18 offensive holding calls per game in Week One and the first 15 games of Week Two have seen 4.67 flags thrown for that infraction per game, but Texans defensive end J.J. Watt said that the number could be even higher.

Watt felt that officials didn’t penalize many clear holding violations by Jaguars offensive linemen over the course of Houston’s 13-12 victory. Watt also said that one member of the officiating crew told him his suspicions were justified.

“There were a couple of holding calls out there, it’s every week,” Watt said, via the Houston Chronicle. “The ref literally admitted to me that guy held me on one play, and he didn’t throw the flag. I don’t know what I’m supposed to do with that after a play. I look over at the ref and he says, ‘Yes, I saw him hold you, but I didn’t throw the flag.’ “I’ll probably get fined for this and that’s fine, but I don’t know what to do with that. I’m also very confused. I don’t know what to do there. It’s just part of the game. It’s something I’ve dealt with for a long time. I literally looked over at him and he said, ‘I know, I saw it.'”

The Jaguars offense was flagged for holding three times during the game, but it seems Watt is not alone in feeling that number was lower than it could have been.

43 responses to “J.J. Watt says official told him “I saw him hold you, but I didn’t throw the flag”

  1. Watt isn’t the only pass rusher getting held on every down for every game. It’s how offenses deal with players like Mack and Watt. They hold the neckline of their shoulder pads, they literally wrap their arms around their throats into a choke hold, they even shove their fists into their throats to push them up and away. It’s on nearly every play week in and week out and the refs are right there looking at it and letting it happen. I personally believe the NFL refs see it and don’t throw it because it’s constantly happening. It would slow down the game too much. They are probably told by the NFL or head referees not to throw the flag.

  2. There’s not much he, the refs or anybody can do. Too many holding calls, even justified ones, make games unwatchable. This is true of course for all penalties, but the DPI/Defensive Holding & Holding calls especially IMO.

  3. Yes, it happens ever play, but some are more egregious than others. When the guy’s arm is around the defenders throat (as seen in numerous games last night, including SNF), there’s no excuse for not throwing the flag.

    Watt will happily pay that fine if it gets a little focus on it.

  4. There are 22 giant sized human beings running around and into each other. So there is a penalty happening on at least every other play. Would you really want the refs to start throwing the flag for every infraction?

    I can’t wait for the day where the refs throw a flag on every other play. The game will last 4 hours, there will be no momentum, the final scores will be 13-10, and the game will be unwatchable.

  5. Just another way to maintain “parity” by the league. The best players are so dominating they often let penalties against them go uncalled.

  6. Is there supposed to be a penalty on every snap? Im sure jj watt is not the only one who gets held on every play. I would suspect every great linenan gets held on every play

  7. I watched a few games this weekend and officiating is getting worse by the week, especially game-impacting plays being missed or called badly.

    Watt gets double/triple teamed on almost every play but seldom gets a holding call. This is the first time I’ve heard him mention it. Regardless, if an official says “I know, I saw it” and doesn’t throw the flag, NFL needs to do something. They won’t, but they need to.

  8. If that was truly said to him, that raises a lot of questions about officiating and whether or not they have an agenda or are told to do their job a certain way. It could also be that the referee felt uncomfortable after he was almost called out and said what he thought the player wanted to hear just to be able to quickly move on. I imagine that will be tough to prove though.

    But I will also say that tons of penalties go uncalled in every game and it causes a lot of people (fans, players, gamblers, etc.) frustration and the overall quality of the game goes down a bit every time. But sadly it is part of the game and regardless of all the things they keep changing, it will remain part of the game. JJ should just be glad his team won and that a bad call(s) didn’t cost his team the game like others have had to endure.

  9. Missing a lot of context about this story to make any conclusions. What was the situation in where the hold took place? Was it anyway from the ball and the play and was it inconsequential to the play? Was it an egregious hold w JJ rushing str8 up the middle from DT? If it was a slight hold that didn’t effect the outcome of the particular play I’m all good w a no call. Holding can get called on almost every play but only the major blatant ones need to be called. No1 was complaining during or after the game from the eye test saying Watt was held on a particular play that had any effect on the outcome.

  10. I notice that according to this story, JJ Watt said two different things. He says the ref said “I know. I saw it.” But then he says the ref said “Yes, I saw him hold you, but I didn’t throw the flag.”

    My guess is that the ref said he saw “it,” by which he meant he had his eyes on the play. Watt interprets this as the ref saying he saw holding but decided not to throw the flag, but come on. Do you believe a ref would actually say that? I don’t.

  11. If you are naive, you will believe that these bad calls are all by accident. I believe that the league is not only helping certain teams win, depending on the Vegas odds, but the don’t even care any more if you figure it out. They do it blatantly, and don’t care.

  12. a bunch of slow 5’7″ men trying to keep up with 22 guys who are bigger, faster, smarter and mostly smarter isnt ever going to be done well.
    Athletes need to be officials, they know what goes on and how to stop it and what to call and what not to. They are big enough,fast enough and can anticipate things people who never played at a high level cannot do.

  13. The refs this week in lots of games were absolutely terrible. I hate to sound like a crybaby Saints fan complaining about calls, but this week was absolutely ridiculous (including the overturned Saints TD, speaking of the Saints)

  14. Refs can do what they want becquse they’re protected by the league. Insert vegas and they’re really untouchable. And to think the nfl is all about integrity. Yea ok

  15. badchannels1 says:
    September 16, 2019 at 8:51 am
    Watt isn’t the only pass rusher getting held on every down for every game. It’s how offenses deal with players like Mack and Watt. They hold the neckline of their shoulder pads, they literally wrap their arms around their throats into a choke hold, they even shove their fists into their throats to push them up and away. It’s on nearly every play week in and week out and the refs are right there looking at it and letting it happen. I personally believe the NFL refs see it and don’t throw it because it’s constantly happening. It would slow down the game too much. They are probably told by the NFL or head referees not to throw the flag.
    ~~~~~~~~~~~~~
    The fix is not to let it go. The fix is to call it EVERY time. It is the players’ responsibility to play within the rules and the officials’ responsibility to flag them when they don’t. If there are too many flags then it is on the players to play right. Telling the officials to use their judgment on whether or not to throw a flag when they see an actual violation means they are no longer officiating. At that point they are shaping the games.

  16. To me it seems like a league office directive to help protect QBs. The DEs in every game I watch are getting clotheslined throughout a game along with magically being held up even when it appears they are clear of the tackle. So now Dlinemen are getting better at the hand fighting. It looks like Kung fu out there now.

  17. FinFan68:
    ///////////
    Exactly, if they would throw the flag more on the OL holding, eventually it make them stop getting away with it. This year I thought they were supposed to be watching for this but I guess they aren’t. The diva QB’s are being protected by the OL holding, that way there’s more yards/points to make the game more exciting to watch I guess.

  18. I am a Texans season-ticket holder and watch Watt with my binoculars quite a bit. Several times I saw an arm completely wrapped around his waist pulling him back as he passed without a call. Why would the O-line stop holding if they aren’t calling it?

  19. The packers did not have one holding call this past Sunday called. I saw holding going on but none were called. The Vikings had some called on them however. With gambling tied so tight to the NFL now it might be time to forget about the NFL.

  20. And this new review situation they have much more power to control games than they did before and blame it on refs error because fans are used to very poor officiating now.

  21. With all the griping going I have a solution that should make everyone happy. Allow the players and coaches to officiate their own damn games and see how many flags they throw.

  22. Pretty sure a few Jaguars can complain about being held as well. It happens every game, heck the announcers have made comments for years on how you can call holding on almost every play.

    I think Watt is just making excuses for why hes been invisible they last two weeks.

  23. Maybe if the NFL had the same rules for two years in a row, that would help. But it will never happen because they continuously change the rulebook and for some reason feel the need to “emphasize” certain things. Just stop changing the rules, just once.

  24. @areyahappynow says:
    September 16, 2019 at 10:16 am
    a bunch of slow 5’7″ men trying to keep up with 22 guys who are bigger, faster, smarter and mostly smarter isnt ever going to be done well.
    Athletes need to be officials, they know what goes on and how to stop it and what to call and what not to. They are big enough,fast enough and can anticipate things people who never played at a high level cannot do.
    ========================================================================
    Looks great on paper but ask yourself, “why don’t more athletes sign up to be officials?”.
    The shortage officials is probably at historic preportions. There are more little league football games intertwined with regular high school football. There’s always emails being sent looking for officials, oftentimes on game day.

  25. I have a solution. (Sarcasim)

    Let’s make offensive holding reviewable !!
    Just like Pass Interference.

    Then the refs can view every play and penalize a defender for something out of the blue. (see packers/vikings week 2)

    It’s what the NFL needs !! (Sarcasm)

  26. I know there are some people on here that don’t particularly care for Watt and that’s perfectly fine by me. Nevertheless, these holds on edge rushers is a serious problem that needs to be addressed. It’s just as important as the holds along the rest of the o-line that create holes for the backs to run through. It’s just as important as pass interference calls. It’s a hold that negates that player on defense completely and it isn’t getting called. My only guess can be for quarterback safety reasons as to why it’s being overlooked. The argument that it slows a game down is just being dismissive. There are plenty of other calls being made throughout games for holding. And maybe…just maybe…if these choke holds on edge rushers gets called more often than not, it will cut back on the holds to begin with. Watt has a very valid point and I’m sure there are plenty of edge rushers in the league that would agree with him. No one wants to be a cry baby, but these particular holds are inexcusable and the refs are looking the other way…on purpose.

  27. protozoa5 says:
    September 16, 2019 at 11:00 am

    I think Watt is just making excuses for why hes been invisible they last two weeks.
    ————————
    I think Watt is saying the only way the Jags stop me is by getting away with holding.

  28. I agree with Collinsworth make holding a 5 yard penalty instead of 10 and maybe they will call it more. And if the refs call it more maybe there will be less of it going on in future games.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.